Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 12449 (KAR)

THE DIVISIONAL CONTROLLER NEKRTC v. MAHANTAPPA S/O NEELAKANTHAPPA YALAWAR

WP/202055/2021 · 2025-01-10

R Nataraj

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - ! "# $ % !"# $%# & %% %%' & & & ( $))*%)%$ $$%)$+ ,! Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: High Court Of Karnataka - 2 - & -. / 01 2321 435 63789462 4694632:47 038 ;:<15 20:8 =6:2 912:2:47 >03<<17?:7? 37 46516 53215 $))*%)%$ 938815@A201618:5:7? ;;:>163@4B6 4B62:C3A39B6:7 4$$%)$+ 8122:7? 38:51 201 46516 4; 5:8D:883< 4; 201 6189475172 ;64D 816E:>1 375 61!:78232:7? 0:D :724 816E:>1 :7 37A 3<216732:E1 C4@ =:204B2 @3>F =3?182 038 3<84>03<<17?1520146516D45:;A:7?2019B7:80D172;64D 5:8D:883<24615B>2:474;471:7>61D172 % 016189475172=381D9<4A1538356:E16!>BD! >475B>246 =:20 201 912:2:4716 01 6189475172 3<<1?15<A 3@817215;64D=46F@12=117%#)%%)$#375)*)#%)$# 01 912:2:4716 20161;461 :7:2:3215 519362D1723< 964>115:7?8 3?3:782 201 6189475172 26132:7? :2 38 3 - 3 - D:8>475B>2 01 6189475172 ><3:D15 2032 01 =38 B7516 26132D17232:C3A39B6375203201=38742:73948:2:4724 916;46D5B2:1838356:E16!>BD!>475B>2461><3:D152032 010358B@D:221537399<:>32:47811F:7?<13E1=0:>0=38 742 >478:51615 01 912:2:4716 742 @1:7? 832:8;:15 =:20 201 619<A 8B@D:2215 @A 201 6189475172 3994:7215 37 :7GB:6A4;;:>16=04>475B>21537:7GB:6A3758B@D:22153 619462 8232:7? 2032 201 >036?18 3?3:782 201 6189475172 =161 964E15 &4<<4=:7? 20:8 201 5:8>:9<:736A 3B2046:2A :D94815 D3C46 9B7:80D172 4; 5:8D:883< ;64D 816E:>1 1:7?3??6:1E15@A20183:5465162016189475172:7:2:3215 964>115:7?8 B7516 1>2:47 $) 4; 201 75B826:3< :89B218 >2 $+' ;46 80462 -201 >2 4; $+'. 01 3@4B6 4B6201<5203220154D182:>:7GB:6A>475B>215@A 201912:2:4716=38742;3:6375964916 * 016189475172=381H3D:71538$37501 D36F15H0:@:28!$24%)01912:2:4716=381H3D:715 38 $ 375 3 =:27188 =38 1H3D:715 38 % 375 H0:@:28!$24*%=161D36F15381547201463<375 - 4 - 54>BD17236A 1E:517>1 201 3@4B6 4B62 01<5 2032 H0:@:28!$ 24 %) 5:8><4815 2032 201 6189475172 =38 8B;;16:7?;64D84D1:<<718837571B64<4?:>3<:7;:6D:2A01 6189475172 035 9645B>15 7136<A $$ >162:;:>3218 24 804= 203201=388B;;16:7?;64DE36:4B85:83@:<:2:18013@4B6 4B62 01<5 2032 D15:>3< >162:;:>3218 9645B>15 @A 201 6189475172 804=15 2032 201 6189475172 =38 8B;;16:7? ;64D 2A904:5 375 17216:> ;1E16 H0:@:2!* =38 201 D15:>3< 619462 ;46 201 916:45 ;64D ))$%)$+ 24 %+)$%)$+ =0:<1 H0:@:2!" :8 201 61>465 375 H0:@:2! :8 201 61>465 4; 201 :826:>2 489:23< 3?3<F42 4B62013@4B6 4B6220161;46101<52032201 6189475172 =38 961E17215 ;64D 322175:7? 24 5B2A 2 04=1E1601<5203220161894751725:57428B@D:23<13E1 399<:>32:47@B20358B@D:2215:247<A3;216>3<<<122168=161 8172@A201912:2:47165:61>2:7?20161894751722461946224 5B2A013@4B6 4B6220161;46101<52032:D948:2:474;3 D3C469173<2A4;5:8D:883<;64D816E:>1:85:89649462:47321 24 201 D:8>475B>2 375 >4781GB172<A 3<<4=15 201 5:89B21 375 812 38:51 201 46516 4; 5:8D:883< 375 D45:;:15 :2 24 - 5 - 615B>2:47 4; 471 :7>61D172 916D37172<A =:20 >BDB<32:E1 1;;1>223<8401<52032:7201;3>28375>:6>BD8237>18201 6189475172 =38 742 :7 3 948:2:47 24 916;46D =46F 38 3 56:E16!>BD!>475B>24637520161;4615:61>215201912:2:4716 24 964E:51 3<2167321 =46F 24 201 6189475172 2 5:61>215 61:782321D172 4; 201 6189475172 =:204B2 @3>F =3?18 1:7?3??6:1E15@A20183:546516201912:2:4716:8@1;461 20:8 4B62 136715 >4B781< ;46 201 912:2:4716 >47217515 20322016189475172038393820:8246A4;3@8172:7?;64D =46F37520161;461201912:2:4716=38CB82:;:15:7:7:2:32:7? 