Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 12220 (KAR)
SAVITRI PURUSHOTTAMA AND ORS v. THE STATE AND ANR
CRL.P/201687/2024 · 2025-02-13
S Vishwajith Shetty
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 12220 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 12220 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! !!!" !!#
!# $!$ % $!& #
! &" # '#(
)%%*% !) % &
(! (! (! (! #
! " #$
%
! # $
Digitally signed by SHIVAKUMAR HIREMATH Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
%
&
' # #
#(
!$
) #
##
) **
! % $# #
##
# * & #
'
#
) # # ##(
) #! ) '
#(*! ) '$( $ # + #
!!! '
) !!!(
) # %%% % % %'(
) !!% #
)
)
"# ' #(#" # )
)
"# ' #( # " #
)
, # ) ) #
)
- 3 -
#
! $
% $#
* &
' # # #(
!$
#
! *
! )
##
) ** '
# ( * # & #
' # #) #
)
!(
) #! ) '
#( *! )'$( ( )
# !! #
)
)
"# # ) "# !(+ # !! ) # )
- 4 -
)) ! $ %
#
)
)
"# # ) "# %(
#
,
# ) #
) #
$
#
! " #$
%
! # $ %
&
' # #
#(
!$
#
##
) **
- 5 -
! !% $# #
##
# * & #
'
#
)
(
) #! ) '
#( *! )'$( $ # +
#
!! ) #
)
)) %%'!(%'%( %'( $
)!!% #
)
)
"# ' #( # " # )
,
#) )#
)
#
# #) #
$ &
' # #(
!$
) #
##
- 6 -
) **
! !% $# #
##
# * & #
'
#
)
(
) #! ) '
#( *! )'$( $ # + ) #
!! ) # ) )) %%'!(%'%(%'( $ ) #
)
)
"# ' #( # " # )
,
# ) )#
)
)
# #
# $# #
- "$"
! $ ' - "$"(
. /0121 3456 76898.:; <1/8/84.2 /01 :77521= 8. 6891 4!!68914!!>68914!!!61?82/161= @A :6B1/ :6= 4;871 /:/84. :87056 :61 @13461 /082 456/
- 7 -
5.=1617/84.*!43!!%C8/0:<6:A16/4D5:20/01 1./861 <64711=8.?2 8. /01 :34612:8= 7:212 61?82/161= :?:8.2/ /019
! 1:6=/01;1:6.1=45.21;346/01<:6/812
% 01:34612:8=/061176898.:;7:2128.68914!! 6891 4!! > 6891 4!!! 61?82/161= @A :6B1/ :6= 4;871 /:/84.
:87056 :68212 45/ 43 : =82<5/1 @1/C11. /01 3:98;A 919@162 C04 :61 <:6/.162 8. /01 <:6/.16208< @528.12243/013:98;A7:6681=4.8./01.:9143 ?64.874 .=8:
68 :?0:E1.=6:?64.=52/68121/7
+,-. ) 8. 6891 4!! C:2 61?82/161= @A :6B1/ :6= 4;871 /:/84. :87056 346 /01 4331.712<5.820:@;15.=1617/84.2!%
4./01@:28243/013862/8.3469:/84.=:/1=%!!61718E1= 3649:E8/68068:620:4:E8/68 565204//:9:?:8.2/:E8/68 068B:6.:? 4 :E8/68 565204//:9 :.= 9/ :E8/68 0:E:.: $4:E8/68068B:6.:?013862/8.3469:./8./012:8=7:2182 /01@64/01643:77521=.4:.=@64/0168.;:C43:77521=.4! 01:;;1?:/84.28./013862/8.3469:/84.82/0:/3862/8.3469:./
