Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 12412 (KAR)

SMT. ANJANA v. SHREE HATKESHWARA CARGO MOVERS AND ANR

MFA/200967/2021 · 2025-02-24

C M Joshi

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - ! "" # $ $ %%& ' ( ) ! " # $ % &' ()%&* (% (+&,' ('!'%& " # - %%%%&%% $ Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - %,#%$ %,&%&% *& &%+ !%'&& ( . $ # .$ /012 34/ 5/016/2 7896:/5 0;;/01<6= >81 34/ 0;;/5506306234/5/016/27896:/5>811/:;862/638 4<: 0;;/05 <: 2<1/73/2 0=0<6:3 34/ ?92=@/63 0620A012203/2%,&%&%;0::/2<68*& &%+ BC 34/ 5/016/2 22<3<8605 /6<81 <D<5 92=/ 062 /@B/1 050B910=<#4/1/<60>3/11/>/11/2380:E34/ 1<B9605F>81:4813$ , C 34/ <@;9=6/2 ?92=@/63 062 0A012 34/ 1<B9605 40: 0558A/2 34/ 750<@ ;/3<3<86 <6 ;013 062 0A012/2 0 :9@ 8> :*+'&& ( 0: 78@;/6:03<86 062 2<1/73/2 34/ 6:91067/ 8@;06C 38 2/;8:<3 34/ :0@/ - 3 - ==1</D/2BC34/:0<2?92=@/630620A01234/;/3<3<86/1 <: B/>81/ 34<: 8913 ://G<6= /64067/@/63 8> 78@;/6:03<86 7863/62<6= 3403 34/ H90639@ 8> 78@;/6:03<86 0A012/2 BC 34/ 1<B9605 <: 86 34/ 58A/1 :<2/ ) 4/ >073905 @031<I 8> 34/ 70:/ <: 3403 86 *&)&%+ A4<5/ 34/ ;/3<3<86/1 A0: ;187//2<6= 86 0 @83817C75/ B/01<6= 8 ,+')+ 0586= A<34 4/1 49:B062:4/@/3A<3406077<2/63A<340306G/1B/01<6= 8% +&,' 062 :9:30<6/2 <6?91</: <6 34/ :0<2 077<2/63 ' 4/>0739@8>34/077<2/63062<6D85D/@/638> 34/306G/15811C8A6/2BC1/:;862/638%062<6:91/2BC 1/:;862/638<:683<62<:;93/4/<6:91067/78D/10=/ 3834/:0<2D/4<75/<:05:86832<:;93/ * 4/ ;/3<3<86/1 750<@<6= 3403 :4/ <: 0=/2 0B893 ' C/01: 062 /016<6= :%'&&& ( ;/1 @8634 BC A81G<6= 0: 06 0=1<79539105 7885</ ><5/2 0 750<@ ;/3<3<86 ://G<6= 02/H903/ 78@;/6:03<86 :<67/ :4/ :9>>/1/2 ;/1@06/63 - 4 - 2<:0B<5<3C 86 0778963 8> 34/ >107391/ 8> 102<9: 9560 062 >107391/8>34/877<;<305B86/062'34@/30701;056812/1 380::/::34/2<:0B<5<3C34/3/:3<@86C8> :062,A0: 5/3<6B/>81/34/1<B9605 4/ 1<B9605 0>3/1 4/01<6= 34/ 01=9@/63: BC B834:<2/:06286;/19:058>34/1/7812:40:0::/::/234/ 683<8605<678@/8>34/;/3<3<86/103:%,'& (;/1@8634 062 34/ 2<:0B<5<3C 03 %'J 062 34/1/BC 0A012/2 0 78@;/6:03<86 