- 1 - ! "" # $ $ %%&' () %%&' ( ) ! " # $ % &' (! ) * ! " # % + !!! $ Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - % % !# $ % % ) !, ! - ,! ( ) % . % (!! / !!!!! / ( ) % ! " # $ % &' (! ) * ! " # % + ! ! $ - 3 - % % !# $ % % ) !, ! - (!! ( ) % . % 0 !! / !!!!! / % ) 1) ) $ # 1) ) $ 2345 672 8234925 :;<9=28 3>>238 ?;4672 3>>288396= 3958234925:;<9=28?;442=>;95296 ; @ :;9=296 ;? 8234925 :;<9=28 3>>234A9B ?;4 C;67672>346A2=672D36624A=63E29<>?;4?A9385A=>;=38 67;<B7A6A==83625?;45DA==A;9 72=2 3>>238= 342 5A42:625 3B3A9=6 672 F<5BD296 395 3G345= 53625 !, ! - >3==25 A9 ;= ,! ( 395 (!! ( C@ 672 8234925 55A6A;938 29A;4 AHA8 )<5B2 395 ;DDA==A;924 ?;4 D>8;@22.= - 4 - ;D>29=36A;9 :6 383C<43BA #7242A93?624 42?24425 6; 3= I672;DDA==A;924?;4=7;46$ ( 72 =<C=6396A38 J<2=6A;9 ;? 83G 6736 34A=2= ?;4 :;9=A52436A;9A9C;67672=23>>238=A= 726724 672 8234925 ;DDA==A;924 G3= F<=6A?A25 A9 :;9=A524A9B 672 G3B2= ;? 672 >26A6A;924= 36 =0!!! >24 D;967 2H29 67;<B7 672 9;6A?A:36A;9A==<25C@672296438;H249D296<9524 2:6A;9 (# $ ;? 672 D>8;@22= ;D>29=36A;9 :6 #?;4=7;46I.$9;6A?A2==!!!>24D;9673= G3B2=K 9 % ;! ,,! 672 355A6A;938 =<C=6396A38J<2=6A;9;?83GA=3=C28;G 726724 672 8234925 ;DDA==A;924 G3= F<=6A?A25 A9 3==2==A9B 672 5A=3CA8A6@ 36 !/ 2H29 67;<B7;:6;47353==2==256725A=3CA8A6@36! 6;/K 0 72?3:6<38D364AL;?672:3=26736A=92:2==34@ ?;4 672 ><4>;=2 ;? 5A=>;=38 ;? 672=2 3>>238= A= 6736 672 >26A6A;924=G242G;4EA9B3=54AH24395:823924;938;44@ C234A9B ;(((, ;G925 C@ 42=>;95296 ; 9 - 5 - !! G729672@G242>4;:225A9B6;G345=<DC3A 9234 3G35@38 ;9 , 672 =3A5 H27A:82 D26 GA67 39 3::A5296 5<2 6; G7A:7 672 >26A6A;924= =<=63A925 A9F<4A2= 395672@G242=7A?6256;6727;=>A63872@:;96295256736 672@ G242 G;4EA9B <9524 42=>;95296 ; ;9 G3B2= ;? =,!!! 395 =0!!! 42=>2:6AH28@ GA67 355A6A;938 C3663 >24 53@ 72@ 38=; :;9629525 6736 672 H27A:82 G3= A9=<425 GA67 42=>;95296 ;9=<439:2 ;D>39@ 395 67242?;42 42=>;95296 ; A= 8A3C82 6; >3@ 672 :;D>29=36A;9 - 9 C2A9B =24H25 GA67 672 9;6A:2 42=>;95296 ;9=<439:2 ;D>39@ 3>>23425 C2?;42 672 ;DDA==A;924 395 42=A=625 672 :83AD >26A6A;9= ;9 672 B4;<95 6736 67242 G3= 9; =<:7 2D>8;@24 395 2D>8;@22 42836A;9=7A> 395 6736 672 54AH24 ;? 