Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 12401 (KAR)

SUBHASHCHANDRA v. SRIKANT AND ORS

WP/201721/2021 · 2025-01-25

R Nataraj

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - !"! #$" " %$ & !! ! " # $ " " % " " $ " & ' '( Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: High Court Of Karnataka - 2 - ' ' ' )** ') " " + +!" " " $ , -* ' $ ! $ ! " ! ./ $ ! ! 0 ! + + 12 345678699 67 :)** ') 327;67< :7 812 9642 :9 812 ;;686:754 6=64 +>;<2 545?>@5<6 127A29:@81 @292@@2; 8: 5B .@654 :>@8/ 6B ?29:@2 816B :>@8 A154427<67< 57 :@;2@ ;582; ' '( ?C D16A1 57 53346A586:7 : 9642; >7;2@ @;2@ ,, >42 ) @25; D681 2A86:7 :9 812 :;2 :9 6=64 @:A2;>@2 *'( 127A29:@81 @292@@2; 8: 5B ./ 8: ?@67< 812 42<54 @23@2B278586=2B :9 812 ;2A25B2; E ;2927;578 : 57; 57 53346A586:7 : 9642; >7;2@ 2A86:7 :9 812 6F68586:7 A8 *% 8: A:7;:72 812 ;245C 67 96467< 812 53346A586:7 8: ?@67< 812 42<54 @23@2B278586=2B :9 812 ;2A25B2; E ;2927;578 - 3 - : 5B D244 5B 57 53346A586:7 : 9642; >7;2@ @;2@ ,, >42 * @25; D681 2A86:7 :9 9:@ B28867< 5B6;2 5?582F278 :9 812 B>68 5<567B8 812 42<54 @23@2B278586=2B :9 812 ;2A25B2; E ;2927;578 : D2@2 @2G2A82; 12 345678699 15B 54B: A154427<2; 57 :@;2@ ;582; ' ' ?C D16A1 57 53346A586:7 :, 9642; ?C 16F >7;2@ @;2@ >42 ' @25; D681 2A86:7 :9 D5B @2G2A82; 12 35@862B B1544 127A29:@81 ?2 @292@@2; 8: 5B 812C D2@2 5@@5C2; ?29:@2 812 @654 :>@8 12 328686:72@ 12@267 D5B 812 345678699 D1642 812 @2B3:7;278 : D5B ;2927;578 : 57; @2B3:7;278 : D5B ;2927;578 : ?29:@2 812 @654 :>@8 B>68 67 :)** ') D5B 9642; 9:@ ;2A45@586:7 :9 86842 @2A:=2@C :9 3:BB2BB6:7 57; 9:@ F57;58:@C 67G>7A86:7 12 B>68 D5B A:782B82; ?C 812 ;2927;578 :B 57; 12 ;2581 :9 812 ;2927;578 : A5F2 8: 812 H7:D42;<2 :9 812 345678699 :7 '' ' 9:44:D67< D16A1 57 53346A586:7 D5B 9642; 8: ?@67< 812 42<54 - 4 - @23@2B278586=2B :9 812 ;2927;578 : :7 ' ' 12 345678699 54B: 9642; 53346A586:7B 9:@ A:7;:7586:7 :9 ;245C 67 96467< 812 53346A586:7 8: ?@67< 812 42<54 @23@2B278586=2B :9 ;2927;578 : :7 @2A:@; 57; 9:@ B28867< 5B6;2 812 5?582F278 :9 812 B>68 5B 5<567B8 812 42<54 @23@2B278586=2B :9 ;2927;578 : ) 12 B56; 53346A586:7B D2@2 @2G2A82; ?C 812 @654 :>@8 67 82@FB :9 57 :@;2@ ;582; ' '( :7 812 <@:>7; 8158 812 345678699 57; ;2927;578 : D2@2 726<1?:@B 57; 8158 812 345678699 15; H7:D42;<2 :9 ;2581 :9 ;2927;578 : :7 ) '% 68B249 57; 8158 812 ;245C 67 96467< 812 53346A586:7 8: ?