8> :*+'&& ( 962/1 2<>>/1/63 4/02: 0: B/58A 8A012:<6?91C;0<6062:9>>/1<6= :)&&&& ( 8A012:@/2<705/I;/6:/: :%'*,&& ( 8A012:>9391/@/2<705/I;/6:/: :%&&&& ( 8A012: >882 062 /I310 6891<:4@/63 062@/2<705033/62063 :')&& ( 8A012:786D/C067/ :%&&&& ( 8A012: 58:: 8> <678@/ 291<6= 31/03@/63 :*'&& ( 8A012:;/1@06/632<:0B<5<3C :)+,&& ( /;1<D03<868>>9391/0@/6<3</: :&&&& ( 830578@;/6:03<86 :*+'&& ( ! 4/5/016/27896:/50;;/01<6=>8134/;/3<3<86/1 7863/62:340334/1<B960540:6830::/::/234/2<:0B<5<3C <6 0 ;18;/1 @066/1 4/ 2<:0B<5<3C 01<:<6= 893 8> 34/ - 5 - >107391/:8>34/9;;/15<@B06234/2<:0B<5<3C877911/229/ 3834/4/02<6?91C:4895240D/B//6786:<2/1/2BC<3B93 86 34/ 834/1 4062 <3 865C 786:<2/1/2 %'J 0: 34/ >9673<8605 2<:0B<5<3C 4/1/>81/ 34/1/ <: 0 6//2 >81 /64067/@/638>34/78@;/6:03<863<::9B@<33/2340334/ 2<:0B<5<3C 0::/::/2 BC 062 , :48952 40D/ B//6 022/238011<D/03060;;18;1<03/2<:0B<5<3C + /1 786310 34/ 5/016/2 7896:/5 0;;/01<6= >81 34/1/:;862/6387863/62:340334/1/<:68?9:3<><703<86 >81 34/ 2<:0B<5<3C B/<6= /64067/2 0: 750<@/2 BC 34/ ;/3<3<86/1 4/ 7863/62: 3403 B/<6= 34/ 31/03/2 28738140:0::/::/2;4C:<7052<:0B<5<3C03,&J4/ , B/<6= 0 ;/1:86 A48 <: 683 H905<></2 38 0::/:: 34/ 6/91858=<705 2<:0B<5<3C 01<:<6= 893 8> 34/ 4/02 <6?91C 4<: /D<2/67/ 40: B//61<=435C2<:7012/2 BC 34/ 1<B9605 4/ 05:8;8<63:8933403 ,40:68331/03/234/;/3<3<86/103 06C3<@/ 8 >01 0: 34/ 78@;/6:03<86 <6 1/:;/73 8> 34/ 1/@0<6<6=4/02::4/2/>/62:34/<@;9=6/2?92=@/63 - 6 - %& 4/ ;/3<3<86/1 0=/2 0B893 ' C/01: 40: :9>>/1/2 34/ <6?91</: A4<74 01/ 2/;<73/2 <6 34/ A8962 7/13<><703/0:A/550:34/2<:0B<5<3C7/13<><703/<::9/2BC34/ 4/C8B:/1D/3403A4/634/;/3<3<86/1A0:02@<33/2 86*&)&%+:4/40278@/A<3434/>8558A<6=<6?91</:( %$ //;793507/103/2A8962<64C;834/6011/=<86A<34 507/103<868>>5/I810620B297381:8>5<335/><6=/1062 4C;834/601@9:75/: $ 107391/8>58A/1102<9:5/>3 ,$ 107391/58A/1,1295605/>3 )$ 107391/6/7G8>'34@/30701;055/>3 '$ <503/105>186305B/@81140=<778639:<86 %% 4/ 1/7812: 05:8 :48A 3403 31/03/2 34/ ;/3<3<86/1 >81 34/ <6?91</: 38 34/ 5/>3 9;;/1 5<@B 062 4/ 28/:683:0C06C34<6=0B89334/4/02<6?91C4/48:;<305 