- 1 - !"" # ! " # $ % % & # % ' # ( )# # )*& + # #, % , Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - % # % , ( )# # )*& # # ! # )*$ , $&$"* , )) )) + # , - ), * # ,% % )# $ , # , % . % / , 0# % % - 3 - $" 0# % % #1234 544621718 9: ;<1 =>84?13; @A 82B?2BB5C 23 @$9:;<1132@6272C%>841538%538 @??2BB2@316 >3816 ;<1 ?DC@:11/B @?D13B5;2@3 E; >658)# A@6 B<@6; .;<1@??2BB2@316/ ;<1 D1;2;2@316B 561 91A@61;<2B@>6;235DD15C <1 A5E;>5C ?5;62F @A ;<1 E5B1 2B ;<5; ;<1 81E15B18@>;5?G5B5862716G@6H234>38161?DC@:?13;@A 61BD@3813;@1G5B8627234556@)$ )' A6@? 58<5 ,2CC541 ;@ #5E<1D5CC2 ,2CC541 5C@34 G2;< 61BD@3813;@@3'$9>;3156#2856;<161G5B5 D>3E;>61 538 ;<161A@61 61BD@3813; @ 23B;6>E;18 ;<1 81E15B18 @>;5? ;@ 41; ;<1 71<2EC1 61D52618 538 E@?1 ;@ #5E<1D5CC2538<1C1A;;@#5E<1D5CC22359>BA;1661D526234 ;<1 56 5>;5? G5B 8627234 ;<1 B5?1 ;@G568B #5E<1D5CC2 5385;59@>;"D?3156 <>D5;<?5<545@3,2CC541<1 G5B9C238189:A@E>B234C24<;@A53@3E@?234C@66:538<1 C@B;E@3;6@C@716;<156<13<1;@@H;@G568BC1A;;@57@28 - 4 - ;<1E@CC2B2@3;<171<2EC1;>6318;>6;C19:;<1B281@A;<16@58 1 G5B B17161C: 23=>618 538 B<2A;18 ;@ 13165C @BD2;5C #2856 538 ;<1615A;16 ;@ @BD2;5C 53=54>;;5 :8165958 @3 ;<1 31F; 85: 1 G5B 54523 B<2A;18 ;@ 5B<@85 @BD2;5C @?5=24>85 :8165958 @3 $ 538 <1 B>EE>?918 ;@ ;<1 23=>61B @3 ;<1 B5?1 85: <1 53=54>;;5 @C2E1 ;5;2@3 6142B;1618 ;<1 E5B1 23 62?1 @& @3 $ 538 ;653BA16618 ;<1 B5?1 ;@ 53;5D>65 @C2E1 ;5;2@3 @3 ;<1 46@>38 @A =>62B82E;2@3 EE@68234C:53;5D>65@C2E1;5;2@36142B;1618;<1E5B123 62?1@$@3$ <1D1;2;2@316BG<@561 ;<1 G2A1 E<2C8613 538 D5613;B @A ;<1 81E15B18 A2C18 ;<1 D1;2;2@3 A@6 E@?D13B5;2@3 >3816 1E;2@3 @A ;<1 ?DC@:11B/ @?D13B5;2@3 E; A@6 B<@6; . E;/ <1: E@3;13818;<5;;<181E15B18G5B5418:156B15632345 B5C56: @A B&) D16 ?@3;< G2;< 852C: 95;5 @A B) 538G5B>3816;<11?DC@:?13;@A61BD@3813;@ <156 G5B 23B>618 G2;< 61BD@3813; @ ;<161A@61 ;<1: 561 13;2;C18A@6E@?D13B5;2@3A6@?61BD@3813;@B538 - 5 - 3912342BB>18G2;<;<13@;2E161BD@3813;@ 5DD15618538A2C18;<1G62;;13B;5;1?13;58?2;;234;<5;;<1 81E15B18 @>;5? G5B >3816 <2B 1?DC@:?13; 538 ;<5; ;<1 56 <58 ?1; G2;< 53 5EE2813; @3 '$ G<2C1 ;<1 81E15B18G5B8627234;<1B5?1A6@?