@67< 812 42<54 @23@2B278586=2B :9 ;2927;578 : D5B 7:8 <27>672 57; ?:7596;2 ":44:D67< 812 59:@2B56; :@;2@ 812 345678699 9642; 57 53346A586:7 :, >7;2@ @;2@ >42 ' @25; D681 2A86:7 :9 8: 6F3425; 812 42<54 @23@2B278586=2B :9 812 ;2A25B2; - ;2927;578 : D16A1 54B: D5B ;6BF6BB2; 67 82@FB :9 812 :@;2@ ;582; ' ' - 5 - % 12 345678699 6B 812@29:@2 ?29:@2 816B :>@8 A154427<67< 812 59:@2B56; :@;2@B 12 425@72; A:>7B24 9:@ 812 345678699 B>?F6882; 8158 812 ;2581 :9 ;2927;578 : :7 ) '% D5B 7:8 679:@F2; 8: 812 :>@8 57; 812@29:@2 812 345678699 D5B 7:8 5D5@2 :9 812 ;2581 :9 ;2927;578 : 2 A:7827;B 8158 2=27 :812@D6B2 812 53346A586:7 D5B 9642; :7 ' ' D16A1 D5B B46<184C ?24582; 57; 812 @654 :>@8 A:FF6882; 57 2@@:@ 67 1:4;67< 8158 812 @25B:7 F2786:72; 67 812 53346A586:7 9:@ A:7;:7586:7 :9 ;245C D5B 7:8 ?:7596;2 57; B586B95A8:@C 2 A:7827;B 8158 812 A5>B2 :9 5A86:7 9:@ 812 B>68 15; B>@=6=2; 5<567B8 812 42<54 @23@2B278586=2B :9 812 ;2927;578 : 57; 812@29:@2 68 D5B 67A>F?278 >3:7 812 @654 :>@8 8: 15=2 544:D2; 812 53346A586:7 9:@ A:7;:7586:7 :9 ;245C 67 96467< 812 53346A586:7 8: ?@67< 812 42<54 @23@2B278586=2B :9 ;2927;578 : 57; 8: B28 5B6;2 812 5?582F278 2 A:7827;B 8158 812 345678699 D5B 54B: 2786842; 8: 9642 57 53346A586:7 8: ?@67< 812 42<54 @23@2B278586=2B :9 ;2927;578 : 5<567B8 D1:F 812 A5>B2 :9 5A86:7 B>@=6=2; - 6 - 57; 812@29:@2 812 @654 :>@8 F>B8 15=2 58 425B8 544:D2; 812 53346A586:7 :, 9642; >7;2@ @;2@ >42 ' @25; D681 2A86:7 :9 ( 1:><1 ;2927;578 : D5B B2@=2; D681 812 7:86A2 :9 816B 328686:7 12 15B 7:8 53325@2; ?29:@2 812 :>@8 12@29:@2 816B :>@8 ;6; 7:8 15=2 812 ?272968 :9 16B B>?F6BB6:7B * 12 425@72; A:>7B24 9:@ 812 ;2927;578 : B>?F68B 8158 12 6B 5 9:@F54 35@8C 67 812 B>68 57; 812 ;6B3>82 6B 2BB2786544C ?28D227 812 345678699 57; 812 ;2927;578 :B 57; ' 15=2 A:7B6;2@2; 812 B>?F6BB6:7B F5;2 ?C 812 425@72; A:>7B24 9:@ 812 345678699 57; 812 425@72; A:>7B24 9:@ 812 ;2927;578 : 12 B>68 6B 9642; 9:@ ;2A45@586:7 :9 86842 @2A:=2@C :9 3:BB2BB6:7 57; 9:@ F57;58:@C 67G>7A86:7 :9 57 6FF:=5?42 3@:32@8C 12@29:@2 812 A5>B2 :9 5A86:7 9:@ 812 B>68 B>@=6=2; 5<567B8 812 42<54 @23@2B278586=2B :9 - 7 - ;2927;578 : 57; 127A2 67 :@;675@C A6@A>FB857A2B 812C D2@2 ?:>7; 8: ?2 ?