Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 12363 (KAR)
JAGANNATH S/O MARUTHI v. YESU S/O BABURAO AND ANR
MFA/200080/2021 · 2025-02-14
C M Joshi
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 12363 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 12363 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! ""
#$ $
%%&' ( )
! "#$
% &&
'
&
! #
(
) "*)" $
(
+
#" &
$$#$###! '$*')###### &( '$#*$#'" ''#*$#'
%
&( $, & '*#*$#$$
'
Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
( ( ') ' (
&
#$#'$#'*
& & '!$ $#'-
( ( &
. $
. /01234/5/016/27896:/5;8134/0<</5506306234/ 1/:<862/638$ #$ /=6>0>>1=/?/2@A34/B92>C/630620D012=6 &8'!$ $#'- 203/2 #$#'$#'* @A 5/016/2 22=3=8605 /6=81 =?=5 92>/ 062 =201 34/ </3=3=86/1=:@/;81/34=:8913
- 3 -
# 4/ ;073905 C031=E 8; 34/ 70:/ =: 3403 86 $#'$$#'" 34/ </3=3=86/1 D0: >8=6> 38 0:4=C<91 86 4=: C83817A75/ @/01=6> />8!-! $ 6/01 0:4=C<9134/8;;/62=6>C83817A75/@/01=6>/>8 -"*)" 1=22/6 @A =3: 1=2/1 F 6=5 70C/ ;18C 34/ 8<<8:=3/ 2=1/73=86 062 20:4/2 38 34/ C83817A75/ 8; 34/ </3=3=86/1 : 0 1/:953 @834 34/ 1=2/1: ;/55 28D6 062 :9:30=6/2 >1=/?89: =6B91=/: 4/ </3=3=86/1 :9;;/1/2 78C<8962 78CC=693/2 ;107391/ 8; 34/ 1=>43 ;/C91 78C<8962 78CC=693/2 ;107391/ 8; 34/ 1=>43 <03/550 78C<8962 78CC=693/2 ;107391/ 8; @834 34/ @86/: 8; 34/ 1=>43 5/> / 402 30G/6 34/ 31/03C/63 /E3/6:=?/5A ;18C 2=;;/1/63 48:<=305: / D0: 31/03/2 D=34 :91>/1=/: 4/1/;81/4/750=C/234034/=:/63=35/2;8178C</6:03=86 4/ 0>205 <85=7/ 402 1/>=:3/1/2 0 70:/ =6 1=C/ 8' ) $#'"
53=C03/5A 34/A ;=5/2 34/ 7401>/:4//3 0>0=6:3 34/ :0=2 6=5 D48 D0: 34/ 1=2/1 8; 34/ 8;;/62=6> ?/4=75/ ;81 34/ 8;;/67/ 8; 6/>5=>/63 21=?=6> 062 683 <8::/::=6>34/21=?=6>5=7/6:/
- 4 -
#" 6 @/=6> =::9/2 D=34 34/ 683=7/ 34/ 1/:<862/63:8'062$0<</01/2@/;81/34/1=@9605062 ;=5/234/=1D1=33/6:303/C/63:
# 4/ 1/:<862/63 8' 8D6/1 8; 34/ 8;;/62=6> C83817A75/7863/63/2340334/6/>5=>/67/D0:6838634/ <013 8; 34/1=2/1 8; 4=: ?/4=75/ @93 34/1/ D0: 6/>5=>/67/ 8634/<0138;34/</3=3=86/1/2=:<93/234/0>/=678C/ 062 8779<03=86 8; 34/ </3=3=86/1 062 7863/63/2 3403 34/ 78C</6:03=86 750=C/2 =: /E81@=3063 =C0>=601A 062 963/60@5/=650D
#- 4/ 1/:<862/63 8$ =6:91067/ 78C<06A 7863/62/2 3403 34/ 1=2/1 8; 34/ C83817A75/ 8D6/2 @A 1/:<862/63 8' D0: 683 40?=6> 0 ?05=2 21=?=6> 5=7/6:/ 4/1/ @/=6> ;9620C/6305 ?=8503=86 8; 34/ 3/1C: 062 7862=3=86: 8; 34/ <85=7A 3 =: 683 5=0@5/ 38 <0A 34/ 78C</6:03=86 63/105=0 =3 402 05:8 2=:<93/2 34/ 0>/ =678C/ 062 8779<03=86 8; 34/ </3=3=86/1 3 40: 05:8 7863/62/2 3403 34/ 78C</6:03=86 750=C/2 =: 4=>45A /E81@=3063=C0>=601A062963/60@5/=650D
- 5 -
#) 6 34/ @0:=: 8; 34/ 0@8?/ 7863/63=86: 34/ 1=@9605;10C/234/;8558D=6>=::9/: 4/34/1 34/ </3=3=86/1 <18?/: 3403 86 $#'$$#'" 4/ D0: >8=6> 38 0:4=C<91 ?=550>/ ;18C =201 86 4=: C83817A75/ @/01=6> />8!-!
