- 1 - !! "# # $$ %& ' ( ! " # $ $ ! %& " $ '&%( ) $ $ Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - $ * " '(#( + " "" '%#( $ * '&%( " + $ '&%( ) $ * , ' , (&( * * * * ((( $ $ - %(% * * .$ - 3 - # .$ /012 34/ 5/016/2 7896:/5 0;;/01<6= >81 34/ 0;;/55063: 062 5/016/2 7896:/5 0;;/01<6= >81 1/:;862/63 8 $/<6= 0==1</?/2 @A 34/ B92=C/63 062 0D012 203/2 ((( ;0::/2 <6 8%(% @A 34/ 5/016/2 22<3<8605 <:31<73 E /::<86: 92=/ 062 /C@/18-<B0A0;9104/1/<60>3/11/>/11/238 0:F34/1<@9605G>81:4813 34/750<C063:0;;18074/234<: 8913<60;;/05://H<6=/64067/C/638>78C;/6:03<8686 07789638>2/0348>86/8406 $A 34/ <C;9=6/2 B92=C/63 34/ 1<@9605 40: 0D012/2 0 :9C 8> :%(%' 0: 78C;/6:03<86 38=/34/1D<34<63/1/:303%I;00622<1/73/234/8D6/1 382/;8:<334/:0C/ # 4/ >073905 C031<J 8> 34/ 70:/ <: 3403 86 (&(%(%030@893+((;C86950B0;91'850;911802 - 4 - 2/7/0:/2 8406 D0: 310?/5<6= 86 C83817A75/ @/01<6= 8'$' 3 3403 3<C/ 34/ 21<?/1 8> 34/ 3197H @/01<6= 8''(#( 70C/ >18C 8;;8:<3/ :<2/ <6 10:40626/=5<=/63C066/106220:4/23834/C83817A75/ 709:<6= <6B91</: 38 2/7/0:/2 8406 062 D4<5/ 4/ D0: 962/1=8<6= 31/03C/63 03 :4D<6< 8:;<305 4/ 2</2 86 (+(%(%4/;/3<3<86/1:750<C<6=340334/077<2/63D0: 29/ 38 34/ 6/=5<=/67/ 8> 34/ 5811A 21<?/1 34/A @/<6= 34/ 2/;/62/63: 750<C 78C;/6:03<86 >18C 34/ 8D6/1 062 <6:91/18>34/5811A & 6 :/1?<7/ 8> 683<7/ 1/:;862/63 8 2<2 683 0;;/01 062 0: :974 ;507/2 J';013/ /:;862/63 8 ' 6:91067/8C;06A0;;/01/234189=4<3:5/016/27896:/5 0621/:<:3/234/;/3<3<86 % /:;862/6387863/62/234030:8634/203/ 8>34/077<2/6334/;85<7AD0:?05<2@9334/21<?/18>34/ ?/4<75/D0:68340?<6=0?05<221<?<6=5<7/6:/<6>817/: - 5 - :97434/3/1C:0627862<3<86:8>34/;85<7A01/?<8503/2 4/1/>81/34/;/3<3<86<:5<0@5/38@/2<:C<::/2 6 34/ @0:<: 8> 34/ 0@8?/ 7863/63<86: 34/ 1<@9605 40: >10C/2 0;;18;1<03/ <::9/: 4/ ;/3<3<86/1: /J0C<6/23D8D<36/::/:8634/<1:<2/0:'062' 062 C01H/2 ><>3//6 2879C/63: 0: J' 38 J'& <6 /?<2/67/ 4/ 8>><7<05 8> 1/:;862/63 8 D0: /J0C<6/2 0: '062 J '3 J 'D/1/C01H/2<6/?<2/67/ >3/14/01<6=34/01=9C/63:34/1<@96054/52 340334/;/3<3<86/1:01//63/1/2>81 :%(%'962/1 34/>8558D<6=4/02: 5 8 /02: 8C;/6:03<86 D012/2 8D012:8::8>2/;/62/67A :(((((' 8D012:8::8>786:813<9C :#((((' 8D012:*96/105 J;/6:/: :&(((' # 8D012:8::8> :303/ :&(((' & 8D012:/2<705 J;/6:/: :%%&(&' % 8D012:033/620637401=/: 6891<:4C/63>8820622</3 :&(((' 8305 :%(%' - 6 - + 8D/?/1<3>0:3/6/234/5<0@<5<3A861/:;862/63 8 86 34/ =18962 3403 34/ 21<?<6= 5<7/6:/ 8> 34/ 5811A 21<?