- 1 - ! ! "" #$%!% &$ ' ! " # " $ " " Digitally signed by NIJAMUDDIN JAMKHANDI Location: High Court Of Karnataka - 2 - % " $ & ' ( ) $ # " * ! & ' %!+ " ! !( " % !!) % % ( " %, - .!! )! ! " $$! % // " - 3 - / '/ ( 0121343456178905:713012;:4634<<8465#!! 56 301 <4;1 5< 301 ==43456:; 4>4; ?=@1 :6= % 4A:B:2?7: '016C1<5730 71<1771= 35 :8 /74:; 5?73/ <57 80573( 0:>1 <4;1= 3048 9743 21343456 C0:;;16@46@ 301 C5771C36188 5< :6 57=17=:31=!! )! !2:881=DB301==43456:;164574>4; ?=@1 4A:B:2?7: '016C1<5730 71<1771= 35 :8 /221;;:31 5?73/ <5780573(465$$! DB904C0301:221:;9:8:;;591= :6= 57=17 5< 463174E 46A?6C3456 @7:631= DB 301 74:; 5?73 56 ! ! 9:8813:84=1 ! 01 8?43 46 5#!! 9:8 <4;1= <57 =1C;:7:345630:3301=1C7112:881=465!*)! !56301 <4;1 5< 301 ==43456:; 4>4; ?=@1 '76( 4A:B:2?7: =:31= !$ *! !! 46 71821C3 5< 301 2752173B D1:746@ 5 *# 5< ":7= 5 4A:B:2?7: 48 461F1C?3:D;1 :6= :;8585?@03<57:=1C7115<=1C;:7:345630:330174@03:CC7?1=35 301 =1<16=:63 5! ?6=17 301 =5C?E163 =:31= $ ! !! 8355= 1F346@?4801= 5681G?163;B : =1C711 5< 217213?:; - 4 - 46A?6C3456 9:8 :;85 85?@03 35 71837:46 301 =1<16=:638 <75E C;:4E46@:6B74@035<9:B463018?432752173B # '4( 01 2;:4634<<8 C56316=1= 30:3 301 =1<16=:63 59:8301596175<5*#E1:8?746@# <3F <3 904C0 <1;; 35 048 80:71 ?6=17 : 2:7343456 =1C711 46 5!** 56 301 <4;1 5< 4>4; ?=@1 16457 4>48456 :@:;H53 01 =1<16=:63 5! 0:= <4;1= 5!*)! ! <57 217213?:;46A?6C3456:@:4683301=1<16=:6353571837:4604E <75E 5D837?C346@ 301 21:C1<?; ?81 5< 301 :<5718:4= ;:6= :8 :6 1:81E1633571:C0301E:4675:=:6=<57E:6=:357B46A?6C3456 35 71E5>1 301 C56837?C3456 9:;; :3 25463 // :6= // 01 8:4= 8?439:8C5E275E481=:6=:=1C7119:82:881=56!$ *! ! 8217301=1C711301=1<16=:635!9:8@4>1674@03352:88 5>17 301 ;:6= 35 71:C0 048 2752173B D1:746@ 5*#! :6= 5*## :6= *$$ 71@483171= 46837?E163 9:8 :;851F1C?31=56$ ! !DB301=1<16=:63546<:>5?7 5< 301 =1<16=:63 5! 217E43346@ 301 =1<16=:63 5! 35 9:;H5>17301;:6=D1:746@5*# '44( 01 =1<16=:63 5 C0:;;16@1= 301 8:4= =5C?E163 =:31=$ ! !!46:8?43<4;1=465$# ! ! - 5 - '444( ?746@301216=16CB5<3018?43301=1<16=:635 85;=3012752173BD1:746@55*#46<:>5?75< 301 2;:4634<<8 56 ! ! $ 46 317E8 5< 395 8:;1 =11=8 0171<571 301 =1<16=:63 5 <4;1= : E1E5 46 5$# ! ! 30:3 01 =4= 653 27188 301 8?43 :6= :CC57=46@;B 301 8?43 9:8 =48E4881= :8 653 271881= 01 =1<16=:635!3016<4;1=5#$! $<57=1C;:7:345630:3 01 0:8 : 74@03 5< 1:81E163 DB 2718C7423456 5>17 301 8?43 2752173B :6= 85?@03 <57 217213?:; 46A?6C3456 35 71837:46 301 2;:4634<<8<75E2?3346@?2:6BC56837?C345601=1<16=:635! :;85 <4;1= 5 #! ! :@:4683 301 2;:4634<< 5! <57 =1C;:7:3456 30:3 301 2752173B D1:746@ 5*# 9:8 71817>1= <57 301 C5EE56 ?81 :8 : 9:B 35 :2275:C0 5*#*#!:6=*##:6=5*$018:4= 8?439:8=48E4881=:8653271881=56*! #012;:4634<<8 30171<571C56316=30:3301=1<16=:635!@:>1?204874@035< 9:BDB9430=7:946@5 #! ! '4>( :317 301 =1<16=:63 5! <4;1= 1F1C?3456 21343456 ! !# 216=46@ 56 301 <4;1 5< ==43456:; 4>4; ?