$ 03 0@893#)$ <C6/010:4=C<91718::86=201 F066/G4/55=180234/077=2/63D0:30G/6<507/29/ 3810:40626/>5=>/6321=?=6>8;/188620<5/6281 59:C83817A75/@/01=6>/>8-"*)"@A=3:
1=2/1 29/ 38 D4=74 4/ 58:3 7863185 8?/1 34/ ?/4=75/ 06220:4/20>0=6:3C83817A75/8;34/</3=3=86/1062 34/1/@A 4/ ;/55 28D6 062 :9:30=6/2 >1=/?89: =6B91=/:H 4/34/1 ':3 1/:<862/63 <18?/: 3403 34/1/ =: 78631=@9381A6/>5=>/67/8634/<0138;1=2/1:8;@834 ?/4=75/:H 4/34/1$621/:<862/63F=6:91067/78C<06A<18?/: 3403 34/ ':3 1/:<862/63 812/1 8; 34/ /18 8620 <5/6281 59: C83817A75/ @/01=6> />8-5
"*)" 2=2 683 40?/ 06A ?05=2 062 /;;/73=?/ 21=?=6> 5=7/6:/ 062 34/1/@A ':3 1/:<862/63 40: ?=8503/2 3/1C:0627862=3=86:8;34/<85=7AH & 4/34/1 34/ </3=3=86/1 =: /63=35/2 ;81 78C</6:03=86 =;:838D403:9C062;18CD48CH & 8D4031/5=/;34/<013=/:01//63=35/2H
- 6 -
#!
4/ </3=3=86/1 D0: /E0C=6/2 0: ' 062 0 287381D480::/::/234/2=:0@=5=3AD0:/E0C=6/20:$ 062E'38*D/1/C01G/2=634//?=2/67/4/8;;=7=05 8;34/1/:<862/638$D0:/E0C=6/20:'062E' 38"D/1/C01G/2=634//?=2/67/
#* 91=6> 34/ <187//2=6>: @/;81/ 1=@9605 0<<5=703=86: 962/1 12/1 '' 95/ '- 8; 062 962/1
12/1 '- 95/ ' 8; D/1/ ;=5/2 @A 34/ =6:91067/ 78C<06A://G=6>34/21=?=6>5=7/6:/;18C34/1/:<862/63 8' ?/6 3489>4 34/1/ D0: 06 812/1 @A 34/ 1=@9605 2=1/73=6>34/1/:<862/638'062=3:1=2/138<18297/34/ 21=?=6> 5=7/6:/ @93 34/A 2=2 683 78C<5A 34/ :0C/ : :97406812/170C/38@/<0::/2340302?/1:/=6;/1/67/ 40:38@/210D60>0=6:334/C
'# 4/ 1=@9605 0;3/1 4/01=6> 34/ 01>9C/63:
06:D/1/2 34/ =::9/: 8' $ 062 " =6 34/ 6/>03=?/ 062 =::9/ 8 =6 34/ 0;;=1C03=?/ 062 2=:C=::/2 34/ </3=3=86 D=3478:3:
- 7 -
'' /=6> 0>>1=/?/2 @A 34/ :0C/ 34/ </3=3=86/1 =: @/;81/34=:8913=60<</05 '$ 4/634/683=7/D0:=::9/2@A34=:89133834/ 1/:<862/63 8' 4/ 1/;9:/2 34/ :0C/ 4/1/;81/ 34/ :/1?=7/8;683=7/D0:4/52:9;;=7=/634/1/:<862/638$ =6:91067/78C<06A40:0<</01/234189>4=3:7896:/5 ' 4/ 01>9C/63: 8; 1= 0:0?010B 034 34/ 5/016/2 7896:/5 0<</01=6> ;81 34/ 0<</55063 062 C3 1//3= 03=5 /5G962= 34/ 5/016/2 7896:/5 0<</01=6> ;81 1/:<862/638$D/1/4/012 '" 4/5/016/27896:/50<</01=6>;8134/0<</55063 </3=3=86/1 D8952 :9@C=3 3403 34/ 7401>/:4//3 3489>4 =62=73: 3403 34/ 1=2/1 8; 34/ C83817A75/ ;81 34/ 8;;/67/ <96=:40@5/ 962/1 /73=86 '!' 