Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 12386 (KAR)
NIJAGUNI S/O MALLAPPA v. BAPTIST MISSIONARY ASSOCIATION OF INDIA AND ORS
WP/201337/2021 · 2025-02-13
R Nataraj
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 12386 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 12386 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "#$$
% &
!!"!#
"$%$! &
'
! '
"$%$!(
(
"$%$!(
'
"$%$!)
&
' !* (
Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: High Court Of Karnataka
- 2 -
' ((+ ((# '
'
'
' '
! (!)
#!((( " ,
' ,
'
()+(!) ' '
!+(!) '
'
'
'
'
- . /
01 2134345617 089 :08;;16<1= 86 57=17 =831= #!(((28991=>? 746:428;49374:3@=<18;8>@78<4 46 5! (!) >? A04:0 43 =49B4991= 301 822;4:83456 C4;1= @6=17 1:3456 D) 5C 301 876838E8 =@:83456 :3 !D%C5790573-301:35C!D%. - 3 -
( 01 2134345617 A89 82254631= 89 8 =78A46< 318:017 83 719256=163 5! 46 301 ?187 !DDD 01 2134345617 :56316=9 3083 719256=163 5( A89 :5F171= @6=17301<7863"46"84=46301?187(%1:56316=93083 C75B 3083 =8? 56A87=9 719256=163 5( A89 08789946< 04B 56 561 57 301 53017 <75@6= 95 3083 301 2134345617 :5@;=B8E1A8?C57865301721795635>18::5BB5=831= 95 3083 719256=163 5( :5@;= :5;;1:3 0@<1 8B5@63 1 :;84B1= 3083 719256=163 5( 08= 38E16 94<683@719 56 F8745@9 >;86E 282179 1 8;;1<1= 3083 56 !+(!) 01 A89 C57:4>;? 91:@71= 46 301 :08B>179 5C719256=1635( A017101A89:5B21;;1=359@>B438;133175C7194<683456 56 301 =4E383 5C 719256=163 5( 049 7194<683456 A89 2@725731=;? 9163 35 301 27194=163 5C 719256=163 5! 3075@<0 86 1"B84; 01718C317 56 ()+(!) 301 2134345617 71:14F1= 8 :5BB@64:83456 938346< 3083 049 7194<683456 =831= !+(!) A89 8::1231= A430 4BB1=4831 1CC1:3 556 301718C317 301 2134345617 <8F1 8 71271916383456 =831= $#(!) 35 A430=78A 049 7194<68345686=71G@1931=719256=1635(35217B4304B
- 4 -
35=49:087<1049=@3419012134345617:56316=9308301=4= 653 9@>B43 301 7194<683456 F5;@63874;? >@3 A89 C57:1= 35 9@>B43 43 01 2134345617 8;;1<46< 3083 3049 8B5@631= 35 =49B4998;C75B917F4:1C4;1=8682218;@6=171:3456D)5C 301:35C!D%465! (!)012134345617:56316=9 3083 301 74>@68; 71H1:31= 301 82218; 56 301 <75@6= 3083 8682218;@6=171:3456D)5C301:35C!D%:08;;16<46< 3018::12386:15C7194<683456A89653B84638468>;18986 82218; @6=17 1:3456 D) 5C 301 :3 5C !D% A89 56;? 8<84693 =49B4998; 71B5F8; 57 71=@:3456 46 786E 86= 301 275217 71B1=? A89 35 822758:0 301 71F494568; 8@305743? @6=171:3456!!5C301:35C!D% 146<8<<741F1=>? 3018C571984=57=17301213434561749>1C57130495@73
01 ;18761= 16457 5@691; C57 301 2134345617 9@>B4331=3083@6=171:3456D#5C301:35C!D%4349 46:@B>163@256719256=1635(355>384687194<68345646 301 2719:74>1= C57B 86= =@;? 8331931= >? 86 5CC4:17 =@;? 8@30574I1= 46 3083 >108;C >? 301 3831 5F176B163 1 :56316=93083@6=171:3456D#(5C301:35C!D%86? - 5 -
7194<683456 A04:0 49 653 46 8::57=86:1 A430 9@>"91:3456 (908;;>146F8;4=86=A4;;>15C651CC1:30171C57101 :56316=9 3083 46 ;8A 301 7194<683456 8::1231= >? 719256=163 5( 49 46F8;4= @616C57:18>;1 86= 301 213434561749=11B1=35>146917F4:1653A4309386=46<301 7194<683456 1 :56316=9 3083 301 C8:3 3083 719256=163 5( 08= 653 8;;5A1= 301 2134345617 35 A57E 905A9 3083 3012134345617A8971B5F1=C75B917F4:186=30171C57186 82218; @6=17 1:3456 D) 5C 301 :3 5C !D% A89 B84638468>;1 ) ;18761=:5@691;C57719256=1635( 9@>B4331=3083301213434561708=F5;@63874;?9@>B4331=049 7194<683456 46 301 271916:1 5C 301 018=B89317 5C 301 9:055;19@>B439308330171A8965:5B2@;945657307183 89:56316=1=>?301213434561786=016:1301:;84B5C301 2134345617 3083 301 7194<683456 A89 5>38461= C57:4>;?
