Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 12414 (KAR)
THE DIVISIONAL MANAGER v. KIRAN KUMAR KADI AND ANR
MFA/201028/2021 · 2025-02-04
C M Joshi
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 12414 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 12414 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "
" ##$%
& '
(
! "
# $ %&' %
#
(
'&&
& #
%
$ %
#
LUCYGRACE Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Date: 2025.02.13 10:52:12 - 0800
- 2 -
(
&)#'*)+
! , &
"
)-!"
$
&&&
&*&&&
--+#&*
$
$
%
% . $
$
" !% .
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
:8 5645/14/2 =>67;> 0 87;;/8=:64:8C02/=6:4=>/51688/H0C:40=:640@67=:= =>/1/:80@8637=/3A46C0=/1:03641/56128>6D:4;=>0==>/1/ D08>/02645633:8:64>/5>01;/8>//=46D>/1/:42:50=/8 =>/9/=:=:64/1>0?:4;564=1:@7=/2<61=>/4/;3:;/45/>/1/ :8 0@8637=/3A 46 :42/9/42/4= /?:2/45/ 64 @/>03< 6< =>/ 4871045/ 6C904A =6 2/C648=10=/ =>0= =>/1/ D08 0 564=1:@7=61A 4/;3:;/45/ >/45/ =>:8 564=/4=:64 6< =>/ - 11 - 099/3304=:8@/1/<=6<04AC/1:=8042/?:2/45/04208875> =>/80C/:83:0@3/=6@/1/B/5=/2 && /45/=>/<6336D:4;% !:" >/099/03:80336D/2:4901= !::" >/ :C97;4/2 B72;C/4= 042 0D012 9088/2 @A =>/ 1:@7403 :8 >/1/@A C62:<:/2 !:::" >/ 9/=:=:64/1 :8 /4=:=3/2 <61 8'*)+# D:=> :4=/1/8= 0= +J 9/10447C<16C=>/20=/6<9/=:=:64 =:33 :=8 1/03:L0=:64 08 0;0:48= 8+)&# 0D012/2 @A =>/ 1:@7403 !:?" >/ 099/3304= :8 2:1/5=/2 =6 2/968:= =>/56C9/480=:640C674=D:=>:4<671 D//I8 <16C =>/ 20=/ 6< =>:8 B72;C/4= - 12 - !?" >/ 0C674= :4 2/968:= :8 612/1/2 =6 @/ =1048C:==/2 =6 =>/ 1:@7403 <61=>D:=> 2# % " ' " :8= 6%3 6%) %