- 1 - ! ! "#" $%#!!&! '# ! " % ()(*+,(!!++ ' !"#$% & ' ( ) !"#$% !"#"% & ' ) Digitally signed by SHILPA R TENIHALLI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - *') *# % % % % % * + ' + ) ,,-./01.2134536/1%5/73.2/5/0 89 :;4:7:5 1;3,/ 2:2314 3<:9:=-5 03.253,2 >15 2?/ 1>>/4,/. =-43.?:8;/ -40/5 /,2314. % % 5/:0 @32? /,2314*1>:5/8/>15/2?3.1-52-40/5/,2314*# 1> %.//A3475/7-;:58:3; /:50;/:54/0,1-4./;>152?/=:523/. 34 536/ 1% @:. 5/73.2/5/0 89 :;4:7:5 1;3,/ 2:2314 3<:9:=-5 03.253,2 :7:34.2 2?/ =/232314/5.?/5/34>152?/:>15/.:301>>/4,/.142?/8:.3.1> 2?/>35.234>156:23140:2/0%5/,/3B/0>516?:3A - 3 - C6:2?-;;: -5347 2?/ ,1-5./ 1> 34B/.237:2314 1> 2?/ ,:./=/232314/5.?/5/34@/5/:55/.2/014$%%*?/ 8:3; :==;3,:2314 >3;/0 89 2?/ =/232314/5. 8/>15/ 2?/ <-53.03,2314:;/..314.1-52345; 3.,1$"%*@:. 5/</,2/0 14 %%* ?/5/>15/ 2?/9 :5/ 8/>15/ 2?3. 1-52 * /:54/0,1-4./;>152?/=/232314/5..-8632.2?:2 =/232314/5. :5/ @3>/ :40 ,?3;05/4 1> 0/,/:./0 ?:3A .3>-;;:/232314/51.:40-403.=-2/0;9:5/.2-0/42. @?3;/ =/232314/5 1 3. : ;:09 :7/0 :81-2 9/:5. :<15 =152314 1> 2?/ 34B/.237:2314 3. ,16=;/2/0 :40 :,,150347;9?/=5:9.21:;;1@2?/=/232314 " /5 ,1425: ;/:54/0 37? 1-52 1B/546/42 ;/:0/5 ?:. 1==1./0 2?/ =/232314 ?/ .-8632. 2?:2 =/232314/5. ?:0 73B/4 @5147 34>156:2314 :81-2 2?/ ,:-./ 1>0/:2?1>2?/0/,/:./0?/=1.26152/65/=1521>2?/ 0/,/:./0 .-==152. 2?/ :;;/7:2314. 6:0/ :7:34.2 2?/ =/232314/5. ?/ ,?:57/ .?//2 3. 9/2 21 8/ >3;/0 34 2?/ - 4 - =5/./42 ,:./ ,,150347;9 .?/ =5:9. 21 03.63.. 2?/ =/232314 $ /5-.:; 1> 2?/ 6:2/53:; 14 5/,150 @1-;0 71 21 .?1@ 2?:2 2?/ =/232314/5. :5/ 2?/ @3>/ :40 ,?3;05/4 1> 0/,/:./0 ?:3A .3>-;;: @?1 3. 2?/ -4,;/ 1> 2?/ >35.2 34>156:42 2 :==/:5. 2?:2 2?/5/ @:. >5/D-/42 D-:55/; 8/2@//4 2?/ 0/,/:./0 ?3. @3>/ :40 ,?3;05/4 4 %%2?/>35.234>156:42@:.34>156/089=/232314/5 12?:2?3.>:2?/5?:0.;3==/0342?/8:2?5116.->>/5/0 34<-53/. :40 ?:0 03/0 ?/ >35.2 34>156:42 ?:0 :.A/0 =/232314/51:40?3.>:63;96/68/5.21853472?/0/:0 8109 1> 2?/ 0/,/:./0 21 -42:A:; >15 2?/ =-5=1./ 1> =/5>156347 2?/ ;:.2 532/. >2/5 2?