Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 12266 (KAR)
JAGANNATH S/O MALLESHAPPA BAGODI v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
CRL.A/200103/2020 · 2025-02-06
S Vishwajith Shetty
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 12266 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 12266 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! ! "#
$% &$ ! #'' ()*(+',-*(,, &
!"" #
$%&
!"
#
'&( !#
$ %$
Digitally signed by SHIVAKUMAR HIREMATH Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
'%)%%
"
& $' !$#!# *
$'!#
"
$)
*
"
+
"*
$# ! +
"*
#
,-.//01234506078-94'&(!#9:6-.:-205 1..1-2-4; 8,0 <35;=048 145 96506 9: 794>-78-94 145 .0480470 51805 %'%)%% /1..05 ?@ 8,0 79368 9: 6-47-/120..-94.35;0145/07-1235;0121?361;--4 /07-121.09$ %$
01658,020164057934.02:968,0/168-0. ' //022148 ,060-4 A1. 7,16;0 .,00805 :96 9::0470./34-.,1?2034506078-94.&$'!$#!5#6015A-8, 078-94$'!#9:60>048-949:9663/8-9478$)!:96 .,968B8,078$)C#?@9D1@3D8192-70121?361;-4
- 3 -
8,0 .1-5 71.0 1//022148 1:806 1//016-4; ?0:960 8,0 86-12 9368,15721-=0589?086-05,0/69.0738-94-49650689 .3?.8148-180 -8. 7,16;0. 1;1-4.8 8,0 1//022148 0E1=-405 $$ A-840..0. 1. *$ 89 *$$ 145 ;98 =16D05 ($ 5973=048. 1. E$ 89
E($ :806 8,0 /69.0738-94 729.05 -8. .-50 9: 0>-50470 .8180=048 9: 8,0 1773.05 1//022148 34506 078-94 '$' 9: 6 A1. 607965059A0>064996120>-50470A1.20594?0,12:9:
8,0 50:0470 ?38 940 5973=048 A1. =16D05 1. E$ -4 .3//9689:8,050:04708,0=1806-129?<078.-48,0/60.048 71.0 A060 ;98 =16D05 94 ?0,12: 9: 8,0 /69.0738-94 1. $89 $(,0601:8068,016;3=048.15560..0594 ?98, 8,0 .-50. A060 ,0165 145 >-50 -=/3;405 <35;=048 145 96506 9: 794>-78-94 145 .0480470 8,0 86-12 9368 ,1. 794>-7805 8,0 1//022148 1773.05 1//022148 :96 9::0470. /34-.,1?2034506078-94.&145$'!#6015A-8,078-94 $'!$#!5# 9: 8,0 78 $) 96 8,0 9::0470 /34-.,1?20 34506078-94&9:8,078$)8,01//022148,1.?004 .048047058934506;96-;9693.-=/6-.94=048:961/06-95 9: ' @016. 145 /1@ :-40 9: .$%%%% 145 -4 50:1328 89
- 4 -
