Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 12292 (KAR)
VINAYAK S/O TUKARAM DHOOPAD v. MAHANTAPPA B. KANTI AND ANR
MFA/200883/2021 · 2025-02-06
C M Joshi
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 12292 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 12292 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! ! "## $$
%& ' (
!"#$%$
&
$
! '
!"($%$
)
!)*
*
%$
&
* )+
%#%$)%),
$
Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
* * $(,$ *
$$$-#(! . *
*
)-%-)%$" )) * )%$$
*
/
#
/
0123453627859:35;12<34589==59:>3?72:@26A6A5 =9:6>546A5B9665:>469C53<=72:7>398;>4=24986A2<?A>6 >448965;72:;B>44>23
A>4 9==598 >4 ;>:5165; 9?9>346 6A5 D<;?B536 93;
9E9:; ;965; )-%-)%$" =9445; >3 2)) )%$$ @0 6A5859:35;53>2:>F>8<;?593;5B@5:2 <;;5@>A98 A5:5>39765: :575::5; 62 94 G6A5 :>@<398H 72: 4A2:6
- 3 -
) 0 6A5 >B=<?35; D<;?B536 93; 9E9:; 6A5 :>@<398 A94 9882E5; 6A5 189>B =56>6>23 >3 =9:6 93;
9E9:;5; 9 4<B 27
4!%,)! 94 12B=53496>23 93;
;>:5165; 6A5 34<:9315 2B=930 62 ;5=24>6 6A5 49B5 ??:>5F5;@06A549>;D<;?B53693;9E9:;6A5=56>6>235: >4@572:56A>42<:6455C>3?53A9315B536123653;>3?6A96 6A5I<936<B2712B=53496>239E9:;5;@06A5:>@<398>4 236A582E5:4>;5
, A5 4A2:6 =2>36 6A96 9:>45 72: 1234>;5:96>23 >3 6A>49==598>4EA56A5:6A5=56>6>235:EA24<775:5;>8244 27 7:236 6556A E>6A @855;>3? >> 822453>3? 27 )3; >31>42: >>>4E588>3?27:>?A6505>F9@:94>232F5:9365:>2:94=516 27 58@2E E>6A 4E588>3? F 8244 27 A987 6226A 93; F>>37:92:@>698:>;?57:916<:5236A5:>?A64>;5>4536>685;
72: 930 9;;>6>2398 12B=53496>23 6A93 EA96 A94 @553 9E9:;5;@06A5:>@<398J
A5 =56>6>235: 189>B5; 6A96 A5 E94 9 59F5:
93; 6A5 :>@<398 9;2=65; 6A5 >312B5 94 =:2F>;5; <3;5:
6A5
1A5B5 27 6A5 ?2F5:3B536 93; 9445445; 6A5
- 4 -
>312B5 96
4!(,% =5: B236A 765: 1234>;5:>3? 6A5 589@2:9655F>;53159F9>89@8523:512:;>6A94?:9365;6A5 12B=53496>2327
4!%,)! <3;5:6A572882E>3?A59;4 9>393;4<775:>3? 4)!%%% :9F588>3? 96653;936 93; 32<:>4AB5365K=53454 4!%%% 5;>1985K=53;>6<:5 4-!-! 2B=53496>2372:89>;<==5:>2; 4!(,% 244279B53>6>54 4!%%% )*+ ,-
! 59:; 6A5 859:35; 12<3458 9==59:>3? 72: 6A5 9==58893693;6A5859:35;12<345872::54=23;5362) # 59:35; 12<34584 9==59:>3? 72: @26A 4>;54 4<@B>6 6A96 6A2<?A 6A5 :>@<398 A94 E:>6653 9 E588 9:6>1<8965; D<;?B536 >6 4A2<8; A9F5 9E9:;5; 9;5I<965 12B=53496>23<3;5:6A5A59;278244279B53>6>54>38>75 K15=66A96:546276A5D<;?B536276A5:>@<398;254326 355;930>365:75:5315 ( 3 6A5 8>?A6 27 6A5 4<@B>44>234 B9;5 93; 23 =5:<498 27 6A5 >B=<?35; D<;?B536 >6 >4 5F>;536 6A96 6A5 =56>6>235: EA2 >4 9 59F5: A9; 8246 7:236 6556A 93;
- 5 -
822453>3? 27 6A5 )3; >31>42: 6 6A5 B246 >6 193 @5 49>;
6A96 6A5 =56>6>235: A9; ;>77>1<860 >3 53D20>3? 6A5 1<8>39:0 ;58>191>54 93; 6A5:572:5 6A5 8244 27 4<1A 53D20B536 4A2<8; A9F5 @553 1234>;5:5; @0 6A5 :>@<398 326A5: 93?85EA>1A355;462@59;;5;>46A966A5=56>6>235:B90 355;9;536<:562B9C5A>B=:545369@85765:1234>;5:>3? 6A545 94=5164 >6 9==59:4 6A96 6A5 =56>6>235: 4A2<8; A9F5 @5539E9:;5;94<B27
4,%%%% <3;5:6A5A59;278244 279B53>6>54>38>756>4984262@53265;6A966A5396<:527 6A5>3D<:>544<775:5;@06A5=56>6>235:;23261236:>@<65>3 930E9062E9:;4824427A>4>312B5
" 3 6A96 F>5E 27 6A5 B9665: 6A5 =56>6>235: >4 536>685; 72: 93 9;;>6>2398 4<B 27
4)!%%% 9765:
;5;<16>3? 4!%%% 9E9:;5;@06A5:>@<398<3;5:6A5 A59;278244279B53>6>54>38>75A5:572:5 6A5 9==598 4<1155;4>3=9:653156A572882E>3?
> A59==598>49882E5;>3=9:6
- 6 -
>> A5 D<;?B536 93; 9E9:; =9445; @0 6A5 :>@<398>4B2;>7>5; >>> A5 9==588936 >4 536>685; 72: 9 4<B 27 , >3 9;;>6>23 62 EA96 A94 @553 9E9:;5; @0 6A5 :>@<398 62?56A5: E>6A >365:54696#L=97:2B6A5;96527=56>6>23 6>88 >64 :598>M96>23 2E5F5: 6A5 9==588936 >4 326 536>685; 72: >365:546 72: 6A5 ;58905; =5:>2;27!);904>37>8>3?6A59==598 >F 54=23;536 2) 34<:9315 2B=930 >4 ;>:5165; 62 ;5=24>6 6A5 536>:5 12B=53496>23 9B2<36E>6A>39=5:>2;274>KE55C47:2B6A5 ;965276A>42:;5: F
3 4<1A ;5=24>6 6A5 536>:5 53A9315; 9B2<36>42:;5:5;62@5:585945;>379F2<:27 6A59==58893623=:2=5:>;536>60 F> 59:35; 12<3458 72: :54=23;536 2) >4 =5:B>665;627>85F9C9896AE>6A>36E2E55C4
; %# ' #
>462$82$