Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 12306 (KAR)
JAVEED MIYAN S/O PASHAMIYAN v. RAJKUMAR S/O REVANAPPA PATIL AND ANR
MFA/201306/2021 · 2025-01-29
C M Joshi
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 12306 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 12306 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"!#
$
"
"
%
! " #$
# %&%' (
# ##) )
$)
)* #
" ) #
# %&%'
)
#
#
* # ) ) # %&%' (
#
$# +
*
LUCYGRACE Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Date: 2025.02.03 10:58:37 - 0800
- 2 -
) )
! *
) * , '%# )
#$
%,%* ,-
*
-
) * )
.#
)
" .#
)
/0123/014/256748/3099/01:4;<61=>/099/3304= 042 =>/ 3/014/2 56748/3 099/01:4; <61 1/89642/4= 6 4871045/6?904@
>67;> =>/ ?0==/1 :8 830=/2 <61 02?:88:64 A@ 5648/4=6<A6=>=>/56748/38=>/80?/:8=0B/479<61<:403 2:896803
- 3 -
#/:4; 0;;1:/C/2 A@ D72;?/4= 042 0E012 20=/2 , 9088/2 :4 6'% A@ =>/ /4:61 :C:3 72;/042223 <618>61=F 1:A7403G=>/9/=:=:64/1 :8 A/<61/ =>:8 671= 8//B:4; /4>045/?/4= 6< =>/ 56?9/480=:64
'
>/ 9/=:=:64/1 E>6 87<</1/2 <105=71/ 6< 1:;>= </?71 :4 0 1602 =10<<:5 055:2/4= 64 &% >02 0991605>/2 =>/ 1:A7403 8//B:4; 56?9/480=:64 <16? =>/ 6E4/1042=>/:4871/16<=>/6<</42:4;C/>:53/ /89642/4= 68 042 A/:4; =>/ 6E4/1 042 :4871/1 6< =>/ 6<</42:4; C/>:53/1/8:8=/2=>/530:?9/=:=:64648/C/103;167428 >/
1:A7403 5648:2/1:4; =>/ 6103 042 2657?/4=01@ /C:2/45/ 0336E/2=>/530:?9/=:=:64:4901=0420E012/256?9/480=:64 6< 8%,%E:=>:4=/1/8=0=,-9/10447?=>/20=/6< <:3:4;=>/9/=:=:64=:33:=81/03:H0=:64042>/321/89642/4=6 I4871045/6?904@3:0A3/=690@=>/56?9/480=:64=6=>/ 9/=:=:64/1 8:45/ =>/1/ E/1/ 46 875> C:630=:64 6< =>/ =/1?8 0425642:=:6486<=>/963:5@042=>0==>/963:5@E08:4<615/ 56C/1:4;=>/1:8B6<=>/6E4/16<=>/C/>:53/ >/1/<61/=>/
- 4 -
643@ J7/8=:64 =>0= 01:8/8 <61 5648:2/10=:64 :4 =>/ 91/8/4= 099/03:81/;012:4;=>/J704=7?6<=>/56?9/480=:64
%
>/ 099/3304=9/=:=:64/1 564=/4=/2 =>0= >/ E08 0;/2@/018E61B:4;0800:4=/104227/=6=>/055:2/4=03 :4D71:/8<105=71/6<=>/8>0<=6<=>/1:;>=</?71>/>08 A//4 2:80A3/2 / <71=>/1 564=/42/2 =>0= /C/4 =>67;> =>/ *65=61>02088/88/2=>/2:80A:3:=@0='-=>/ 1:A7403 =66B =>/ 80?/ 0= '- >/45/ =>/ 56?9/480=:64 0E012/2 742/1=>/1/?0:4:4;>/028:803866436E/18:2/ >/1/<61/ >/87A?:=8=>0==>/56?9/480=:64>08=6A/1/088/88/2
3/014/2 56748/3 099/01:4; <61 1/89642/4= 6 87A?:=8 =>0= =>67;> =>/ 1:A7403 >08 088/88/2=>/56?9/480=:64A@=0B:4;=>/46=:6403:456?/0= 8 9/1 ?64=> E>:5> :8 3:==3/ 64 >:;>/1 8:2/ =>/ 0E012 :4 1/89/5= 6< =>/ 6=>/1 >/028 01/ 56?9/480=/2 02/J70=/3@ !