34506;9 :368,06 6-;9693. -=/6-.94=048 :96 1 /06-95 9: F =948,. 96 8,0 9::0470 /34-.,1?20 34506 078-94. $' !$#!5#6015A-8,$'!#9:8,078$)1//022148,1.?004 .048047058934506;96-;9693.-=/6-.94=048:961/06-95 9:'@016.145/1@:-409:.$%%%% 145-450:132889 34506;9 .-=/20 -=/6-.94=048 :96 1 /06-95 9: F =948,. 98,8,0.0480470.1605-6078058963479473660482@ ( 0-4;1;;6-0>05?@8,0-=/3;405<35;=048145 965069:794>-78-94145.0480470/1..05?@8,086-129368 -4 /07-12 71.0 9$ %$ 8,0 1//022148 1773.05 1//022148-.?0:9608,-.9368
016405934.02:968,01//022148.3?=-8.8,18 8,050=145:96?6-?0,1.498?004/69>05-48,0/60.048 71.0 ,0 79=/21-4148 ,1. 836405 ,9.8-20 89 8,0 71.0 9: 8,0/69.0738-941458,01220;05794>06.18-94?08A0048,0 79=/21-41481458,01773.05 1//022148A1.498:96A16505 898,09604.-77-04701?961896@-48,0/60.04871.00 .3?=-8. 8,18 86-12 9368 ,1. 8,060:960 06605 -4 794>-78-4; 8,01//022148:968,01220;059::0470. - 5 -
F 06 794861 2016405 7934.02 1//016-4; :96 8,0 60./945048 ,1. 16;305 -4 .3//968 9: 8,0 -=/3;405 <35;=048 145 96506 9: 794>-78-94 145 .0480470 0 .3?=-8.8,188,0.,159AA-840..*,1..3//968058,0 71.0 9: 8,0 /69.0738-94 ,0 1773.05 1//022148 ,1. 15=-8805 6070-/8 9: 8,0 =940@ 18 8,0 8-=0 9: 61-5 145 8,060:960 8,060 -. 1 /60.3=/8-94 1;1-4.8 ,-= 34506 078-94%9:8,0178A,-7,-.49860?38805,086-129368 A1.8,060:960<3.8-:-05-4794>-78-4;8,01773.05 1//022148 :968,01220;059::0470.77965-4;2@,0/61@.895-.=-.. 8,01//012 & ,0 1773.05 1//022148 A1. A96D-4;
1. 1 147,1@18 0>029/=048
::-706 -4 61= 147,1@18 -/14/122@ 145 8,0 50:1789 79=/21-4148 161.@1 1-D !*$# A1. 8,0 "-70 ,1-6=14 9: 8,0 .1-5 61= 147,1@18220;18-941;1-4.88,01773.05 1//022148-.8,18 :96 .1478-94-4; /1@=048 9: .(&) 89A165. 51-2@ A1;06C.
1=9348,0,1550=14505 1?6-?09:.'%%% :69=8,050:178979=/21-4148145-8-.-48,-.?17D;69345
- 6 -
8,0 50 :1789 79=/21-4148 !*$# ,15 1//6917,05 8,0 9D1@3D81 /92-70 94 $(%%$' 145 ,15 295;05 1 79=/21-48 ,0601:806 8,0 794>06.18-94 ?08A004 8,0 1//0221481458,050:178979=/21-4148A1.60796505-41 >9-7060796506145-41861/8,18A1.,02594$&%%( 8,0 1//022148 A1. 1220;052@ 713;,8 605 ,14505 A,-20 6070->-4;8,0?6-?01=93489:.%% :69=*$
,0 /69.0738-94 -4 96506 89 /69>0 -8. 7,16;0. 1;1-4.8 8,0 1//022148 ,1. 0E1=-405 50:1789 79=/21-4148 1.*$*-.8,0.,159AA-840..*'-.8,0147, 89 8,0 /60861/ 147,141=1 145 12.9 89 8,0 861/ 147,141=1 18