- 8 -
:77521= :.= /0186 <:61./2 C161 :;; <:6/.162 8. /01 3:98;A @528.122 C0870 C:2 7:6681= 4. 8. /01 .:91 43 ?64.874 .=8:
68 :?0:E1.=6:?64.=52/68121/7:.=C01./01 9://16 2/44= /052 :77521= .42 > ! 8. /01 2:8= 7:21 0:E1 12/:@;8201= : @528.122 8. /01 .:91 :.= 2/A;1 43 F68 :?0:E1.=6: )44=2, :.= 0:E1 @11. 7:66A8.? 4. @528.122 2898;:6/4/01@528.122C0870C:27:6681=4.@A/01<:6/.16208< 386968 :?0:E1.=6:?64.=52/6812:.=/0161@A74998//1= /01 :;;1?1= 4331.712 0:;;1.?8.? /01 <64711=8.?2 8. 6891 4!! :77521= .42 > ! 0:E1 38;1= 6; 4!*%!! * +,-. ) 8. 6891 4!! C:2 61?82/161= @A :6B1/ :6= 4;871 /:/84. :87056 346 /01 4331.712 <5.820:@;1 5.=16 17/84.2 % %'!( %'%( %'(43!!%4./01@:28243/013862/8.3469:/84. =:/1= !! 61718E1= 3649 :E8/68 68B:6.:? 4 :E8/68
565204//:9 :.= /01 :77521= 8. /01 2:8= 7:21 :61 :E8/68
565204//:9 :E8/68 ":A:<6:=0: $4 :E8/68 565204//:9 :E8/68 680:620: 4 :E8/68 565204//:9 :E8/68 #56?:
:.:2: $4 :E8/68 680:620: :.= :/A:.:6:A:.: C04 82 /01
- 9 -
:.:?16 43 #) :.B :87056 01 :;;1?:/84. 8. /01 3862/ 8.3469:/84. 25@98//1= @A :E8/68 68B:6.:? C04 82 /01 24. 43 :77521=.42>!:.=@64/01643:77521=.4%:.=@64/0168. ;:C 43 :77521= .4 82 /0:/ /01 :77521= <1624.2 C04 :61 <:6/.162 43 /01 3:98;A <:6/.16208< 3869 8. /01 .:91 43
?64.874.=8:
68 :?0:E1.=6:?64.=52/68121/70:E1 /6:.231661= /01 :945./ 3649 /01 :7745./ 43 /01 :34612:8= <:6/.16208< 3869 /4 /0186 <1624.:; :7745./2 C01. /01 3862/ 8.3469:./ C:2 /6:E1;8.? :@64:= :.= :77521= .4* 0:= 74.2<861= C8/0 /019 346 /01 8;;1?:; /6:.2316 43 :945./ :2 :34612:8= :.= /0161@A /01A 0:E1 74998//1= /01 :;;1?1= 4331.712 0:;;1.?8.? /01 <64711=8.?2 8. 6891 4!! :77521= .42 /4 0:E1 38;1= 6; 4!!! :.= :77521=.4*0:238;1=6; 4!%!!*
+,-. ) 8. 6891 4!!! C:2 61?82/161= @A :6B1/ :6= 4;871 /:/84. :87056 346 /01 4331.712 <5.820:@;1 5.=16 17/84.2 %% % % % %'(43!!%<5625:.//4:613161.7146=16<:221=@A /01G5682=87/84.:;456/43:?82/6:/18. 4!!!01 <68E:/1 749<;:8./ 8. 4!!! C:2 25@98//1= @A
- 10 -
:E8/68 068B:6.:? 4 :E8/68
565204//:9 @13461 /01 G5682=87/84.:;456/43:?82/6:/1:2:?:8.2/082<:61./2@64/016 :.= 282/168.;:C :;;1?8.?
