Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 12455 (KAR)

SMT ARCHANA W/O SUBHAS GHODAKE AND ORS v. SRI NURUDDIN S/O BABU SHAIKH AND ANR

MFA/200716/2021 · 2025-02-13

C M Joshi

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - ! "" # $ $ %%& ' ( ) ! " # $ # $ % & '()%# * !'( ' " Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - # ( )# ++ + '()%# * ! '+, ' ++ " + + !" + ' ( %- '( ' '( ' ++ (' - 3 - .( ( $ ! .( ( " /01234/5/016/27896:/5;8134/0<</55063:06234/ 1/:<862/638 /=6> 0>>1=/?/2 @A 34/ B92>C/63 =6 ' 8 203/2 %- @A 34/ 5/016/2 22=3=8605/6=81 =?=5(92>/062 '03'=B0A0<910 34/</3=3=86/1:01/@/;81/34=: 8913=60<</05 4/ ;073905 C031=D 8; 34/ 70:/ =: 3403 86 34/ 49:@062 8; 34/ </3=3=86/1 8 60C/5A 9@40:4 E0: <187//2=6> 86 4=: C83817A75/ @/01=6> />8 )))#;18CFF05F8338 066911802062 34/ ?/4=75/ @/01=6> />8 )))%%#% 70C/ ;18C 8<<8:=3/ 2=1/73=86 =6 0 10:4 062 6/>5=>/63 C066/1 062 E4=5/8?/130F=6>06834/1?/4=75/20:4/23834/C83817A75/ 8; 34/ 2/7/0:/2 4/ 2/7/0:/2 ) 9@40:4 ;/55 28E6 062 2=/20334/:<834/1/0;3/134/@82A8;34/2/7/0:/2E0: 30F/6389105 8:<=305FF05F830620<8:3C813/CE0: - 4 - 7862973/2 4/1/0;3/1 34/ @82A 70C/ 38 @/ 2=:<8:/2 8; 4/ </3=3=86/1: E48 01/ 34/ 2/</62/63: 8; 34/ 2/7/0:/2 40?/ 0<<18074/2 34/ 1=@9605 750=C=6> 78C</6:03=86 86 07789638;34/2/0348;34/2/7/0:/2)9@40:4;18C34/ 8E6/1062=6:91/18;34/8;;/62=6>?/4=75/ 6@/=6>:/1?/2E=3434/683=7/34/1/:<862/63 8 8E6/1 8; 34/ 8;;/62=6> ?/4=75/ 2=2 683 0<</01 062 34/1/;81/<507/2/D)<013/4/1/:<862/638=6:91067/ 78C<06A 0<</01/2 062 1/:=:3/2 34/ </3=3=86 @A ;=5=6> E1=33/6 :303/C/63 4/ 1/:<862/63 8 2/6=/2 34/ =6?85?/C/638;34/?/4=75/=634/077=2/63305:82/6=/2 3403 34/ 21=?/1 8; 34/ 8;;/62=6> ?/4=75/ 402 /;;/73=?/ 062 ?05=221=?=6>5=7/6:/3821=?/34/:0C/305:82/6=/234/ 0>/=678C/0628779<03=868;34/2/7/0:/263/1)05=0=3 7863/62/2 3403 34/ 78C</6:03=86 750=C/2 =: 4=>45A /D81@=3063=C0>=601A062963/60@5/=650E3055/>/23403 34/ 077=2/63 402 877911/2 86 0778963 8; 34/ 10:4 062 6/>5=>/63 21=?=6> 8; 34/ 2/7/0:/2 4=C:/5; 4/1/;81/ 34/ 5=0@=5=3A706683@/;0:3/6/29<8634/1/:<862/6384/ 1=@9605;10C/20<<18<1=03/=::9/:E4=741/020:@/58E) - 5 - 4/34/134/</3=3=86/1:<18?