E 145
E) *( -. 8,0 608-605 69<078-6078969:-221147,1@18,A,9,1.:364-.,058,0 -4 60./078 9: A96D 34506 8,0 1,18=1 145,- 18-9412 3612
=/29@=048 31614800 7,0=0 1. /06 E$A,-7,.8180.8,181.3=9:.(&) A1.530-4 60./078 9: 8,0 51-2@ A1;0. * -. 8,0
4;-4006 9: 8,0 -496 66-;18-94 0/168=048 A,9 ,1. ./9D04 1?938 8,0 A96D 34506 8,0 1,18=1 145,- 18-9412 3612
- 7 -
=/29@=048 31614800 7,0=0 A,-7, A1. 34506 /69;60.. *& -. 8,0 ..-.8148 -607896 9: ;6-7328360 0/168=048145*-.8,0..-.8148
4;-4006A,9,1. -..305 8,0 .D087, 9: 8,0 ./98 18
E'( *) -. 8,0
::-706 9: 9604.-7 7-0470 21?961896@ A,9 ,15 -..305 E' 60/968 145 *$% 145 *$$ 160 8,0 /92-70 9::-706. A,9 ,1>0 60;-.80605 8,0 145 794537805 8,0 -4>0.8-;18-94145.3?=-88057,16;0.,008 ) *$ 50:1789 79=/21-4148 ,1. 498 .3//96805 8,0 71.0 9: 8,0 /69.0738-94 0 A1. 8601805 1. ,9.8-20 A-840.. 145 ,0 A1. 769.. 0E1=-405 ?@ 8,0 /3?2-7 /69.073896?38498,-4;=1806-12,1.?00402-7-805:69=,-. =938, 0 ,1. 504-05 1?938 14@ 50=145 ?@ 8,0 1//022148 1773.05:96/1@=0489:.'%%% 1.?6-?0145 ,0 ,1. 12.9 /201505 -;4961470 1?938 607965-4; 9: ,-. 794>06.18-94 A-8, 8,0 1//022148 1773.05 0 ,1. .81805 8,18 94 8,0 5180 9: 861/ ,0 ,15 :967-?2@ D0/8 8,0 ?6-?0 1=9348 -4 8,0 /97D08 9: 8,0 1//022148 1773.05 145 8,0601:806.-;4122058,0/92-706015-4;9:,-.50/9.-8-94
- 8 -
A9325 12.9 ;9 89 .,9A 8,18 49 A96D A1. /045-4; ?0:960 8,0 1773.05 1//022148 1. 1220;05 -4 8,0 79=/21-48 * 14=148,-.8,0.,159AA-840..-48,0/60.04871.0,-. A-840.. ,1. 498 ./9D04 1?938 8,0 50=145 =150 ?@ 8,0 1773.05 1//022148 :96 /1@=048 9: ?6-?0 145 ,0 ,1. 12.9 .1-58,18,0A1.498-41/9.-8-9489,0168,0794>06.18-94 9:*$A-8,8,01773.05 1//022148948,051809:861/0 942@ ,1. .1-5 8,18 ,0 ,15 .004 *$ /1@-4; 8,0 ?6-?0 1=9348898,01773.05 1//022148A,-7,,0D0/8-4,-..,-68 /97D08 060 6079>06@ 9: ?6-?0 1=9348 :69= 1773.05 -. 498.3::-7-04889794>-78,-=:968,01220;059::0470.8-. 86-808,18:968,0/36/9.09:794>-78-4;141773.05:968,0 1220;059::0470.A,0608,01220;18-941;1-4.88,01773.05 -.8,18,0,1550=145051?6-?0-40E7,14;0:9659-4;1 :1>96145-4:368,0614709:.37,50=145,151770/8058,0 ?6-?0 8,0 /69.0738-94 -.
