Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 12335 (KAR)
BABU S/O PREMASINGH RATHOD v. SANJAY S/O VACHU LAMANI AND ANR
MFA/201277/2021 · 2025-02-04
C M Joshi
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 12335 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 12335 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!! "
#
#
$$%
& ' (
! "
#
$
%
&&& ! '
& & ( )* & (
%!!!!'
"
# * '+ ',! '!''
($
LUCYGRACE Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Date: 2025.02.05 11:56:14 - 0800
- 2 -
* *
, # $ *
(
*
( %!)'!'! ''%'! * -,'!!(. -%)!!!( '. (
(
%!)'!'! ''%'! '
*
(
/
# # /
$
01 -0234 52674 4084 836-1 67 406- 98-1 4084 8- 42 :014013 401 67-;38791 92<587= 6- >68?>1 42 58= 401 92<517-84627 23 724 87@ :014013 401 92<517-84627 8--1--1@?=40136?;78>6-532513
- 3 -
!' 183@401>18371@92;7-1>A234018551>>87487@ 40131-527@174
2'
! 015146462713?167B8BB361C1@?=401D;@B<174 87@ 8:83@ 58--1@ 67 2 ''%'! @841@ %!)'!'!08-855328901@406-2;346785518>
!% 01 98-1 2A 401 5146462713 6- 4084 27 ',!'! 8>27B :640 -2<1 24013- 01 :8- 438C1>67B 67
C1069>1 ?18367B 1B
2&'
' A32< 40163 7846C1 5>891 42 8@08?08C6 01 @36C13 @32C1 401 -8<1 67 8 71B>6B174 <87713 8- 8 31-;>4 401 C1069>1 4;371@ 4;34>1 87@ 67 401 -86@ 8996@174 401 5146462713 -;-48671@ 67D;361- 01 5146462713 9>86<- 4084 01 085517- 42 ?18922>61 8B1@ 8?2;4 ' =183- 87@ 01 08@ -;AA131@ A3894;31 2A 401 -5671 36B04 A224 149 87@ 8- -;90 01 6- 17464>1@A2340192<517-84627
! 01 51464627 :8- 31-6-41@ ?= 401 31-527@174 2' E 67-;38791 92<587= 01 31-527@174
2 @6@ 724 92741-4 401 <84413 87@ 01 31<8671@ 1F58341 01 31-527@174
2' E 67-;38791 92<587= 8<27B-4 24013 9274174627- 536<836>= 927417@1@ 4084 64 08@ 6--;1@ 8
- 4 -
536C84198352>69=67-;3879187@401C1069>108-?117;-1@ ?=4012:7132A401C1069>1A23063187@31:83@0131A231 40131?167B?>84874C62>846272A401413<-87@927@64627-2A 40152>69=646-724>68?>14258=40192<517-8462742401 5146462713
! 0136?;78>08-A38<1@855325368416--;1-87@ 401 5146462713 :8- 1F8<671@ 8- ( 87@ :6471-- 1F8<671@2706-?108>A8-('87@ F 42 F:131 <83G1@ 67 401 1C6@1791 01 31-527@174
2' @6@ 724 1F8<671 87= :6471-- ?;4 F 42 F % :131 <83G1@ ?=927-174
!, 0136?;78>8A413018367B83B;<174-2A>18371@ 92;7-1> A23?240401583461- 98<1 424019279>;-6274084 401C1069>1:8-;-1@A2306312331:83@:06906-8?>84874 C62>84627 2A 401 413<- 87@ 927@64627- 2A 401 52>69= 0131A231A8-4171@401>68?6>64=2740131-527@174
2 4 8>-2 01>@ 4084 401 5146462713 6- 17464>1@ A23 8 4248> 92<517-84627 2A -,'!! ?= 02>@67B 401 @6-8?6>64= 84 .87@6792<12A401514646271384 -%!!!513<2740 ;7@13401A2>>2:67B018@-
- 5 -
> 2 18@- 2<517-84627 :83@1@
7D;3=86787@-;AA1367B- -'!!!! ' 2--2AA;4;316792<1 -%'!! 2--2AA;4;318<176461- - !!! 248> -,'!! !
