Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 12297 (KAR)
SANTOSH G CHANAGONDA v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA AND ORS
WP/203931/2024 · 2025-02-05
R Nataraj
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 12297 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 12297 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! ""#
$%&!&
'! (%)
!"#$! %
&
&
#
& &
"'''#
$
&& !"#'#
&&
Digitally signed by SACHIN Location: High Court Of Karnataka
- 2 -
(
&
)" )
" &&*
)"' ) *
+ ,& )" ) *
! &
) $ )
&*
* )$ ) *
#' &
) $ )
## &
& )$ )
#$ * & )$ )
- 3 -
%
& # - & & (
#$
*
$$" $$+
*
&
#+#$$'$(
,
* &
& *
&
&
*& )
&) .&
/0 120345067 89 :2:6:; 2:< :6=/:>:7
0?:2:
411:2:@4 :;AB 4C:>:1A2: 543724=7 /:3 94;05 7/43 10747486
- 4 -
=/:;;06@46@ 7/0 6874=0 5:705 #+#$$'$( 433A05 D> 203186506783=/05A;46@:<00746@897/0<0<D02389 :6=/:>:7 86 ''#$'$ 78 =8634502 : <87486 89 68 =8694506=0 $ /01074748602=86706537/:7/0E:30;0=705:3 7/0120345067892:<:6=/:>:7 :2:6:;:77/00;0=74863 /0;5 86 #'+$'$ /0 :2:6:; 2:< :6=/:>:7 43 =8<124305 89 ## <0<D023 /0 1074748602 =8670653 7/:7 =027:46 464<4=:;;> 4;;54318305 <0<D023 /:7=/05 :6 0?4; 1;:6 78 <8?0 : <87486 89 68 =8694506=0 :@:4637 7/0 1074748602 0?06 7/8A@/ 7/0 1074748602 /:5 D006 5A;> 0F0=A746@ 7/0 E82B3 89 7/0 :6=/:>:7 /0 <0<D023 3AD<47705 : 201203067:7486 46 82< 8# 78 2031865067 8 86 '"#$$'$( 0F1203346@ ;:=B 89 =8694506=0 46 7/0 1074748602:6520GA03705/4<78=86?060:<00746@:305 86 7/0 3:45 201203067:7486 2031865067 8 433A05 :
6874=0 5:705 #+#$$'$( 12818346@ 78 =865A=7 : <00746@ 89 7/0 <0<D023 86 ''#$'$ /0 1074748602 =8670653 7/:77/436874=0433A0578/4<E:346?48;:748689A;089
- 5 -
:26:7:B: :6=/:>:7 :C &87486 9 88694506=0 @:4637 5/>:B3/: 65 1:5/>:B3/: 9 2:<:
:6=/:>:7 A;03 #( /02046 :9702 20902205 78 :3 7/0 HA;03 #(I 0 =8670653 7/:7 7/0 6874=0 5:705 #+#$$'$( E:3 302?05 86 7/0 1074748602 86 $#$$'$( /0209820 /0 =8670653 7/:7 7/020 43 68 =;0:2 # 5:>3 6874=0:31203=24D05A6502A;0#89A;03#(
0:2605 06482 =8A630; :110:246@ 982 7/0 1074748602 =8670653 7/:7 7/0 6874=0 89 7/0 <00746@ E:3 302?051/>34=:;;>867/0107474860286##$$'$(:657/:7 7/0 1074748602 :=B68E;05@05 7/0 3:<0 86 : =81> 89 7/0 6874=0 0 46?4705 7/0 :77067486 89 7/43 8A27 78 7/0 3:45 6874=0E/0207/01074748602/:5<06748605:398;;8E3) !"#$% & '% ( %)*" + , -.
/0" ( !" 123
(
0 7/0209820 =8670653 7/:7 7/0 1074748602 20=04?05 7/0 6874=0 89 7/0 <00746@ 86 ##$$'$( :65 346=0 7/0 <00746@ E:3 3=/05A;05 86 ''#$'$ 7/020
- 6 -
E:368=;0:2# 5:>36874=0:31203=24D05A6502A;0# 89 7/0 A;03 #( /A3 /0=8670653 7/:77/0 4<1A@605 6874=09:;;398A;89A;0#897/0A;03#(46?40E89 7/0 CA5@<067 89 A;; 06=/ 89 7/43 8A27 46 7/0 =:30 89
02 =8672: ;0:2605 5547486:; 8?026<067 5?8=:70 :110:246@ 982 2031865067 83# 78 3AD<473 7/:7 7/0 1074748602 /:5 :=B68E;05@05 7/0 20=0417 89 7/0 6874=0 DA7 /:5 687 :994F05 7/0 5:70 ##$$'$( 0 =8670653 7/:7 7/0 =81> 89 7/0 6874=0 E:3 3067 78 7/0 :6=/:>:7
0?0;81<067 994=02
86#!#$$'$(:65 :==82546@787/0201827897/0
7/06874=0E:3302?05 86 #!#$$'$( :65 /06=0 7/0 6874=0 43 46 3724=7 =8<1;4:6=0 89 A;0 # 89 A;03 #( :3 7/020 E:3 =;0:2 # 5:>3 6874=0 89 7/0 <00746@ /A3 /0 =8670653 7/:7 7/020 43 68 02282 46 7/0 128=05A20 :581705 D> 2031865067846/8;546@7/0<00746@86''#$'$
1 #$ 6;460:2+(
- 7 -
" 0:2605=8A630;98220318650678(204702:705 7/0:D8?0:65=867065057/:77/0E8253J !"#$% & '% ( %)*" + ,-. /0" ( !" 123 43 E247706 D> 7/0 1074748602 86 /43 =81> E/4=/ 43 :6 :97027/8A@/7 :3 7/0 3:<0 43 687 06582305 86 7/0 6874=0 20=04?05 D> /4< E/4=/ 43 98A65 46 7/0 94;0 0 7/0209820 3AD<4737/:77/06874=0=:6687D0/0;578D0302?05867/0 107474860286##$$'$(D:305867/0:33027486<:50D> 7/01074748602
+ /43 8A27 /:5 5420=705 7/0 ;0:2605 5547486:;
8?026<067 5?8=:70 78 30=A20 7/0 94;0 20;:746@ 78 68 =8694506=0<87486:657/03:<0431;:=05D09820<0/0 94;0543=;83037/:77/01074748602/:520=04?05:=81>897/0 6874=0 DA7 /:5 687 <:2B05 7/0 5:70 86 7/0 6874=0
8E0?02 E/:7 43 E247706 86 7/0 :=B68E;05@<067 433A05 D>7/0107474860220:53:398;;8E3)
"%!/0"4 ((" 5 6!-.%3
- 8 -
!