/ 0/:0 8109 1> 2?/ 0/,/:./0@:.851-7?2;:.2532/.@/5/=/5>156/0:400/:0 8109@:.8-53/034,/2?/>35.234>156:42?:0.-.=/,2/0 >1-;=;:9342?/0/:2?1>?3.-4,;/?/?:0:==51:,?/02?/ =1;3,/:40.-86322/02?/>35.234>156:23148:./014@?3,? 34 536/ 1% @:. 5/73.2/5/0 4 2?/ =1.26152/6 5/=152 32 3. 6/42314/0 2?:2 0/:2? 1> 2?/ - 5 - 0/,/:./0 @:. 0-/ 21 :.=?9E3: 5/.-;2347 >516 ;37:2-5/ .25:47-;:2314 :..1,3:2/0 @32? 6:4-:; 2?5122;347 -5347 2?/ ,1-5./ 1> 34B/.237:2314 =/232314/5. ?/5/34 @/5/ :55/.2/014$%%* :<15=1523141>2?/34B/.237:2314 34 2?/,:./ 3.:;5/:09 ,16=;/2/0?/ /4235/ ,:./1> 2?/ =51./,-2314 3. 8:./0 14 2?/ ,35,-6.2:423:; /B30/4,/ /232314/51@?13.2?/@3>/1>0/,/:./03.:7/0:81-2 9/:5./232314/51.:40:,,-./01.:40:5/ 2?/ ,?3;05/4 1> =/232314/5 1:,,-./0 1 403.=-2/0;9=/232314/51.:40:,,-./01.:40 :5/.2-0/42. F 14.30/5347 2?/ >:,2 2?:2 6:<15 =152314 1> 2?/ 34B/.237:2314 3. ,16=;/2/0 :40 =/232314/5 1. :40 :,,-./01.:40:5/;:03/.:40=/232314/51.:40 :,,-./01.:40:5/.2-0/42.:61>2?/1=34314 2?:2 =5:9/5 6:0/ 89 2?/ =/232314/5. >15 75:42 1> 5/7-;:5 8:3; 4//0. 21 8/ :4.@/5/0 :>>356:23B/;9 ,,150347;9 >1;;1@347150/53.=:../0 - 6 - ?/=/2323143.:;;1@/0 ?/=/232314/5.:5/035/,2/0218//4;:57/0148:3;34 536/ 1%* 1> :;4:7:5 1;3,/ 2:2314 3<:9:=-5 5/73.2/5/0>152?/1>>/4,/.=-43.?:8;/-40/5/,2314.% % 5/:0 @32? /,2314 * 1> =/40347 14 2?/ >3;/ 1> ;/:54/0 0032314:; /4315 3B3; -07/ :40 3<:9:=-5.-8</,2212?/>1;;1@347,14032314. :) /232314/5. .?:;; /E/,-2/ =/5.14:; 8140 >15 : .-6 1> .%%%%%! /:,? @32? 2@1 .-5/23/. >15 2?/ ;3A/.-6 21 2?/ .:23.>:,2314 1> 2?/ <-53.03,2314:;1-52G 8) /232314/5..?:;;:==/:55/7-;:5;914:;;2?/ 0:2/.1>?/:53478/>15/2?/53:;1-52-4;/..2?/ 53:; 1-52 /E/6=2. 2?/35 :==/:5:4,/ >15 B:;30 5/:.14.G ,) /232314/5. .?:;; 412 035/,2;9 15 34035/,2;9 2?5/:2/4 15 2:6=/5 @32? 2?/ =51./,-2314 @324/../.G 0) /232314/5. .?:;; 412 34B1;B/ 34 .363;:5 1>>/4,/.34>-2-5/G - 7 - /) /232314/5..?:;;412;/:B/2?/<-53.03,23141> 2?/ 53:; 1-52 @32?1-2 =/563..314 1> 2?/ .:30 1-52 -423; 2?/ ,:./ 5/73.2/5/0 :7:34.2 2?/6 3. 03.=1./01>> !-, (!&! '# ! "+ # 3.21;1