- 1 - !" ! #$ "% &" ! $ % '(')*+(,'** & !"# $ % & ' ' ' ( !"# ' $ %' & ')#*+) & ' & ' ) *,!",", ' "",* ' ) ' ' ) ' ) +"", ' ) ' ++#",! ) Digitally signed by SHILPA R TENIHALLI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - )) ' # ) ' ) ' ' ))' ' ' '- ''' %'- '''& ./0123/0/45627/7/45859212:7/45#*+12;9</7. 2:7/45,4=1/0=/>29?@7.2;::8029</7.;61;@21 74 027 ;0/92 7.2 A89BC257 ;59 41921 4= :453/:7/45 ;59 025725:2 9;729 +"", 6;0029 ?@ 7.2 4817 4= /3/> 89B2 ;59 ) 8992?/.;> /5 4++#",! ;59 7.2 A89BC257 ;59 419219;729 *,!",", 6;0029 ?@ 7.24817 4=99/7/45;>200/45089B2/A;@;681/51/C/5;>662;> 4"",* " '2;197.2>2;1529:48502>=417.26;17/20 # 206459257 .212/5 .;9 =/>29 ; 61/3;72 :4C6>;/57 ;B;/5077.2627/7/4521.212/5=417.24==25:2685/0.;?>285921 2:7/45# 4=2B47/;?>250718C2570:7 %.212/5;=721 - 3 - 12=21129 74 ;0 D7.2 :7E =41 0.417& ;>>2B/5B 7.;7 7.2 :.2F82 /5 F8207/45 /00829 ?@ 7.2 627/7/4521 =41 ; 08C 4= 0,,,,, 74<;190 9/0:.;1B2 4= ./0 >2B;>>@ 12:4321;?>2 92?7 <;0 9/0.4548129 ?@ 7.2 91;<22 ;5G ;59 /5 06/72 4= 0213/:2 4= 07;78741@ 547/:2 7.2 627/7/4521 .;9 =;/>29 74 6;@ 7.2 ;C4857 :432129 85921 7.2 :.2F82 74 7.2 1206459257 .2 1/;> 4817 .;3/5B 7;G25 :4B5/H;5:2 4= 7.2 ;>>2B29 4==25:2 .;9 /00829 08CC450 74 7.2 627/7/4521 <.4 ;=721 ;662;1/5B ?2=412 7.2 1/;> 4817 .;9 :>;/C29 74 ?2 71/29 81/5B 7.2 :48102 4= 71/;> 7.2 1206459257 /5 0866417 4= ./0 :;02.;92I;C/529./C02>=;0;59;547.21</75200;0 " /52 94:8C2570 <212 C;1G29 ;0 I 74 I* 5 0866417 4= ./0 92=25:2 7.2 627/7/4521 B47./C02>=2I;C/529 ;0 ;59 2>2325 94:8C2570 <212 C;1G29 ;0 I 74 I .2 1/;> 4817 ;=721 .2;1/5B 7.2 ;1B8C2570 ;99120029?@?47.0/9203/92/C68B529A89BC257;5941921 9;729 +"", :453/:729 7.2 627/7/4521 =41 7.2 4==25:2 685/0.;?>2859212:7/45# 4=7.2:7;59025725:29 ./C 74 6;@ =/52 4= 0",,,, ;59 /5 92=;8>7 74 85921B4 0/C6>2 /C61/045C257 =41 ; 621/49 4= 0/I C457.0 .2 0;/9 - 4 - 419214=:453/:7/45;59025725:26;0029?@7.248174=/3/> 89B2;59 )4817 8992?/.;>/54++#",!<;0 :45=/1C29 /5 1/C/5;> 662;> 4"",* ?@ 7.2 4817 4= 99/7/45;> 200/450 89B2 /A;@;681 3/92 A89BC257 ;59 41921 9;729 *,!",", .212=412 7.2 627/7/4521 /0 ?2=412 7./04817 2;1529 :48502> =41 7.2 627/7/4521 .;3/5B 12/721;7297.2B14859081B29/57.2627/7/4508?C/707.;77.2 41;> ;5994:8C257;1@ 23/925:2 61498:29 ?2=412 7.2 48170 .;32547?2256146217@;6612:/;729'208?C/707.;7I! /07.2;66>/:;7/4508?C/7729?@7.2627/7/4521?2=4127.2;5G :4C6>;/5/5B;?4877.2>4004=:.2F82/5F8207/45'208?C/70 7.;7 I" /0 7.2 :;5:2>>;7/45 4= ;B122C257 4= 0;>2 9;729 +, ",!