672 H27A:82 G3= 9;6 73HA9B 3 H38A5 395 2??2:6AH2 54AHA9B 8A:29:2 395 3= =<:7 6728A3CA8A6@;?6729=<439:2;D>39@C23C=;8H25 3=25;9672=3A5>8235A9B=672;DDA==A;924 ?43D253>>4;>4A362A==<2=39542:;45256722HA529:272 - 6 - >26A6A;924= G242 2L3DA925 3= = 395 42=>2:6AH28@ 39567225A:38 ??A:24G7;3==2==256725A=3CA8A6@;?672 >26A6A;924= G3= 2L3DA925 3= L= 6; G242 D34E25A9672A4 2HA529:272 ;??A:A38 ;?42=>;95296 ; G3= 2L3DA925 3= 395 672 A9=<439:2 >;8A:@ G3= D34E253=L , 72 ;DDA==A;924 3?624 7234A9B C;67 672 >346A2= 7285 6736 672 >26A6A;924 A9 ; ,! ( 735 672 G3B2= ;? =0!!! >24 D;967 395 3==2==25 672 5A=3CA8A6@ 36 !/ 395 3G34525 3 :;D>29=36A;9 ;? = (!! C@ 35;>6A9B 3 ?3:6;4 ;? 0, ; ?34 3= 672 >26A6A;924 A9 ; (!! ( A= :;9:24925 A6 G3= 72856736672>26A6A;924735=<=63A9255A=3CA8A6@;?/395 672 G3B2= G242 7285 6; C2 =0!!! >24 D;967 395 :38:<83625672:;D>29=36A;936=0 !!C@35;>6A9B3 ?3:6;4;? 0, ! 2A9B3BB4A2H25C@672=3D2672>26A6A;924A9 ; ,! (73=?A825% ;! ,,! 395672 >26A6A;924 A9 ; (!! ( 73= ?A825 % - 7 - ;! ,! =22EA9B A9624H296A;9 ;? 67A= ;<46 42B345A9B672J<396<D;?:;D>29=36A;9 3HA9B723456728234925:;<9=283>>234A9B?;4 C;67 672 =A52= A6 A= 4282H396 6; 9;62 6736 735 3==2==25 672 5A=3CA8A6@ ;? 672 >26A6A;924= 395 72 :3D2 6; 672 :;9:8<=A;9 6736 672 >26A6A;924372C;;C A9 ; ,! ( #3>>288396 A9 % ;! ,,! $ 735 =<??242535A=3CA8A6@;?!6;/A=?A95A9BG3=C3=25 ;9672D25A:3842:;45=G7A:7=7;G673672735=<??2425 ?43:6<42 ;? 82?6 :38:392<= 395 6736 72 G3= A9>36A296 ?;4 67422 53@= 6 A= G;467 6; 9;62 6736 672 >26A6A;924 372C;;CG3=354AH24C@>4;?2==A;9=2;?67282?682BA= ;?>AH;638AD>;4639:2?;47A=>4;?2==A;996736HA2G;?672 D366246725A=3CA8A6@3==2==25C@3D25A:38>43:6A6A;9243= 52?A925A9672>4;HA=A;9=;?672:6=7;<8573H2C229 3==2==25 GA67 42?2429:2 6; :725<82 6 A= >246A9296 6; 9;62673667;<B7 735 =636256736 6725A=3CA8A6@ G3= ! 6; / GA67;<6 3==AB9A9B 39@ 423=;9 672 ;DDA==A;924 73= 7285 672 5A=3CA8A6@ 36 !/ H29 672 - 8 - 936<42;?672A9F<4A2==<??2425C@672>26A6A;924372C;;C 3429;6>4;>248@3>>42:A3625C@6728234925;DDA==A;924 9 672 :;9=A52425 ;>A9A;9 ;? 67A= ;<46 672 ?<9:6A;938 5A=3CA8A6@ ;? 672 >26A6A;924 A= 7285 6; C2 !/ = 3 :;9=2J<29:2672:;D>29=36A;973=6;C242G;4E25;<6 234925 :;<9=28 ?;4 672 3>>288396= 38=; >;A96= ;<6 6736 672 ;DDA==A;924 73= 9;6 :;9=A52425 3 D25A:38 CA88G;467=!!!!G7A823==2==A9B672:;D>29=36A;9A9 ; ,! (967A=42B3457273=D3523H3A83C823 :246A?A25 :;>@ ;? L G7A:7 =7;G 6736 3 =<D ;? =!!!!G3=9;6:;9=A52425C@672;DDA==A;924 ; ?34 3= 672 =<C=6396A38 J<2=6A;9 ;? 