8; 34/ 8381 &/4=75/: 73 34/1/:<862/638'402;=5/24=:D1=33/6:303/C/63D4/1/ 4/4027863/62/2340334/1=2/14020?05=221=?=6>5=7/6:/ 489>4 =3 =: 0 ;073 3403 34/ 1/:<862/63 8' 402 683 <18297/2 0 21=?=6> 5=7/6:/ 2/:<=3/ 06 0<<5=703=86 @/=6> ;=5/2@A34/1/:<862/638$34/=63/1:/2=:<93/@/3D//6 34/1/:<862/63:8'062$706683@=624=C;18C750=C=6> 78C</6:03=86 ;81 34/ =6B91=/: :9;;/1/2 @A 4=C /
- 8 -
:9@C=33/2 3403 34/ B92>C/63: 8; 34/ </E 8913 =6 34/ 70:/8; 062=634/70:/ 8;
78C/ 38 34/ 0=2 8; 0 12 <013A D48 :9;;/1: =6B91A 03 34/ 4062: 8; 34/ D186>28/1 3 =: :9@C=33/23403=60108!8;34/D1=33/6:303/C/63=3=: 703/>81=7055A:303/234031=2/18;4=:C83817A75/D0:40?=6> ?05=2 21=?=6> 5=7/6:/ 4/1/;81/ 34/1/ @/=6> 06 =63/1:/ 2=:<93/ @/3D//6 34/ 1/:<862/63: 8' 062 $ 34/ </3=3=86/1D0:/63=35/2;8134/78C</6:03=86/<8=63:893 340334/1=@960540:966/7/::01=5A210D67/130=602?/1:/ =6;/1/67/ 86 34/ >18962 3403 34/ </3=3=86/1 402 683 <18297/2 34/ 7401>/:4//3 062 4/ 402 683 <18297/2 055 34/ C/2=705 1/7812: /37 / 05:8 <8=63: 893 3403 34/ 1=@9605966/7/::01=5A78CC/63/2340334/</3=3=86/140:
D=344/52 7/130=6 C03/1=05 2879C/63: 4/1/;81/ 4/ ?/4/C/635A 01>9/2 3403 34/ =C<9>6/2 B92>C/63 =: 5=0@5/ 38@/:/30:=2/
1
2 $##"$*)
- 9 -
' /1 786310 34/ 5/016/2 7896:/5 ;81 34/ 1/:<862/63 8$ :9@C=3: 3403 D4/6 34/1/ =: C03/1=05 38 :48D 3403 34/ 1=2/1 8; 34/ C83817A75/ D0: 683 40?=6> 0 ?05=2 21=?=6> 5=7/6:/ 062 D4/6 34/ 1/:<862/63 8' 402 683 A=/52/2 38 06 812/1 <0::/2 @A 34/ 1=@9605 2=1/73=6> 4=C 38 <18297/ 34/ 2879C/63: 062 D4/6 34/ 1/:<862/63 8' 402 683 1/<5=/2 38 34/ 683=7/ =::9/2 @A 34/ 1/:<862/63 8$ 0: </1 E 34/ =6:91067/ 78C<06A 40?=6>2=:7401>/2=3:293A706683@/;0:3/6/2D=345=0@=5=3A 38 <0A 34/ 78C</6:03=86 4/1/;81/ 34/ =C<9>6/2 B92>C/63=:5=0@5/38@/9<4/52
'- 4/ </19:05 8; 34/ 1=@9605 1/7812: D8952 =62=703/3403=60108!8;34/D1=33/6:303/C/638;34/ 1/:<862/638'4/40::303/20:962/1
!
