Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 12295 (KAR)
AKASH @ YALLAPPA v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA AND ANR
CRL.A/200352/2024 · 2025-01-23
S Vishwajith Shetty
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 12295 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 12295 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"
# $
"%%&'(&)&)) '$
"%%&'(&)&))
"%%&'(&)&))
'
$
! "#
$
% # ##
"
$
&
#'
! "#
% #
%&$
Digitally signed by SHILPA R TENIHALLI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
%
' "$ "&$ "$ $ (# #
& & & &' )*& &'#
$
%
#
#
(# #
#
&
& #
%
+&& &'
% %
% %%
#
"&$ ++ * +& + +"$ % # & &+ +"$",$ +"$"-$ +"&$".$%&
'
$
#
'
! "#
$
% # ##
"
$
&
#'
$ ! "#
% #
%&$
- 3 -
%
' "&$ % "$
& && &'
& &' #
$
%
#
#
(# #
#
+&& &'
% %
% %%
#
"&$++ *+&++"$%#& &+
+"$",$+"$"-$+"&$".$%&
'
$
/ #/#
)
#"% $%
#/#
! "#
$
% # ##
"
$
&
#'
- 4 -
! "#
% #
%&$
%
'"$"&$ % "$
& && &'
& &' #
$
%
#
#
(#
#
#
+
+ #
%
+&& &'
% %
% %%
#
"$++ *+&+"&$+"$%#& &+
+"$",$+"$"-$+"&$"0.$%&
%
1
2#
1
- 5 -
"
" 2#
1 $
334-567-87+9:,9;57+&& &',5<9-85,56 => 50.,. 9??.,.<9 7@935 8.897: 9A.>.?4, B7, 8C5 7BB5:35-?4:9-C.=@54:65,53897:-"&$++ *+& ++"$7B#& &+.:653897:-+"$",$+"$"-$.:6 +"&$"0.$ 7B 3C564@56 .-85- .:6 3C564@56 ,9=5-
",505:897:7B8,739895-$;5:6;5:838& "B7,-C7,8 28C5 38 7B & ($ .,5 =5B7,5 8C9- 74,8 9: 8C5-5 8C,55 .??5.@- B9@56 4:65, 53897: '"&$ 7B 8C5 38 7B & .--.9@9:< 8C5 7,65, 6.856 & && &'
?.--56 9: ,@9-37& &' ,@9-37)*& &' .:6 ,@9-37 & &' => 8C5 74,8 7B 669897:.@ 9-8,938.:65--97:-46<5.:6?539.@46<59A.>.?4,
& 5.,6@5.,:56374:-5@B7,8C5?.,895-
+ % 9: ,9;5 7+&& &' D.- ,5<9-85,56 => 50.,.
9??.,.<9 7@935 8.897:
9A.>.?4, B7, 8C5 .B7,5-.967BB5:35-.-.<.9:-88C5.??5@@.:8-C5,59:7:8C5 =.-9- 7B 8C5 B9,-8 9:B7,;.897: 6.856 && &' ,5359056
- 6 -
B,7; ,5-?7:65:8 7& C5,59: DC7 9- 8C5 B.8C5, 7B 8C5 9:A4,56 9,.: .<56 .=748 >5.,- : 8C5 -.96 3.-5 .334-56 7 D.- .,,5-856 7: && &' C5 =.9@ .??@93.897: B9@56 => C9; =5B7,5 8C5 A4,9-693897:.@ 5--97:- 74,8 9: ,@9-37& &' D.- ,5A53856 7:
& && &'C5,5B7,5C59-=5B7,58C9-74,89:,9;9:.@ ??5.@7& + & &'??,5C5:69:<8C59,.,,5-89:8C5 -.96 3.-5 .334-56 7-& .:6 + C.6 B9@56 ,@9-37-)*& &'.:6,@9-37 & &'=5B7,5 8C574,87B669897:.@9-8,938.:65--97:-46<5.:6 ?539.@ 46<5 9A.>.?4, .:6 8C5 -.96 ?589897:- D5,5 .@-7 69-;9--56 7: & && &' C5,5B7,5 .334-56 7& 9- =5B7,58C9-74,89:,9;9:.@??5.@7& +'*& &'.:6 .334-56 7+ 9- =5B7,5 8C9- 74,8 9: ,9;9:.@ ??5.@ 7& +&& &'
