Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 12145 (KAR)
SHANKARAGOUDA v. THE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER AND ORS
WP/203671/2024 · 2025-01-08
R Nataraj
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 12145 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 12145 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! " #$#%
&'$!$
( )
! "#$#
"#$#
%&'
(
"#$#
%
((
"#$#
) ("! "'
("
Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: High Court Of Karnataka
- 2 -
* (
+ ( (
* ( (* (
)( !!,% - "
( (
( (
!, ( . )
)(
(
*
/) )
01 2134345617 81469 : ;1;817 5< :9:6557 7:; :6=0:>:34?81<571304?5@735225?469301:==123:6=15< 71?496:34565<71?256A16353530125?35<71?4A1635< :9:65577:;:6=0:>:3
3 4? ?3:31A 46 301 B743 21343456 30:3 :3 301 1C1=3456 35 301 25?3 5< 71?4A163 35 7:; :6=0:>:3 :9:655771?256A1635B:?1C1=31A:6A301?:;1B:? - 3 -
D@1?34561A8>301213434561701714646 5!,<4C1A @6A17 @C1 !% 5< :76:3:E: :6=0:>:3 :F C1=3456 5< A0>:E?0: :6A 2:A0:E?0>: 5< 7:; :6=0:>:3 @C1? !&&# @7469 301 216A16=> 5< 301 1C1=3456 21343456 71?256A16352@725731AC>?@8;4331A71?496:345635301 25?3 5< 71?4A163 5< 7:; :6=0:>:3 56 !,!,% 35 71?256A1635012134345617<4C1A04?58F1=3456?:9:46?3 :==123:6=1 5< 301 ?:4A 71?496:3456 56 !!,% 1343456174?81<571304?5@73<57:A471=34563571?256A163 535=56?4A1704?58F1=3456?<4C1A:9:46?3:==123469301 71?496:34565<71?256A1635
1:761A=5@6?1C<573012134345617=56316A?30:3 71?256A163 5 B:? 85@6A 35 ?@8;43 04? 71?496:3456 35 301??4?3:635;;4??456175B1G1730171?496:3456B:? :=E65BC1A91A 8> :6=0:>:3 1G1C52;163 <<4=17
6:;1C> 71?256A163 5% 017146 1 30171<571 =56316A? 30:3 71?256A163 5% 4? 85@6A 35 1H2C:46 301 =47=@;?3:6=1 @6A17 B04=0 01 71=14G1A 301 71?496:3456 C13317 <75; 71?256A163 5 1 :C?5 ?@8;43? 30:3 301
- 4 -
??4?3:635;;4??45617A4A653:=E65BC1A9130171=14235< 301 C13317 5< 71?496:3456 A:31A !,!,% 0@? 01 =56316A?30:371?256A1635=:6653:==123301C133175< 71?496:34565<71?256A16351?4A1?304?01=56316A? 30:3 2134345617 0:? =0:CC1691A 301 1C1=3456 5< 71?256A163 5 46 :6 1C1=3456 21343456 :6A 30171<571 :CC5B469 71?256A163 5 35 71?496 <75; 301 25?3 5< 71?4A163 5< :9:6557 7:; :6=0:>:3 B5@CA 716A17 301 1C1=3456 21343456 46<7@=3@5@? 0171<571 01 =56316A? 30:3 71?256A163 5 5@903 35 81 A471=31A 35 =56?4A17 301 58F1=3456? <4C1A 8> 2134345617 :9:46?3 :==123:6=1 5< C13317 5<71?496:34565<71?256A1635
% 17=5637:C1:761A=5@6?1C<5771?256A1635 ?@8;43? 30:3 01 0:A ?@8;4331A 301 71?496:3456 35 71?256A163 5 B04=0 B:? <57B:7A1A 3075@90 41 71?256A163 5% 1 71<1771A 35 301 C13317 5< 71?496:3456 A:31A !,!,% 16=C5?1A :3 661H@71" :6A ?@8;43? 30:3301=52>5<C133175<71?496:3456B:?71=14G1A8>301 2134345617 <75; 301 5<<4=1 5< 301 ??4?3:63 5;;4??45617
- 5 -
4171?256A1635301718>46A4=:346930:3301C133175< 71?496:3456 B:? 46<:=3 2C:=1A 81<571 301 ??4?3:63 5;;4??45617 0@? 01 ?@8;43? 30:3 30171 4? 65 4;21A4;163<57301??4?3:635;;4??4561735:==123301 71?496:3456C133175<71?256A16351:C?5?@8;43?30:3 301 1C1=3456 21343456 A51? 653 81=5;1 46<7@=3@5@? ?46=1 301 2134345617 0:? ?5@903 <@73017 71C41< 35 A1=C:71 04; :? 301 713@761A =:6A4A:31 0@? 01 =56316A? 30:3 301 :2271016?456 1H271??1A 8> 301 2134345617 4? @6B5730> 5< =56?4A17:3456 :6A 30171<571 301 21343456 4?