=@1 76 4A:B:2?7: :@:4683 301 =1<16=:63 5 35 1F1C?31 301 C5E275E481 =1C711 46 5!*)! ! :6= <57 :6 57=17 - 6 - =471C346@301=1<16=:63535=48E:63;19:;;:88059646 3018H13C0:33:C01=353012;:46301=1<16=:6359050:= 2?725731=;B85;=91831760:;<257345646<:>5?75<2;:4634<<5 :6=1:831760:;<257345646<:>5?75<2;:4634<<58!350:=65 8?D848346@ 74@03 :6= 301 217E488456 @7:631= 35 301 =1<16=:63 5! 0:= 82163 46 4381;< 01 2;:4634<<8 C;:4E1= 30:3 301 217E488456@7:631=35301=1<16=:635!?6=17301=5C?E163 =:31=$ ! !:6=C5E275E481=1C711465!*)! ! 9:8:E171;4C16C1:6=46>4195<3018:;15<3012752173BDB =1<16=:63 5 46 317E8 5< 301 8:;1 =11= =:31= ! ! $ 30174@03C71:31=DB301=1<16=:63546<:>5?75<=1<16=:63 5!8355=:?35E:34C:;;B1F346@?4801=0?8439:8C56316=1= 30:3 301 =1<16=:63 5! C:6653 275C11= 9430 301 1F1C?3456 21343456 <4;1= 35 1F1C?31 301 C5E275E481 =1C711 46 5!*)! ! 01 2;:4634<<8 30171<571 85?@03 <57 301 :<5718:4=71;14<8 '>( 01=1<16=:635!C5631831=3018?43:6=C;:4E1= 30:3301217E488456@7:631=DB301=1<16=:635DB9:B5< 301 C5E275E481 =1C711 46 5!*)! ! :6= DB 9:B 5< =5C?E163=:31=$ ! !91714671C5@6434565<30174@035< 301=1<16=:635!352:885>17301;:6=5<301=1<16=:635 - 7 - :6= 016C1 G?:;4<41= 35 D1 :6 1:81E163 DB 9:B 5< @7:63 1 :;85 C56316=1= 30:3 56C1 301 =1<16=:63 5 0:= :CC1=1= 35 301 1:81E163 5< =1<16=:63 5 301 8:E1 C5?;= 653 D1 9430=7:96577184;1= '>4( 6:22;4C:34569:8<4;1=DB3012;:4634<<8<57463174E 46A?6C34563571837:46301=1<16=:635!<75E71E5>46@301 9:;;;:4=:330116=5<3012752173BD1:746@5*# :6= 35 =471C3 301 =1<16=:638 35 E:463:46 83:3?8G?5 048 :22;4C:3456 9:8 C5631831= DB 301 =1<16=:63 5! 56 84E4;:7 ;4618 '>44( 0174:;5?73:<317C5684=1746@301C56316345685< 3012;:4634<<8:6==1<16=:635!@7:631=463174E46A?6C345646 <:>5?75<3012;:4634<<8:6=71837:461=301=1<16=:635!<75E 71E5>46@ 301 9:;; 146@ :@@741>1= DB 301 8:4= 57=17 301 =1<16=:635!<4;1=5$$! 01221;;:315?73:<317 217?846@30171C57=801;=30:3301C5E275E481163171=4635DB 301=1<16=:6358:6=!465!*)! !9:8C56C;?84>1 :6=D46=46@D139116=1<16=:6358:6=!:6=30:3 E171:;416:34565<3012752173B46<:>5?75<3012;:4634<<8=518 653 1F346@?480 301 74@03 C71:31= DB 301 =1<16=:63 5 46 - 8 - <:>5?75<=1<16=:635!5681G?163;B43:;;591=301:221:; :6=813:84=130157=172:881=DB30174:;5?73 $ 146@ :@@741>1= DB 301 8:E1 301 2;:4634<<8 :71 D1<57130485?73463048974321343456 1:761= C5?681; <57 301 2;:4634<<8 C56316=1= 30:3 301 C5E275E481 163171= 46 5!*)! ! 718?;31= 46 : =5C?E163 =:31= $ ! ! 904C0 9:8 46 301 6:3?71 5< : ;4C16C1:6=653:61:81E163:6=?2568:;15<3012752173B35 904C0 301 ;4C16C1 9:8 @7:631= 8?C0 ;4C16C1 @7:631= 8355= 1F346@?4801= DB 5217:3456 5< 1C3456 * 5< 301 6=4:6 :81E1638C3!71:=94304;;?837:3456'D(351C34565< 6=4:6:81E1638 C3130171<571C56316=830:330171 4865 1:81E163@7:631=46<:>5?75<301=1<16=:635!:6=016C1 301 2;:4634<<8 :71 16343;1= 35 2588188 301 2752173B DB 4@65746@ 301 ;4C16C1 30:3 9:8 @7:631= 35 301 =1<16=:63 5! 846C1 301 8:E18355=1F346@?4801= 17 C5637: 301 ;1:761= C5?681; <57 301 =1<16=:63 5!C56316=1=30:390:39:8@7:631=35301=1<16=:635! DB 9:B 5< C5E275E481 7125731= 46 5!