/340334/2/7/0:/240: :9:30=6/2 >1=/?89: =6B91=/: 29/ 38 073=860@5/ 10:4 0626/>5=>/630738;21=?/18; 19=:/1/C<8@/01=6> />8 )))%%#%=634/8381'/4=75/77=2/63 8634/203/3=C/062<507/0:@/=6>0::/13/2G 4/34/1 34/ 1/:<862/63 8 <18?/: 3403 29/ 38 ?=8503=868; <85=7A 7862=3=86:=6:91/1=: 683 5=0@5/ 38 <0A34/78C</6:03=86G 4/34/1 </3=3=86/1: 01/ /63=35/2 ;81 34/ 78C</6:03=86G;:848EC974062;18CE48CG ' 403812/1810E012G 4/</3=3=86/18E0:/D0C=6/20:062 D38-E/1/C01F/2=634//?=2/67/4/1/:<862/63 8 ) =6:91067/ 78C<06A 2=2 683 02297/ 06A /?=2/67/ @9334/ D 38 E/1/ C01F/2@A 786:/63 8; @83434/ <013=/: 34/A 01/ 34/ =6:91067/ <85=7A 21=?=6> 5=7/6:/ 8; 34/ 21=?/1 8; 34/ 8;;/62=6> ?/4=75/ 062 34/ @88F /D31073 - 6 - # ;3/14/01=6>@83434/:=2/:34/1=@960570C/ 3834/786759:=86340334/</3=3=86/1:40?/;0=5/238<18?/ 340334/?/4=75/8E6/2@A1/:<862/638062=6:91/2@A 1/:<862/638E0: =6?85?/2 =634/ 077=2/634/1/;81/ =32=:C=::/234/</3=3=86 /=6> 0>>1=/?/2 @A 34/ :0C/ 34/ </3=3=86/1: 01/@/;81/34=: 8913=60<</05 % 4/ 5/016/2 7896:/5 0<</01=6> ;81 34/ 0<</55063: :9@C=3: 3403 34/ 1=@9605 40: /11/2 =6 2=:C=::=6></3=3=863=::9@C=33/234033489>434/<85=7/ 402 30F/6683/ 8;34/2/034 8;34/ 2/7/0:/2 H 9@40:4 34/ FF05F83 8134 <85=7/ ;0=5/2 38 1/>=:3/1 06 + 3 =: :9@C=33/2 3403 34/ 055/>/2 + E4=74 E0: 1/>=:3/1/2 86 % E4=74 =: 6/015A 0;3/1 C8634: 8; 34/ 8;;/67/ 601103/: 3403 34/ 077=2/63 402 877911/2 86 062/?/634/634/+70C/38@/1/>=:3/1/2 865A 0;3/1 3107=6> 34/ 8;;/62=6> ?/4=75/ 3 =: <8=63/2 893 3403 06 =11/>9501 =6?/:3=>03=86 286/@A34/<85=7/ 706683 =606AE0A073<1/B92=7=053834/=63/1/:38;34/</3=3=86/1: - 7 - 3 =: 7863/62/2 3403 34/ FF05F83 <85=7/ F6/E 0@893 34/ 077=2/63 86 062 /?/6 34/ </3=3=86/1: E/1/ 960E01/ 8; 34/ 8;;/62=6> ?/4=75/ :=67/ 34/ 2/7/0:/2 ) 9@40:4 E0: ;8962 @A :8C/ <0::/1@A 062 4/ 402 =6;81C/234/</3=3=86/1:4/1/;81/E4/634/1/:<862/63 ) 6:91067/ 8C<06A 40: 683 5/2 06A /?=2/67/ 38 :48E 3403 34/1/ =: 7866=?067/ @/3E//6 34/ </3=3=86/1: 062 34/ <85=7/06205:8340334/3107=6>8;34/8;;/62=6>?/4=75/@A 34/<85=7/E0:;0953A34/=6:91067/78C<06A706683://F 0@:8?/5C/638;=3:5=0@=5=3A - 3 =: ;9134/1 7863/62/2 3403 34/ =6?/:3=>03=6> 8;;=7/18634/@0:=:8;34/:303/C/63C02/@A 062 %=2/63=;=/234/?