Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 12411 (KAR)
RAMESH @ RAMANNA v. SYED AHAD PASHA AND ORS
MFA/200815/2021 · 2025-01-22
C M Joshi
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 12411 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 12411 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "
#
! ! $
!"
# $# % & %
# $'
&%% ( )
'" '' %%%
"
%%"
%'' *"
%
"$+( $ % & % (
%'%$ % , #
"$+( $ %
LUCYGRACE Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Date: 2025.01.28 18:03:37 - 0800
- 2 -
& % (
%
%% % % ( )
%
'" % - . % % ! %
%#
%%
! "
# %%" ,% % # % % % *
% +* '" %%% %
,%
%
$' %
(+ # /
! # /
%
%",% #%
% %
0'
, ,
! 0'
, ,
1234 5123614 7896:15 2;;123<6= >83 ?@1 2;;15526?;1?<?<8613 264 5123614 7896:15 2;;123<6= >83 31:;86416?8 A6:9326718B;26C
- 3 -
8?<71 ?8 31:;86416? 8: 264 @2: D116 4<:;16:14E<?@
@89=@?@1B2??13<::52?14>8324B<::<86DC?@1 786:16?8>D8?@;23?<1:<?<:?2F169;>83><6254<:;8:25
(
@<: 2;;125 <: DC ?@1 752<B26?;1?<?<8613 2=2<6:? ?@1 G94=B16? 264 2E234 42?14 * ;2::14 <6 8+*86?@1><518>?@1893?8>44<?<8625%<:?3<7? 2641::<86:,94=1264 2? 2<7@93>83:@83??@1
3<D9625 :11F<6= 16@2671B16? 8> 78B;16:2?<86 2E23414 DC?@1 3<D9625
@1;1?<?<8613E@8:9>>1314277<416?25<6G93<1:<6 2 3824 ?32>><7 277<416? 86 @24 2;;3827@14 ?@1
3<D9625 :11F<6= 78B;16:2?<86 ? E2: ?@1 72:1 8> ?@1 ;1?<?<86132;;15526? ?@2? E@<51 @1 E2: ;<55<86 3<413 86 ?@1 B8?837C751 8> @<: >3<164 ?@1 833C 43<H16 DC 31:;86416? 88E614DC31:;86416?8264<6:9314DC31:;86416? 8 72B1 <6 @<=@ :;114 264 42:@14 2=2<6:? ?@1 :2<4 B8?837C75131:95?<6=<6;1?<?<8613:9:?2<6<6=:1H131<6G93<1:
@1;1?<?<8613E2:@8:;<?25<I142? 8:;<?25 2<7@93>83
- 4 -
2D89?(42C: @1317834:31H12514?@2?@1@24:9>>1314 41=58H<6= <6G93C >38B ?@1 ?@<=@ ?8 F611 8> ?@1 51>? 51= E<?@ B9:751:264?16486:1J;8:14264@1@24?896413=8?16486 31;2<3 264 8?@13 :97@ :93=13<1: 2? 8:;<?25 2<7@93
@1317834:31H125?@2?:97@41=58H<6=<6G93C<::1H131264 1H162>?13?@1?312?B16??@1;1?<?<8613<::9>>13<6=
+ 123614 7896:15 2;;123<6= >83 ?@1 ;1?<?<8613 E8954 :9DB<? ?@2? ?@1 ;1?<?<8613 D1<6= 2 2:86 DC ;38>1::<86 2=14 2D89? C123: :9>>1314 2 ;@C:<725 4<:2D<5<?C 8> / 2: 8;<614 DC ?@1 14<725 '8234 8> 8:;<?25 2<7@93 @131>831@1:9DB<?:?@2??@1>967?<8625 4<:2D<5<?C2::1::14DC?@1 3<D96252?/<:<6:9>><7<16?264 ?@1 :2B1 6114: ?8 D1 16@26714 77834<6= ?8 @<B 2 >967?<86254<:2D<5<?C8>/@2:?8D1?2F161:9DB<?:?@2? ?@1;1?<?<8613D1<6=22:862??@12=18> C123:72668? 248;? @<B:15> ?8 2 4<>>1316? ;38>1::<86 264 <? @2: D178B1 4<>><795? >83 @<B ?8 75<BD ?@1 :72>>854<6=: 264 ?8 1236 @<: 5<H15<@884
! 5123614 7896:15 2;;123<6= >83 31:;86416? 8 6:932671 8B;26C E8954 :9DB<? ?@2? - 5 -
?@89=@ ?@1 14<725 '8234 @24 =<H16 4<:2D<5<?C 8> / ?@1
3<D9625@2::9>><7<16?5C786:<41314?@14<:2D<5<?C2648;<614 ?@2? <? E8954 D1 / 264 ?@131>831 68 <6?13>131671 83 <6495=1671<:31K9<314DC?@<:893? ? E8954 D1 :9>><7<16? ?8 68?1 ?@2? ?@1 >967?<8625 4<:2D<5<?C264?@1;@C:<7254<:2D<5<?C231?E84<>>1316?2:;17?: @C:<7254<:2D<5<?CE8954D12::1::14DC?@114<725>><713:
D2:14 86 ?@1 31:?3<7?<86: ?@2? @2H1 731;?<6 2>?13 ?@1 277<416?: 264 <6G93<1: DH<89:5C 2 14<725 >><713 E8954 68?D1<6?@1F68E514=18>?@1D27F=389648>?@1<6G9314264 @<: ;38>1::<86 @1 <6G93<1: :9>>1314 E8954 @2H1 2 4<317? D123<6=86?@1>967?<8625<?C8>?@1;13:86264@<:2H872?<86 264 <? B2C 2>>17?