519362D1723< :7GB:6A 3?3:782 201 6189475172 1 3<84 >47217515 2032 201 6189475172 =38 @4B75 24 811F ;46 <13E1:;01=388B;;16:7?;64D37A:<<718818B@D:282032 201:<<7188183<<1?15<A8B;;1615@A2016189475172=161742 84 81E161 2032 01 =38 961E17215 ;64D D3F:7? 3 61GB182 ;46 <13E1 0B8 01 8B@D:28 2032 201 D15:>3< >162:;:>3218 375 42016 54>BD1728 361 742 26B82=4620A 375 20161;461 2013@4B6 4B62>4DD:22153716646:761<A:7?B94720481 - 6 - 54>BD1728 1 ;B62016 8B@D:2215 2032 201 3@4B6 4B62 =172 @1A475 :28 CB6:85:>2:47 :7 5:61>2:7? 201 912:2:4716 24 964E:51 3<2167321 =46F 24 201 6189475172 47 201 ?64B75 2032 201 6189475172 =38 742 ;:2 174B?0 24 916;46D 201 5B2:18 4; 3 56:E16!>BD!>475B>246 0161;461 01 8B@D:28 2032 201 :D9B?715 46516 938815 @A 201 3@4B6 4B62 =3663728:7216;1617>1 " 01 <136715 >4B781< ;46 201 6189475172 47 201 42016 0375 8B@D:28 2032 20161 :8 3 963>2:>1 :7 201 912:2:4716!>4694632:47 4; D3F:7? 3 61GB182 ;46 <13E1 375 74 3>F74=<15?D172 ;46 03E:7? 61>1:E15 201 <13E1 399<:>32:47=4B<5@1:88B15@A201912:2:4716120161;461 8B@D:2820322016189475172=38>4D91<<1524;46=365201 61GB182 2064B?0 1 8B@D:2215 201 E16A ;3>2 2032 H0:@:2!*$=38:7201;:<14;201912:2:4716?41824804= 2032 201 6189475172 035 D351 3 61GB182 ;46 <13E1 DB>0 136<:1620370161D3:7153@81720B801>47217582032 201:D9B?71546516938815@A2013@4B6 4B62:8CB82375 964916:7201;3>28375>:6>BD8237>184;201>3813755418 - 7 - 742 =366372 :7216;1617>1 1 3<84 8B@D:28 2032 201 6189475172:874=742:73948:2:4724916;46D2015B2:18 4; 3 56:E16!>BD!>475B>246 :7 E:1= 4; 0:8 ;63?:<1 013<20 >475:2:47 1 8B@D:28 2032 201 912:2:4716 :8 B7516 3 8232B246A 5B2A 24 964E:51 <:?02 =46F =0:>0 :8 8B:23@<1 24 201 90A8:>3< >475:2:47 4; 201 6189475172 0B8 01 >4721758 2032 201 3@4B6 4B62 038 23F17 >4?7:I37>1 4; 201 8232B246A 5B2A 375 038 5:61>215 201 912:2:4716 24 964E:51 0:D 3<2167321 =46F =0:>0 :8 71:2016 B7CB82 746 :D964916 03E1 >478:51615 201 8B@D:88:478 4; <136715 >4B781< ;46 201 912:2:4716 375 <136715 >4B781< ;46 201 6189475172 ' 013@4B6 4B6201<5203220154D182:>:7GB:6A >475B>2153?3:7822016189475172=38742;3:6375964916 01 6189475172 =38 1H3D:715 @1;461 201 3@4B6 4B62 375 01 9645B>15 54>BD1728 24 1823@<:80 2032 01 =38 8B;;16:7?;64D84D1:<<7188375=3826132152:8742201 >381 4; 201 912:2:4716 2032 20181 54>BD1728 =161 1:2016 - 8 - ;63B5B<17246;3@6:>3215 7201>472636A:2=38201>381 4; 201 912:2:4716 2032 201 6189475172 =38 @4B75 24 811F ;46<13E1@1;4613@8172:7?;64D=46F2:87454B@226B1 2032 :513<<A 201 6189475172 DB82 03E1 399<:15 ;46 <13E1 @1;461 3@8172:7? ;64D =46F 4=1E16 03E:7? 61?365 24 201 961>36:4B8 013<20 >475:2:47 4; 201 6189475172 :2 >37 @101<520322016189475172=38961E17215;64D322175:7? 24 =46F =0:>0 =38 5B1 24 3 613847 @1A475 0:8 >47264< 0161;461 201 9B7:80D172 4; 5:8D:883< =38 26B<A 5:89649462:47321 24 201 D:8>475B>2 0161 =38 74 D3216:3< 9645B>15 @1;461 201 3@4B6 4B62 @A 201 912:2:4716 24 1823@<:80 2032 201 6189475172 035 3 9382 0:8246A4;61D3:7:7?3@8172;64D=46F # 72032E:1=4;201D3221620:8 4B625418742 811 37A D:823F1 :7 201 3@4B6 4B62 8122:7? 38:51 201 46516 4; 5:8D:883< ;64D 816E:>1 375 :D948:7? 3 D:746 9173<2A 4; 615B>2:47 4; 471 :7>61D172 =:20 >BDB<32:E1 1;;1>272032E:1=4;201D3221620161:87420:7?=647? - 9 - :7201:D9B?71546516=366372:7?:7216;1617>117>1201 912:2:47<3>F8D16:2375:8 &' $ % :82 4$< 4 $ 28: