Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 12351 (KAR)
GUDUSAB S/O FAKIRSAB CHIRLAKOPPA v. BASAVARAJ S/O BHEEMAPPA MUDARADDI AND ANR
MFA/200098/2021 · 2025-01-31
C M Joshi
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 12351 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 12351 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"!#
$
"
"
%%&
' ( )
! " #
$
% && '
( % (
( ) ! & &
(
& %
* ! " # + !'!! ($
LUCYGRACE Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Date: 2025.02.04 17:37:30 - 0800
- 2 -
&
,# $ & & %&(
! !!! & ! ,
%&&
& %
%
( & & !**'!! &
-
& & %&( & .&
%&%
" #
.&
%&% $
/01234/5/016/27896:/50;;/01<6=>8134/0;;/55063 06234/5/016/27896:/50;;/01<6=>811/:;862/638
489=4 34/ ?033/1 <: 5<:3/2 >81 02?<::<86 @<34 34/ 786:/63 8> 5/016/2 7896:/5 0;;/01<6= >81 A834 34/ ;013</:<3<:30B/69;>81><6052<:;8:05
4<:0;;/05<:2<1/73/20=0<6:334/C92=?/63062 0@012 203/2 ! !!! <6 & 8 ! , ;0::/2 AD 5/016/2 22<3<8605 /6<81 <E<5 %92=/ 062 & <C0D0;910 #4/1/<60>3/1 1/>/11/2 38 0: F34/ 1<A9605- >81 :4813$
- 3 -
' 4/ 962<:;93/2 >073: 01/ 3403 86 !G! * 03 0A893 ! ;? 34/ ;/3<3<86/1 :9>>/1/2 0 1802 310>><7 077<2/63 <6E85E<6= 34/ ?83817D75/ A/01<6= 8* (! ' 062 4/ 40: :9>>/1/2 >107391/ 8> 3<A<0 062 ><A950 >107391/8>60:05A86/062>107391/8>>186305A86/:062834/1 ?<681 <6C91</: / @0: 02?<33/2 38 /6/105 8:;<305 010=96206234/6>814<=4/1>07<5<3</:039A5<062401@02 06234/1/0>3/138/50=0E</67/4/><5/20750<?;/3<3<86 A/>81/34/1<A9605
4/6:91067/8?;06D40:1/:<:3/234/;/3<3<86 86 E01<89: =18962: A93 <3 @0: 960A5/ 38 :9A:3063<03/ 34/ :0?/A/>81/34/1<A9605
* >3/1 4/01<6= A834 34/ :<2/: 34/ 1<A9605 4/52 3403 34/ 077<2/63 A/<6= 86 0778963 8> 6/=5<=/63 21<E<6= AD 34/1<2/18>34/?83817D75/34/6:91067/8?;06D<:5<0A5/ 38 ;0D 34/ 78?;/6:03<86 38 34/ 750<?063 062 953<?03/5D 0@012/278?;/6:03<86962/12<>>/1/634/02:0:A/58@
- 4 -
6C91D0<60629>>/1<6=:
:!!!! &/2<705H;/6:/: :!!!! 8:: 8> 678?/ 29/ 38 /1?06/63 4D:<705 <:0A<5<3D :G*!! '
882062891<:4?/63 :!!!! 33/62063401=/: :!!!! * 86E/D067/401=/: :!!!! , 8::8>?/6<3</:062 9391/ 640;;<6/:: :!!!! :'*!! , /016/2 7896:/5 0;;/01<6= >81 34/ 0;;/55063 ;/3<3<86/1@8952:9A?<3340334/1<A9605>0<5/2380::/::34/ >9673<86052<:0A<5<3D8>34/;/3<3<86/1<60;18;/1;/1:;/73<E/ 489=4 34/ (87381 @48 402 0::/::/2 34/ 2<:0A<5<3D 402 :;8B/6 38 34/ />>/73 3403 34/ >107391/ 8> 34/ 3<A<0 062 ><A950 402 :9>>/1/2 0 68696<86 2/:;<3/ 06 <63/1605 ><H0381 A/<6=0;;5</206234/1/@0:02<:0A<5<3D3834//H3/638>'!
