Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 12167 (KAR)

MAHADEVAPPA v. STATE OF KARNATAKA AND ORS

WP/203457/2023 · 2025-01-28

R Nataraj

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - ! "#"$ %&# # ' ( ) !" #$ % " % " "&''' ( Digitally signed by SACHIN Location: High Court Of Karnataka - 2 - & ) ) * & " % * * " + % * * " ' ' % * * " ' % * * - 3 - " * * " ( * # " % % # " & " * " ) * ' " * &) !" # %$ - 4 - * % &% % * '''( " '& '( , % * -"# # ./ 0/121234/5 .67 8.699/4:/; 1./ 35;/5 </6524: 3 64 64 00/69 '& '( ;61/; '''( 0677/; <= 5/7034;/41 3 <= >.28. 5/?/4@/ 5/835;7 >/5/ 8.64:/; 24 5/70/81 3A 0530/512/7 </6524: =3 ) B ) B ( ' B 64; ' B ) 3A 25/;2442 ?2996:/ C 67D2 271 628.@5 ./0/121234/58341/4;71.6167@2124 3 '') >67 A29/; A35 065121234 64; 7/06561/ 0377/77234 <= 5/7034;/41 37& 64; ) 6:62471 E1 ==6E6 64; 31./57 8348/5424: 0530/512/7 24 =3) " 64; ' " 3A 25/;2442 ?2996:/ 4 6;;2123469 5/92/A >67 6973 73@:.1 13 ;/8965/ 1./ :2A1 ;//; </6524: 3('& ''& 67 4@99 64; ?32; ./ 762; 7@21 6A1/5 8341/71 >67 ;/85//; 34 )'' 64; A2469 ;/85// - 5 - 0538//;24:7.67431=/1</:@4*./41.24:77133;1.@734/3A 1./ ;/A/4;6417 24 3 '') A29/; *3'& ' 6:62471 1./ 3;;6 6996006 64; 31./57 8.699/4:24: 1./ 35;/5 ;61/;(''(0677/;<=1.//0@1=3EE277234/5628.@5 24/?27234/1212343( ''+'341./:53@4;1.611./762; 35;/5>670677/;>21.3@183472;/524:1./;/85//0677/;24 3 '').273@51241/5E73A1./35;/5;61/;'('') 6993>/;1./>5210/12123464;./9;1.611./5/?/4@/3@51765/ <3@4; <= 1./ ;/85// 0677/; 24 3 '') 34/1./9/77 1./762;;/A/4;641/F/8@1/;1>3769/;//;7;61/;)'' /48@E</524: =3) 24 1>3 03512347 /7034;/41 3 ./5/24 A29/; 600/69 3& '( </A35/ 5/7034;/41 3 @4;/5 /81234(&!$3A1./654616D664;/?/4@/81+& 8.699/4:24: 1./ E@161234 <53@:.1 6<3@1 24 5/70/81 3A 1./ 6A35/762; 0530/512/7 1 >67 <53@:.1 13 1./ 43128/ 3A 1./ 5/7034;/4131.61<=?251@/3A1./;/85//24 3 '') 64;1./35;/50677/;<=1.273@5124*3'& '1./ 5/?/4@/3@51765/<3@4;<=1./;/85//64;64=E@16123424 A6?3@5 3A 5/7034;/41 37 64; ./5/24 65/ 299/:69 /7034;/4130677/;1./2E0@:4/;35;/57/1124:672;/1./ E@161234 64; ;25/81/; 1./ 46E/ 3A 5/7034;/41 3 13 </ - 6 - /41/5/; 24 1./ 5/?/4@/ 5/835;7 24 5/70/81 3A ./5 7.65/ ./ 0/121234/58341/4;/;1.611.2786@7/;7/523@705/G@;28/13.2E 67 .27 52:.17 65/ 2E0625/; ./ 0/121234/5 27 1./5/A35/ </A35/ 1.273@518.699/4:24:1./35;/50677/;<=5/7034;/413 ( /654/; 83@47/9 A35 1./ 0/121234/5 5/21/561/; 1./ 6<3?/ 8341/412347 64; 8341/4;/; 1.61 348/ 1./ 2?29 3@51 0677/;1./05/92E2465=;/85//340651212341./5/2743C@/71234 3A64=3A1./;/A/4;6417241./7@21/48@E</524:1./0530/51= 64; 1./5/A35/ 1./ /4152/7 E6;/ <= 5/7034;/41 3 24 1./ 46E/ 3A 5/7034;/41 3 27 2E0530/5 64; ;/7/5?/7 13 </ 241/5A/5/;>21. /5834156/654/;;;21234693?/54E/41;?3861/ 7@<E211/;1.611./0/121234/52743160651=131./0538//;24:7 </A35/5/7034;/41364;.67A9/;1.270/1212348.699/4:24: 1./ 762; 35;/5 / 7@<E217 1.61 <= ?251@/ 3A 1./ G@;:E/41 3A %@99 "/48. 3A 1.27 3@51 24 1./ 867/ 3A 67 >/99 67 1 ') - 7 - !" 1./ 0/121234/5 27 <3@4; 13 8.699/4:/ 1./ 35;/5 3A 1./ 77271641 3EE277234/5 </A35/ 1./ /0@1= 3EE277234/5 24 6 /?27234 /121234 @4;/5 /81234(&!($3A1./654616D664;/?/4@/81+& .6?/83472;/5/;1./7@<E2772343A9/654/;83@47/9 A35 1./ 0/121234/5 64; /654/; ;;2123469 3?/54E/41 ;?3861/ & ./ 0/121234/5 27 6;E211/;9= 431 6 0651= 13 1./ 0538//;24:7 </A35/ 5/7034;/41 3 3>/?/5 ./ .67 8.699/4:/; 1./ 35;/5 3A 5/7034;/41 3 688/0124: 1./ E@16123413/41/51./46E/3A5/7034;/413./5/24241./ 5/?/4@/ 5/835;7 3 ;3@<1 5/7034;/41 3 E@71 .6?/ ;25/81/;1.611.//4152/7241./5/?/4@/5/835;77.699</E6;/ A3993>24: 1./ A2469 ;/85 ;24:7 1.61 E6= </ 2421261/; 0@57@641 13 1./ 05/92E2465= ;/85// 24 3 '') 3>/?/55/7034;/4132471/6;3A;324:73.67;25/81/;1./ 5/?/4@/5/835;713<//41/5/;241./46E/3A5/7034;/413 ./5/24 2 +&'+ - 8 - ) 4 ?2/> 3A 1./ G@;:E/41 3A 1./ %@99 "/48. 3A 1.27 3@51 67 >/99 67 1./ 2?27234 "/48. 3A 1.27 3@51 5/A/55/; 13 7@0566005305261/5/E/;=A351./0/121234/52713A29/6/?27234 /121234@4;/5 /81234(&!($3A1./654616D664;/?/4@/ 81 ./5/A35/ 1.27 >521 0/121234 27 ## 5/7/5?24:92</51=131./0/121234/5138.699/4:/1./35;/50677/; <=5/7034;/413246005305261//?27234/121234A29/;@4;/5 /81234 (&!($ 3A 1./ 654616D6 64; /?/4@/ 81 +& </A35/ 1./ /0@1= 3EE277234/5 4= 3<7/5?61234 E6;/ 5/:65;24:1./E/52173A1./867/7.6994316AA/813524A9@/48/1./ 5/?27234696@1.3521=13;/82;/1./867/34E/5217 *( '#) # # 2713 93