/6-=16-2@ 60G3-605 89 /69>0 8,0 50=1451451770/814709:?6-?0145-8-.942@8,0601:806 8,0/60.3=/8-9434506078-94%9:8,078$)714?0 61-.051;1-4.88,01773.05 1//022148
- 9 -
$% ,0 21A -4 8,-. 60;165 ,1. ?004 21-5 59A4 ?@ 8,094C?203/60=09368-48,071.09:
60/96805 -4 145 .3?.0G30482@ 8,0 94.8-838-9412 ?047, 9: 94C?20 3/60=0 9368 -4 8,0 71.0 9: ! "# 60/96805 -4 $ 1:806 60:066-4; 89 122 -8. 0162-06 <35;=048. -4 /161;61/, 9 ,1.9?.06>051.:9229A. $!1# 699: 9: 50=145 145 1770/81470 9: -220;12 ;618-:-718-94 ?@ 1 /3?2-7 .06>148 1. 1 :178 -4 -..30?@8,0/69.0738-94-.1.-40G31494-49650689 0.81?2-., 8,0 ;3-28 9: 8,0 1773.05 /3?2-7 .06>148 34506078-94.&145$'!$#!5#!-#145!--#9:8,078
!?# 4 96506 89 ?6-4; ,9=0 8,0 ;3-28 9: 8,0 1773.05 8,0 /69.0738-94 ,1. 89 :-6.8 /69>0 8,0 50=145 9: -220;12 ;618-:-718-94 145 8,0 .3?.0G3048 1770/814701.1=188069::178,-.:178-4-..30714 ?0/69>050-8,06?@5-60780>-50470A,-7,714?0-4 8,04183609:96120>-50470965973=04816@0>-50470
'!7# 368,06 8,0 :178 -4 -..30 41=02@ 8,0 /699: 9: 50=145 145 1770/81470 9: -220;12 ;618-:-718-94 714 12.9 ?0 /69>05 ?@ 7-673=.8148-12 0>-50470 -4 8,0 1?.0470 9: 5-6078 9612 145 5973=04816@0>-50470
(!5# 4 96506 89 /69>0 8,0 :178 -4 -..30 41=02@ 8,0 50=145 145 1770/81470 9: -220;12
- 10 -
;618-:-718-94 ?@ 8,0 /3?2-7 .06>148 8,0 :9229A-4; 1./078.,1>089?0?9640-4=-45
!-# -: 8,060 -. 149::06 89 /1@ ?@ 8,0 ?6-?0 ;->06A-8,938 8,060 ?0-4; 14@ 50=145 :69= 8,0 /3?2-7.06>1481458,0218806.-=/2@1770/8.8,09::06 145 6070->0. 8,0 -220;12 ;618-:-718-94 -8 -. 171.0 9: 1770/814701. /06 078-94 & 9: 8,0 78 4 .37, 1 71.08,0604005498?01/6-9650=145?@8,0/3?2-7 .06>148
!--# 48,098,06,145-:8,0/3?2-7.06>148=1D0. 1 50=145145 8,0 ?6-?0;->06 1770/8. 8,0 50=145 145804506.8,050=14505;618-:-718-94A,-7,-48364 -. 6070->05 ?@ 8,0 /3?2-7 .06>148 -8 -.1 71.0 9: 9?81-4=048 4 8,0 71.0 9: 9?81-4=048 8,0 /6-96 50=145 :96 -220;12 ;618-:-718-94 0=14180. :69= 8,0 /3?2-7 .06>148 ,-. -. 14 9::0470 34506 078-94. $'!$#!5#!-#145!--#9:8,078
!---#4?98,71.0.9:!-#145!--#1?9>08,09::06?@ 8,0?6-?0;->061458,050=145?@8,0/3?2-7.06>148 60./078->02@,1>089?0/69>05?@8,0/69.0738-941. 1 :178 -4 -..30 4 98,06 A965. =060 1770/81470 96 6070-/8 9: 14 -220;12 ;618-:-718-94 A-8,938 14@8,-4; =960A9325498=1D0-8149::047034506078-94& 96 078-94. $'!$#!5#!-# 145 !--# 60./078->02@ 9: 8,0 78,060:96034506078-94&9:8,078-49650689 ?6-4;,9=08,09::04708,060=3.8?0149::06A,-7, 0=14180.:69=8,0?6-?0;->06A,-7,-.1770/805?@ 8,0 /3?2-7 .06>148 A,-7, A9325 =1D0 -8 14 9::0470 -=-2162@1/6-9650=145?@8,0/3?2-7.06>148A,04 1770/805 ?@ 8,0 ?6-?0;->06 145 -4 8364 8,060 -. 1 /1@=048 =150 A,-7, -.