@:><18 :7 @2A:@; 12 ;2927;578 : ;62; :7 ) '% 57; 5335@2784C 812@2 6B 7:8167< 8: B1:D 8158 812 ;2581 D5B @23:@82; 8: 812 :>@8 B: 5B 8: 32@F68 812 345678699 8: 85H2 B823B 8: ?@67< 812 42<54 @23@2B278586=2B :7 @2A:@; 12 345678699 :7 A:F67< 8: H7:D :9 812 ;2581 :9 ;2927;578 : 15; 9642; 812 53346A586:7 :7 ' ' 12 53346A586:7B D2@2 9642; 5982@ 7672 ;5CB ?2C:7; 812 86F2 3@2BA@6?2; 9:@ ?@67<67< 812 42<54 @23@2B278586=2B :7 @2A:@; 12@29:@2 812 A5>B2 B1:D7 9:@ 7:8 96467< 812 53346A586:7 8: ?@67< 812 42<54 @23@2B278586=2B :9 ;2927;578 : F>B8 15=2 ?227 5AA2382; ?C 812 @654 :>@8 12 @25B:767< :9 812 @654 :>@8 8158 812 345678699 57; ;2927;578 : D2@2 726<1?:@B 57; 812@29:@2 812 345678699 D5B ?:>7; 8: H7:D 812 ;2581 :9 ;2927;578 : 6B 57 5BB>F386:7 :7 812 35@8 :9 812 @654 :>@8 9 812 345678699 D1: 6B 57 ;=:A582 H72D 812 ;2581 :9 ;2927;578 : 12 D:>4; 15=2 ;29676824C 85H27 B823B 8: ?@67< 812 42<54 @23@2B278586=2B :9 ;2927;578 : D68167 812 86F2 B863>4582; 5B 12 D:>4; ?2 5D5@2 8158 ?C - 8 - 7:8 ;:67< B: 12 D:>4; @>7 812 @6BH :9 <28867< 812 2786@2 B>68 5?582; 7 8158 =62D :9 812 F5882@ 812 9:44:D67< 6 16B D@68 328686:7 6B 66 12 6F3><72; :@;2@ ;582; ' '( 35BB2; ?C 812 ;;686:754 6=64 +>;<2 545?>@5<6 67 :)** ') @2G2A867< 812 53346A586:7B :B 8: 9642; ?C 812 345678699 6B B28 5B6;2 666 12 53346A586:7 : 9642; >7;2@ @;2@ ,, >42 ) @25; D681 2A86:7 :9 8: ?@67< 812 42<54 @23@2B278586=2B :9 812 ;2A25B2; E ;2927;578 : 57; 53346A586:7 : 9642; >7;2@ 2A86:7 :9 812 6F68586:7 A8 *% 8: A:7;:72 812 ;245C 67 96467< 812 53346A586:7 8: ?@67< 812 42<54 @23@2B278586=2B :9 812 ;2A25B2; - 9 - E ;2927;578 : 5B D244 5B 53346A586:7 : 9642; >7;2@ @;2@ ,, >42 * @25; D681 2A86:7 :9 5@2 544:D2; 12 42<54 @23@2B278586=2B :9 ;2927;578 : 5@2 :@;2@2; 8: ?2 ?@:><18 :7 @2A:@; 6= 7 =62D :9 812 59:@2B56; 812 :@;2@ ;582; ' ' 35BB2; ?C 812 @654 :>@8 :7 :, 9642; >7;2@ @;2@ >42 ' @25; D681 2A86:7 :9 ;:2B 7:8 D5@@578 6782@92@27A2 '( %"& " ! 6B8 : 4 :