/1D0:683<6>817/0:86203/8>34/077<2/63 ( $/<6= 0==1</?/2 @A 34/ K90639C 8> 34/ 78C;/6:03<86 0D012/2 @A 34/ 1<@9605 062 34/ >0:3/6<6= 34/5<0@<5<3A861/:;862/63834/;/3<3<86/1:01/@/>81/ 34<:8913<634/0;;/05 4/ 5/016/2 7896:/5 0;;/01<6= >81 34/ 0;;/55063: D8952 :9@C<3 3403 <3 <: 683 0 70:/ D4/1/ 34/ 21<?/18>34/8>>/62<6=?/4<75/402685<7/6:/@938634/ 834/1 4062 34/ 21<?/1 402 0 ?05<2 21<?<6= 5<7/6:/ D4<74 402/J;<1/2062503/134/5<7/6:/D0:1/6/D/24/1/>81/ <3<::9@C<33/2340334/:H<558>34/21<?/18>34/?/4<75/38 21<?/34/5811AD0:683<6289@3812<:;93//J;<1A8>34/ 5<7/6:/ 38 21<?/ 062 :9@:/K9/63 1/6/D05 8> 34/ 5<7/6:/ D8952 <62<703/ 3403 34/ 21<?/1 402 34/ 6/7/::01A :H<55 38 21<?/ :974 0 ?/4<75/ 4/1/>81/ 34/ 786759:<86: 1/074/2 - 7 - @A 34/ 1<@9605 <6 >0:3/6<6= 34/ 5<0@<5<3A 86 1/:;862/63 801/683B9:3<><0@5/ <: :/7862 ;186= 8> 34/ 01=9C/63: <: 3403 34/ 1<@9605 40: >0<5/2 38 786:<2/1 34/ >9391/ ;18:;/73: 0: 962/1 34/ 2<739C 8> 34/ ;/J 8913 <6 34/ 70:/ 8> 34/ . 4/1/>81/ 4/ :9@C<3: 3403 34/ K90639C 8> 34/ 78C;/6:03<86 0D012/2@A34/1<@9605<:683;18;/10627811/73 /1 786310 34/ 5/016/2 7896:/5 0;;/01<6= >81 34/ 1/:;862/63 8 D8952 :9@C<3 3403 D4/6 34/ 21<?/1 40268?05<221<?<6=5<7/6:/0:8634/203/8>34/077<2/63 1/:;862/638<:6835<0@5/38;0A34/78C;/6:03<86 21<?<6=5<7/6:/0334/3<C/8>34/077<2/63<:38@/<6>817/ 38 >0:3/6 34/ 5<0@<5<3A 86 34/ <6:91067/ 78C;06A 4/1/>81/<3<::9@C<33/2340334/<C;9=6/2B92=C/63<: ;18;/10627811/73/05:87863/63/2340334/K90639C8> 34/78C;/6:03<866//2683@/<63/1>/1/2D<34 1 - 8 - # ;/19:058>34/1<@96051/7812:D8952<62<703/ 3403 34/ /J31073 8> 34/ 21<?<6= 5<7/6:/ 8> 34/ 21<?/1 <: ;18297/203 - '3D8952:48D34030:8634/203/8> 34/077<2/63</86(&(%(%34/21<?/1D0:68340?<6= 0?05<221<?<6=5<7/6:/8D/?/1:97421<?<6=5<7/6:/402 /J;<1/2 86 (((% 062 503/1 <3 D0: 1/6/D/2 86 (((+3<:05:81/5/?06338683/340334/21<?/1402 0 ?05<2 21<?<6= 5<7/6:/ 38 21<?/ 0 3106:;813 ?/4<75/ >18C #((# 38 (((% 4/1/0>3/1 :974 5<7/6:/ D0: 1/6/D/2D<34/>>/73>18C((+38(((4/ ?01<89:3106:073<86:4<:381A<::48D6<6 J '403706 @/C02/893>18C34/;/19:058> J '<:3403/?/6;1<81 38 (((% 21<?<6= 5<7/6:/ 38 ?01<89: 703/=81</: 8> ?/4<75/:/J;<1/24/D0:;8::/::<6=34/21<?<6=5<7/6:/38 21<?/34/3106:;813?/4<75/D<34@02=/05:89@:/K9/6338 3403 34/ 5<7/6:/ D0: 1/6/D/2 4/1/>81/ >81 0 :4813 ;/1<82>18C(((%38((+<30;;/01:340334/ ;/3<3<86/1D0:68340?<6=0?05<25<7/6:/ - 9 - & 4<:8913C9:38@:/1?/34030;/1:8621<?<6=0 =882: 3106:;813 ?/4<75/ D<34893 :974 :H<55 2/><6<3/5A 0C8963 38 ?