35 81 A4?;4??1A
# 1:761A AA43456:C 5G176;163 AG5=:31 ?@225731A 301 =563163456 5< C1:761A =5@6?1C <57 71?256A163 5 :6A ?@8;4331A 30:3 71?256A163 5 :=E65BC1A91A 301 71=1423 5< C13317 5< 71?496:3456 5< 71?256A1635:6A016=12134345617=:66535225?1301 :==123:6=15<71?496:3456
- 6 -
0:G1 =56?4A171A 301 =563163456? 5< C1:761A =5@6?1C<573012134345617:?B1CC:?5<C1:761AAA43456:C 5G176;163AG5=:31:6AC1:761A=5@6?1C<5771?256A163 5
+ 3 4? 653 46 A4?2@31 30:3 71?256A163 5 B:? A1=C:71A :? : 713@761A =:6A4A:31 :3 301 1C1=3456 35 301 25?3 5< A0>:E?0>: 5< :9:6557 7:; :6=0:>:3 56 ,%,$, 0171 4? 65 1;8:795 30:3 : 217?56 56=1 1C1=31A :? 71?4A163 ?05@CA 653 71?496 5 A5@83 301 21343456170:?=0:CC1691A3011C1=34565<71?256A1635 :? 301 71?4A163 5< :9:6557 7:; :6=0:>:3 :6A 0:? :C?5?5@903<57:6:AA43456:C71C41<30:301B:?16343C1A35 81 A1=C:71A :? 713@761A =:6A4A:31 :? 01 0:A ?1=@71A ;:F5743> G531? 6 G41B 5< 301 ?@8;4??456 5< C1:761A =5@6?1C <57 71?256A163 5 30:3 01 0:A <57B:7A1A 301 71?496:3456 C13317 3571?256A1635 3075@9071?256A163 5%:6A?46=1301=52>5<71?496:3456C13317B:?71=14G1A 8> 301 2134345617 <75; 301 5<<4=1 5< 71?256A163 5 43 ;:E1? 43 ;571 30:6 1G4A163 30:3301 C13317 5<71?496:3456
- 7 -
B:? 46A11A 2C:=1A 81<571 71?256A163 5 <57 =56?4A17:3456 6A17 301 =47=@;?3:6=1 301 2134345617 =:6653 0:G1 :6> 9741G:6=1 :9:46?3 71?256A163 5 71?496469 <75; 301 25?3 5< 71?4A163 5< :9:6557 7:;
:6=0:>:3 01 :==123:6=1 5< 71?496:3456 5< 71?256A163 5 B5@CA =173:46C> 653 =5;1 46 301 B:> 5< 2134345617 2@7?@469 301 1C1=3456 21343456 :6A 8> :==123:6=1 5< 71?496:34565<71?256A16353011C1=345621343456B5@CA 65381716A171A46<7@=3@5@?0171<5716546A@C916=1=:6 81 ?05B6 353012134345617 46 304? B743 21343456 355225?1 301:==123:6=15<71?496:34565<71?256A1635
$ 630:3G41B5<301;:3317304?B743213434564? A4?25?1A5<<56301<5CC5B469317;? 4 1?256A163 5 ?0:CC =56?4A17 301 C13317 5< 71?496:3456 ?@8;4331A 8> 71?256A163 5 :6A 2:??:2275274:3157A17?B43046:21745A5< 561 B11E<75;35A:> 44 34?;:A1=C1:730:371?496:34565<71?256A163 5 <75; 301 25?3 5< 71?4A163 5< :9:6557 7:;:6=0:>:3B5@CA653=5;146301B:>5<
- 8 -
2134345617 2@7?@469 301 71C41< ?5@903 <57 46 301 1C1=345621343456B04=04?216A469=56?4A17:3456 46 5!, 81<571 16457 4G4C )@A91 057:2@7
!*+
($) $
) 4?35!C5,