/:?0 =863450205 7/0 3AD<433486 89 ;0:2605 306482 =8A630; 982 7/0 1074748602 :65 ;0:2605 5547486:; 8?026<067 5?8=:70 982 2031865067 83# 78 :65 ;0:2605 5547486:; 8?026<067 5?8=:70 982 2031865067 8(
/43 8A27 46 702<3 89 7/0 82502 5:705 ##$$'$( /0;5 7/:7 7/0 8A7=8<0 89 7/0 <00746@ 5:705 ''#$'$ 3/:;; D0 3ADC0=7 78 7/0 203A;7 89 7/43 E247 10747486 7 43 37:705 7/:7 7/0 68 =8694506=0 <87486 E:3 /0;53A==0339A;;>:@:46377/0107474860286''#$'$
#' 3 102 A;0 # 89 7/0 A;03 #( 2031865067843D8A6578433A0# 5:>3=;0:26874=078 :;;7/0<0<D023897/0:6=/:>:7897/046706505<00746@ A;; 06=/ 89 7/43 8A27 46 7/0 =:30 89 A77:3E:<> 3A12:/0;57/:77/0A;03#(43:=8<1;070=850:65 /:3 78 D0 98;;8E05 3724=7;> /02098202031865067843 D8A65 78 =8<1;> 7/0 3:45 128=05A20 9:4;46@ E/4=/ 7/0 6874=0897/0<00746@E8A;5;:130
- 9 -
## 6 7/0 =:30 86 /:65 7/0 6874=0 5:705 #+#$$'$( E:3 E47/46 #' 5:>3 201203067:7486 5:705 '"#$$'$(928<7/03AD<433486897/0201203067:748678 /8;57/068=8694506=0<00746@=81>897/436874=0E:3 20=04?05 D> 2031865067 8( 86 #!#$$'$( 031865067 8(/:337:7057/:77/0=81>897/436874=0E:3302?0586 7/01074748602:6587/02<0<D02386#!#$$'$(/02043 687/46@ 78 3/8E 7/:7 7/0 6874=0 E:3 302?05 86 7/0 1074748602 86 ##$$'$( 82 7/:7 :6> 87/02 <0<D02 /:5 20=04?05 7/0 6874=0 86 ##$$'$( 860 89 7/0 124?:70 20318650673 82 87/02 <0<D023 89 7/0 :6=/:>:7 /:?0 =;:4<05 7/:7 7/0 6874=0 E:3 302?05 86 7/0< 86 ##$$'$(074748602467/0E2471074748646474:;;>=;:4<05 7/:7 7/0 6874=0 E:3 302?05 86 /4< 86 $#$$'$(
8E0?02 ;:702 /0 545 : 7A26 D> =;:4<46@ 7/:7 7/0 3:45 6874=0 E:3 302?05 86 /4< 86 ##$$'$( 6 82502 78 DA772033/43=867067486/020;405867/00672><:50D>/4< 86 : =81> 89 7/0 6874=0 E/4=/ E:3 /:6505 8?02 78 7/0 :3 :6 :=B68E;05@<067 89 7/0 302?4=0 6874=0
8E0?02497/01074748602/:5<:507/03:450658230<067
- 10 -
867/0:=B68E;05@<0677/:7E:3/:65058?02787/0 7/0824@46:;=81>897/03:45;07702<A37/:?0D006467/0 94;0A786102A3:;897/006742094;07/0824@46:;=81>89 7/0 3:45 :=B68E;05@<067 E:3 687 98A65 /0209820 7/0 =;:4<897/010747486027/:77/06874=0E:3302?0586/4< 86##$$'$(43E47/8A7:6>D:343 #$ 67/0:D306=089:6><:7024:;783/8E7/:77/0 6874=0 E:3 302?05 86 7/0 1074748602 86 ##$$'$( 7/0 =86706748689;0:260506482=8A630;9827/010747486027/:7 47E:3302?0586##$$'$(5803687<0247=8634502:7486 8630GA067;>4743/0;57/:77/01074748602E:3@2:6705# 5:>3 =;0:2 6874=0 89 7/0 <00746@ :65 /06=0 7/020 43 68 02282 46 7/0 128=05A20 :581705 D> 2031865067 8 46 =86?0646@7/0<00746@86''#$'$
# ==82546@;> 7/0 10747486 ;:=B3 <0247 :65 7/0 3:<043
#( 09820 1:2746@ 47 43 :1128124:70 78 5420=7 7/0 33437:678<<4334860278/06=09827/063A207/:77/05:70
- 11 -
89 302?4=0 89 6874=0 43 128102;> <06748605 38 7/:7 7/030 B465 89 433A03 58 687 :2430 982 =8634502:7486 D09820 7/0 8A273469A7A20
!*(
'&) &
4378)#;8)#" )