/1/ := :8 E61=> =6 46=/ =>0= =>/ 1:A7403 >08 0E012/2=>/56?9/480=:64742/12:<</1/4=>/02808A/36E
- 5 -
0:4K7<</1:4;8 8
/2:503
L9/48/8 8%
64C/@045/ ==/4204= 5>01;/8 K671:8>?/4= 8% ' ?/4:=:/804274>099:4/88 8 % 688 6< <7=71/ /014:4; 50905:=@ 64 055674= 6< /1?04/4= 2:80A:3:=@ 8&&
6=03 8%,
&
>/ /C:2/45/ 64 1/5612 E6732 8>6E =>0= =>/
1:A74030<=/1088/88:4;=>/2:80A:3:=@8=0=/2A@=>/*>08 >/32=>/<745=:64032:80A:3:=@0='-4=>/3:;>=6<0;/042 655790=:646<=>/9/=:=:64/1=>/2:80A:3:=@6<'-64055674= 6<08:4;3/<105=71/=6=>/1:;>=>7?/1678042:=>0C:4;A//4 =1/0=/2 E:=> 40:3:4; 50446= A/ <073=/2 >/ :456?/ 6< =>/ 9/=:=:64/1088/88/2A@=>/ 1:A74030= 89/1?64=> 038650446=A/<073=/2<61=>/1/0864=>0=:=:883:;>=3@>:;>/1 =>04 =>/ 46=:6403 :456?/ 5648:2/1/2 A@ =>/ $0140=0B0 =0=/ /;03 /1C:5/8 7=>61:=:/8 <61 8/==3/?/4= 6< 2:897=/8 A/<61/ =>/ 6B 2030= AC:6783@ =>/ 9/=:=:64/1 >08 46= 916275/204@2657?/4=01@/C:2/45/=6916C/=>/:456?/ ,
>/9/=:=:64/1>0C:4;87<</1/2=>/<105=71/6<=>/ 8>0<= 6< =>/ </?71 >/ A/:4; 0 0:4=/1 56732 46= >0C/
- 6 -
1/87?/2>:8E61B0=3/08=<6109/1:626<=>1//?64=>8A7= =>/ 1:A7403>0846=0E012/204@56?9/480=:64:41/89/5=6< 36886<:456?/271:4;=>/30:2799/1:62 >/1/<61/64=>:8 5674==>/9/=:=:64/1:8/4=:=3/2<61087?6< 8
>/56?9/480=:640E012/2A@=>/ 1:A7403742/1 =>/ >/028 90:4 042 87<</1:4; 3688 6< 0?/4:=:/8 01/ 742/1 36E/18:2/ >/1/<61/:=E6732A/D78=0429169/1=60E0120 87?6< 8%E>:5>E6732<:33=>/;096<=>/8>61=0;/ 6<=>/56?9/480=:64742/1=>/>/026<90:404287<</1:4;042 0?/4:=:/8:43:</
71=>/1 =>/ * >02 8=0=/2 =>0= =>/1/ :8 1/J7:1/?/4=6<0<71=>/1871;/1@<611/?6C036<=>/:?9304=8 >/45/ =>/ <7=71/ ?/2:503 /L9/48/8 >0C/ 46= A//4 0E012/2 A@=>/ 1:A7403 >/1/<61/=>/9/=:=:64/1:80386/4=:=3/2<61 087?6< 8%742/1=>:8>/02E>:5>E673246=5011@ 04@ :4=/1/8= >/ 56?9/480=:64 0E012/2 742/1 =>/ 1/?0:4:4; >/028 26/8 46= 1/J7:1/ 04@ :4=/1</1/45/ /45/ =>/099/038755//28:4901=04208875>=>/<6336E:4;
- 7 -
:
>/099/03:80336E/2:4901=
::
>/ 9/=:=:64/1 :8 /4=:=3/2 <61 0 87? 6< 8&:4022:=:64=6E>0=>08A//40E012/2 A@=>/ 1:A74030364;E:=>:4=/1/8=0==>/10=/6< - 9/1 0447? <16? =>/ 20=/ 6< 9/=:=:64 =:33 :=8 2/968:=A/<61/=>/ 1:A7403/L5372:4;=>/:4=/1/8= :4 1/89/5= 64 =>/ 56?9/480=:64 0E012/2 742/1 <7=71/ ?/2:503 /L9/48/8 =6 =>/ =74/ 6< 8%
:::
/8= 6< =>/ 612/1 9088/2 A@ =>/
1:A74031/?0:487403=/1/2
2 &
" '
"
# :8=6 36 %,
$