/4=75/E4=7478CC=33/234/077=2/63062 34/686/8;34/<85=7/8;;=7=058;34/<85=7/:303=864=C:/5; C02/01/<8130621/>=:3/1/234/+86/8;34/4062: 8;34/</3=3=86/1:E/1/=6?85?/2=61/>=:3103=868;34/+ 86 % 4/1/;81/ 34/ </3=3=86/1: 706683 @/ 2/6=/28;34/78C</6:03=863=:05:8<8=63/2893340334/ + 062 7401>/):4//3 40: 683 @//6 74055/6>/2 /=34/1 @A - 8 - 34/21=?/1818E6/18;34/:0=2?/4=75/ /67/4/://F06 =6295>/67/ 8; 34=: 8913 062 :9@C=3 3403 34/1/ @/=6> :9;;=7=/63 /?=2/67/ 1/>012=6> 34/ 0::/::C/63 8; 34/ 78C</6:03=8634=: 8913@/<5/0:/2380558E0<</05062 0::/:: 34/ 78C</6:03=86 @A 0E012=6> 34/ B9:3 062 1/0:860@5/78C</6:03=86 /1 786310 34/ 5/016/2 7896:/5 0<</01=6> ;81 34/1/:<862/638)=6:91067/78C<06A7863/6234030: 86 34/ 203/ 8; 077=2/63 =3 E0: 34/ # E48 402 =6;81C/20@89334/077=2/633834/<85=7/ /402683://6 34/077=2/630624/865A=6;81C/2340334/2/7/0:/2402 :9779C@/2 38 34/ 2/034 062 34/ C83817A75/ 402 ;055/6 6/010@1=2>/8634/1=>43:=2/8;34/18024/1/;81/4/ 402:9:</73/2340334/2/7/0:/2402;055/628E6;18C34/ C83817A75/ 062 402 2=/2 4=: E0: 34/ ;=1:3 =6;81C03=86 E4=74 402 1/074/2 34/ <85=7/ :303=86 062 34/1/;81/ 34/ :9@:/I9/63 =6?85?/C/63 8; 34/ ?/4=75/ 8E6/2 @A 34/ 1/:<862/63 8 062 =6:91/2 @A 1/:<862/63 8 =: 289@3;95 7=179C:3067/ / 7863/62: 3403 0;3/1 C81/ 3406 - 9 - C8634:34/:303/C/63:8; 062%E/1/1/7812/2 @A34/<85=7/062863403@0:=:34/A40?/1/>=:3/1/2+3 =:<8=63/2893340334/2/50A75/015A=62=703/:340334/1/=: 7866=?067/ @/3E//6 34/ </3=3=86/1: 062 34/ <85=7/ =6 =C<5=703=6> 34/ ?/4=75/ 8E6/2 @A 1/:<862/63 8 062 =6:91/2 @A 1/:<862/63 8 4/1/;81/ 4/ ://F: 34/ 2=:C=::058;34/0<</05 3=:;9134/1:9@C=33/23403=670:/34=: 8913=: 8; 34/ 8<=6=86 3403 34/ 1/:<862/63 8 40: 683 5/2 /?=2/67/ @/;81/ 34/ 1=@9605 34/ C033/1 C0A @/ 1/C062/23834/1=@9605634=:1/>0124/1/5=/:8634/ B92>C/63 =6 34/ 70:/ 8; 4/ </19:05 8; 34/ + E4=74 =: 03 D 062 34/3106:503/278<A8;E4=74=:03D!0"2=:758:/:3403 34/(0A0E063C02/0:303/C/63E4=74E0:@0:=:;81 34/+634/:0=2:303/C/63=3=:C/63=86/234037/130=6 1 - 10 - 70:/E0:1/>=:3/1/2=669C@/1# 634/@0:=:8;34/ :0=2/6I9=1A34/(0A0E063C02/7/130=6=6?/:3=>03=86 062865A34/1/0;3/134/ 1=C/8% E0:1/>=:3/1/2 @A34/:0=2<85=7/:303=866834/1E812:34/=6?