- 1 - ! ! " # $ !% # $ $ ""&% ' ( ! "#$# % & ' ! "() Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ! "#$* % & +, $*- ' + + )&' + + **-*- -* + + + + . $#)#*" +, ++ + / / $ &/ ' 01230405 674458 9: :;745< =18 <69::91> ?940 405 @1>:5>41=;578>5<@12>:5;7AA5789>3=18B140405A78495: 949:47C5>2A=18=9>7;<9:A1:7; - 3 - 59>3733895D5<BE405F2<365>47><7?78<9> 1-* <745< **-*- A7::5< BE 405 ;578>5<5>9189D9;2<35G+7><56B58 ". 9><739 405 A549491>58: 785 B5=185 409: 1284 9> 7AA57; :55C9>3 9>458D5>491> 9> 85:A5@4 1= 405 H27>426 1= @16A5>:7491> 05 =7@4: 4074 785 85;5D7>4 =18 405 A28A1:5 1= 409: 7AA57; 785 4074 1> *(** 1>5 11D7>>7 2C787E?7:89<9>309:@114EB5789>31 "#") ?94009:4?1387><@09;<85>7:A9;;91>89<58:1>9F7E7A287" 7;7B23789 7491>7; 930?7E 4 7B124 * A6 7 829:5855AB5789>31 ""*(*@765=816B509>< 7><<7:05<41405:@114E85:2;49>39>4057@@9<5>4<2541 ?09@0 405 :79< 11D7>>7 7>< 405 A9;;91> 89<9>3 @09;<85> :2:479>5< 9>F2895: 7>< 405E ?585 :09=45< 41 405 01:A947; 11D7>>7<95<?09;52><584857465>45>@5405?9=57>< @09;<85> 1= 11D7>>7 7AA817@05< 405 89B2>7; 9> 1-* :55C9>3 @16A5>:7491> =816 405 1?>58 7>< 9>:28581=405@829:58F55A05E@1>45><5<4074<5@57:5< - 4 - 11D7>>7 ?7: 7 854985< 56A;1E55 578>9>3 7B124 :***" 7: A5>:91> 7>< <25 41 09: <5740 405 A549491>58: 07D5 ;1:4 40598 B857< 578>58 7>< 40585=185 405E7855>494;5<=18@16A5>:7491> - 05 A549491> ?7: 1AA1:5< BE 405 85:A1><5>4: 5:A1><5>4 1 <5>95< 09: >53;935>@5 B24 01?5D58 @1>45><5< 4074 09: D509@;5 ?7: 9>:285< ?940 85:A1><5>4 1">:287>@516A7>E7><7::2@0405;97B9;94E9=7>E 67EB5=7:45>5<2A1>4059>:2858 5:A1><5>4 1I>:287>@5 16A7>E 401230 @1>45><5< 4074 40585 ?585 D91;7491>: 1= 405 4586: 7>< @1><9491>: 1= 405 A1;9@E 7>< 405 @16A5>:7491> @;7965< 9: 0930;E 5J18B947>4 7>4 96739>78E <9< >14 7<<2@5 7>E 5D9<5>@5B247<69445<4059>:287>@5@1D58735 $ =458 =8769>3 7AA81A89745 9::25: 5D9<5>@5 ?7: ;5< BE 405 A549491>58: 7>< 761>3 14058 <1@265>4: 5>:91>5849=9@7451=405<5@57:5<?7:678C5<7:J( ?09@0<5A9@45<4074 405<5@57:5<?7: <87?9>3 7A5>:91> 1=:-*)"A5861>400589B2>7;7=45805789>3B140 - 5 - 405 :9<5: 05;< 4074 A549491>58 1: 7>< B59>3 67F18 :1>: 1= 405 <5@57:5< 7>< A549491>58 1 785 >14 405 <5A5><5>4:7><7::2@0<5<2@45<*K1=4059>@1651= 405 <5@57:5< 41?78<: 09: A58:1>7; 5JA5>:5: 7>< @7;@2;745< 405 ;1:: 1= <5A5><5>@E <<9>3 405 @16A5>:7491> 2><58 405 @1>D5>491>7; 057<: 7 :26 1= :*"?7:7?78<5<41405A549491>58: ) > 409: 7AA57; >149@5 41 85:A1><5>4 1"405 9>:285<?7:<9:A5>:5<?9407><85:A1><5>41I9>:2858 07:7AA5785<408123094:@12>:5; # 578< 405 ;578>5< @12>:5; 7AA5789>3 =18 405 7AA5;;7>4: 7>< 405 ;578>5< @12>:5; 7AA5789>3 =18 85:A1><5>41">:287>@516A7>E ( 578>5< @12>:5; 7AA5789>3 =18 405 7AA5;;7>4: ?12;< :2B694 4074 405 <5<2@491> 1= *K 41?78<: 405 A58:1>7;5JA5>:5:1=405<5@57:5<11D7>>79:96A81A58 9>7:62@0 7: 405 A549491>58: ?585 405 <5A5><5>4: D5> 401230 A549491>58 1: 7>< 785 67F18 :1>: 405 A549491>5819:405?9=51=405<5@57:5<7><40585=185 - 6 - 405 F2<365>4 1= 405 A5J 1284 9> 405 @7:5 1= 07: >14 B55> A81A58;E =1;;1?5< BE 405 89B2>7; 5 :2B694: 4074 