" !#$
- 10 -
% & ## '$! #&
"
& #
'$" !(
$)
') 4/;073340334/7401>/:4//3D0:;=5/20:</1 E" =62=73=6> 34/ 1=2/1 8; 34/ C83817A75/ 8D6/2 @A 1/:<862/638';8134/8;;/67/<96=:40@5/962/1/73=86 '!' 8; 34/ 8381 &/4=75/: 73 706683 @/ 2=:<93/2 4/ 718::/E0C=603=86 8; ' =6=3=055A :48D: 3403 34/ 686 <8::/::=868;21=?=6>5=7/6:/@A34/1=2/18;34/1/:<862/63 8'D0::9>>/:3/238'
'! 4//?=2/67/8;'D8952:48D34034/402 =::9/2 34/ 683=7/ 38 34/ 1/:<862/63 8' 0: </1 E 7055=6> 9<86 4=C 38 <18297/ 34/ 21=?=6> 5=7/6:/ 8; 34/ 1=2/1 /:<=3/ :974 683=7/ 34/ 1/:<862/63 8' 40: 683 <18297/234/21=?=6>5=7/6:/
- 11 -
'* 4/1/;81/ 34/1/ 706683 @/ 06A 289@3 3403 34/ 1=2/18;34/C83817A75/2=2683<18297/06A21=?=6>5=7/6:/ /60@5=6>4=C38;0:3/634/5=0@=5=3A8634/1/:<862/638$
$# 4/ =63/1:/ 2=:<93/ @/3D//6 34/ 1/:<862/63:
8' 062 $ :48D: 3403 3489>4 1/:<862/63 8' 402 7863/62/2 =6 34/ D1=33/6 :303/C/63 0: 0@8?/ 4/ 2=2 683 <18297/34/21=?=6>5=7/6:/634/1/:95334/1=@9605402 812/1/238210D02?/1:/=6;/1/67/0>0=6:334/1/:<862/63 8' $' 4/ </E 8913 =6 34/ 70:/ 8;
!=60108''#40:8@:/1?/20:@/58D $
## *
+%
, - .! /# ( 0 & # # & # $
# # &1
. & &1$
- 12 -
% #
2 . 22
, -
.! / # 3/ .$
&
$$! ! &4 3/! & &##& & &
$ , &! (
#! # & $ & ! 0& # &
#$
- 13 -
#! ! & # &
& &#&
5&
5 6 &
&
#$
&&
!# # #
$ 7
& &
& ! & & &
&
"
#
& $
&
8
# 8 8#&
8& 3/
.$
- 14 -
(& &
! (
! #
& #
$ %
# &
5! # & & $ 0
#& 29
2 # 1 # & 1 # # $
& # & # # ! $% 1
# # & ! & 1 &
$ #
- 15 -
& 1 # # & #
# &0&
## :3
. # 0 #$ 0;
1
# . &
3/
&4:! & &! & & & #& & #
# &# &$ ##&
& &&
# #
&& &
&
## :3
. $
&
! & &4
- 16 -
2
.