<.212/5/7/0321@:>2;1>@07;7297.;71206459257 .;0 12:2/329 7.2 257/12 ;C4857 4= 0 >;G.0 =14C 7.2 627/7/4521 ;59 7.212;=721 I" <;0 2I2:8729 '2 08?C/70 7.;7?@61498:/5B41;>;5994:8C257;1@23/925:2/50866417 4=./092=25:261208C67/45<;008::200=8>>@12?87729?@7.2 627/7/4521 ;59 7.212=412 7.2 1/;> 4817 ;59 7.2 662>>;72 - 5 - 4817 <212 547 A807/=/29 /5 :453/:7/5B ./C =41 7.2 4==25:2 685/0.;?>2859212:7/45# 4=7.2:7 21 :4571; >2;1529 :48502> =41 7.2 1206459257 .;0;1B829/508664174=7.2/C68B529A89BC257;5941921 4=:453/:7/45;59025725:2;5908?C/707.;7?47.7.248170 .;32:45:811257>@.2>9;B;/5077.2627/7/4521;597.212/054 0:462 =41/5721=2125:2::419/5B>@.261;@0749/0C/007.2 627/7/45 ! 62180;> 4= 7.2 C;721/;> ;3;/>;?>2 45 12:419 <48>9 B4 74 0.4< 7.;7 /7 /0 7.2 062:/=/: :;02 4= 7.2 1206459257:4C6>;/5;57 7.;7 .2 .;9 2572129 /574 ;5 ;B122C2574=0;>2</7.7.2627/7/4521.212/5=41681:.;024= 6146217@ ?2;1/5B @4" " C2;081/5B ;:120 * B857;0 0/78;729 ;7 ;0./5;G857/ />>;B2 8992?/.;>; ;>8G /A;@;681; /071/:7 =41 ; 747;> 0;>2 :450/921;7/45 4= 0!>;G.0;59859217.2;B122C257=410;>2.2.;96;/9 ;5 ;93;5:2 ;C4857 4= 0 >;G.0 74 7.2 627/7/4521 ;59 ?;>;5:2 ;C4857 <;0 ;B1229 74 ?2 6;/9 ;7 7.2 7/C2 4= 2I2:87/45 4= 0;>2 /5:2 7.2 627/7/4521=;/>29 74 2I2:872 7.2 - 6 - ;>2229;=72112:2/3/5B;08C4=0>;G.01206459257 .;9 =/>29 4!#",! =41 7.2 12>/2= 4= 062:/=/: 621=41C;5:2 4= 7.2 ;B122C257 4= 0;>2 ;59 981/5B 7.2 625925:@ 4= 7.2 0;/9 08/7 C;7721 ?27<225 7.2 6;17/20 <;0 0277>29;5945+, ",!7.2627/7/4521.;96;/9;08C4= 0!,,,,, ?@ <;@ 4= :;0. ;59 12C;/5/5B ;C4857 4= 0*,,,,,<;06;/97.148B.:.2F82?2;1/5B4#+!+ .2;=4120;/9:.2F8291;<5=41;08C4=0*,,,,,<;0 9/0.4548129 ?@ 7.2 91;<22 ?;5G =41 7.2 12;045 D=8590 /508==/:/257E ;59 7.212;=721 85921 ; 6;5:.;@;7. 627/7/4521 .;96;/9;08C4=0>;G.0747.21206459257/5:;0.45 ,,*",! ;59 =41 7.2 ?;>;5:2 ;C4857 4= 0 >;G.0 7.2 :.2F82 /5 F8207/45 ?2;1/5B 4#+ 91;<5 45 /9;B859/ 1;5:. <;0 /00829 /5 =;3481 4= 7.2 1206459257 .2 0;/9 :.2F82 <.25 612025729 =41 12;>/H;7/45 <;0 9/0.4548129 ?@ 7.2 91;<22 ?;5G =41 7.2 12;045 D=8590 /508==/:/257E ;59 7.212=412 ;=721 :4C6>@/5B 7.2 07;78741@ 12F8/12C2570 85921 7.2 :7 .2 .;9 ;6614;:.29 7.2 4817 - 7 - + 21 :4571; /7 /0 7.2 062:/=/: 92=25:2 4= 7.2 627/7/4521 7.;7 257/12 ;C4857 4= 0 >;G.0 <;0 6;/9 ;59 7.212;=721 I" :;5:2>/5B 7.2 ;B122C257 4= 0;>2 9;729 +, ",! <;0 2I2:8729 .2 :.2F82/5 F8207/45 <;0>407 ?@./C;59/57./012B;19.2.;908?C/7729;:4C6>;/5774 7.2;5G;0621I!;597.2>407:.2F82.;0?225C/08029 ?@7.21206459257 62180;> 4= I! <./:. /0 7.2 :4C6>;/57 08?C/7729?@7.2627/7/452174./0?;5G/5=41C/5B;?487>400 4=:.2F82<48>9B4740.4<7.;7/57.20;/994:8C257/7/0 C257/4529 7.;7 7.2 :.2F820 ?2;1/5B 4#+ 74 #+!