/:3=>03=86 402 78CC/67/2 86 =3:/5; @93 0 ;81C05 + E0:1/>=:3/1/286 % 4/ </19:05 8; D 2=:758:/: 3403 34/ =6?/:3=>03=8678CC/67/2868634/@0:=:8;0 :303/C/63 C02/ @A 86/ =5=< '=:4E06034 0B05/ / 402 ://6030@893 <C86)34030C83817A75/ 402;055/68634/1=>43:=2/6/0134/@1=2>/4/1/;81/4/ :38<</2 4=: ?/4=75/ 062 34/6 :0E 3403 34/ 2/7/0:/2 ) 9@40:4 402 ;055/6 28E6 062 4=: C83817A75/ 402 05:8 ;055/6 28E6 E=34 34/ 20C0>/: 062 34/ 2/7/0:/2 H 9@40:44022=/2CC/2=03/5A4/E/6338<85=7/:303=86 062=6;81C/234/:0C/ /:9:</73/2340334/2/7/0:/2) 9@40:4402;055/628E6864=:8E6@?=89:5A34/:0=2 =5=< E0: 683 06 /A/E=36/:: 38 34/ 077=2/63 4/1/0;3/1 34/<85=7/?=:=3/234/:<8306234/6:4=;3/234/@82A8;34/ - 11 - 2/7/0:/2)9@40:43834/48:<=305E4/1/34/2/7/0:/2) 9@40:4 E0: =2/63=;=/2 @A 34/ ;0C=5A C/C@/1: 8; 34/ 2/7/0:/2 H 9@40:4 4/ @82A E0: :9@B/73/2 38 <8:3 C813/C 4/1/0;3/1 =3 E0: 4062/2 8?/1 38 34/ ;0C=5A C/C@/1: 4/ :<83 C040J01 E0: 05:8 7862973/2 86 34/ ?/1A6/D320A8;34/077=2/63=/860#E4=74 =: <18297/2 03 D 4/1/;81/ =3 =: /?=2/63 3403 34/ =6?/:3=>03=86402:3013/28634/203/8;34/077=2/63=3:/5; 06234=:;05:=;=/:34/7863/63=868;34/=6:91067/78C<06A 340334/=6?/:3=>03=86:3013/2865A0;3/1 % 4/D;9134/12=:758:/:34030334/3=C/8; 34/ /6I9=1A 34/A 1/7812/2 34/ :303/C/63 8; 86/ 91A0F06306206=FE4801/686//5:/3406 062% 4/A402:303/234033489>434/A2=2683://34/077=2/63 34/A4024/01234/:89628;7855=:=868;34/?/4=75/:E4=5/ 34/A E/1/ 03 :8C/ 2=:3067/4/A 402 :303/2 3403 =6 34/ 791?=6> E4/6 34/ 19=:/1 ?/4=75/ E0: 8?/130F=6> 0 @9: 34/A 4/012 34/ :8962 8; 06 077=2/63 93 48E/?/1 34/A 402 683 ?=:=3/2 34/ :<83 0;3/1 34/ 077=2/63 4/A 05:8 - 12 - :303/2340334/ 19=:/1?/4=75/402<0::/234/C05:86 34/ @0:=: 8; :974 :303/C/63 34/ =6?/:3=>03=6> 8;;=7/1 3107/2 34/ 19=:/1 ?/4=75/062 /6I9=1/2 34/8E6/1 8; 34/ ?/4=75/=/91922=64/8E6/1)91922=6402=6;81C/2 340386/6=5E0:34/21=?/18;34/?/4=75/ /05:8:303/2 3403 6=5 402 =6;81C/2 0@893 06 077=2/63 062 86 3403 @0:=: 0 2/30=5/2 :303/C/63 E0: 1/7812/2 @A 34/ <85=7/ 4/634/?/4=75/E0::/=J/2962/10C040J01E4=74=:03 D 49: 0;3/1 3107=6> 34/ :0=2 ?/4=75/ 34/A 78C<5/3/2 34/ =6?/:3=>03=86 062 34/6 34/A 40?/ ;=5/2 34/ 7401>/):4//3 3 =: </13=6/63 38 683/ 3403 963=5 34/ 19=:/1 ?