# # #
&
&$ 0
&4 3 &4 9
#
& # & &(&
&& 0 # &
# # & # 1 ##
1 #
#$)
$$ 4/ 0@8?/ <1=67=<5/: 50=2 28D6 @A 34/ </E 8913=634/70:/8; !01/1/=3/103/2 0>0=6 =6 =3: B92>C/63 =6 34/ 70:/ 8; 4/ <8:39503/ 8 :48D: 3403 C/1/ 0@:/67/ 81 ;0G/ =6?05=2 21=?=6> 5=7/6:/ 81 2=:I905=;=703=86 8; 34/ 21=?/1 ;81 21=?=6> 34/ ?/4=75/ 03 34/ 1/5/?063 3=C/ 706683 @/ 0 2/;/67/
- 17 -
0?0=50@5/3834/=6:91/10>0=6:334/=6:91/28112<013=/:
3 =: 6/7/::01A 3403 34/ =6:91/1 :48952 <18?/ 3403 34/ =6:91/2D0:>9=53A8;6/>5=>/67/062;0=5/238/E/17=:/34/ 1/0:860@5/ 701/ 83 865A 3403 34/ =6:91/1 :48952 05:8 /:30@5=:4 34/ @1/074 86 34/ <013 8; 34/ 8D6/1 8; 34/ ?/4=75/34/@912/68;:974<188;=:8634/C634/70:/ 8640623489>434/1/:<862/638'4027863/62/23403 34/ 1=2/1 402 34/ 21=?=6> 5=7/6:/ 4/ 2=2 683 <18297/ 34/ :0C/8289@334/1/:<862/638$40:C02/=3:/;;813=6 :/791=6> 34/ 21=?=6> 5=7/6:/ ;18C 1/:<862/63 8' 4/ E=0@=5=3A865A<85=7A06234/E"7401>/ :4//3 01/ 34/ 2879C/63: D4=74 >8 =6 ;0?891 8; 34/ 1/:<862/63 8$ 8D/?/1 86 3403 78963 34/ 1=@9605 7895268340?/2=:C=::/234/</3=3=864/=63/1:/2=:<93/ @/3D//6 34/ 1/:<862/63: 8' 062 $ 78952 683 40?/ 1/:953/2 =6 2=:C=::05 8; 34/ </3=3=86 A 028<3=6> 34/ <1=67=<5/ 50=2 28D6 =6 34/ 70:/ 8; !
34/ 1/:<862/638$=:5=0@5/3878C</6:03/34/</3=3=86/1D48 =:012<013A06234/64/=:035=@/13A381/78?/134/:0C/ ;18C34/1/:<862/638'
- 18 -
$ 4/ </19:05 8; 34/ =C<9>6/2 B92>C/63 :48D: 3403=340:8@:/1?/2340334/</3=3=86/140:683<18297/2 7/130=6 2879C/63: 062 4/ 40: D=344/52 34/C 4/6 34/ 7401>/:4//3 =: <18297/2 @A 34/ 1/:<862/63 8$ 0: </1 E"34/ </3=3=86/1 0>0=6<18297=6>34/ :0=2 2879C/63 2868301=:/3=:683G68D6D4=74834/12879C/63D0: D=344/52@A34/</3=3=86/14/1/;81/34/2=:C=::058;34/ </3=3=86 @A 34/ 1=@9605 =: 0 <1=C0;07=0 /1186/89: 062 706683@/:9:30=6/2