167B 8BB361C1@ ?= 401 -8<1 401 5146462713 6- ?1A231406-2;346785518>
!) 01>18371@92;7-1>85518367BA234018551>>874 -;?<64- 4084 401 C1069>1 6- 8 58--17B13 9833=67B C1069>1 :640-18467B9858964=2A!0131A23140136?;78>1331@ 67 A8-41767B 401 >68?6>64= 27 401 31-527@174
2 1 A;34013-;?<64-4084:017401316-C62>846272A4018>>1B1@ 927@64627 2A 401 52>69= 401 5367965>1 2A 58= 87@ 3192C13 08- 42 ?1 8@2541@ 0131A231 401 36?;78> 1331@ 67 A8-41767B401>68?6>64=2740131-527@174
2 *;3401301 -;?<64- 4084 401 5146462713 08@ -;AA131@ 8 @6-8?6>64= 2A !.?=>2--2AC6-62706-8-519408-724?117532513>= 927-6@131@ ?= 401 36?;78> 1 8>-2 -;?<64- 4084 401 92<517-846278:83@1@?=40136?;78>;7@13401@6AA13174 018@-6-8>-227401>2:13-6@1
- 6 -
! 13 927438 401 >18371@ 92;7-1> 85518367B A23 401 31-527@174
2' E 67-;38791 92<587= -;?<64- 4084 40131-527@174
2 08C67B5;3908-1@8589G8B152>69=2A 8536C8419830108-;-1@401C1069>1A23063187@31:83@ :06906-6<513<6--6?>10131A2314016<5;B71@D;@B<174 58--1@?=40136?;78>987724?167413A131@:640
46-:23404272414084401513;-8>2A40152>691 58513-:0690831532@;91@?=401514646271384 F 42 -02: 4084 401 92<5>867874 :02 6- 7271 1>-1 4087 401 5146462713 013167 08- 9>183>= <1746271@ 67 401 92<5>8674 4084 01 :8741@ 42 B2 42 8@8?08C6 87@ 401
C1069>16-?167B;-1@A234387-523467B40158--17B13-1 -4841-408401?283@1@401-86@C1069>167401<23767B87@ -6<6>83 42 06< -1C138> 24013- 4084 6- ;76> 8742-0 87@ &6-087 149 8>-2 ?283@1@ 401 -8<1 01 @36C13 :06>1 @36C67B 401 -8<1 42:83@- 8@08?08C6 @32C1 401 -8<1 71B>6B174>=6789;3C67B87@401C1069>14;371@4;34>101 52>69167C1-46B841@ 401<84413 87@ 08C1 A6>1@ 401 9083B1 -01148B867-4401@36C13
- 7 -
' 4 6- 31>1C874 42 7241 4084 401 @36C13 2A 401 C1069>108- 5>18@1@B;6>4= ?1A231 40136<678> 2;34 01 31>1C87423@13-01142A40136<678>2;346-532@;91@84
F % 01 925= 2A 401 52>69= 6- 532@;91@ 84 F 01 98-1 -0114 2A 401 6-43694 2-5648> 6- 532@;91@ 84 F @1569467B40844015146462713:8-8@<6441@424012-5648> 27',!'! 87@:8-@6-9083B1@27')!'! 01 A63-4 8-5194 42 ?1 @196@1@ 6- :014013 401 >68?6>64= A8-4171@ ;527 401 31-527@174
2 6- 532513 23 724 4 6- 513467174 42 7241 4084 401 925= 2A 401 52>69= 532@;91@ 84 F -02: 4084 64 6- 8 536C841 983 589G8B1 52>69= 87@ 401 C1069>1 08- 8 -18467B 9858964= 2A ! 01 >6<6484627- 8- 42 401 ;-1 2A 401 C1069>1 679>;@1- 8 53206?64627 A23 0631 87@ 31:83@ 0131A231 64 6- 1C6@174 408464:8-7248C1069>1:0690:8-42?1;-1@A235;?>69 4387-52348462746-8>-25134671744272414084401932-- 1F8<6784627 2A 401 ( @6-9>2-1- 9841B23698>>= 4084 401 2:7132A401C1069>1:8-;-67B401-8<1A234387-523484627 2A 401 58--17B13- A32< 8@8?08C6 42 >6=8?8@ 1 8>-2
- 8 -
8@<6441@ 4084 01 08@ ?283@1@ 401 -86@ C1069>1 84 8@8?08C6 87@8 1 8>-2 8@<64- 4084 8724013 !% 42 !