<8503<86 8> 34/ 3/1C: 062 7862<3<86: 8> 34/ ;85<7A@938634/834/140620;/1:86D4840234/:0<2 :H<550625<7/6:/383403/>>/73@93<3D0:/J;<1/20624/ 2<26831/6/D/234/:0C/706683@/786:<2/1/20=18:: 81>9620C/6305?<8503<868>34/;85<7A7862<3<86/><6<3/5A 34/ 8D6/1 8> 34/ ?/4<75/ 78952 40?/ 10<:/2 0 7863/63<86 34034/402/6319:3/234/?/4<75/3834/21<?/1@A1/5A<6= 86 34/21<?<6= 5<7/6:/ D4<744/402 ;18297/2 4/1/>81/ 34<: 8913 >/53 3403 5/62<6= 34/ ?/4<75/ <6 34/ 4062: 8> 0 ;/1:86 D48 D0: 40?<6= 34/ :H<55 38 21<?/ :974 ?/4<75/ 706683@/0331<@93/23834/8D6/1 % 4/B92=C/638>34/;/J8913<634/70:/8> ! " #06234/:9@:/K9/632/7<:<868>34/;/J8913<6 34/ 70:/ 8> !! " #06234/:9@:/K9/632/7<:<868>34/;/J8913<6 34/ 70:/ 8> !! $% &' <3 706 @/ 2 (2004) 3 SCC 297 3 (2018) 3 SCC 208 - 10 - :0>/5A@/:0<2340334/8D6/18>34/?/4<75/402/6319:3/2 34/ ?/4<75/ 38 34/ 21<?/1 @A @/5</?<6= 3403 4/ 402 0 :H<55 062 34/1/ D0: ?05<2 34/ 1/0:86 >81 34/ 8D6/1 38 @/5</?/ :974 D812: <6 ?</D 8> 34/ 21<?<6= 5<7/6:/ D4<74 /J<:3/2 /67/ <3 <: 0 70:/ D4/1/ 34/ >0953 706683 @/ >8962 D<34 34/ 8D6/1 8> 34/ ?/4<75/ 4/1/>81/ 34/ ;1<67<;5/: 50<2 28D6 <6 34/ 70:/ 8>!!( D8952 78C/ <6 ;50A 63403 ?</D8>34/C033/16:91067/8C;06A40:38@/>0:3/6/2 D<345<0@<5<3A38;0A34/78C;/6:03<86<6<3<055AD<345<@/13A 381/78?/134/:0C/>18C34/8D6/18>34/?/4<75/ 4/6/J30:;/7338@/786:<2/1/2@A34<:8913 <: 1/=012<6= 34/ K90639C 8> 34/ 78C;/6:03<86 4/ 1<@9605D4<5/2/7<2<6=34/C033/140:683786:<2/1/234/ >9391/;18:;/73:062060;;18;1<03/683<8605<678C/05:8 4/1/<:68/?<2/67/1/=012<6=34/<678C/8>34/2/7/0:/2 4/ =9<2/5<6/: <::9/2 @A 34/ " >81 :/335/C/63 8> 2<:;93/: @/>81/ 8H'205034 ;1/:71<@/ 0 683<8605 <678C/ 8> :&(' ;/1 C8634 >81 34/ A/01 - 11 - (% 6 9C;3//6 69C@/1 8> B92=C/63: 34<: 8913 40: 4/52 3403 34/ =9<2/5<6/: <::9/2 @A 34/ " 01/ <6 =/6/105 786>81C<3A D<34 34/ D0=/: ><J/2 962/1 34/ <6<C9C 0=/: 73 4/1/>81/ 34/A 01/ 077/;30@5/ /67/34/683<8605<678C/8>34/2/7/0:/2<:786:<2/1/2 03 :&('4/1/>81/34/58::8>2/;/62/67A40:38@/ 70579503/2 D<34 83<8605 678C/ 8> <: 0: :&(' ;/1 C8634 062 @A 022<6= #(I 38 34/ :0C/ /67/ 34/ />>/73<?/ C953<;5<7062 D8952 @/ :&(' L :&((' M&('4/2/7/0:/240:5/>3@/4<624<:>0C<5A8>(# C/C@/1: 4/1/>81/ 34/ ;/1:8605 /J;/6:/: D8952@/N /67/34/58::8>2/;/62/67A<:70579503/20: :&(' JJ&JOM :%&&(' + 6 022<3<86 38 34/ 0@8?/ 78C;/6:03<86 34/ ;/3<3<86/1:01/05:8/63<35/2>81:9C8> :&((('962/1 34/ 4/02 8> 786:813<9C 0 :9C 8> :+&((' 962/1 34/ 4/02 8> >96/105 /J;/6:/: :9C 8> Rs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