$" 4/ 1/:<862/63 8' =6 4=: D1=33/6 :303/C/63 7863/63/2340334/077=2/63877911/229/3834/6/>5=>/67/ 8;34/</3=3=86/14/6/=34/1<18?/2=3681718::/E0C=6/2 34/ ' 86 3403 78963 4/ 7401>/:4//3 40?=6> ;=5/2 0>0=6:3 34/ 1=2/1 8; 34/ 1/:<862/63 8' :974 0 7863/63=868;34/1/:<862/638';055:3834/>18962
$ 3=:D813438683/340334/=6?/:3=>03=6>8;;=7/1 40:683;896206A795<0@5/6/>5=>/67/8634/<0138;34/ </3=3=86/1/67/34/2=:C=::058;34/</3=3=86=:5=0@5/38 @/:/30:=2/
- 19 -
$- 4/6/E30:</73=:D4/34/134/C033/140:38@/ 1/C062/23834/1=@9605;8134/<91<8:/8;0::/::C/638; 34/78C</6:03=864/634/1/=:/?=2/67/1/7812/2@A34/ 1=@9605062D4/634/1/=:06=::9/8634030:</73=3D0:
=679C@/63 9<86 34/ 1=@9605 38 2/3/1C=6/ :974 =::9/: 49:=3=:/?=2/63340334/1=@96052/:<=3/34/1/@/=6>06 =::9/ 40: ;0=5/2 38 0::/:: 34/ 78C</6:03=86 062 78CC=33/2 06 /1181 4/ 1/C062=6> 8; 34/ C033/1 38 34/ 1=@960540:38@/1/:813/2380:0;=6051/:813=;1/7812=6> 8; 34/ /?=2/67/ =: 6/7/::01A 4/1/ @/=6> :9;;=7=/63 /?=2/67/ 86 1/7812 =3 =: 683 6/7/::01A ;81 34=: 8913 38 1/C06234/C033/1 $) 4/ </19:05 8; 34/ D8962 7/13=;=703/ 03 E D8952:48D340334/</3=3=86/1402:9:30=6/234/;107391/ 8;;/C9106G5/<03/550062;/D793507/103/2D8962:4/ 2=:7401>/ :9CC01A 03 E! 05:8 :48D: 3403 4/ D0: =6 <03=/63 ;18C $)'$$#'" 38 '#'$#' 4/ </3=3=86/1 D0:/E0C=6/2@A$;810::/::C/638;34/2=:0@=5=3A/ 8<=6/2340334/1/=:02=:0@=5=3A8;*#J3834/1=>439<</1 5=C@062 J3834/1=>4358D/15=C@60554/7867592/2 340334/1/=:*#J8;2=:0@=5=3A
- 20 -
$! 3=:1/5/?06338683/340334/</3=3=86/1750=C:
4=C:/5; 38 @/ 0>/2 # A/01: 50@891/1 062 /016=6> :$ ### </1 C8634 @?=89:5A =6 812/1 38 <18?/ 4=: =678C/4/40:683<18297/206A2879C/634/024001 012<18297/2@A34/</3=3=86/1:48D:34/203/8;@=13438 @/ #'#''*!) 4/1/;81/ 0: 86 203/ 8; 34/ 077=2/63 4/ D0: 0>/2$!