?@1 17868B<7 ;8:<?<86 25:8 6 2 31716? G94=B16?<6?@172:18>
<6
417<414 86 ?@1 ;1J 893? @2: 68?14 ?@2? ?@1 ;@C:<725 4<:2D<5<?C 87793314 86 277896? 8> 58:: 8> 861 1C1 ?8 2 %<2B8649??13E895431:95?<6>967?<86254<:2D<5<?C8>/
@131>831 <? <: ?@1 49?C 8> ?@1 3<D9625 ?8 786:<413 ?@1
- 6 -
>967?<8625 4<:2D<5<?C <6 ?@1 5<=@? 8> ?@1 2H872?<86 264 ?@1 ;@C:<7254<:2D<5<?C8;<614DC?@114<725>><713
* 6?@172:186@264E@16?@1;@C:<7254<:2D<5<?C 8>/<:G9J?2;8:142=2<6:??@12H872?<868>?@1;1?<?<8613 E@<7@<:B2:863C26425:8<6?@15<=@?8>?@1>27??@2?@1<:
2=14 C123:<?E8954D1G9:?264;38;13?8@854?@2??@1 >967?<86254<:2D<5<?CE8954D1 /
@1 =9<415<61: <::914 DC ?@1 $2362?2F2 ?2?1 1=2513H<71:9?@83<?C>83:1??51B16?8>?@14<:;9?1:D1>831 ?@18F4252?;31:73<D1?@168?<8625<678B18> :! >83 ?@1 C123 6 9B;?116 69BD13 8> 417<:<86: ?@<: 893?@2:@154?@2??@1=9<415<61:<::914DC?@1$231 ?8 D1 2771;?2D51 86 ?@1 =38964 ?@2? ?@1C 231 <6 =161325 786>83B<?C E<?@ ?@1 B<6<B9B E2=1: ><J14 96413 ?@1 <6<B9B#2=1:7? @131>831?@12771;?<6=?@168?<8625 <678B18>?@12;;15526?2: :!;13B86?@?@158:: 8> >9?931 1236<6= 86 277896? 8> 4<:2D<5<?C <: 7257952?14 2? :!JJ+J /L :+!+86:1K916?5C ?@178B;16:2?<86>832;13<848>(B86?@:M2:52<49;;13<84 <:7257952?142:!J(L :(! @1 3<D9625@24
- 7 -
2E23414 :?8E234:58::8>2B16<?<1:E@<7@<:25:8 86 ?@1 58E13 :<41 1671 ?@1 :2B1 <: <67312:14 ?8 :DC244<6= :
@178B;16:2?<862E23414DC?@1 3<D962596413 31B2<6<6= @124: 481: 68? 31K9<31 26C <6495=1671 DC ?@<:
893? @9:?@12;;15526?<:16?<?514>83?8?2578B;16:2?<86 8> :+(! 2: 2=2<6:? :(+ 2E23414 DC ?@1
3<D962596413>8558E<6=@124:
5 8 124: E234DC
3<D9625 E234DC ?@<:893? 2<6264:9>>13<6= :( :(
14<7251J;16:1: :* :*
??16426?M:@23=1: : : ( 8:: 8> <678B1 493<6= ?312?B16? : + :(! 8::8>B16<?<1: : : + 8::8>>9?931<678B1 :* :+!+ ! 884 264 893<:@B16? 264786H1C26717@23=1: : :
:(+ :+(! @131E<55D116@2671B16?8> :(+
6H<1E8>?@12D8H1?@1>8558E<6=
- 8 -
<
@12;;125<:2558E14<6;23? <<
@1<B;9=614G94=B16?2642E234;2::14DC ?@1 3<D9625<:@131DCB84<><14DC2E234<6=2 :9B 8> :(+ 2: 78B;16:2?<86 <6 244<?<86 ?8 E@2? @2: D116 2E23414 DC ?@1
3<D96252586=E<?@<6?131:?2??@132?18>+/ ;2 >38B ?@1 42?1 8> ;1?<?<86 ?<55 <?: 41;8:<? D1>831?@1 3<D9625 <<<
@1 31:;86416? 8 A6:932671 8B;26C <: 4<317?14?841;8:<??@116@2671478B;16:2?<86 2B896? E<?@<6 >893 E11F: >38B ?@1 42?1 8> 3171<;?8>278;C8>?@<:G94=B16? <H
@131:?8>?@1?13B:2647864<?<86:31=234<6= 41;8:<? 31512:11?7 8341314DC ?@1 3<D9625 31B2<69625?1314
4 %
! & ! ' <:?858! $