5J@5A4 09: 3895D7>@5 7B124 405 ;1::1=<5A5><5>@E05<15:>1407D57>E140583895D7>@5 4167C5 * 58 @1>487 ;578>5< @12>:5; 7AA5789>3 =18 85:A1><5>4 1 ?12;< :2B694 4074 405 89B2>7; 07: 7AA85@9745< 405 5D9<5>@5 7D79;7B;5 1> 85@18< 7>< 40585 B59>3 >1 9147 1= 5D9<5>@5 7B124 405 <5A5><5>@E 1= A549491>58 1: 7>< 405 89B2>7; 9: F2:49=95< 9> @1>:9<589>3A58:1>7;5JA5>:5:74*K 5 07D5 A582:5< 405 96A23>5< F2<365>4 7>< 4056745897;7D79;7B;51>85@18< 05 =7@4 4074 <5@57:5< 11D7>>7 <95< 9> 405 817< 487==9@ 7@@9<5>4 9>D1;D9>3 405 D509@;5 1?>5< BE 85:A1><5>417><9>:285<BE85:A1><5>419:>149> <9:A245 05 ;97B9;94E 1= 85:A1><5>4 1 9: 7;:1 >14 9> 1 (2009) 6 SCC 121 - 7 - <9:A24549:7>7<69445<=7@44074405<5@57:5<?7:735< $E578:7><?7:<87?9>37A5>:91>1=:-*)"7:A58 J( 4 9: ?1840 41 >145 4074 405 F2<365>4 1= 405 A5J 1284 9> 405 @7:5 1= 9> A787387A0:*415;7B18745;E;7E:<1?>4074?0585405 =769;E1=7B7@05;189:;78357><<5A5><5>41>4059>@165 1=405<5@57:5<405<5<2@491>67EB585:489@45<418< >14058?18<:405<5<2@491>41?78<:A58:1>7;5JA5>:5: 07: 41 B5 7::5::5< 7: 7H25:491> 1= =7@4 > 405 @7:5 1> 07><405<5@57:5<07:;5=4B509><09609:?9=57><4?1 @09;<85>0589B2>7;1B:58D5<4074405859:>15D9<5>@5 59405841:01?40744054?1@09;<85>785<5A5><5>418405E 785>14<5A5><5>4>4074D95?94@7>:7=5;EB5:79<4074 405 <5@57:5< 11D7>>7 B59>3 405 5;<5:4 656B58 1= 405 =769;E ?7: ;11C9>3 7=458 405 ?5;=785 1= 09: ?9=5 7>< ?7: 7;:1 @1>489B249>3 41 405 =769;E 9>@;2<9>3 09: @09;<85> 5>@5 ?5 =9>< 4074 405 @1>@;2:91>: 857@05< BE 405 89B2>7; 785 >14 :2:479>7B;5 05 <5<2@491>: 41?78<: 405 - 8 - A58:1>7; 5JA5>:5: 1= 405 <5@57:5< :012;< 07D5 B55> 8< 5>@5 405 ;1:: 1= <5A5><5>@E 9: @7;@2;745< 7: :-*) J J J 8< L :$(*" 1 409: 5J45>440585:07;;B561<9=9@7491>9>405H27>4261=405 @16A5>:7491>7612>4 - 05 @16A5>:7491> 7?78<5< BE 405 89B2>7; 2><58405@1>D5>491>7;057<:4140542>51=:-***" 9: >14 <9:A245< 5>@5 405 :765 <1 >14 85H2985 7>E 9><2;35>@5BE409:1284 05 89B2>7; 9> 405 1A58749D5 A18491> 1= 405 F2<365>4 07: 18<585< *K 1= 405 7612>4 7;;1445< 41 A549491>58 1 41 B5 85;57:5< 7>< 85679>9>3 K 41 B5 C5A4 9> +9J5< 5A1:94 4 07: >14 18<585< 7: 41 ?01 9: 5>494;5<=18B7;7>@5K4:556:40589B2>7;9>45><5< 4074K41B5A79<41A549491>581:7><41354058 $ 5>@5 405 A549491>58: 785 5>494;5< =18 7 4147; :26 1= :)$(*" 9>:457< 1= :*" 7;1>3 ?9409>4585:40585=1854057AA57;<5:58D5:41B57;;1?5< 9>A7845>@5405=1;;1?9>3 - 9 - 9' 057AA57;9:7;;1?5<9>A784 99' 05 96A23>5< F2<365>4 7>< 7?78< A7::5< BE 40589B2>7;:47><:61<9=95< 999' 05 7AA5;;7>4: 785 5>494;5< =18 7> 7<<9491>7; :26 1= :-*)**" &:)$(*" ;5:: :*"'7;1>3?9409>4585:474$KA7 =186405<7451=A549491>49;;94:857;9M7491> 9D' 5:A1><5>4 1 I >:287>@5 16A7>E 9: <985@45<41<5A1:944055>07>@5<@16A5>:7491> 7612>4 7;1>3 ?940 9>4585:4 ?9409> 7 A5891< 1= :9J?55C:=816405<7451=409:F2<365>4 D' 24 1= 405 5>4985 @16A5>:7491> 7612>4 7?78<5< A549491>58 1 9: 5>494;5< =18 *K 7><A549491>581:7><7855>494;5<=18K 57@0 - 10 - D9' 05 89B2>7; 9: 74 ;9B584E 41 18<58 =18 85;57:5 7>< +9J5< 5A1:94 124 1= 5>494;565>4: 1= A549491>581:41 <" & !%' $ <" &$ ' $ 9:41;1