Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 12269 (KAR)
MALLAYYA AND ORS v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA AND ANR
CRL.A/200351/2024 · 2025-01-21
S Vishwajith Shetty
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 12269 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 12269 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! " # $
"
%%
&'&(( $
! "
"
#
$! %
Digitally signed by SHILPA R TENIHALLI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
&
!! ! '"
! '"
#
$!&
%
&
' $% & $ %
(% )! ! **
"" ! + +
&
&
&
** ((% &
! ! ! ! ! ,-
,- ! &
" &
&&
! *$% *$%*$%*"$% $%*""$%$% * &! $%$.%$/% $%$01% &
& &
+ +
&
&
"*
&
+
- 3 -
2!+
+
" $ 2!+
+%
31.435 6784/39 :7. ;<3 1==39914;/ /8>?(;/ ;<1; ;<3 1==39914; 7/ 145 " <103 >334 1..3/;35 58.(4@ ;<3 =345346A 7: ;<(/ 1==319 145 ;<3.3:7.3 ;<3 1==319 ?1A >35(/?(//351/1@1(4/;;<3? 40(3B7:;<3/8>?(//(747:;<3931.4356784/39 :7. ;<3 1==39914;/ ;<3 1==319 (/ 5(/?(//35 1/ 1@1(4/; 1==39914;7/145"
<31==39914;7<3.3(4B<7(/1668/357,(4 =36(19 1/3 7"* =345(4@ >3:7.3 ;<3 78.; 7: 55(;(7419 (/;.(6; 145 3//(74/ +85@3 1(6<8. /(;;(4@ 1;
(45<148.1.(/(4@78;7:16.(?37" .3@(/;3.35>A 8;;( 79(63 ;1;(74 1(6<8. 5(/;.(6; :7. ;<3 7::3463/ =84(/<1>93 8453. 36;(74/ *$% *$% *$% *
"$% $%""$%$%.315B(;<36;(74* 7:!<1.1;(A1A1A114<(;1$:7./<7.;C!%145 36;(74 $%$.%$/% $%$01% 7: 6; (/ >3:7.3 ;<(/
- 4 -
78.; (4 ;<(/ 1==319 1//1(9(4@ ;<3 7.53. 51;35 ** =1//35 >A ;<3 ;.(19 78.; (4 .(?(419 (/6 7"" :(935 8453. 36;(74 7: !<1.1;(A1 1@1.(D1 8.1D/<1 14<(;1/33D(4@14;(6(=1;7.A>1(9
31.5;<3931.4356784/39:7.;<31==39914;7 145 ;<3 931.435 (@< 78.; 703.4?34; 93153. :7. ;<3 .3/=74534;7
" 3/=74534;7B<7(//3.035(4;<3?1;;3.<1/ .3?1(43584'.3=.3/34;35>3:7.3;<(/78.;
, & (4 .(?3 7" B1/ .3@(/;3.35 >A 8;;( 79(63 ;1;(74 1(6<8. 5(/;.(6; 1@1(4/; .( 1.(A1==1 145-7;<3./:7.;<31:7.3/1(57::3463/74;<3>1/(/7:;<3 :(./;(4:7.?1;(7451;35-.363(035:.7?.3/=74534; 7 ==.3<345(4@ 1..3/; (4 ;<3 /1(5 61/3 ;<3 1==39914; 7<3.3(4<15:(935.(?(419(/67"" >3:7.3;<3 ;.(19 78.; B<(6< B1/ 5(/?(//35 1/ 1@1(4/; <3. 74 ** <3.3:7.3 ;<3 1==39914; 7 1668/35 7, (/ >3:7.3;<(/78.;
- 5 -
- 31.435 6784/39 :7. ;<3 1==39914; /8>?(;/ ;<1;
;<3 1==39914; 7 (/ 1 ?1..(35 915A 1@35 1>78; A31./ <3<1/477;<3.6.(?(41914;363534;/<3(403/;(@1;(747:
;<3 61/3 (/ 67?=93;35 145 749A ;<3 1993@1;(74 1@1(4/; ;<3 1==39914;7 1668/357,(4;<36<1.@3'/<33;(/;<1;/<3 <151//189;35;<3:(./;(4:7.?14;B(;<<3.<145/14593@/
3. 674;.1 931.435 (@< 78.; 703.4?34;
93153. <1/ 7==7/35 ;<3 =.1A3. ?153 (4 ;<3 1==319 145 =.1A/;75(/?(//;<31==319
* &(4.(?37" B1/.3@(/;3.35>A8;;( 79(63;1;(741(6<8.5(/;.(6;1@1(4/;.(1.(A1==1145- 7;<3./ 74 ;<3 >1/(/ 7: ;<3 :(./; (4:7.?1;(74 .363(035 :.7? .3/=74534; 7 74 - 8.(4@ ;<3 678./3 7: (403/;(@1;(74 /7?3 7: ;<3 1668/35 B3.3 1..3/;35 :;3. 67?=93;(4@ ;<3 (403/;(@1;(74 6<1.@3'/<33; <1/ >334 47B :(935 1@1(4/; 3(@<; 1668/35 =3./74/ <3 1==39914; 7 <3.3(4(/1..1(@4351/1668/357,(4;<36<1.@3'/<33;4 ;<3:(./;(4:7.?1;(7447/=36(:(6703.;16;<1/>334?1531/ 1@1(4/;;<31==39914;7<3.3(44;<36<1.@3'/<33;(;(/
- 6 -
1993@35;<1;;<31==39914;7 1668/357,<151//189;35 ;<3 :(./; (4:7.?14; B(;< <3. <145/ 145 93@/145 19/7 =89935 ;<3 <1(.