513-27-08@?283@1@401-86@C1069>146-8>-28@<6441@ 4084 -6791 40131 831 72 ?;-1- 401 5125>1 831 ;-67B 401 C1069>1 >6G1 0;- 401 8@<6--627 2A 401 ( 92;5>1@ :640 401 * 84 F 87@ 401 9083B1-0114 4013127 9>183>= 67@69841 4084 401 C1069>1 :8- ?167B ;-1@ A23063187@31:83@ C6@174>=;-12A401C1069>1A230631 87@31:83@6-53206?641@8-401927@64627<1746271@67401 52>69= 64-1>A 0131A231 72 A8;>4 987 ?1 A2;7@ :640 401 9279>;-627 318901@ ?= 401 36?;78> 4084 40131 6- C62>84627 2A 401 413<- 87@ 927@64627- 2A 401 52>69= 87@ 40131A231 401 67-;38791 92<587= 6- 724 >68?>1 42 58= 401 92<517-84627 % 724013 6<5234874 8-5194 42 ?1 7241@ 6- 4084 4015146462713?167B858--17B136--11G67B8?-2>C67B401 >68?6>64= 2A 401 31-527@174
2 4 6- 6<<841368> A23 401 8551>>874 8- 42 :014013 01 6- 92<517-841@ 164013 ?= 401 31-527@174
2 23 ?= 401 31-527@174
2' 0131A231
- 9 -
:01740131-527@174
2 08-7248551831@87@08-724 927417@1@ 4084 401 C1069>1 :8- 724 ;-1@ A23 0631 87@ 31:83@64987724?1-86@40844015146462713987174136742 401 -021- 2A 401 31-527@174
2 42 @1A17@ 06< 27-1H;174>=401A63-4526746-87-:131@67A8C2;32A401 31-527@174
2'67-;3879192<587= 2<67B 42 401 H;874;< 2A 401 92<517-84627 401 98-1-0114 84 F -02:- 4084 6<<1@6841>= 27 8@<64467B 06< 42 401 2-5648> 01 :8- A2;7@ 42 08C1 -;-48671@8?38-6278440136B049011G87@-:1>>67B2C13401 9011G46-8>-2513467174427241408440131:8-8?38-627 87@ ?>11@67B 2C13 401 36B04 9011G 87@ F38= 2A 401 -9;>> :8-48G17?;401:8-431841@927-13C846C1>=2278A413 06-@6-9083B1A32<4016-436942-5648>27')!'! 01 855328901-401('29423*84415;316--;1-8 :2;7@ 91346A69841 8- 513 F% 87@ F, 87@ 01 25671- 4084401F38=-02:-A3894;312A401<8F6>>83=?27187@01 8>-2 8@C6-1@ 06< 9134867 5867G6>>13- 1 25671@ 4084 401 67D;3=
2 :06906-401-:1>>67B2C1340136B049011G2A6- B361C2;-67784;31?;472712A401@29;<174--02:87=
- 10 -