' 5.,:56 374:-5@ B7, 8C5 .??5@@.:8- C.09:< ,5985,.856 8C5<,74:6-4,<56 9:8C5 .??5.@ ;5;7,.:64;
-4=;98- 8C.8 8C5.@@5<.897:7B .--.4@89:< 9:A4,56 9,.: 7: C9-C5.6D98C.:9,7:,769-7:@>.-.<.9:-8.334-567
- 7 -
DC7 9- .@,5.6> .,,5-856 334-56 7-& .:6 + C.05 .@@5<56@> .--.4@856 9:A4,56 9,.: .:6 ,5;E4;., D98C 3C.??.@ .:6 -87:5- C5 9:A4,56 ?5,-7:- C.05 :78 -4BB5,56.:><,95074-9:A4,95-9:8C59:3965:89:F45-897: 5-4=;98-8C.87;:9=4-.@@5<.897:-.,5;.65.<.9:-8.@@ 8C5.334-56D98C,5<.,687.=4-9:<8C509389;,5B5,,9:<87 8C59, 3.-85 .:6 :7 -?539B93 .@@5<.897: 9- ;.65 .- .<.9:-8 .:> 7:5 7B 8C5 .334-56 .:6 8C5,5B7,5 8C5 =., 4:65, 53897:7B8C5387B& 3.::78=5;.65.??@93.=@5 5 -4=;98- 8C.8 .??5@@.:8- 67 :78 C.05 .:> 3,9;9:.@ .:853565:8-.:6.334-567+9-.-8465:8.<56.=748) >5.,-
5-4=;98-8C.8.??5@@.:8-.,5,5.6>.:6D9@@9:<87 377?5,.85D98C8C5?7@935B7,8C5?4,?7-57B9:05-89<.897: 337,69:<@>C5?,.>-87.@@7D8C5.??5.@-
5, 37:8,. @5.,:56
9<C 74,8 705,:;5:8 @5.65, .??5.,9:< B7, ,5-?7:65:8 7 .:6 @5.,:56 374:-5@.??5.,9:<B7,,5-?7:65:87&C.057??7-568C5 ?,.>5,;.659:8C5.??5.@-C5>-4=;988C.89:095D7B 8C5=.,4:65,53897:7B8C5387B& 8C5?,.>5,
- 8 -
;.65=>.334-567-&.:6+B7,<,.:87B.:8939?.87,>=.9@ 3.::78 =5 5:85,8.9:56 C5> .@-7 -4=;98 8C.8 8C5 .??5@@.:8-C.05:78;.65=78C8C509389;-.-?.,8>878C5 .??5.@-.-,5F49,564:65,53897:7B8C5387B& C5> B4,8C5, -4=;98 8C.8 8C5 9:A4,56 9,.: C.- -4BB5,56 <,95074-9:A4,>7:C9-C5.6.:6.337,69:<@>8C5>?,.>87 69-;9--8C5.??5.@-
5,4-.@ 7B 8C5 % D74@6 <7 87 -C7D 8C.8 8C5 B9,-8 9:B7,;.:8 9- 8C5 B.8C5, 7B 8C5 09389; 9,.: DC7 9- . -8465:8.<56.=48>5.,-C578C5,09389;,5;E4;., 9--.9687=5.B,95:67B-.96 9,.::8C5B9,-89:B7,;.897:
:7DC5,5 98 9- -8.856 8C.8 ,5;E4;., .@-7 =5@7:<- 87 3C564@56.-857,3C564@56,9=537;;4:98>C74<C @5.,:56374:-5@B7,,5-?7:65:87&C.-B9@56-8.85;5:87B 7=A53897:7??7-9:<8C5?,.>5,;.659:8C5.??5.@-505:
9: 8C5 -8.85;5:8 7B 7=A53897: 98 9- :78 37:85:656 8C.8 09389; ,5;E4;., .@-7 =5@7:<- 87 3C564@56 .-85 7, 3C564@56 ,9=5 37;;4:98> .:6 8C5,5B7,5 9:A4,56 ,5;E4;., 3.::78 =5 37:-965,56 .- .
09389; D98C9: 8C5
- 9 -
;5.:9:< 7B 53897: &"$"53$ 7B 8C5 38 7B & DC93C ,5.6-.-B7@@7D-
!"