1/7812: 5<G/ 2<:7401=/ :9@@01C 03 I :48A 3403 34/ ;/3<3<86/1 402 05:8 :9>>/1/2 34/ 4/02 <6?91C 062 34/ 8;<6<86 8> 34/ 6/918:91=/86 A0: 05:8 30G/6 291<6= 34/ 31/03@/634/;/3<3<86/14021/;813/23834/48:;<305A<34 4<:381C 8> 58:: 8> 786:7<89:6/:: 0: A/55 0: D8@<3<6= 4/ - 7 - 1/7812:1/D/05340334/7068>34/10<6A0:30G/686 &' 8770:<86: 291<6= 34/ <6;03</63 31/03@/63 38 :// A4/34/1 34/ 4/02 <6?91C A4<74 <67592/2 B<503/105 >186305 4/@81140=<7 78639:<86 <: 1/:;862<6= 38 34/ 31/03@/63 81 683 4/ 2<:7401=/ :9@@01C 05:8 @/63<86: 3403 786:/1D03<D/@/34828>31/03@/63A0:028;3/2 % 4/ 3/:3<@86C 8> 34/ , 789;5/2 A<34 34/ 2<:0B<5<3C 7/13<><703/ <::9/2 BC 4<@ 03 I ! A8952 :48A 3403 34/1/ <: 2/0>6/:: <6 34/ 1<=43 /01 34/ ;/3<3<86/1 <: 960B5/387011CA/<=438634/4/0234/1/<:6/7G;0<6062 1/:31<73/2 6/7G @8D/@/63: 062 34/ =0<3 <: 96:30B5/ 062 7093<89:489=434/ ,<:6830/918:91=/86062683 087381 4840231/03/234/;/3<3<86/134/8B:/1D03<86: @02/ BC 4<@ 01/ 1/5/D063 3 <: 0 :91;1<:<6= 3403 /D/6 3489=434/;/3<3<86/1402/I0@<6/2 8678@@<::<86 6834<6= <: /5<7<3/2 >18@ 4<@ 0B893 34/ 4/02 <6?91</: :9>>/1/2BC34/;/3<3<86/1<@<5015C34/1/<:6834<6=<634/ 3/:3<@86C 8> , 062 4<: 2<:0B<5<3C 7/13<><703/ 03 I ! 0B89334/<6?91</::9>>/1/23834/5/>39;;/15<@B634<: - 8 - =18962 34/ 5/016/2 7896:/5 0;;/01<6= >81 34/ ;/3<3<86/1 :9B@<3:340334/2<:0B<5<3C:303/2BC 03,&J06234/ 2<:0B<5<3C:303/2BC ,03,J01/38B/022/2 %, 4/ 0B8D/ :9B@<::<86 706683 B/ 077/;3/2 >81 34/ :<@;5/ 1/0:86 3403 34/ 8913 40: 38 786:<2/1 34/ >9673<8605 2<:0B<5<3C B93 683 34/ ;4C:<705 2<:0B<5<3C 4/ 60391/8>34/2<>><7953</:683/2BC <64<:3/:3<@86C0: A/55 0: 34/ 2<:0B<5<3C 7/13<><703/ 03 I + 062 05:8 34/ 3/:3<@86C 8> 34/ , 789;5/2 A<34 34/ 2<:0B<5<3C 7/13<><703/ 03 I ! A8952 2<:758:/ 3403 34/1/ <: :8@/ 2<>><7953C >81 34/ ;/3<3<86/1 38 28 34/ 7885</ A81G 62/1 34/:/ 7<179@:3067/: <6 34/ 786:<2/1/2 8;<6<86 8> 34<: 8913 40D<6= =<D/6 :9>><7</63 A/<=43 38 34/ 3/:3<@86C 8> 34/ A48<:031/03/228738134/>9673<86052<:0B<5<3C <:0::/::/203%!J %) 4/683<8605<678@/786:<2/1/2BC34/1<B9605 03:%,'& (286831/H9<1/06C1/786:<2/103<86BC34<: 89134/1/>81/34/58::8>>9391/<678@/<:70579503/20: - 9 - :%,'& (I%I%!I%!JK:'%'%*& (BC028;3<6= 0@953<;5</18>%!