/0:/ /01 :77521= <1624.2 C04 :61 <:6/.162:;4.?C8/00898./013:98;A<:6/.16208<38692B.4C. :2 2 68 :?0:E1.=6: :648;1= .=52/6812 2 68 :?0:E1.=6: ?64 .=52/6812 2 68 :?0:E1.=6: ?64 6:=8.? 4 2 ?64.874 .=8: :.= 2 68 :?0:E1.=6:?64/170.=52/68120:E12083/1=6871@:?2C46/0 2%! 8. ;466812 3649 /01 C:6104521 43 /01 <:6/.16208< 3869 /4 :.4/016 C:6104521 :.= 0:E1 2/47B1= /01 2:91 8;;1?:;;A C01. /01 3862/ 8.3469:./ C:2 /6:E1;8.? :@64:= :.= ://1.=8.? 2491 74.3161.71 :/ :;:A:28: 6;
4!*!! 82 38;1= @A /01 :77521= 8. 6891 4!!! C8/0 : <6:A16 /4 D5:20 /01 1./861 <64711=8.?2 8. /012:8=7:21:2:?:8.2//019
1652:; 43 /01 9:/168:; :E:8;:@;1 4. 61746= C45;= ?4 /4 204C /0:/ /01 749<;:8.:./2 8. /01 :34612:8= /0611 7:212 :.= /01:77521=1H71</:77521=.4*8.68914!!C0482 /01 :.:?16 43 #) :.B :87056 C04 :;;1?1=;A 0:= 74.2<861=C8/0/014/016:77521=<1624.2/474998//0176891
- 11 -
:61 :;; 919@162 43 : 3:98;A :.= /01A C161 <:6/.162 8. /01 3:98;A <:6/.16208< 3869 @A .:91 2 68 :?0:E1.=6: :6 48;1= .=52/6812 2 68 :?0:E1.=6: ?64 .=52/6812 2 68 :?0:E1.=6: ?64 6:=8.? 4 2 ?64.874 .=8:
:.=268 :?0:E1.=6:?64/170.=52/6812
/ :<<1:62 /0:/ :3/16 : =82<5/1 :6421 @1/C11. /01 1;=16 24.:.=082C8314./014.128=1:.=/014/016919@16243/01 3:98;A 4. /01 4/016 28=1 C8/0 61?:6= /4 /01 :34612:8= <:6/.16208<@528.12243/013:98;A/0:/C:2@18.?7:6681=8./01 .:91 43 =833161./ <:6/.16208< 38692 /01 1;=16 24. :E8/68 068B:6.:?0:=38;1=
4!!!@13461/01G5682=87/84.:;
8E8;456/:/ :87056:.=0823:/016:E8/68 565204//:9:.= 082A45.?16@64/016I:E8/68680:620:C161=131.=:./.42> !8./012:8=258/012:8=258/C:238;1=4.!!!:.=4. %!!/01G5682=87/84.:;8E8;456/0:=82251=1916?1./ .4/8714..42>!/4/01=131.=:./2:.=0:==8617/1=/01 9://16/4@1<42/1=4.!! ) 8. 6891 4!! C:2 61?82/161= :?:8.2/ /01 <;:8./833 8. 4!!! :.= :?:8.2/ 082 C831 4. /01 749<;:8./ 43 082 A45.?16 @64/016 :E8/68 680:620: :.=
- 12 -
/0161:3/16 ) 8. 6891 4!! C:2 61?82/161= 4. /01 @:282 43 /01 749<;:8./ 61718E1= 3649 /01 <;:8./833
8. 4!!! :?:8.2/ /01 4/016 919@162 43 082 3:98;A 5@21D51./;A4./01@:28243/01749<;:8./25@98//1=@A/01 <;:8./8338. 4!!!) 8.68914!!!C:2:;24 61?82/161=:?:8.2//014/016919@162430823:98;A
019:/168:;4.61746=C45;=?4/4204C/0://01<;:8./833
8. 4!!!:.=082C831I :E8/680:E:.:0:E138;1= 4%!!! @13461 /01 G5682=87/84.:; 8E8; 456/ :?:8.2/ :E8/68 565204//:9 :E8/68 ":A:<6:=0: :E8/68 680:620: :.= :E8/68 #56?: :.:2: C04 :61 /01 :77521= 8. 6891 42!!>!!!01:;;1?:/84.43@1/6:A8.?/013:98;A 919@162 @A 7;:.=12/8.1;A 61?82/168.? 8=1./87:; 3869 1/7 82 345.=8./01<;:8./8. 4%!!! 0174./12/8.?612<4.=1./20:E138;1=/01864@G17/84.2/4 /01 :<<;87:/84. 38;1= @A /01 <;:8./8332 211B8.? /19<46:6A 8.G5.7/84.)649:61:=8.?43/01<;1:=8.?28./01:34612:8=78E8; <64711=8.?2 8/ 82 :<<:61./ /0:/ /01 76898.:; <64711=8.?2 6131661= /4 :@4E1 :61 :;; /01 45/749143 /01 =82<5/1@1/C11. /01<:6/812C0870:642145/43/01@528.12243/01<:6/.16208<
- 13 -
3869243/013:98;A919@162012:8=78E8;=82<5/1@1/C11./01 <:6/812 82 ?8E1.