6070->05 ?@ 8,0 /3?2-7 .06>148 A9325 ?0 14 9::0470 9: 9?81-4=048 34506 078-94.$'!$#!5#!-#145!--#9:8,078
- 11 -
!0# ,0 /60.3=/8-94 9: :178 A-8, 60;165 89 8,0 50=145 145 1770/81470 96 9?81-4=048 9: 14 -220;12;618-:-718-94=1@?0=150?@1793689:21A?@ A1@9:14-4:060470942@A,048,0:934518-9412:178. ,1>0?004/69>05?@6020>14896121455973=04816@ 0>-50470 145 498 -4 8,0 1?.0470 8,0609: 4 8,0 ?1.-. 9: 8,0 =1806-12 94 607965 8,0 79368 ,1. 8,0 5-.7608-94 89 61-.0 1 /60.3=/8-94 9: :178 A,-20 794.-506-4; A,08,06 8,0 :178 9: 50=145 ,1. ?004 /69>05 ?@ 8,0 /69.0738-94 96 498 : 7936.0 1 /60.3=/8-94 9: :178 -. .3?<078 89 60?38812 ?@ 8,0 1773.05145 -4 8,0 1?.04709:60?38812 /60.3=/8-94 .8145. F!:# 4 8,0 0>048 8,0 79=/21-4148 8364. H,9.8-20I 96 ,1. 5-05 96 -. 341>1-21?20 89 208 -4 ,-. 0>-50470 536-4; 86-12 50=145 9: -220;12 ;618-:-718-94 714?0/69>05?@2088-4;-48,00>-504709:14@98,06 A-840..A,97141;1-4208-40>-504700-8,0696122@96 ?@ 5973=04816@ 0>-50470 96 8,0 /69.0738-94 714 /69>0 8,0 71.0 ?@ 7-673=.8148-12 0>-50470 ,0 86-12
590. 498 1?180 496 590. -8 60.328 -4 14 96506 9: 17G3-88129:8,01773.05/3?2-7.06>148
&!;# 4.9:16 1. 078-94 & 9: 8,0 78 -. 794706405948,0/699:9:8,0:178.-4-..30078-94 % =145180. 8,0 79368 89 61-.0 1 /60.3=/8-94 8,18 8,0 -220;12 ;618-:-718-94 A1. :96 8,0 /36/9.0 9: 1 =98->0 96 60A165 1. =048-9405 -4 8,0 .1-5 078-94 ,0 .1-5 /60.3=/8-94 ,1. 89 ?0 61-.05 ?@ 8,0 79368
1. 1 20;12 /60.3=/8-94 96 1 /60.3=/8-94 -4 21A : 7936.0 8,0 .1-5 /60.3=/8-94 -. 12.9 .3?<078 89 60?38812 078-94 % 590. 498 1//2@ 89 078-94. $'!$#!5#!-#145!--#9:8,078
!,# *0 7216-:@ 8,18 8,0 /60.3=/8-94 -4 21A 34506 078-94 % 9: 8,0 78 -. 5-.8-478 :69= /60.3=/8-94 9: :178 60:06605 89 1?9>0 -4 .3?/161 !0# 1?9>0 1. 8,0 :96=06 -. 1 =1451896@
- 12 -
/60.3=/8-94 A,-20 8,0 218806 -. 5-.7608-9416@ -4 418360
$$ 69=8,01:960.1-521A50721605?@8,094C?20 3/60=09368-8-.>06@720168,18.-470141220;18-94-. =150 1;1-4.8 8,0 1773.05 1//022148 -4 8,0 /60.048 71.0 1220;-4;50=1451451770/814709:?6-?08,0/69.0738-94 A1. /6-=16-2@ 60G3-605 89 /69>0 8,0 :178 9: 50=145 ?@ 5-60780>-5047048,071.094,1458,079=/21-4148,1. 498.3//968058,071.09:8,0/69.0738-94,0,1./201505 -;4961470 9: 607965-4; ,-. 794>06.18-94 A-8, 8,0 1773.05 1//022148 -4 1 >9-70 60796506 45-./38052@ 8,0 >9-70 60796506 -4 A,-7, 8,0 794>06.18-94 9: 8,0 1773.05 1//022148 145 *$ A1. 1220;052@ 60796505 A1.