A/01: @93 34/ D8962 7/13=;=703/ :48D:3403 4/D0:0>/2#A/01:
$* 634/7=179C:3067/:8;34/70:/34/;9673=8605 2=:0@=5=3A 8; 34/ </3=3=86/1 40: 38 @/ 786:=2/1/2 03 $ J 489>4 34/ </3=3=86/1 7863/62/2 3403 4/ D0: /016=6> :$ ### </1 C8634 4/1/ =: @/=6> 68 C03/1=05 34/ 683=8605=678C/40:38@/786:=2/1/2
# 4/ >9=2/5=6/: =::9/2 @A 34/ ;81 :/335/C/63 8; 2=:<93/: @/;81/ 8G205034 <1/:71=@/ 0 683=8605 =678C/ 8; :) ## </1 C8634 ;81 34/ A/01 $#'" 6 9C<3//6 69C@/1 8; B92>C/63: 34=: 8913 40:
4/52 3403 34/ >9=2/5=6/: =::9/2 @A 34/ 01/ =6 >/6/105 786;81C=3A D=34 34/ D0>/: ;=E/2 962/1 34/
- 21 -
=6=C9C 0>/: 73 4/1/;81/ 34/A 01/ 077/<30@5/ /67/34/683=8605=678C/8;34/</3=3=86/1=:786:=2/1/2 03 :) ## 4/1/;81/ 34/ 78C</6:03=86 962/1 34/ 4/02 8; 58:: 8; =678C/ 29/ 38 58:: 8; ;9391/ =678C/ =: 70579503/2 0: :) ## E '$ E ') E $ J K :!$ ##
' 4/ </3=3=86/1 40?=6> :9;;/1/2 34/ =6B91=/: 0: 0@8?/D0:960@5/381/:9C/4=:D81G035/0:3;810</1=82 8; #$ C8634: 4/1/;81/ 4/ =: /63=35/2 ;81 0 :9C 8;
:' ### 962/1 34/ 4/02 8; 58:: 8; =678C/ 291=6> 34/ 50=29<</1=82
$ 4/</3=3=86/1=:/63=35/2;81:9C8;:' ### 962/1 34/ 4/02 8; 033/62063 7401>/: ;882 062 6891=:4C/63/37
4/ </3=3=86/1 =: 05:8 /63=35/2 ;81 :9C 8; :#### 962/134/4/028;<0=6062:9;;/1=6>
" 4/ </3=3=86/1 =: 05:8 /63=35/2 ;81 0 :9C 8;
:#### 962/134/4/028;58::8;0C/6=3=/:=65=;/
- 22 -
49: </3=3=86/1 =: /63=35/2 ;81 0 :9C 8;
:")$ ## 962/1;8558D=6>4/02:
5 8 /02: 8C</6:03=86 D012/2 @A34=:8913 ' 8::8;;9391/=678C/ :!$ ## $ 8::8;=678C/291=6> 50=29<</1=82 :' ###
8D012:033/62063 7401>/:;882062 6891=:4C/63 :' ###
" 8D012:<0=6062 :9;;/1=6> :####
8D012:58::8; 0C/6=3=/:=65=;/ :####
8305
:")$ ##
- /67/ 0<</05 2/:/1?/: 38 @/ 0558D/2 =6 <013 4/1/;81/34/;8558D=6>,
4/0<</05=:0558D/2 4/ =C<9>6/2 B92>C/63 062 0D012 =6 &8'!$ $#'- 203/2 #$#'$#'* <0::/2 @A 34/ 1=@9605=:4/1/@A:/30:=2/
- 23 -
4/ 0<</55063 </3=3=86/1 =: /63=35/2 ;81 0 :9C 8;
:")$ ## 0586> D=34 =63/1/:3 03 34/ 103/ 8; -J </10669C;18C34/203/8;</3=3=863=55=3:1/05=L03=86 @/;81/ 34/ 1=@9605 /E7592=6> 34/ =63/1/:3 ;81 0 2/50A/2</1=828;#!20A:=6;=5=6>34/0<</05
& 4/ 1/:<862/63 8$ =: 2=1/73/2 38 2/<8:=3 34/ 78C</6:03=86 0C8963 D=34=6 0 </1=82 8; #- D//G: D=345=@/13A381/78?/134/:0C/;18C34/1/:<862/63 8'@A/E/793=6>34=:0D012=3:/5;
& 634//?/638;2/<8:=38;34/78C</6:03=860C8963 $#J8;34/78C</6:03=860C896338@/2/<8:=3/2=6 0 ;=E/2 2/<8:=3 ;81 0 </1=82 8; #$ A/01: 062 34/ 1/C0=6=6>0C8963:4055@/1/5/0:/2=6;0?8918;34/ </3=3=86/186<18</1=2/63=;=703=868;34/</3=3=86/1
2 &$ ( $
=:38'58)"