: 76898.:; /1H/561 :.= /01 89<5?.1= 76898.:; <64711=8.?20:E1@11.8.8/8:/1=:2:?:8.2/1:704/016C087082 .4C 70:;;1.?1= @A /01 :77521= @13461 /082 456/ 8. /0121 76898.:;<1/8/84.2
! 01 4.,@;1 5<6191 456/ 8. /01 7:21 43 ! !() #! ! *% %! ! ! !$ / 01 % 8. <:6:?6:<0!0:24@216E1=:25.=16 J!$08;11H167828.?8/2G5682=87/84.5.=1617/84. !43/014=1/018?0456/0:2/4@17:5/8452082 <4C1682/4@1521=2<:68.?;A:.=4.;A346/01<56<42143 <61E1./8.? :@521 43 /01 <647122 43 :.A 7456/ 46 4/016C821/42175611.=243G52/871$01/016:749<;:8./ =827;4212 : 76898.:; 4331.71 46 .4/ =1<1.=2 5<4. /01 .:/561 43 3:7/2 :;;1?1= /01618. $01/016 1221./8:; 8.?61=81./24376898.:;4331.71:61<6121./46.4/0:2/4 @1G5=?1=@A/018?0456/749<;:8./=827;428.?78E8;
/6:.2:7/84.2 9:A :;24 0:E1 : 76898.:; /1H/561 5/ /01 8?0 456/ 952/ 211 C01/016 : =82<5/1 C0870 82 1221./8:;;A 43 : 78E8; .:/561 82 ?8E1. : 7;4:B 43 76898.:; 4331.71.2570:28/5:/84.83:78E8;6191=A82:E:8;:@;1 :.=828.3:7/:=4</1=:20:20:<<1.1=8./0827:21/01 8?0 456/ 2045;= .4/ 0128/:/1 /4 D5:20 76898.:; <64711=8.?2/4<61E1./:@52143<647122437456/K
- 14 -
% . /01 7:21 43 *%! $% 01 $ *% %! !! / 01 % /01 4.,@;1 5<6191 456/ 0:2 4@216E1= /0:/ 76898.:; <64711=8.?2 2045;= .4/ @1 1.7456:?1= C01.8/82345.=/4@19:;:38=1464/016C821:.:@52143/01 <64712243/017456/0125<168467456/2C08;11H167828.?<4C16 5.=16 17/84. ! 6 2045;= 2/68E1 /4 216E1 /01 1.=2 43 G52/871
01 9:/168:; 4. 61746= C45;= ?4 /4 204C /0:/ /01 <:6/.16208<@528.1228./01<6121./7:21@1/C11./01919@162 43/013:98;A0:=74991.71=:21:6;A:28./01A1:6!:.= /0161C:2.4749<;:8./:2:?:8.2/1:704/016/8;;/01A1:6!! / 82 4.;A :3/16 /01 =82<5/1 @1/C11. /01 3:98;A 919@162 61?:6=8.?<:6/.16208<@528.1222/:6/1=8./01A1:6!!C0870 0:= 6125;/1= 8. 8.8/8:/8.? 78E8; <64711=8.?2 :?:8.2/ 1:70 4/016 /01 919@162 43 /01 3:98;A 0:E1 :;24 E1./561= 8./4 8.8/8:/8.? 76898.:;<64711=8.?2:2:?:8.2/1:704/016@A?8E8.?:76898.:;