498 :96A16505 89 9604.-7 7-0470 1?961896@ :96 8,0 /36/9.0 9: 79=/16-4; 8,0 >9-70 .1=/20 ,060:960 8,0 /69.0738-94 ,1. :1-205 89 /69>0 ?@ 5-6078 0>-50470 -4 8,0 /60.04871.08,181773.05 1//022148,15=150150=145 :96 /1@=048 9: ?6-?0 ,0 /69.0738-94 ,1. 498 0E1=-405 14@ 98,06 A-840.. 89/69>08,0 1220;0550=145=150?@
- 13 -
8,0 1773.05 1//022148 :96 /1@=048 9: ?6-?0 496 8,060 -. 14@5973=04816@0>-50470/695370589.,9A8,18.37,1 50=145 A1. =150 4 8,0 98,06 ,145 8,0 50:1789 79=/21-4148 *$ ,1. .81805 8,18 49 A96D A1. /045-4; ?0:9608,01773.05 1//0221481.948,051809:60;-.8618-94 9:
$ 48,071.09:0061<1881!.3/61#8,094C?20 3/60=0 9368 ,1. 7180;96-7122@ ,025 8,18 8,0 /60.3=/8-949::178A-8,60;1658950=1451451770/81470 96 9?81-4=048 9: 14 -220;12 ;618-:-718-94 =1@ ?0 =150 ?@ 9368 9: 21A ?@ A1@ 9: -4:060470 942@ A,04 8,0 :934518-9412 :178. ,1. ?004 /69>05 ?@ 6020>148 9612 145 5973=04816@0>-50470145498-48,01?.04708,0609:4 8,071.094,1458,0/69.0738-94,1.:1-20589/69>08,0 :934518-9412 :178. 4070..16@ 89 61-.0 1 /60.3=/8-94 ,0 86-129368,1.9?.06>058,188,00>-504709:79=/21-4148 79669?96180. A-8, 8,0 0>-50470 9: .,159A A-840.. 145 ?1.05 94 .37, 9?.06>18-94 ,1. /69700505 89 794>-78 8,0 1//022148 :96 8,0 1220;05 9::0470. 37, 14 9?.06>18-94
- 14 -
=150?@8,086-129368A9325720162@;989.,9A8,188,0 86-12 9368 ,1. 498 /69/062@ 1//607-1805 8,0 9612 145 5973=04816@ 0>-50470 1>1-21?20 94 607965 145 ,1. 06605 -4 794>-78-4; 8,0 1//022148 :96 8,0 7,16;0 .,00805 9::0470. $' 4506 8,0 7-673=.81470. 1= 9: 9/-4-94 8,18 8,0 -=/3;405 <35;=048 145 96506 9: 794>-78-94 145 .0480470 51805 %'%)%% /1..05 ?@ 8,0 79368 9: 6-47-/12 0..-94. 35;0 145 /07-12 35;0 121?361;- 714498?0.3.81-40577965-4;2@/1..8,0:9229A-4;
- ,06-=-412//012-.""%
J -- ,035;=0489:794>-78-94145965069: .0480470 51805 %'%)%% /1..05 ?@ 8,0793689:6-47-/120..-94.35;0145 /07-12 35;0 121?361;- -4 /07-12 1.0 9$ %$ 794>-78-4; 8,0
- 15 -
1//022148 :96 8,0 7,16;0 .,00805 9::0470.-..081.-50J --- ,01773.05 1//022148-.17G3-88059:8,0 7,16;0.,00805 9::0470. 145 ,-. ?1-2 ?945.-:14@.8145.714702205 iv. ,0 :-40 1=9348 -:14@ 50/9.-805?@8,0 1773.05 1//022148 .,122 ?0 60:34505 89 ,-=
.-
(% &$ !, $
-.89$29($