>8134/0=/8>'C/01: %' 4/1<B960540:0A012/234/78@;/6:03<868> :*'&& (38A012:34/58::8><678@/291<6=34/50<29; ;/1<8234/:0@/6//2:38B//64067/2>81,@8634:</ :%,'& (I,K:,+'& ( %* 4/1<B960540:0A012/20:9@8>:)&&&& ( 962/134/4/028>;0<6062:9>>/1<6=34/:0@/6//2:38 B//64067/238:*&&&& ( % 4/ 40: :303/2 0B893 34/ >9391/ @/2<705 /I;/6:/: 1/=012<6= 1/@8D05 8> 34/ <@;5063: /37 062 0::/::/2 34/ 78:3 8> :!&&& ( 4/1/>81/ 0 :9@ 8> :,&&&& ( 40: 38 B/ 0A012/2 962/1 34/ 4/02 8> >9391/ @/2<705/I;/6:/: %! 4/1<B960540:0A012/20:9@8>:')&& ( 962/134/4/028>>882062/I3106891<:4@/63033/62063 7401=/: /37 34/ :0@/ 6//2: 38 B/ /64067/2 38 - 10 - :%'&&& (786:<2/1<6=34/>0733403:4/A0:<6;03</63>81 0;/1<828>%20C: %+ 4/ 78@;/6:03<86 962/1 34/ 4/02 8> 58:: 8> 0@/6<3</:6//2:38B//64067/238:)&&&& ( & 4/ 1<B9605 40: 0A012/2 1/0:860B5/ 78@;/6:03<86 0@8963 38A012: @/2<705 /I;/6:/: 062 786D/C067/4/:0@/6//2683B/2<:391B/2 % 4/1/>81/ 34/ 750<@063 <: /63<35/2 >81 34/ @82<></278@;/6:03<86962/12<>>/1/634/02:0:B/58A( 5 8 /02: 8@;/6:03<86 A012/2 BC 34<: 8913 % 8A012:58::8>>9391/<678@/ :'%'%*& ( 8A012:58::8><678@/291<6= 34/50<29;;/1<82 :,+'& ( , 8A012: 0<6062:9>>/1<6= :*&&&& ( ) 8A012:>9391/@/2<705/I;/6:/: :,&&&& ( ' 8A012:>882062/I310 6891<:4@/63062@/2<705 033/62063 :%'&&& ( * 8::8>0@/6<3</: :)&&&& ( 8A012:@/2<705/I;/6:/: :%'*,&& ( ! 8A012:786D/C067/ :%&&&& ( 8305 /::A012/2BC34/1<B9605 :!**%& ( :*+'&& ( 8305/64067/@/63 :%*!%& ( - 11 - 49: 34/ 0;;/55063 <: /63<35/2 >81 /64067/2 78@;/6:03<868>:%*!%& (A<34<63/1/:3 /67/ 0;;/05 2/:/1D/: 38 B/ 0558A/2 <6 ;013 4/1/>81/34/>8558A<6=- 4/0;;/05<:0558A/2<6;013 4/ <@;9=6/2 ?92=@/63 062 0A012 ;0::/2 BC 34/ 1<B9605<:@82<></2 4/ 0;;/55063 <: /63<35/2 >810:9@8> :%*!%& ( <6022<3<8638A40340:B//60A012/2BC34/1<B9605 0586=A<34<63/1/:30334/103/8>*J;0>18@203/ 8>;/3<3<863<5534/203/8>2/;8:<3 /:3 8> 34/ 812/1 ;0::/2 BC 34/ 1<B9605 1/=012<6= 2/;8:<3/371/@0<6:96053/1/2 2 ( & $ ( $ <:38%58)'