"
"#
"" $ # # # %&
) :8C5B9,-89:B7,;.897:-4=;98856=>8C5B.8C5, 7B8C509389; 9,.:989--8.8568C.8 9,.:D.-=59:<85.-56 => C9- B,95:6 .334-56 7+ ,5B5,,9:< 87 C9- 3.-85 .:6 7:
&'& &' DC5: 9,.: C.6 <7:5 87 =,9:< ;9@E B,7; 8C5 ;9@E -87,5 :5., 8C5 =4--8.:6 9: 8C59, 09@@.<5 .334-56 7+.@@5<56@>9:B7,;56C9;8C.8.334-567-.:6&C.6 -4;;7:56 9,.: 337,69:<@> 9,.: C.6 .337;?.:956 .334-56 7+ G E.-C 87 8C5 ?@.35 DC5,5 .334-56 7- .:6&D5,5-9889:<334-567-.:6&.@@5<56@>.=4-56
- 10 -
9,.: ,5B5,,9:<87 C9-3.-85 .B85, -559:<C9; .:6 .334-56 78C5,5.B85,.@@5<56@>.--.4@856 9,.:D98C.:9,7:,76 7: C9- C5.6 .:6 3.4-56 =@776 77H9:< 9:A4,> 1C5: ,5;E4;.,8,956879:85,B5,5.334-567.--.4@856C9;
7: C9- @5< D98C .: 9,7: ,7.6 334-56 7& DC7 9- 8C5 B.8C5, 7B .334-56 7 .@@5<56@> .--.4@856 9,.: 7: C9- =.3E D98C C9- 3C.??.@ .:6 .334-56 7+ .--.4@856 9,.: D98C.-87:5C5,5.B85,.@@8C5.334-56?5,-7:-.@@5<56@> .=4-56 9,.:.:678C5,-DC7C.6<.8C5,568C5,587?.39B> 8C5B9<C8,5B5,,9:<878C59,3.-85.:6D5:8.D.>B,7;8C5 -?78 334-56 7 9- -.96 87 =5 8C5 ;.85,:.@ 4:3@5 7B .334-56 7+ .:6 .334-56 7& 9- 8C5 B.8C5, 7B .334-56 7C5.@@5<.897:7B.--.4@89:< 9,.:D98C.:9,7:,7.6 7: C9- C5.6 9- 7:@> .- .<.9:-8 .334-56 7 DC7 9- 9: 34-876>334-5679-.,,5-8567: && &'.:69-9: 34-876>B7,8C5@.-8;7,58C.:7:5;7:8C:69-?4856@> C5C.-:778C5,3,9;9:.@.:853565:8-334-567-&.:6 + .@@5<56@> C.6 .--.4@856 9,.: D98C 3C.??.@ .:6 -87:5- ,5-?538905@> 05:.-?5,8C5%=@77677H9:<9:A4,>D.- 3.4-56 87 9,.: 7:@> .- . ,5-4@8 7B .--.4@8 ;.65 =>
- 11 -
.334-56 7 : 8C5 % ,5<9-85,56 7: 8C5 =.-9- 7B 8C5 B9,-8 9:B7,;.897: -4=;98856 => ,5-?7:65:8 7& 7:@> 7BB5:35?4:9-C.=@5 4:65, 53897: "$ 7B# & &+9- 9:07E56.:68C57BB5:35?4:9-C.=@54:65,53897:"&$ 7B # & &+ DC93C 9- 37,,5-?7:69:< 87 53897: +& 7B 9- :78 9:07E56 C5,5B7,5 98 9- .??.,5:8 8C.8 8C5 9:A4,56C.05-4BB5,567:@>-9;?@59:A4,95-9:8C59:3965:89: F45-897:
5.,:56
9<C 74,8 705,:;5:8 @5.65, C.- -4=;98856 8C.8 9:A4,56 ,5;E4;., C.- -4BB5,56 7:@> -9;?@59:A4,95-9:8C59:3965:89:F45-897:C5?C787<,.?C 7B 9:A4,56 9,.: ?,764356 => @5.,:56 374:-5@ B7, ,5-?7:65:8 7& .@7:< D98C C9- -8.85;5:8 7B 7=A53897:
D74@6 .@-7 ?,9;.
B.395 <7 87 -C7D 8C.8 C5 C.- -4BB5,56 7:@>-9;?@5 9:A4,>7:C9-C5.6 05:78C5,D9-5.334-56 7DC7C.-3.4-568C5-.969:A4,>9-9:34-876>B7,8C5 @.-8;7,58C.:7:5;7:8C5,4-.@7B8C5B9,-89:B7,;.897:
D74@6 <7 87 -C7D 8C.8 8C5,5 9- :7 -?539B93 .@@5<.897: .- .<.9:-8 .:> 7:5 7B 8C5 .334-56 .=748 8C5> .=4-9:< 8C5
- 12 -
09389; 9,.: 7, 8C5 78C5, ?5,-7:- =5@7:<9:< 87 8C5 -.96 37;;4:98> DC7 C.6 <.8C5,56 87 ?.39B> 8C5 B9<C8 => ,5B5,,9:< 87 8C59, 3.-85 C5,5B7,5 .; 7B 8C5 7?9:97:
8C.88C5=.,4:65,53897:7B8C5387B& 3.::78=5 -8,938@>;.65.??@93.=@59:8C5?,5-5:83.-5B7,37:-965,9:< 8C5 .:8939?.87,> =.9@ .??@93.897: 7B .334-56 7-& .:6 + 334-567&9-.<56.=748>5.,-.:6C59--.9687=5 8C5 B.8C5, 7B .334-56 7 .:6 <,.:6B.8C5, 7B .334-56 7+ 334-56 7+ 9- . -8465:8 .<56 .=748 ) >5.,- :65, 8C5 39,34;-8.:35- .; 7B 8C5 7?9:97: 8C.8 8C5 ?,.>5,;.65=>8C5.??5@@.:8-.334-567-87+9:8C5-5 8C,55.??5.@-:556-87=5<,.:856337,69:<@>B7@@7D9:< 7,65,9-?.--56
C5.??5.@-.,5.@@7D56
C5 9;?4<:56 7,65,- ?.--56 => 8C5 74,8 7B 669897:.@9-8,938.:65--97:-46<5.:6?539.@46<5 9A.>.?4, 6.856 & && &' 9: ,@9-37& &'
- 13 -
,@9-37-)*& &' .:6 ,@9-37 & &' 9- -58 .-965 C5 .??5@@.:8.334-56 7 9- 69,53856 87 =5 5:@.,<56 7: =.9@ 9: ,9;5 7+&& &' 7B 50.,. 9??.,.<9 7@935 8.897: 9A.>.?4, ,5<9-85,56 B7, 8C5 7BB5:35-?4:9-C.=@54:65,53897:-"&$++ *+& ++"$7B#& &+.:653897:-+"$",$+"$"-$.:6 +"&$"0.$ 7B 3C564@56 .-85- .:6 3C564@56 ,9=5-
",505:897:7B 8,739895-$ ;5:6;5:8 38& ?5:69:< =5B7,5 8C5 74,8 7B 669897:.@ 9-8,938 .:6 5--97:- 46<5 .:6 ?539.@ 46<5 9A.>.?4, -4=A538 87 8C5 B7@@7D9:<37:69897:- .$??5@@.:8-C.@@5I53485?5,-7:.@=7:6B7,.-4;
7B - D98C 8D7 -4,5895- B7, 8C5 @9E5-4; 87 8C5 -.89-B.3897: 7B 8C5 A4,9-693897:.@ 74,8 =$??5@@.:8-C.@@.??5.,,5<4@.,@>7:.@@8C56.85- 7BC5.,9:<=5B7,58C5,9.@74,84:@5--8C5,9.@ 74,85I5;?8-C5,.??5.,.:35B7,0.@96,5.-7:-
- 14 -
3$ ??5@@.:8-C.@@:7869,538@>7,9:69,538@>8C,5.85: 7,8.;?5,D98C8C5?,7-534897:D98:5--5- 6$??5@@.:8 -C.@@ :78 9:07@05 9:-9;9@., 7BB5:35-9: B484,5
C5 ,5-?7:65:8 7@935 7, .:> 78C5, ?7@935 9: 8C5 8.85 7B .,:.8.E. .,5 69,53856 87 ,5@5.-5 8C5 .??5@@.:8-.334-56 7-& .:6 + 9: 8C5 505:8 7B 8C59, .,,5-8 9: ,9;5 7+&& &' ,5<9-85,56 => 50.,. 9??.,.<9 7@935 8.897: 9A.>.?4, B7, 8C5 7BB5:35- ?4:9-C.=@5 4:65, 53897:- "&$ ++ * +& + +"$ 7B # & &+ .:6 53897:- +"$",$ +"$"-$ .:6 +"&$"0.$ 7B 3C564@56 .-85- .:6 3C564@56 ,9=5-
",505:897:7B8,739895-$;5:6;5:838& ?5:69:< =5B7,5 8C5 74,8 7B 669897:.@ 9-8,938 .:6 5--97:- 46<5 .:6 ?539.@ 46<5 9A.>.?4, -4=A538 87 8C5 B7@@7D9:<37:69897:-
??5@@.:8- -C.@@ .??5., =5B7,5 8C5 :05-89<.89:< BB935, D98C9: 6.>- B,7; 8C5 6.857B,5359?87B35,89B95637?>7B8C9-7,65,.:6 -C.@@ 5I53485 . ?5,-7:.@ =7:6 B7, . -4; 7B - 5.3C D98C 8D7 -4,5895- B7, 8C5
- 15 -
@9E5-4; 87 8C5 -.89-B.3897: 7B 8C5 9:05-89<.89:< 7BB935, & ??5@@.:8--C.@@,5<4@.,@>.??5.,=5B7,58C5 ,9.@ 74,8 D98C748 B.9@ 4:@5-- 5I5;?856 => 8C5 ,9.@74,8B7,0.@96,5.-7:- + ??5@@.:8- -C.@@ :78 8.;?5, D98C 8C5 ?,7-534897: D98:5--5- .:68C5> -C.@@ 377?5,.85 D98C 8C5 ?7@935 B7, 9:05-89<.897: .:6 .??5., =5B7,58C5;DC5:505,3.@@564?7: ' ??5@@.:8- -C.@@ :78 9:07@05 9: -9;9@., 7BB5:35-9:B484,5
*'
&# $ )
9-87@7*