Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 12194 (KAR)

MALLIKARJUNAYYA v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA AND ORS

WP/203735/2024 · 2025-01-30

R Nataraj

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - ! "#"$ %&#!# ' ( !"!### # $ !"!### % & ' ( # !"!) !"!### Digitally signed by SACHIN Location: High Court Of Karnataka - 2 - * + !"!### ! !"!### , $ ! !"!### - ! !"!### " $ ! !"!### *# !"!### ) ! !"!### - 3 - $ # !"!### # ! !"!### $ *! !"!### * *# !"!### % & . * ! . , *' $ ##, ##- ),##)#* $*##)#* #)#! + /0 $ - 4 - 1 234356567839:;27<9393:6=385<8=6>3 93:6=385 7? 9<@ <8>2<A<5 <=<B< <93 C3?793 526: 7D95 >2<EE38B68B < 8756>3 =<53= ),##)#* 6::D3= CA 523 93:478=385757>78F383<@33568B7?523@3@C39:7? 523 <8>2<A<5 78 #,##)#* 57 >78:6=39 523 87 >78?6=38>3@75678 # &6' 23 4356567839: >78538= 52<5 93:478=385 7:,57*2<=3<9E639:DC@6553=<93493:385<5678=<53= )*#)#* 3G493::68B E<>H 7? >78?6=38>3 68 523 4356567839: 3:478=385 7:, 57 * 2<= 68F7EF3= 523 93:478=385 7! 68 523 :<6= 497>3:: <8= 52393?793 523 4356567839: >2<EE38B3= 65 C3?793 526: 7D95 68 $7#))#)#* 26: 7D95 68 539@: 7? 523 79=39 =<53= #-#)#* ID<:23= 523 93493:385<5678 7? 523 93:478=385 7:, 57 * <8= 8756>3 6::D3= CA 93:478=385 7 CD5 93:39F3= E6C395A 57 93:478=385 7:, 57 * 57 :DC@65<?93:293493:385<5678 - 5 - &66' 23 4356567839: >78538= 52<5 93:478=385 7:, 57 * 2<= <EE3B3=EA :DC@6553= < 93493:385<5678 =<53= )*##)#* 57 93:478=385 7 3G493::68B E<>H 7? >78?6=38>3685234356567839: &666' 23 4356567839: 52393?793 :DC@6553= < 93493:385<5678 =<53= )!##)#* 57 93:478=385 7 :33H68B ?79 4<956>DE<9: 7? 523 93493:385<5678 =<53= )*##)#* 3:478=385 7 6::D3= <8 38=79:3@385 :5<568B52<593:478=3857:,57*2<=875:DC@6553=<8A 93493:385<5678 78 )*##)#* <8= 52<5 523 93:478=385 7 2<= 875 6::D3= <8A 8756>3 =<53= #-#)#* 57 523 <8>2<A<53F3E74@385??6>3957:574523@33568B &6F' 7EE7;68B 526: 523 4356567839: :DC@6553= < 93493:385<5678 =<53= )##)#* 57 523 93:478=385 7 <B<68 <8= 523 93:478=385 7 <B<68 6::D3= <8 38=79:3@385:5<568B52<58793493:385<5678;<::DC@6553= CA 523 @3@C39: 78 )*##)#* <8= 52<5 52393 ;<: 87 8756>3 =<53= #-#)#* <==93::3= 57 523 <8>2<A<5 3F3E74@385??6>3957:574523@33568B - 6 - &F' 23 4356567839: 52393?793 >78538= 52<5 93:478=385 7:, 57 * ;6527D5 :DC@65568B < 93493:385<5678 ;393 ?7EE7;68B D4 < @75678 7? 