/4=75/ @/01=6> />8 )))%%#% E0: 3107/2 0 ;81C05 + =6 1=C/ 8% E0: 683 1/>=:3/1/2 @A 34/FF05F838134<85=7/4=:0?/1C/63=6D75/015A 2/<=73 3403 =6=3=055A /=34/1 34/ </3=3=86/1: 81 06A@82A /5:/ 402 683 3107/2 0: 38 E4=74 ?/4=75/ 402 709:/2 34/ 077=2/63 65A 0;3/1 34/ :303/C/63 8; 062 % E/1/ - 13 - 1/7812/234/=6?/:3=>03=6>8;;=7/170C/38F68E0@89334/ 19=:/1?/4=75/65A8634/@0:=:8;34/:303/C/638;34/ 8E6/1 8; 34/ ?/4=75/ 34/ 21=?/1 E0: 3107/2 062 4/ E0: 7401>/:4//3/2 4=: 3916 8;; /?/63: 062 7=179C:3067/: 601103/2 =6 D :9<<813/2 @A 34/ :<83 C040J01 03 D34/:/=J91/8;34/?/4=75/:503/10:</1D:#062 34/ =6I9/:3 062 34/ <C 1/<813 E4=74 01/ 03 D: 062 062 34/ 7401>/):4//3 03 D% :48E 3403 34/ =6?/:3=>03=86706683@/;0953/24/<187/291/;8558E/2@A 34/ <85=7/ =6 683 1/>=:3/1=6> 34/ + 86 @93 <187//2=6> E=34 34/ =6?/:3=>03=86 86 34/ @0:=: 8; 0 70:/ E4=74 =: :48E6 0: 88# !E4=74 =: =6 01034=" <1/:9C0@5A070:/8;9660391052/034C0A683;=3E/55=6 34/ =6?/:3=>03=86 7863/C<503/2 962/1 34/ 1 4/ <85=7/:4895240?/1/>=:3/1/234/+062=;=3 E0:;8962 340334/2/7/0:/24=C:/5;40221=?/634/?/4=75/=6010:4 062 6/>5=>/63 C066/1 0 758:91/ 1/<813 78952 40?/ @//6 ;=5/2@A34/C - 14 - # 3 =: </13=6/63 38 683/ 3403 34/ =6?/:3=>03=86 7862973/2@A34/ <85=7/<013=795015A34/ :303/C/63C02/ @A(0A0E063=634/+HD40:683@//61/@933/2@A 34/=6:91067/78C<06A8134/8E6/18;34/?/4=75/=606A E0A4/:0=2(0A0E0638134/ 062%40?/683@//6 :9CC86/2 81 /D0C=6/2 38 :48E 3403 34/ 1/<813 8; 34/ =6?/:3=>03=6> 8;;=7/1 E48 40: ;=5/2 34/ 7401>/):4//3 =: =67811/73 62/1 34/:/ 7=179C:3067/: 34/ 786759:=86: 1/074/2 @A 34/ 1=@9605 3403 34/1/ E0: 68 :974 077=2/63 062 34/ =::9/ 8 =: 683 <18?/2 @A 34/ </3=3=86/1: =: <1=C0);07=/=67811/73062E=34893<18</15A0<<1/7=03=6>34/ /?=2/67/861/7812489>47863/63=86E0:30F/6340334/ 78559:=86 @/3E//6 34/ </3=3=86/1: 062 34/ <85=7/ =: 683 195/2893@9334/1/=:68/?=2/67/38:48E340334/1/E0: :974 78559:=86 4/ 1=@9605 78952 683 40?/ <1/:9C/2 7/130=6 0:</73: E4=74 01/ 683 @816/ 893 8; 34/ 1/7812 2/50A =6 ;=5=6> 34/ 78C<50=63 =3:/5; 706683 @/ 0 1/0:86 38 289@334/=6?85?/C/638;34/?/4=75/ - 15 - % 6 34/ 70:/ 86 4062 34/ =6?/:3=>03=86 402 :3013/2 86 34/ 203/ 8; 34/ 077=2/63 =3:/5; 062 :974 =6?