# <212 8029 ?@ 7.2 627/7/4521 ;59 7.2 12C;/5/5B :.2F820 ?2;1/5B 4#+! 74 #+!,, <;0 >407 ?@ ./C 45 ,+",!::419/5B74./C7.2>407:.2F820<2120/B529 ?@ ./C ;59 .2 .;0 8029 :.2F82 ?2;1/5B 40#+ 74 #+!# ;59 7.212=412 7.2 :.2F82 /5 F8207/45 ;7 I ?2;1/5B4#+/08029?@7.2627/7/4521;597.20;C2/0 547452;C45B077.2:.2F82<./:.;>>2B29>@<;0>407?@7.2 627/7/4521 .212=412 7.2 92=25:2 4= 7.2 627/7/4521 7.;7 7.2 - 8 - 1206459257 .;9 C/08029 7.2 >407 :.2F82 ?2>45B/5B 74 ./C 9420547C21/7:450/921;7/45 * 206459257:4C6>;/5;57 .;0 B47 2I;C/529 " <.4/0545247.217.;57.2B1;59=;7.214=7.2627/7/45215 7.2 :./2= 2I;C/5;7/45 4= " .2 .;0 9264029 7.;7 .2 .;9 ;B1229 74 681:.;02 7.2 6146217@ ?2;1/5B @4" " 4= ;0./5;G857/ />>;B2 8992?/.;> ;>8G /A;@;681; /071/:7 =41;08C4=0>;G.045+, ",!=14C7.2627/7/4521 ;59 45 +, ",! 627/7/4521 12:2/329 ; 08C 4= 0!,,,,,=14C./C;596;/97.20;C2747.21206459257 /5./0612025:2;59=417.212C;/5/5B;C4857627/7/4521.;9 /00829 ; :.2F82 =41 ; 08C 4= 0* >;G.0 7 /0 7.2 062:/=/: :;02 4= 7.2 1206459257 7.;7 ;7 7.2 7/C2 4= 0277>2C257 /5 6;5:.;@;7. 7.2 41/B/5;> 4= 7.2 :.2F82 =41 ; 08C 4= 0* >;G.0?2;1/5B4#+!+<;012781529747.2627/7/4521;59 /57815.2.;96;/9;08C4=0>;G.0/5:;0.;59/00829 :.2F82/5F8207/45/5I=41;08C4=0>;G.074<;190 6;@C257 4= 7.2 ?;>;5:2 ;C4857 I /0 7.2 :4>481 6.474:46@4=7.2:.2F82?2;1/5B4#+!+/00829?@7.2 627/7/4521 =41 ; 08C 4= 0* >;G.0 74 7.2 1206459257 - 9 - 62180;>4=7.2.;59<1/7/5B/57.2:.2F82/5F8207/45;7I ;597.2:.2F82;7I <48>9B4740.4<7.;7.;59<1/7/5B /5 ?47. 7.2 :.2F820 ;12 452 ;59 7.2 0;C2 7 /0 547 /5 9/068727.;7I <;09/0.4548129?@7.291;<22?;5G;59 7.212=412/7/0321@:>2;17.;71206459257.;96120257297.2 :.2F82 =41 12;>/H;7/45 .2 1/;> 4817 ;59 7.2 662>>;72 4817 .;3/5B ;6612:/;729 7./0 ;062:7 4= 7.2 C;7721 .;32 1/B.7>@ 12A2:729 7.2 92=25:2 4= 7.2 627/7/4521 ;59 .;32 :453/:729./C=417.24==25:2685/0.;?>2859212:7/45# 4=7.2:7 , 7/071/727.;7:45:811257=/59/5B012:41929:;5547 541C;>>@?2/5721=2129/52I21:/024=123/0/45;>64<21085921 2:7/45 #*+ 12;9 </7. 2:7/45 , 4= 1 85>200 /7 /0 =4859 7.;7 7.2 /C68B529 A89BC257 ;59 41921 4= :453/:7/45 ;59025725:2;12 62132102;59/>>2B;>62180;> 4= 7.2 /C68B529 A89BC257 ;59 41921 4= :453/:7/45 ;59 025725:26;0029?@7.21/;>4817;597.2662>>;724817 <48>9B4740.4<7.;77.248170.;3/5B;6612:/;7297.241;> ;59 94:8C257;1@ 23/925:2 ;3;/>;?>2 45 12:419 ;59 .;32 6;0029;12;0452941921<./:.5229054/5721=2125:25921 - 10 - 7.2:/1:8C07;5:20;C4=7.246/5/457.;723/0/4527/7/45 >;:G0C21/7::419/5B>@7.2627/7/45/09/0C/0029 206459257 /0 ;7>/?217@ 74 </7.91;<7.2 ;C4857 /592640/7/=;5@ -+ '% &" !* " /074>4