38 'I 4/ 0::/::?/63 286/ AD ( @0: 683 ;18;/15D 786:<2/1/2AD34/1<A960506234/1/>81/34/1/<:06//2>81 <6295=/67/ AD 34<: 8913 <6 /64067<6= 34/ 2<:0A<5<3D 062 34/1/AD34/78?;/6:03<86 4/;8<63:893340334/ 78?;/6:03<86 0@012/2 962/1 834/1 4/02: <: 05:8 86 34/ 58@/1:<2/
- 5 -
5/016/2 7896:/5 0;;/01<6= >81 1/:;862/63 8 @8952 :9A?<3 3403 34/ 0::/::?/63 8> 34/ 2<:0A<5<3DAD34/1<A9605<:;18;/10627811/73062;/3<3<86/1 A/<6=0A9:<6/::?06<6E85E/2<6483/5A9:<6/::70668340E/ 04<=4/1>9673<86052<:0A<5<3D06234/1/>81/34/1/<:686//2 >81/64067/?/638>34/78?;/6:03<86 G 701/>95;/19:058>34/1/7812:@89521/E/053403 34/;/3<3<86/1@0:0=/20A893!D/01:<6E85E/2<60483/5 A9:<6/:: 062 4/ :9>>/1/2 >107391/ 8> 3<A<0 062 ><A950 @4<74 40: 1/:953/2 <6 68696<86 6 0778963 8> :974 68696<86 06234//H3/1605><H0381@0:0;;5</2@4<74@0:8A:/1E/2AD 34/ ( 4/ 40: 78?/ 38 34/ 786759:<86 3403 34/1/ <:
2<:0A<5<3D8>'!38 'I3<:@813438683/34/ >107391/8> 3<A<0 062 ><A950 062 <3: 68696<86 1/:953: <6 0 :9A:3063<05 5<?;<6= AD 34/ ;/3<3<86/1 062 <3 @8952 2/><6<3/5D 0>>/73 34/ >9673<8605<3D 8> 34/ ;/3<3<86/1 4/1/>81/ <3 <: /E<2/63 3403 34/1<A9605402
/11/2<60::/::<6=34/>9673<8605 2<:0A<5<3D 03 !I 6 34/ 786:<2/1/2 8;<6<86 8> 34<: 8913 34/>9673<86052<:0A<5<3D@8952A/ I
- 6 -
! 4/ 0=/ 8> 34/ ;/3<3<86/1 <: 683 <6 2<:;93/ 4/ ;/3<3<86/1 40: 683 ;18297/2 06D 2879?/6301D ;188> <6 1/:;/738>4<:<678?/4/1/>81/683<8605<678?/40:38A/ 028;3/2>8134/;91;8:/8>70579503<868>34/78?;/6:03<86
4/ =9<2/5<6/: <::9/2 AD 34/ 016030B0 303/ /=05 /1E<7/: 93481<3D #$ >81 :/335/?/63 8> 34/ 2<:;93/:A/>81/34/8B20503;1/:71<A/34/683<8605<678?/ 8>
:,! >81 34/ D/01 ! * 6 9?;3//6 69?A/1 8> 2/7<:<86: 34<: 8913 40: 4/52 3403 34/ =9<2/5<6/: <::9/2 AD 01/077/;30A5/8634/=18962340334/D01/<6=/6/105 786>81?<3D @<34 34/ ?<6<?9? @0=/: ><H/2 962/1 34/ &<6<?9?(0=/:734/1/>81/34/683<8605<678?/8>34/ ;/3<3<86/1 <:077/;3/2 0:
:,! ;/1?8634 4/1/>81/ 34/58::8>>9391/<678?/<:70579503/20:
:,!H H H IJ
:',!! 86:/K9/635D 34/ ;/3<3<86/1 <: 05:8 /63<35/2 >81 78?;/6:03<86962/134/4/0258::8><678?/291<6=50<29;
;/1<82 >81 0 ;/1<82 8> 341// ?8634:
:,! H J :*! - 7 -
4/78?;/6:03<860@012/2AD34/1<A9605962/1 34/ 4/02 ;0<6 062 :9>>/1<6= <: 05:8 86 34/ 58@/1 :<2/ 062 34/1/>81/ 34/ :0?/ <: /64067/2 38
:'!!!! 4/ 1<A960540:0@012/20:9?8>
:!!!!962/134/4/02 8> 58:: 8> 0?/6<3</:<6 5<>/ 4/ 68696<86 8> 34/3<A<0 062 ><A95040:1/:953/2<60=0<3@05B<6=06234/1/>81/34/58::8> 0?/6<3</: <: /64067/2 38
:'!!!! 4/ 78?;/6:03<86 0@012/2 AD 34/ 1<A9605 962/1 834/1 4/02: 28 683 1/K9<1/ 06D<63/1>/1/67/634/1/:95334/;/3<3<86/1<:/63<35/2>81 34/78?;/6:03<860:A/58@
5 8 /02: @012AD34/ 1<A9605 @012AD34<: 8913
6C91D 0<6 062 9>>/1<6=:
:!!!! :'!!!! &/2<705H;/6:/: :!!!! :!!!! 8::8>678?/29/ 38 /1?06/63 4D:<705<:0A<5<3D :G*!! :',!! '
882 062 891<:4?/63 :!!!! :!!!! 33/62063401=/: :!!!! :!!!! * 86E/D067/ 401=/: :!!!! :!!!! , 8:: 8> ?/6<3</: 062
9391/ 640;;<6/:: :!!!! :'!!!!
- 8 -
8:: 8> <678?/ 291<6= 50<2 9; ;/1<82
:*! :'*!! :*' G! /::0@012AD34/1<A9605
:'*!! 64067/?/63
:!! '
8134/0>81/:0<21/0:86:34/0;;/052/:/1E/238 A/0558@/2<6;013/67/34/>8558@<6=
#<$ 4/0;;/05<:0558@/2<6;013 #<<$ 4/ <?;9=6/2 C92=?/63 062 0@012 ;0::/2 AD 34/ 1<A9605 <: 4/1/AD ?82<></2 #<<<$ 4/ 0;;/55063 <: /63<35/2 >81 0 :9? 8> :!! @<34 <63/1/:3 03 *I ;/1 0669? >18? 34/ 203/ 8> ;/3<3<86 3<55 1/05<L03<86<6022<3<8638@40340:A//6 0@012/2AD34/1<A9605 #<E$ 4/ 1/:;862/63 8 M 6:91067/ 8?;06D <: 2<1/73/2 38 2/;8:<3 34/ /64067/2 78?;/6:03<86 @<34 <63/1/:3
- 9 -
@<34<6 0 ;/1<82 8> ! @//B: >18? 34/ 203/ 8> 1/7/<;3 8> 0 78;D 8> 34<: C92=?/63 #E$ 4/0?8963<62/;8:<3<:812/1/238A/ 3106:?<33/23834/1<A9605>8134@<34
2 &
" (
"
<:38 58