49 >891;199 1 :56316=9 3083 C75B 301 =831 5C 301 7194<68345630121343456170896537125731=35A57EA04:0 46=4:831= >1?56= =5@>3 3083 301 2134345617 08=
- 6 -
8:E65A;1=<1= 301 C8:3 3083 01 08= 9@>B4331= 301 7194<683456 56 049 5A6 0171C571 01 :56316=9 3083 301 7194<683456 A89 275217 86= A89 F8;4=;? 8::1231= >? 719256=163 5( 1 :56316=9 3083 301 2134345617 08= 9@>B4331=3017194<68345686=65AA8639357194;1C75B43 16:1 301 82275274831 71B1=? 49 35 822758:0 301 :5B2131638@305743?@6=171:3456!!5C301:35C!D% 18;95:56316=930833018::12386:15C3017194<6834565C 301 2134345617 A89 >75@<03 35 301 6534:1 5C 301 3831 5F176B163 86= 016:1 30171 49 653046< 8B499 8>5@3 301 7194<6834569@>B4331=>?3012134345617 $ 01 719256=163 5! 49 8 274F831 1=@:834568;
469343@3456 A04:0 49 :5F171= >? <7863"46"84= >? 301 3831 5F176B1630171C571301275F4945695C301:35C!D% 49 822;4:8>;1 9 74<03;? :56316=1= >? 301 ;18761= 16457 5@691;C5730121343456173017194<6834565C86?1B2;5?11 5C 8 274F831 1=@:834568; 469343@3456 905@;= >1 89 275F4=1= @6=17 1:3456 D# 5C 301 :3 5C !D% 86= 301 98B1 49 1J378:31=>1;5A
- 7 -
! "
#
$
% &
'
( + 1:3456D#(5C301:35C!D%4946:57257831= 46 301 275F49456 56;? 35 169@71 3083 301 7194<6834569 871 6535>38461=C86:4C@;;?57:5;5@78>;?57>?@915CC57:101 9383@3108946F5;F1=865CC4:175C30138315F176B16335 169@71 3083 301 7194<6834569 871 653 5>38461= C57:4>;? 57 @6=17 =@7199 1:3456 D# 5C 301 :3 5C !D% =1:;8719 3083 86? 7194<683456 A04:0 =519 653 :56C57B 35 1:3456 D#(5C301:3!D%A5@;=>146F8;4=86=@616C57:18>;1
- 8 -
6301:89156086=4C3017194<683456;1331749217@91=43 496538331931=>?865CC4:17=@;?8@3057491=>?3013831 5F176B1633B8?>130833017194<683456A899@>B4331= 46 301 271916:1 5C 301 018=B89317 5A1F17 @634; 301 98B1 A89 8331931= >? 86 5CC4:17 =@;? 8@3057491= >? 301 3831 5F176B163 43 =4= 653 28738E1 301 :0878:317 5C 7194<683456 6 F41A 5C 301 =11B46< C4:3456 :5638461= 46 1:3456 D# 5C 301 :3 5C !D% 301 7194<683456 ;13317 8;;1<1=;?9@>B4331=>?3012134345617A5@;=>15C65F8;@1 86=016:1719256=16359!86=(:5@;=65308F18:31= @2563017194<683456;1331786=:5@;=65308F171C@91=35 8::123 301 2134345617 35 A57E 01 F17? C8:3 3083 301 213434561708=<4F1687127191638345656$#(!)<519 351938>;49030833012134345617A89A4;;46<35=49:087<1049 =@3419 86= 43 A89 301 719256=163 5! 86= ( A05 08= 71C@91=3012134345617358;;5A04B35A57E0171C5713049 =4=8B5@63358=1:1234F171B5F8;5C3012134345617C75B 917F4:1 0171C571 01 A89 16343;1= 35 G@193456 301 7194<683456>?3718346<43898657=175C71B5F8;46:1301 7194<68345649653F8;4=301213434561749=11B1=35>146
- 9 -
917F4:186=30171C@98;358;;5A04B35A57E=4=8B5@6335 71B5F8; 86= :5691G@163;? 301 74>@68; A89 16343;1= 35 1631738461= 301 82218; C4;1= >? 301 2134345617 86= 2899 82275274831 57=179 35 714693831 301 917F4:1 5C 301 2134345617 # 63083F41A5C301B83317301C5;;5A46<
4 01743
134345649 44 01 4B2@<61= 57=17 28991= >?
301 74>@68; 46 5! (!)=831=#!(((49913894=149 86= 301 7194<683456 ;13317 =831= !+(!) 2@725731=;? 9@>B4331= >? 301 2134345617 7194<646<C75B301917F4:195C8=78A46<318:017 83719256=1635(49=1:;871=35>146F8;4= 444 5691G@163;? 719256=163 59! 86= ( 871 =471:31= 35 217B43 301 2134345617 35 712573 35 =@3?349611=;19935B1634563083213434561749
- 10 -
16343;1=3530187718795C98;87?30198B1908;; >1284=468::57=86:1A430;8A 4F 19256=16359!86=(908;;275:199301:;84B 5C 301 2134345617 86= C57A87= 43 35 301 3831 5F176B163 86= 301 3831 5F176B163 908;; :5694=1730198B1468::57=86:1A430;8A
'(
%$& $
4935!;5$