#2856;@#5E<1D5CC21 5CB@58?2;;18;<5;@>;5?82188>1;@;<123=>621BB>AA1618 23 ;<1 5EE2813; 1 5CB@ 58?2;;18 ;<5; ;<1 81E15B18 G5B D528 B&)D16?@3;<538852C:95;5@A B) $ <1 61BD@3813; @ I 3B>653E1 @?D53: A2C18 G62;;13B;5;1?13;E@3;138234;<5;;<1612B3@61C5;2@3B<2D@A 1?DC@:16 538 1?DC@:11 91;G113 81E15B18 538 61BD@3813; @538813218;<15EE2813;2;B1CA;5CB@813218;<1541 23E@?1 538 @EE>D5;2@3 @A ;<1 81E15B18 538 5CC1418 ;<5; ;<1612B81C5:23A2C234;<1E@?DC523;538;<161A@612;912345 E@@H18)>D E5B1 C259C1 ;@ 91 82B?2BB18 2; 5CB@ E@3;13818;<5;;<181E15B18G5B3@;<57234 6272342E13B1 538 ;<161A@61 ;<161 G161 72@C5;2@3 @A ;16?B 538 E@382;2@3B @A;<1D@C2E: - 6 - 3 ;<1 95B2B @A ;<1 59@71 E@3;13;2@3B ;<1 @??2BB2@316 A65?18 5DD6@D625;1 2BB>1B 538 ;<1 172813E1 G5B C18 <1 D1;2;2@316 @ G5B 1F5?2318 5B 538 FB;@G161?56H18@172813E1G5BC18@391<5CA @A;<161BD@3813;B & A;16 <156234 ;<1 564>?13;B ;<1 @??2BB2@316 E5?1 ;@ ;<1 E@3EC>B2@3 ;<5; ;<1 D1;2;2@316B <571 A52C18 ;@ D6@71 ;<5; ;<1 81E15B18 <58 ?1; G2;< ;<1 5EE2813; @3 '$ 538 G5B >3816 ;<1 1?DC@:?13; @A 61BD@3813; @5385BB>E<82B?2BB18;<1D1;2;2@3 ' 3 2BB>53E1 @A 3@;2E1 D138234 58?2BB2@3 61BD@3813; @ 828 3@; 5DD156 9>; 61BD@3813; @ 5DD15618;<6@>4<2;BE@>3B1C * 1568 564>?13;B 9: 9@;< ;<1 B281B 538 D16>B18 ;<1?5;1625C5752C59C1@361E@68 " <1 B>9B;53;25C J>1B;2@3 @A C5G ;<5; 562B1B A@6 E@3B28165;2@323;<2B5DD15C2B5B91C@G - 7 - <1;<16 ;<1 C156318 @??2BB2@316 2B =>B;2A21823<@C8234;<5;;<1D1;2;2@316B<571 3@;D6@718;<5;;<181E15B18@>;5?8218 8>1;@;<15EE2813;5C23=>621BG<2C1<1G5B 23 1?DC@:?13; >3816 61BD@3813; @ 1713 ;<@>4< ;<1 @C2E1 D5D16B B<@G ;<5; ;<181E15B18G5B58?2;;18;@;<1<@BD2;5CB 5;:81659588>1;@;<123=>621BB>B;52318 23;<15EE2813;K 156318E@>3B1C5DD156234A@6;<15DD1CC53;B<5B A2C18535DDC2E5;2@3>38166816$ >C1'@AB11H234;@ D6@8>E1 ;G@ 8@E>?13;B ;@ B>9B;53;25;1 <2B E@3;13;2@3 ;<5; ;<1 81E15B18 G5B A26B; ;5H13 ;@ ;<1 @7163?13; # @BD2;5C5;#2856 <1C156318E@>3B1C5DD156234A@6;<15DD1CC53;B G@>C8 E@3;138 ;<5; ;<1 F 2B ;<1 C1;;16 G62;;13 9: 3BD1E;@6 @A 53=54>;;5 @C2E1 ;5;2@3 ;@ ;<1 @A 53;<5D>65 @C2E1 ;5;2@3 G<2E< 81D2E;B ;<5; ;<1 81E15B18 G5BA26B;;5H13;@# @BD2;5C538;<13<1G5B;5H13;@ @BD2;5C 53=54>;;5 @3 *$ <13 <1 G5B B<2A;18 ;@ 58<@85 @BD2;5C G<161 <1 B>EE>?918 ;@ 815;< - 8 - @3$ <2BE<523@A<@BD2;5C2L5;2@3@A;<181E15B18 91234 9@631 @>; @A ;<1 61E@68B ;<1 C156318 @??2BB2@316 <5B 16618 23 <@C8234 ;<5; G<5; ;653BD2618 91;G113 '$ 538 $ G5B 3@; DC5E18 @3 61E@68 3 5882;2@3 ;@ 2; 2; 2B B>9?2;;18 ;<5; F 538 F E@66@9@65;1G2;< F5385CC;<1B18@E>?13;B61A16;@;<1 6@58 ;65AA2E 5EE2813; 538 ;<1 ?182E@ C145C E5B1 91234 6142B;161823;<1<@BD2;5CB15CB@B>9?2;B;<5;;<1D@C2E1 D5D16B 538 D53E<35?5 E@38>E;18 9: 53=54>;;5 @C2E1 5B D16 FB"5385CB@B<@G;<5;;<15EE2813;<58@EE>6618 @3 '$ <1 815;< B>??16: @A 5B<@85 @BD2;5C G<2E<2B5; F35665;1B;<1<2B;@6:538;<161A@61;<161 G5B 3@ 615B@3 A@6 ;<1 C156318 @??2BB2@316 ;@ 82B91C2171 ;<1B1 8@E>?13;B ; 2B E@3;13818 ;<5; ;<1 E6@BB) 1F5?235;2@3 @A B<@G ;<5; 5CC 61J>2618 23A@6?5;2@3 <58 91131C2E2;189:;<161BD@3813;B9>;1713;<13;<1C156318 @??2BB2@316166182382B?2BB234;<1D1;2;2@3 C156318 E@>3B1C 5DD156234 A@6 61BD@3813; @ I 3B>653E1 @?D53: G@>C8 E@3;138 ;<5; ;<1 F 2B ;<1 6142B;1618 9: 53=54>;;5 @C2E1 @3 - 9 - $ <5; ;653BD2618 91;G113 '$ ;@ $2B3@;A@6;<E@?2342353:@A;<18@E>?13;B538 ;<161A@61;<1716B2@3@A;<1D1;2;2@316B2B>391C21759C1CC @;<16 8@E>?13;B G<2E< B<@G ;<1 1713;B 91;G113 '$ 538 $ @624235;1 B>9B1J>13; ;@ $538;<161A@61;<1:5613@;@A53:61C1753E1@6 61C253E11A>6;<16E@3;13818;<5;;<1E@?DC523;3@G<161 B;5;1B;<5;;<181E15B18G5B;<1862716@A;<156 7132A2; 2B5EE1D;18;<5;<12B58627161FE1D;;<1G62;;13B;5;1?13; @A61BD@3813;@;<1612B3@;<234@361E@68;@B<@G;<1 61C5;2@3B<2D @A 1?DC@:11 538 1?DC@:16 <161A@61 <1 81A138B;<12?D>4318=>84?13; 3B@A56;<15DDC2E5;2@3>38166816$ >C1'2B E@3E163182;2BB>9?2;;18;<5;;<17165E2;:@A;<15882;2@35C 8@E>?13;B561;@91;1B;18538;<161A@6161BD@3813;@ B<@>C8 91 42713 53 @DD@6;>32;: ;@ ;1B; ;<1 B5?1 9: B>9=1E;234;<1G2;31BB1B;@;<1E6@BB)1F5?235;2@3 $ #1A@61 4@234 23;@ ;<1 ?162;B 2; 2B 31E1BB56: ;@ E@3B2816;<15DDC2E5;2@323@A2C18>38166816 - 10 - $ >C1'@A;2BD16;2313;;@3@;1;<5;@9=1E;2@3B561 3@; A2C18 9: ;<1 61BD@3813;B ;@ ;<2B 5DDC2E5;2@3 72813;C: ;<1B18@E>?13;B5615C1;;162BB>189:;<1 2B;62E;>641@3 538 182E5C >D1623;13813; @A # @BD2;5C #2856 58861BB18 ;@ D1;2;2@316 @ 538 ;<1 ?182E5C 61E@68BE5B1) B<11;538 C2D85;18'$@A81E15B18@>;5? 72813;C:;<1B18@E>?13;BG161@9;523189:;<1D1;2;2@316B @3"B>9B1J>13;;@;<12?D>4318=>84?13;@A;<1 C156318@??2BB2@316 <2B @>6; 2B 23EC2318 ;@ 5CC@G ;<1 5DDC2E5;2@3 B23E1 ;<1B1 8@E>?13;B C138 B>DD@6; ;@ ;<1 61?523234 8@E>?13;BG<2E<561DC5E18538?56H1891A@61;<1C156318 @??2BB2@316 @61@716 ;<1B1 61E@68B G161 H1D; 9: ;<1 # @BD2;5C #2856 538 561 B13; ;@ ;<1 D1;2;2@316B ;<6@>4< ;<1 2B;62E; >641@3182E5C >D1623;13813; <161A@61 ;<1B1 8@E>?13;B 561 @A 2?D@6;53E1 23 @6816 ;@ 5BE16;523 ;<1 E@661E;31BB @A ;<1 E@3;13;2@3B @A ;<1 D1;2;2@316B3;<1C24<;@A;<1=>84?13;@A;<1D1F@>6;23 - 11 - ;<1 E5B1 @A %&% %'&( $) *+(,&- ''&% ;<1 8@E>?13;B G<2E< 561 1BB13;25C A@6 53 1AA1E;271 58=>82E5;2@3 @A;<1 E53915CC@G18;@91D6@8>E18>38166816$ >C1 ' @A 13E1 ;<2B @>6; A57@>6B 5CC@G234 ;<1 B528 5DDC2E5;2@3 A@6 ;<1 615B@3B ;<5; ?5: 91 A@>38 23 ;<1 A@CC@G234D565465D<B & <1 D16>B5C @A ;<1 8@E>?13;B D6@8>E18 9: ;<1 D1;2;2@316BB<@GB;<5;232;25CC:;<1E5B1G5B;<16142B;16189: 53=54>;;5@C2E1@3$@3;<195B2B@A23A@6?5;2@3 42713 9: @31 5<>C G<@ G5B ;<1 96@;<16 @A ;<1 81E15B18 <1B528 G5B;653BA16618;@53;<5D>65@C2E1;5;2@3@3 '$5BD16;<1E@??>32E5;2@35; F9:;<1 @A 53=54>;;5 @C2E1 ;5;2@3 :8165958 <1 B528 G5B 61E12718 9: 53;<5D>66 @C2E1 ;5;2@3 @3 $ 538 G5B6142B;16182362?1@$3 F2;2B5B;5;18 ;<5; 5<>C <58 23A@6?18 23 <2B E@?DC523; ;@ 53=54>;;5 @C2E1 ;<5; 5EE2813; <5B @EE>6618 @3 '$ 237@C7234 ;<1 56 9156234 )$) ' 538 ;<1 81E15B18 @>;5? G5B ;5H13 ;@ #2856 @7163?13; @BD2;5C <13 @3 *$* - 12 - *$<1G5B;<1B<2A;18;@@BD2;5C53=54>;;5 :8165958 <1615A;16 @3 $ 5; 5; ;<1 ?28324<; <1 G5B B<2A;18 ;@ 1B<@8<5 @BD2;5C @?5=24>85 :8165958#>;<1B>EE>?918;@;<123=>621B5;$5? @3 $ <1615A;16 ;<1 371B;245;234 AA2E16 <5B 72B2;18 1B<@8<5 @BD2;5C B<2A;18 ;<1 9@8: ;@ 538<2 @BD2;5C A@6 23J>1B; 1 5CB@ E@38>E;18 ;<1 23J>1B; 23 ;<1 D61B13E1 @A ;G@ G2;31BB1B 538 61E@6818 ;<126 B;5;1?13;B G<2E< <58 E@66@9@65;18 ;<1 E@3;13;B @A ;<1 <13 ;<1 9@8: G5B B>9=1E;18 ;@ 5>;@DB: 538 <53818 @716 ;@ ;<1 61C5;271B@A;<181E15B18 <2B35665;2@323 F3118B;@ 91E@66@9@65;18 ' <1 815;< B>??16: @A 81E15B18 @>;5? 2BB>18 9:1B<@8<5@BD2;5C:8165958D6@8>E185; FB<@GB ;<1<2B;@6:5B91C@G !" # # # $%& # # ' # ( ) - 13 - #' # ) ! ! * & + # #,- * <1 @BD2;5C >;<@62;21B B>BD1E;18 B1716 <:D@7@C1?2E B<@EH 538 A5; 1?9@C2B? 5B E5>B1 @A 815;< <1B18@E>?13;BG161@9;523189:;<1371B;245;234AA2E16 @A 53;<5D>6 @C2E1 ;5;2@3 538 ;<1615A;16 E@?DC1;18 ;<1 2371B;245;2@3538A2C1853595;1B>??16:61D@6; " <1 8@E>?13;B B@>4<; ;@ 91 D6@8>E18 9: ;<1 D1;2;2@316B >38166816 $ >C1 '@A B<@G ;<5; G<13 ;<181E15B18@>;5?G5B232;25CC:;5H13;@;<1@7163?13; @BD2;5C#2856;<1:<586142B;16185182E@145C5B15; $" D? @3 '$ ; 2B ?13;2@318 ;<5; ;<161 G5B 53 23=>6: ;@ 624<; ;<24< 538 D1C72E 6142@3 538 ;<1 81E15B18 G5B 82BE<56418 54523B; ?182E5C 5872E1 <2B 8@E>?13; E@>DC18 G2;< BC2D B<@G ;<5; ;<1 @BD2;5C >;<@62;21B <58 6142B;1618 182E@ 145C 5B1 2??1825;1C: 5A;16;<15EE2813; <1<2B;@6:2BB<@G35BC2DD541@A56 - 14 - 382E5 5; 59@>; "$ D? 3156 <>D5;<?5<545@3 ,2CC541 <1 E6@BB)1F5?235;2@3 @A B<@GB ;<5; ;<161 561E16;523B>441B;2@3B9:61BD@3813;@;<5;61BD@3813; @ 585DD5 2B ;<1 @G316 @A ;<1 56 538 <1 G5B A6@? 58<5 ,2CC541 538 <1 <58 5BH18 ;<1 81E15B18 ;@ 96234 ;<1 56 ;@ #5E<1D5CC2 ,2CC541 5B ;<1 56 <58 D>3E;>618 3156 <>D5;<5?5<545@3 6@BB <1 <5B B;5;18 ;<5; 585DD5G5B5CB@23;<1B528565385A;16;<156B>AA1618 D>3E;>61 ;<1 @G316 G13; ;@ #5E<1DD5CC2 ,2CC541 23 5 #>B <1B1 B>441B;2@3B B<@G ;<5; 61BD@3813; @ <58 ;<1 H3@GC1841@A;<1?5331623G<2E<;<15EE2813;@EE>6618 <159@71172813E1B<@GB;<5;;<15EE2813;<5B @EE>6618 @3 '$ 5; 59@>; "$ D? 538 ;<1 81E15B18 G5B B<2A;18 ;@ ;<1 @BD2;5C 5; 59@>; D? <13<1G5BB<2A;18;@@7163?13;# @BD2;5C5;#2856 538;<1615A;16<1G5BB<2A;18@BD2;5C:8165958@3 *$53854523@3$23;<1?28324<;<1G5B - 15 - ;<1 B<2A;18 ;@ 1B<@8<5 @BD2;5C G<161 <1 8218 G2;<23 $ <@>6B5;59@>;$5?972@>BC:<1G5B@3713;2C5;2@3 <2BB<@GB;<1E@3;23>2;:@A;<1;615;?13;A6@?'