A3894;31 2A 401 36B04 A224 23 87= 24013 018@ 67D;3= 4 6- 513467174 8 7241 4084 (' 25671- 4084 40131 6- 8 36B04 -6@1<8F6>>83=?271A3894;311F417@67B42A>2232A40136B04 23?640131A2316408-9;><67841@67@6<676-01@C6-62767 40136B041=101('?167B871=1-;3B12708-25671@ 4084 401316- 8 @6<676-01@C6-627 01 784;312A 40141-4- 8@2541@ A23 8--1--67B @6<676-01@ C6-627 831 724 A234092<67B 67 401 @6-8?6>64= 91346A69841 4 6- 513467174 42 7241 4084 401 41-46<27= 2A 401 (' 92;5>1@ :640 401 @6-8?6>64= 91346A69841 532@;91@ 84 F @2 724 67-5631 927A6@17912A406-2;3442899154401-8<17=02:401 36?;78>08-8--1--1@401@6-8?6>64=84.:0690711@724 ?167413A131@:640 7-2A83 8- 401 7246278> 6792<1 6- 92791371@ 401 36?;78> 08- 48G17 401 -8<1 -%!!! 513 <2740 :0690 ?167B 27 401 >2:13 -6@1 08- 42 ?1 679318-1@ 42 -,!!!
513 <2740 0131 ?167B 72 @6-5;41 67 31-5194 2A 401 <;>465>613 401 92<517-84627 6- 98>9;>841@ 8- -,!!!F 'F F.I -,!!;7@13401018@ 2A>2--2AA;4;316792<1
- 11 -
, 01 92<517-84627 ;7@13 401 018@ 2A 5867 87@ -;AA1367B- 6- 1708791@ 42 -!!!! 01 >2-- 2A 8<176461- 67 >6A1 711@- 42 ?1 1708791@ 42 -%!!!! 0136?;78>08-7248:83@1@87=92<517-84627;7@13401 018@ 2A 84417@874 9083B1- 149 87@ 64 :6>> ?1 D;-4 87@ 532513428:83@8-;<2A -!!!;7@13406-018@
8C67B 927-6@131@ 401 784;31 2A 401 67D;361- -;AA131@ 401 5146462713 6- 8>-2 17464>1@ A23 8 -;< 2A - %!!!;7@13401018@2A>2-- 2A6792<1@;367B>86@ ;551362@
) 01514646271308-724532@;91@87=583469;>83- 2A 401 <1@698> 1F517-1- 0131A231 401 9>86<874 6- 17464>1@ A23 87 8@@646278> 92<517-84627 2A -%!! ;7@13401A2>>2:67B018@-
- 12 -
> 2 18@- 2<517-84627 :83@1@ ?=406-2;34
2--2AA;4;316792<1 -,!! ' 7D;3=586787@ -;AA1367B -!!!! 2--2A8<176461- -%!!!! % 2:83@-84417@874 9083B1-149 -!!! 2--2A6792<1@;367B >86@;551362@ - %!!! 248> 1--:83@1@?=401 36?;78> - %!! -,'!! 248>1708791<174 -%!! '! 1791 85518> @1-13C1- 42 ?1 8>>2:1@ 67 5834 0131A231401A2>>2:67B+
0185518>6-8>>2:1@675834
018551>>8746-17464>1@A238-;<2A -%!!67 8@@64627 42 :084 08- ?117 8:83@1@ ?= 401 36?;78> 8>27B:640674131-48440138412A.58A32<@841 2A5146462746>>401@8412A@152-64
1-4 2A 401 23@13 58--1@ ?= 401 36?;78> 31B83@67B @152-6414931<867;78>4131@
- 13 -
0131-527@174
2 2:7136-@631941@4258=401 92<517-84627
01 85518> 8- 8B867-4 401 31-527@174
2' 67-;3879192<587=6-@6-<6--1@
@ %
# ' #
& 6-4
2 >
2 &