/:3=>03=867862973/2@A34/<85=7/40:683@//6:48E6 38@/;05507=89:4/1/;81/E4/6:974/?=2/67/<507/286 1/7812 =: 683 :48E6 38 @/ =67811/73 81 78559:=?/ 81 ;109295/6334/1=@960575/015A/11/2=64852=6>340334/1/ E0:68:974077=2/63634/<0138;34/8@?=89:5A :4/ =: =>681063 8; 34/ C066/1 =6 E4=74 34/ 077=2/63 402 877911/2 4/ E0: 683 06 /A/E=36/:: 062 34/1/;81/ 6834=6> =: /5=7=3/2 /?/6 =6 4/1 718::)/D0C=603=86 ?/6 34/6 34/ 718::)/D0C=603=86 8; 34/ 28 683 2=:758:/ 340334/1/=:06A7866=?067/@/3E//634/</3=3=86/1:062 34/<85=7/ /67/34/;=62=6>8;34/1=@960586=::9/8 =:683:9:30=60@5/=650E - 4/B92>C/638;34/</D 8913=634/70:/8; 34/ 706683@/C02/0<<5=70@5/ 38 34/ 70:/ 86 4062 :=67/ 34/ 055/>03=86 8; ;1092 E0: 7863/62/2@A34/=6:91067/78C<06A062=3402:89>43;81 - 16 - :/33=6> 0:=2/ 34/ B92>C/63 @A 1/:813=6> 38 /73=86: 0628; ://F=6>1/70558;34/0E012:6:974 7=179C:3067/: 34/ </D 8913 402 1/C062/2 34/ C033/1 3834/1=@96050;1/:4382/7=2/34/2=:<93/634/70:/86 4062 0C<5/ 8<<81396=3A E0: >=?/6 38 34/ 1/:<862/63 84/1/;81/34/1/=:681/0:86381/C06234/C033/1 3834/1=@9605 6 34/ 1/:953 34/ =6?85?/C/63 8; 34/ ?/4=75/ 8E6/2 @A 1/:<862/63 8 062 =6:91/2 @A 1/:<862/63 8 =6 34/ 077=2/63 =: <18?/2 86:/I9/635A 34/ 1/:<862/63:806201/B8=635A062:/?/1055A5=0@5/38 <0A34/78C</6:03=863834/</3=3=86/1: 4/1=@9605/?/63489>4402;10C/234/=::9/ 1/>012=6>34/I90639C8;34/78C</6:03=86=634/;81C8; =::9/ 8 40: 683 2/053 E=34 34/ :0C/ 4/6 06 =::9/ 40: @//6 ;10C/2 34/ 78C</6:03=86 :48952 40?/ @//6 I9063=;=/2@A=34/1/C0628;34/C033/1;8134/<91<8:/ 8; 34/ 0::/::C/63 8; 34/ 78C</6:03=86 =: 683 1/I9=1/2 :=67/34//?=2/67/=:051/02A0?0=50@5/ - 17 - 4/ 2/7/0:/2 ) 9@40:4 E0: 0>/2 0@893 A/01: 0: C/63=86/2 =6 <C 1/<813 03 D 4/ </3=3=86/1: 7863/62 3403 34/ 2/7/0:/2 ) 9@40:4 E0: 0>1=795391=:3 062 7885=/ 4/1/ =: 68 C03/1=05 38 :48E 34/ =678C/8;34/2/7/0:/2H9@40:4/1/;81/34/683=8605 =678C/8;:% )=:786:=2/1/2@A34=: 8913E4=74=: =6786:86067/E=3434/683=8605=678C/786:=2/1/2;8134/ <91<8:/ 8; :/335/C/63 8; 2=:<93/: @/;81/ 34/8F)205034 =6 <91:9067/ 38 34/ >9=2/5=6/: =::9/2 @A 34/ /67/34/58::8;2/</62/67A=:70579503/20:Rs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