$ ;@ $ 538 2B 5752C59C1 23 ;<1 61E@68B D6@8>E18 91A@61 ;<1 @??2BB2@316 3 ;<5; 721G @A ;<1 ?5;;16 ;<1 E@3;13;2@3;<5;;<1612B3@?5;1625C;@B<@GG<5;;653BD2618 91;G113 '$ ;@ $ 2B 3@; 5752C59C1 E533@; 915EE1D;18;2B172813;;<5;;<196@;<16@A;<181E15B18 G5B 5CC 5C@34 1345418 23 5;;138234 ;@ ;<1 23=>621B ;@ ;<1 81E15B18 A E@>6B1 ;<1 E@?DC523; 5; F 8@1B 3@; ?13;2@3 ;<5; ;<1 81E15B18 G5B 862716 @A ;<1 E56 #>; ;<1 E6@BB)1F5?235;2@3 @A 1C2E2;B ;<1 B5?1 <161A@61 ;<1 E@3;13;2@3B@A61BD@3813;@)3B>653E1@?D53:E533@; 915EE1D;18 <1 @??2BB2@316 <5B EC156C: 16618 23 <@C8234 ;<5;;<1237@C71?13;@A;<15CC14185623;<15EE2813;2B3@; D6@718 <1 81C5: 23 C@84234 ;<1 E@?DC523; <5B 9113 1FDC523189>;;<1B5?1G5B3@;D6@D16C:5DD61E25;189:;<1 @??2BB2@3163;<161B>C;;<1B>9B;53;25CJ>1B;2@3@AC5G - 16 - A65?18 9: ;<2B @>6; 81B1671B ;@ ;<1 53BG1618 23 ;<1 3145;271 <1 @??2BB2@316 <@C8B ;<5; ;<1 G541B @A ;<1 81E15B18 @>;5? G5B B&) D16 ?@3;< G2;< 95;5 @A B)D1685: <13@;2A2E5;2@32BB>189:;<1@7163?13; @A3825>38161E;2@3$)#@A E;<@C8B;<1G541B5; B*) D16 ?@3;< <1 172813E1 B<@GB ;<5; ;<1 81E15B18 G5B 5418 :156B 5B D16 ;<1 ?182E5C 61E@68B <161A@61 ;<1 D1;2;2@316B 561 13;2;C18 A@6 E@?D13B5;2@3 @A B*)FMF"'&N'**$)35882;2@3;@2;5 B>? @A B) 2B ;@ 91 5G56818 5B A>3165C 1FD13B1B 13E1 ;<1 D1;2;2@316B 561 13;2;C18 B>? @A B'"$) 5B E@?D13B5;2@3 $ 3;<161B>C;;<1A@CC@G234 2 <1 5DD15C 2B 5CC@G18 23 D56; 5G568234 ;<1 E@?D13B5;2@3 @A B'"$) 5C@34 G2;< 23;161B; 65;1 @A M D16 533>? A6@? ;<1 - 17 - 85;1@A1FD26:@A85:BA6@?'$;2CC ;<1D5:?13;91A@61;<1@??2BB2@316 22 <1 2?D>4318 =>84?13; 85;18 * D5BB18 23 @$ 9: ;<1 @??2BB2@3162B<1619:B1;5B281 222 1BD@3813; @ ) 3B>653E1 @?D53: 2B 8261E;18;@81D@B2;;<1E@?D13B5;2@35?@>3; G2;<23B2FG11HBA6@?;<185;1@A61E12D;@A5 E@D:@A;<2B=>84?13; 8) ." / " # 2B;@C@* !