83G A9 42=>2:6;?672G3B2=A=:;9:24925A6A=4282H3966;;C=24H2 67366729;6A?A:36A;9A==<25<9524 2:6A;9(# $;?672 :6A=CA95A9B673=672?;4:2;?672=636<239567242?;42 672 8234925 ;DDA==A;924 =7;<85 73H2 ?;88;G25 =<:7 9;6A?A:36A;9A==<25C@672296438;H249D2969<D>6229 9<DC24 ;? F<5BD296= A6 A= ;C=24H25 C@ 672 ;<46= 6736 6729;6A?A:36A;9A==<25<9524 2:6A;9(# $;?672:6 - 9 - 73=3?;4:2;?83G7242?;42A6G3=9;6>4;>24;9672>346 ;? 672 8234925 ;DDA==A;924 6; 425<:2 672 G3B2= 6; 3 ?AB<42 G7A:7 A= 82== 6739 672 G3B2= 9;6A?A25 C@ 672 ;H249D296;?95A37242?;42A9C;67672=23>>238=672 G3B2= ;? 672 >26A6A;924= A= 7285 6; C2 =!!! >24 D;967 ( 9 672 8AB76 ;? 672 3C;H2 :;9:8<=A;9= 672 3>>288396 A9 % ;! ,,! # ; ,! ($ A= 296A6825?;4672:;D>29=36A;93=<9524 =!!!L0!/L!/L 0, M=! 9 355A6A;9 6; A6 72 A= 38=; 296A6825 ?;4 D25A:38 2L>29=2=;?=!!!! 9 388 72 A= 296A6825 ?;4 3 6;638 :;D>29=36A;9 ;? = ?624525<:6A9B 3 =<D ;? = (!! 3G34525 C@ 672 ;DDA==A;924 672 >26A6A;924 A= 296A6825 ?;4 39 355A6A;938=<D;?=,038;9BGA67A96242=6 - 10 - ;?343=6723>>288396A9% ;! ,! # ; (!! ($ A= :;9:24925 72 A= 296A6825 ?;4 :;D>29=36A;9 ;? =!!! L 0!/ L / L 0, M =! 72 4AC<938 73= 384235@ 3G34525 3 =<D ;? =0 !!G7A:7A=D;426739G73673=C229:38:<83625 C@ 67A= ;<46 29:2 A6 42J<A42= 9; A9624?2429:2 ;9=2J<2968@6723>>23852=24H2=6;C25A=DA==25 0 96728AB76;?6723C;H2423=;9=6723>>238A9 % ;! ,,! =<::225= A9 >346 395 % ;! ,! ?3A8=29:2672?;88;GA9B #A$ % ;! ,,! 34A=A9B ;<6 ;? ; ,! (A= #AA$ % ;! ,! 34A=A9B ;<6 ;? ; (!! (A= #AAA$ 72 F<5BD296 395 3G345= >3==25 C@ 672 8234925;DDA==A;9243427242C@D;5A?A25 - 11 - #AH$ 72 3>>288396 A9 % ;! ,,! A= 296A6825?;43=<D;?=,0A9355A6A;9 6; G736 73= C229 3G34525 C@ 672 ;DDA==A;924 38;9B GA67 A96242=6 36 / >3?4;D6725362;?2L>A4@;?!53@=3?624 6725362;?A9:A5296 #H$ 2=>;95296 ;9=<439:2 ;D>39@ A= 5A42:625 6; 52>;=A6 672 296A42 :;D>29=36A;9 GA67A93>24A;5;?=ALG22E=?4;D6725362;? 67A=;4524 #HA$ 2=6 ;? 672 ;4524 >3==25 C@ 672 8234925 ;DDA==A;92442D3A9=<93862425 #HAA$ 234925 :;<9=28 ?;4 42=>;95296 ; A= >24DA6625 6; ?A82 H3E38367 GA67A9 3 >24A;5 ;? 6G;G22E= 5 & $ ' $ A=6 ; 8 ;(