*)! ! 9:8 :6 1:81E163 DB 9:B 5< @7:63 1 C56316=8 30:3 301 8:E1 9:8 - 9 - :CH659;1=@1=DB301=1<16=:635DB1F1C?346@:=5C?E163 =:31= $ ! ! 904C0 9:8 =?;B 71@483171= 1 30171<571 C56316=8 30:3 E171 C56>1B:6C1 5< 301 2752173B DB 301 =1<16=:63546<:>5?75<3012;:4634<<8=4=6531F346@?480301 1:81E163 DB 9:B 5< @7:63 46 <:>5?7 5< 301 =1<16=:63 5! 16C1 01 C56316=8 30:3 301 57=17 2:881= DB 301 221;;:31 5?7348A?83:6=275217:6==5186539:77:6346317<1716C16 8?22573 5< 048 C563163456 01 71;41= ?256 301 <5;;5946@ A?=@E1638 '4( ! "#$ '44( 17546530'E4657(8180:EE:;! !!#$+ '444(7:=1124;57257:34568?64C42:;57257:34565< 1;04:6=67! '!( :76:3:H:#$+ '4>(7 ?E:7 I 78 8 :E:;46@:E ! * #$ ) <31701:746@301;1:761=C5?681;<5730121343456178 :6= ;1:761= C5?681; <57 301 718256=1638 3048 5?73 48 5< 301 5246456 30:3 8?D83:634:; G?1834568 5< ;:9 :74818 <57 C5684=17:3456463018?43 6 301 561 0:6= 301 2;:4634<<8 C;:4E1= 30:3 90:3 9:8C71:31=DB301=1<16=:63546<:>5?75<301=1<16=:63 - 10 - 5! 9:8 : ;4C16C1 904C0 9:8 8?8C1234D;1 35 1F346C3456 ?6=17 301 C47C?E83:6C18 275>4=1= ?6=17 1C3456 * :6= 4;;?837:3456 'D(351C34565<6=4:6:81E1638C3!301=1<16=:63 5!C56316=835301C5637:7B:6=C;:4E1=30:390:39:8@4>16 9:8 :6 1:81E163 DB 9:B 5< @7:63 :6= E171 1F48316C1 5< :6530179:B3571:C03012752173B5<301=1<16=:635!=518 6531F346@?480301@7:63E:=146<:>5?75<301=1<16=:635! 0171<571 30181 :71 2?71 G?1834568 5< ;:9 30:3 71G?471 35 D1 C5684=171= 46 301 8?43 :6= 8:E1 611=8 35 D1 3741= 46C1 301 2;:4634<<80:>1659=1>1;521=3012752173B:6=0:>116C;581= 3012752173BD1:746@5*#:6=0:>14683:;;1=1;1C374C 37:68<57E178 :=A:C163 35 301 C5E25?6= 9:;; 43 48 653 :2275274:31:3304883:@135C5E21;3012;:4634<<83571E5>1301 9:;; :6= 71;5C:31 301 37:68<57E178 0171<571 301 2;:4634<<8 0:>1E:=15?3:C:81<57@7:635<:657=175<46A?6C3456:6= 016C1 301 4E2?@61= 57=17 2:881= DB 301 221;;:31 5?73 =1817>1835D1813:84=1:6=846C13016:3?715<3012752173B 0:8659C0:6@1=4348:2275274:3135=471C3D5303012:7341835 E:463:4683:3?8G?55<301:<5718:4=2752173B?634;=48258:;5< 301 8?43 01 =1<16=:63 5! 905 0:8 : 9:B 35 71:C0 048 - 11 - 2752173B95?;=6538?<<17:6B0:7=804257=4<<4C?;3B4<30157=17 2:881=DB30174:;5?73487183571= * 5681G?163;B 3048 21343456 48 =482581= 5<< 813346@ :84=1 301 57=17 =:31= !! )! ! 2:881= DB 301 221;;:31 5?73 46 5$$! :6= 71835746@ 301 57=17 =:31= ! ! 2:881= DB 301 74:; 5?73 46 5#!! 48 7183571= 348E:=1C;1:730:33012;:4634<<880:;;6532?3?2 :6B 5D837?C3456 57 90:3851>17 6:3?71 46 301 2752173B 53017 30:6 90:3 1F4838 :8 56 =:31 3 48 611=;188 35 E163456 30:3 4< 301 2;:4634<<8 <:4; 46 30147 8?43 301 =1<16=:638 :71 16343;1= 35 2?78?1301471F1C?345621343456351F1C?31301=1C7112:881=46 5!*)! !46C13018?4348<4;1=46301B1:7! 301 74:; 5?73 48 71G?1831= 35 =482581 5<< 301 8?43 :8 1:7;B :8 25884D;1 :6= 46 :CC57=:6C1 9430 :76:3:H:':81 %;59 :6:@1E16346?D57=46:315?738(?;18! !() &%' % 4835;5$)