7: ;<3 :(./; (4:7.?14; E63=; ;<3 /1(5 1993@1;(74 ;<3.3 (/ 47 7;<3. 1993@1;(74 1/ 1@1(4/; ;<3 1==39914; 7 1668/35 7, <3 1==39914; 7 1668/35 7, (/ 1 ?1..(35915A74/(53.(4@;<341;8.37:1993@1;(74/:7845(4 ;<3:(./;(4:7.?1;(74145(4;<36<1.@3'/<33;1/1@1(4/;;<3 1==39914; 7 <3.3(4 B<7 <1/ 47 7;<3. 6.(?(419 14;363534;/1?7:;<37=(4(74;<1;;<3=.1A3.:7.@.14;7:
14;(6(=1;7.A >1(9 4335/ ;7 >3 14/B3.35 1::(.?1;(039A 667.5(4@9A;<3:7997B(4@7.53. $(% <31==319(/1997B35(4=1.;F $((% <3 7.53. 51;35 ** =1//35 >A ;<3 55(;(7419 (/;.(6; 145 3//(74/ +85@3 1(6<8. /(;;(4@ 1; (45<148.(4.(?(419(/67"" (4/7:1.(;.391;3/ ;7.3G36;(4@;<3=.1A3.?153>A;<31==39914;7 1668/35 7,:7.@.14;7:14;(6(=1;7.A>1(9(//3;1/(53F
- 7 -
$(((% <3.3/=74534;'79(637.14A7;<3.=79(63(4;<3 ;1;3 7: 1.41;1D1 1.3 5(.36;35 ;7 .3931/3 ;<3 1==39914; 7 1668/35 7, (4 ;<3 3034; 7: <3. 1..3/; (4 .(?3 7" .3@(/;3.35 >A 8;;( 79(63 ;1;(74 1(6<8. 5(/;.(6;:7.;<37::3463/=84(/<1>938453.36;(74/ *$% *$%*$%*""$% *"$%"$% .315 B(;< 36;(74 * 7: ! 145 8453. 36;(74/ $%$.%$/%$%$01%7: 6;>3:7.3;<355(;(7419 (/;.(6; 145 3//(74/ +85@3 1(6<8. /(;;(4@ 1; (45<148. /8>G36;;7;<3:7997B(4@6745(;(74/
==39914;7 1668/357,/<1991==31. >3:7.3;<3403/;(@1;(4@ ::(63.B(;<(4"51A/:.7? ;<3 51;3 7: .363(=; 7: 63.;(:(35 67=A 7: ;<(/ 7.53. 145 /<199 3E368;3 1 =3./7419 >745 :7. 1 /8? 7:
/" 'B(;<;B7/8.3;(3/:7.;<39(D3/8?;7;<3 /1;(/:16;(747:;<3(403/;(@1;(4@7::(63. ==39914; 7 1668/35 7, /<199 .3@891.9A1==31.>3:7.3;<3.(1978.;B(;<78;:1(9 8493// 3E3?=;35 >A ;<3 .(19 78.; :7. 019(5 .31/74/
==39914; 7 1668/35 7, /<199 47;
;1?=3. B(;< ;<3 =.7/368;(74 B(;43//3/ 145 /<3
- 8 -
/<199 67'7=3.1;3 B(;< ;<3 =79(63 :7. (403/;(@1;(74 1451==31.>3:7.3;<3?B<34303.6199358=74
==39914; 7 1668/35 7, /<199 47; (407903(4/(?(91.7::3463/(4:8;8.3 )'
&# $ (
(/;797