/1H/561 /4 /01 78E8; =82<5/1 @1/C11. /019 C8/0 61?:6= /4 7:66A8.?4./01<:6/.16208<@528.12243/013:98;A
*
1652:; 43 /01 :;;1?:/84.2 345.= 8. /01 3862/ 8.3469:/84. C0870 0:2 6125;/1= 8. 61?82/168.? /01 :34612:8= /0611 76898.:;
- 15 -
7:212 C45;= ?4 /4 204C /0:/ .17122:6A 8.?61=81./2 24 :2 /4 8.E4B1/01:;;1?1=4331.712:?:8.2//01:77521=:61:@21./01 4E16:;;:<<6178:/84.43/013:7/2:.=7867592/:.71243/017:21 C45;= 61E1:; /0:/ /01 ?1.1282 346 8.8/8:/8.? /01 89<5?.1= 76898.:; <64711=8.?2 82 /01 =82<5/1 @1/C11. /01 3:98;A 919@162 61?:6=8.? /01 <:6/.16208< @528.122 43 /01 3:98;A C0870 C:2 @18.? 7:6681= 4. 8. /01 .:91 43 /01 :34612:8= 38E1 38692 3649 ! 4.C:6=2 :.= /01 2:8= =82<5/1 82 1221./8:;;A 78E8;8..:/56101919@16243/013:98;AC04:61@13461/01 7456/ @A ?8E8.? : 76898.:; /1H/561 /4 /01 8./16 21 78E8; =82<5/1 @1/C11.
/019 0:E1 8.8/8:/1= /01 :34612:8= /0611 76898.:;
7:212 8.71 /01 <:6/812 0:E1 :;61:=A 61246/1= /4 :E:8; 78E8;
6191=A 8.8/8:/84. 43 76898.:; <64711=8.?2 :?:8.2/ 1:70 4/016 C8/0/01:;;1?:/84.2C0870:61:;249:=1:?:8.2/1:704/0168. /01 78E8; =82<5/12 C45;= 9:B1 8/ E16A 7;1:6 /0:/ /01 76898.:; <64711=8.?2:618.8/8:/1=4.;A/40:6:22:.=C617BE1.?1:.71 :?:8.2//01:77521=01613461<1698//8.?74./8.5:/84.43/01 2:8=76898.:;7:212:?:8.2//01:77521=C45;=6125;/8.:@52143 <64712243;:C:.=/01613461/4217561/011.=243G52/8718/82 .17122:6A /4 D5:20 /01 89<5?.1= 76898.:; <64711=8.?2 8. :;; /01:34612:8=3456<1/8/84.27746=8.?;A/0134;;4C8.?46=16
- 16 -
1/8/84.2 :61 :;;4C1= 01 1./861 <64711=8.?2 8. 6891 4!! 82 61?82/161= @A :6B1/ :6= 4;871 /:/84. :87056346/014331.712<5.820:@;15.=1617/84.2 !% L/011./861<64711=8.?28.68914!! 82 61?82/161= @A :6B1/ :6= 4;871 /:/84. :87056 346 /01 4331.712 <5.820:@;1 5.=16 17/84.2 % %'!( %'%( %'(43!!%L:.=/011./861<64711=8.?28.6891 4!!! 82 61?82/161= @A :6B1/ :6= 4;871 /:/84. :87056346/014331.712<5.820:@;15.=1617/84.2%% %%%%'(43!!%:61D5:201=
%2
0%*% !) % &1 )$