87 >78?6=38>3 C3?793 523 93:478=385 7 <8= 93:478=385 7 6::D3= < 8756>3 =<53= ),##)#* >78F3868B < @33568B78#,##)#* 23 E3<983= >7D8:3E ?79 523 4356567839: 936539<53= 523 <C7F3 >785385678: <8= >78538=3= 52<5 523 385693 497>33=68B: <93 =783 C3268= 523 C<>H 7? 523 4356567839:<8=;6527D5?7EE7;68B=D3497>3::7?E<; * 39 >7859< E3<983= >7D8:3E ?79 93:478=385 7:, 57 * :DC@65: 52<5 523 @3@C39: 7? 523 4<8>2<A<5 2<=:DC@6553=<93493:385<567878)!##)#*3G493::68B E<>H 7? >78?6=38>3 68 523 4356567839: ?7EE7;68B ;26>2 523 93:478=385 7 6::D3= < 8756>3 =<53= ),##)#* ?6G68B 523 =<53 7? @33568B <: #,##)#* 2393?793 23 >78538=: 52<5 52393 ;<: 87 @6:5<H3 68 523 497>3=D93 ?7EE7;3=CA52393:478=3857686::D68B5238756>33 <E:7 >78538=: 52<5 523 4356567839: 2<= :DC@6553= < - 7 - 93493:385<5678 :33H68B ?79 < >74A 7? 79@ 7 ?6E3= 78 )*##)#*;26E368?<>587:D>293493:385<5678;<:?6E3= 78 523 :<6= =<53 <8= ;2<5 ;<: ?6E3= ;<: 78 )!##)#* 2D:23>78538=:52<55236@4DB83=38=79:3@3856::D3= CA52393:478=3857936539<53=523?<>552<552393;<: 87 :D>2 93493:385<5678 68 79@ 7 ?6E3= CA 93:478=385 7:,57*?79>78F3868B<@33568B7?87 >78?6=38>3 ! 3<983= ==65678<E 7F398@385 =F7><53 ?79 93:478=385 7: 57 <E:7 :D447953= 523 >785385678: 7? 523 E3<983= >7D8:3E ?79 93:478=385 7:, 57 * <8= >78538=3=52<5:778<?53952393>36457?52393493:385<5678 68 79@ 7 < 8756>3 68 79@ 7# ;<: 6::D3= 78 ),##)#* , 2<F3>78:6=393=523:DC@6::6787?523E3<983= >7D8:3E ?79 523 4356567839: <8= 523 E3<983= >7D8:3E ?79 93:478=3857:,57 * <: ;3EE <: 523 E3<983= ==65678<E 7F398@385=F7><53?7993:478=3857:<8=# - >3956?63= >74A 7? 79@ 7 ?6E3= CA 93:478=385 7:, 57 * C3?793 523 93:478=385 7 6: - 8 - ?D986:23=CA523E3<983=>7D8:3E?7993:478=3857:,57 *;26>2:27;:52<5523:<6=93493:385<5678;<:?6E3=78 )!##)#* <8= 52<5 523 :<@3 ;<: 93>36F3= CA 523 93:478=385 7 <8= 52<5 523 @3@C39: ;27 2<= :6B83= 523 93493:385<5678 ;393 <E:7 493:385 C3?793 523 93:478=385 7 2393?793 523 :D:46>678 3G493::3= CA 523 4356567839: 52<5 523 ;27E3 497>3:: ;<: D8=395<H38 ;6527D5?7EE7;68B=D3497>3::7?E<;<8=C3268=52369C<>H 6:;6527D5<8AC<:6:F3875239;6:352393:478=3857 ;6527D5 ;<:568B @D>2 56@3 2<= 6::D3= < 8756>3 =<53= ),##)#*<8=2<=?6G3=<@33568B78#,##)#*<?539 B9<8568B?6?5338>E3<9=<A:8756>3575234356567839:38>3 52393 6: 87 39979 68 523 497>3=D93 <=7453= CA 523 93:478=385768>78F3868B<@33568B " 7; 52<5 523 @33568B 52<5 ;<: :>23=DE3= 78 #,##)#* ;<: >78=D>53= <8= < 87 >78?6=38>3 ;<: @7F3= :D>>3::?DEEA <B<68:5 523 4356567839: 875268B :D9F6F3:?79>78:6=39<567868526:;96543565678 - 9 - 78:3ID385EA 526: ;965 43565678 :5<8=: !)* '#( # ,*