- 1 - !" ! #$ " % &" ! $ '()'*+,)' ++ & !" # $ % & ' $ & !( # $ % & ) & $% )"&$ '% ' ' Digitally signed by SHILPA R TENIHALLI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - & " "!") & && ** (*$"%$+% )"! )" !* !) ! ' ) & & & & ' , ' $ , ' % --./01 2 3+ 4350 2 " "!") 4063/70401 89 :;:8.4:63 379 '250+ 2;3-0 7:732+ :;:8.4:63 <24 7=0 2<<0+-0/ >.+3/=:8;0 .+104 0-732+/ ** (*$"%$+% )"! )"!*!) !40:1?37=0-732+ )2<3/80<240 7=3/ 2.47 .+104 0-732+ )" 2< "!" /00@3+6 :+73-3>:72498:3; " 0:41 ;0:4+01 -2.+/0; <24 7=0 >073732+04 :+1 ;0:4+01 36= 2.47 2A04+50+7 ;0:104 <24 7=0 40/>2+10+7B7:70 & 3+ 4350 2 " "!") ?:/ 4063/70401 89 :;:8.4:63379'250+2;3-07:732+:;:8.4:63:6:3+/7 7=0>073732+04=0403+:+127=04/<247=0:<240/:312<<0+-0/ - 3 - 2+ 7=0 8:/3/ 2< 7=0 <34/7 3+<245:732+ 1:701 ! "!") 40-03A01 <425 7=0 A3-735 ;:19 :601 :82.7 " 90:4/ >>40=0+13+6 =3/ :440/7 3+ 7=3/ /:31 -:/0 >073732+04 =:1 <3;01 4;3/-2"!) "!") 80<240 7=0 C.43/13-732+:; 0//32+/ 2.47 ?=3-= ?:/ 40C0-701 :/ :6:3+/7 =35 2+ " ""!")=040<240=03/80<2407=3/2.47 ) 0:4+01 -2.+/0; <24 7=0 >073732+04 =:A3+6 403704:7017=0642.+1/.46013+7=0>073732+=:/>4:90172 :;;2?7=0>073732+ 0:4+01 36= 2.47 2A04+50+7 ;0:104 ?=2 =:/2>>2/017=0>073732+>4:9/7213/53//7=0>073732+ * 04./:; 2< 7=0 79>01 <34/7 3+<245:732+ 1:701 ! "!") /.8537701 89 7=0 A3-735 ;:19 :601 :82.7 " 90:4/ ?2.;1 62 72 /=2? 7=:7 =04 5:443:60 ?37= 2+0 :+.5:+7=: 70+:A:4 ?:/ >04<24501 89 =04 >:40+7/ 3+ 7=090:4"! )=0>073732+04:;;0601;9?:/40/313+63+: =2./0 :1C:-0+7 72 7=0 =2./0 2< 7=0 <34/7 3+<245:+7D/ =./8:+140:13+62<7=0<34/73+<245:732+?2.;16272 /=2?7=:70A04/3+-07=090:4"! 7=0A3-735;:19=:1:+ - 4 - 3;;3-3740;:732+/=3>?37=7=0>073732+04=0403+:+137:>>0:4/ 7=:73+7=090:4"! 37/0;</=0=:110/04701=04=./8:+1 :+1 /7:4701 40/313+6 ?37= 7=0 >073732+04 =0 :;;06:732+ :6:3+/77=0>073732+043/7=:7?37=:>4253/0725:4497=0 A3-735 ;:19 =0 =:1 /0E.:; 3+704-2.4/0 ?37= =04 7 3/ <.47=04:;;06017=:73+7=090:4"!"7=0>073732+04:/@01 7=0A3-735;:1972843+6:/.52</"!!!!! <425=04 >:40+7/D=2./0:+1/3+-0/=040<./0172843+67=052+09 7=0>073732+04:;;0601;9;0<7=043+=04>:40+7/D=2./0=0 0<<247/ 5:10 89 7=0 A3-735 ;:19 72 -2+7:-7 7=0 >073732+04 7=040:<704 =:1 <:3;01 7 3/ 3+ 7=3/ 8:-@642.+1 /=0 =:/ :>>42:-=017=0>2;3-02+! "!") ( &425 : 40:13+6 2< 7=0 <34/7 3+<245:732+ 37 :>>0:4/ 7=:7 7=0 >073732+04 :+1 7=0 A3-735 ;:19 =:1 : -2+/0+/.:; 40;:732+/=3> <24:>04321 2< +0:4;9 036=7 90:4/ :+12+;9 :<7047=0 /:3140;:732+/=3>=:1 <:3;01 7=0 A3-735 ;:19 =:/ :>>42:-=01 7=0 >2;3-0 7 :>>0:4/ 7=:7 =04 5:443:60?37=:+.5:+7=:70+:A:43//73;;/.8/3/73+6:+1 7=040<240 7=0 :;;06:732+ 7=:7 >073732+04 =:1 /0E.:; - 5 - 3+704-2.4/0?37=7=0A3-735;:19?37=7=0>4253/0725:449 =04-:++278080;30A01+1047=0-34-.5/7:+-0/:52< 7=0 2>3+32+ 7=:7 7=0 >4:904 5:10 89 7=0 >073732+04 <24 64:+7 2< :+73-3>:7249 8:3; +001/ 72 80 :+/?0401 :<<345:73A0;9--2413+6;97=0<2;;2?3+6241043/>://01 =0>073732+3/:;;2?01 =0 40/>2+10+7 2;3-0 24 :+9 27=04 >2;3-0 3+ 7=0 7:702<:4+:7:@::401340-7017240;0:/07=0>073732+043+ 7=00A0+72<=3/:440/73+43502 " "!")4063/7040189 :;:8.4:63 '250+ >2;3-0 /7:732+ :;:8.4:63 <24 7=0 2<<0+-0/ >.+3/=:8;0 .+104 0-732+/ ** (*$"%$+% )"! )"!*!) !40:1?37=0-732+ )2<>0+13+6 80<240 7=0 2.47 2< 113732+:; & :7 :;:8.4:63 /.8C0-7727=0<2;;2?3+6-2+13732+/ 073732+04/=:;;0E0-.70:>04/2+:;82+1<24 :/.52</ !!!!! ?37=7?2/.40730/<247=0 ;3@0/.5 72 7=0 /:73/<:-732+ 2< 7=0 3+A0/736:73+6 2<<3-04 - 6 - " 073732+04/=:;;406.;:4;9:>>0:480<2407=0 43:;2.47?37=2.7<:3;.+;0//0E05>701897=0 43:;2.47<24A:;3140:/2+/ 073732+04 /=:;; +27 7:5>04 ?37= 7=0 >42/0-.732+ ?37+0//0/ :+1 =0 /=:;; -22>04:70 ?37= 7=0 >2;3-0 <24 3+A0/736:732+ :+1 :>>0:4 80<2407=05?=0+0A04-:;;01.>2+ ) 073732+04 /=:;; +27 3+A2;A0 3+ /353;:4 2<<0+-0/3+<.7.40 -, ' % &" !+ " 3/72 ;2