- 1 - ! " " #$ %!!&! '% ! " $ (' $ $) $* $ $* ( ' ! " # # $% & ! $$ " Digitally signed by SHIVAKUMAR HIREMATH Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - # '# !" # ( # ' )* ! $ *" # # ## ) )) )* + ' # !"!," +!"!" +!"!-")!"!."# $ ( ' ! " # # ! $$ " # ' # !" # ! +" ( # ' )* ! $ **" # # ## ))))* +'# !"!," + !." !" + !" !-" )!" !."# $ # / /$# - 3 - )( ' ! " # # ! $$ " # '# !" # ! +" ( # ' ! $ *'*" # # ## ) )) )* + ' # !"!," + !." !" + !"!-")!"!."# $ # /#/$# *( ' $ / ') 0 # ! " $ * ! " - 4 - # # $% ! $$ " # '# !" # ( # ! $ *'*"# # ## ) )) )* + ' # !"!," +!."!" +!"!-" )!"!."# $ ( ' $ / ') 0 # ! " $ * ! " # # $% ! $$ " - 5 - # '# !" # ! +" " # 1 / /$# % " ( # )* ! $ *"# # ## ))))* +'# !"!," + !." !" + !" !-" )!" !."# $ *( ' $ / ') 0 # ! " $ * ! " # # $% ! $$ " # '# !" # ( )* ! $ **" # # ## ) )) )* + ' # !"!" + !."!" + !"!-" )!" !." # $ - 6 - # $ # $ # $#+ 0 $0 2$ / +/ & ! 0 2$ / +/ " 3454567389 :38357 ;:6 -83 -<<=93> 57 85?3 6** 85?3 6*'* -7> 85?3 6 * 83@594383> .A :->-<:-7 6B5<3 4-4567 5C-A-D=8- E68 4:3 6EE37<39 D=759:-.B3 =7>38 3<45679 ) )) )* 83-> ;54: 3<4567'6E -7> 3<45679!"!,"!."!"!"!-" )!"!."-7>6E4:3 7>5-78?9<4!:38357-E438 83E3883>46-9F4:3<4GE689:684"-83.3E6834:596=84574:393 95HD34545679E5B3>=7>38 3<4567'6E8;54:-D8-A3846 I=-9: 4:3 374583 D86<33>57@9 57 4:3 -E6839-5> 4:833 <-939 83@594383>-@-57944:3? 3-8>4:3B3-873>6=793BE684:3D-84539 3-873> <6=793B E68 4:3 D3454567389 9=.?549 4:-4 3J37 5E 4:3-BB3@-45679E6=7>574:3<:-8@39:334-@-57944:3D3454567389 -83 D839=?3> 46 .3 48=3 4:3 6EE37<39 D=759:-.B3 =7>38 - 7 - 3<45679))-7>)*6E >6764 @34-448-<43> 74:364:38:-7>6EE37<3D=759:-.B3=7>38 3<45676E 6=@:446:-J3.33757J6,3> 57<34:39-5>6EE37<359<6J383> =7>38 3<4567 6E 8 >3B5.38-43BA 4:3 9-5> 6EE37<3 59 764 57J6,3> 57 4:3 <:-8@3 9:334 E5B3> 57 4:3 D839374 <-93 3 9=.?549 4:-4 D3454567389 -83 6B5<3 EE5<389 -7> 4:383E683 9-7<4567-9D86J5>3>=7>38 3<4567*6E86=@:446:-J3 .337 6.4-573> -7> 57 4:3 -.937<3 6E 9=<: 9-7<4567 =7>38 3<4567 * 6E 8 D3454567389 <-7764 .3 D8693<=43> 7 9=DD684 6E :59 -8@=?3749 :3 :-9 DB-<3> 83B5-7<3 67 4:3 C=>@?3746E4:367G.B3 =D83?36=84574:3<-936E! + ! &! ! '! ,-!* ' 38<6748-B3-873>:-96DD693>4:3D34545679 :3 9=.?549 4:-4 D3454567389 :38357 ;:6 -83 6B5<3 EE5<389 -83 <:-8@3 9:3343> E68 4:3 :3576=9 6EE37<3 6E ?=8>38 57 85?3 6** -7> 85?3 6 83@594383> .A :->-<:-7 6B5<3 4-45675C-A-D=8:35?D=@73><85?57-BD86<33>57@957 4:3D839374<-93;38383@594383>.A6D-B-BB=8;:6;-94:37 ;68,57@ -9 4:3 =. 79D3<468 6E 6B5<3 :->-<:-7 6B5<3 - 8 - 4-4567-44:35794-7<36E:59:5@:386EE5<38$-BB5,-8C=796>3 ;:6;-94:374:358<B3 79D3<4686E:->-<:-76B5<3 4-4567 -7>4:383E683 3<45676E >639764@34-448-<43>-7>67 4:3 64:38 :-7> 67BA 6EE37<39 D=759:-.B3 =7>38 3<45679 )) -7>)*6E @349-448-<43> :39=.?5494:-44:3-BB3@3>-<4 6E 4:3 D3454567389 <-7764 .3 9-5> 46 :-J3 .337 <6??5443> .A 4:3? >=857@ 4:3 <6=893 6E >59<:-8@3 6E 4:358 6EE5<5-B >=4A -7> 4:383E6839-7<4567=7>38 3<4567*6E85976483I=583> <<68>57@BA9:3D8-A946>59?5994:3D34545679 3-873> ;:6 :-9 93856=9BA 6DD693> 4:3 D8-A38 ?->3 57 4:393 D34545679 :-9 D86>=<3> - <6DA 6E 4:3 <:-8@3 9:3349E5B3>5785?3 6**-7>5785?3 6.A :->-<:-7 6B5<3 4-4567 :3 D3454567389 :38357 -83 <:-8@3 9:3343>E684:36EE37<3D=759:-.B3=7>38 3<45676E 57 85?3 6** -7> 85?3 6 .A :->-<:-7 6B5<3 4-4567 5C-A-D=8 59485<4 -7> 957<3 4:3 5?D=@73> <85?57-BD86<33>57@9:-9-73H=9;54:4:3<85?3<6??5443>.A D34545673895785?3 6**-7>85?3 65459 83B3J-74 46 7-88-43 4:3 .-<,@86=7> 57 ;:5<: 4:3 D839374 <85?57-B <-939 ;383 83@594383> 7 4:3 <:-8@3 9:334 E5B3> 57 - 9 - 85?3 6** D3454567389 ;:6 ;383 ;68,57@ -9 =. 79D3<4686E6B5<3-7>58<B3 79D3<4686E6B5<3-44:383B3J-74 D65746E45?357:->-<:-76B5<3 4-4567:-J3.337-88-5@73> -9-<<=93> 6-7>-<<=93> 6-7>574:3<:-8@39:334E5B3> 57 85?3 6 D3454567389 :-J3 .337 -88-5@73> -9 -<<=93> 6-7>-<<=93> 6839D3<45J3BA ) 7 4:3 9-5> <:-8@3 9:3349 54 59 -BB3@3> 4:-4 D3454567389 ;:6 -83 -88-5@73> -9 -<<=93> 57 4:3 -.6J3 9-5> <-939 ;383 <B693BA -996<5-43> 46 -<<=93> 6$-:->3J- -:=,-8- :-58-@67>- 57 4:3 9-5> <-939 -7> 9-5> $-:->3J- -:=,-8- :-58-@67>- :-> B67@ 94-7>57@ 37?54A ;54: :-8?-8-C :->-<:-7--7>-7@->:-8:->-<:-7-9-@-5794-E6839-5> :-8?-8-C:->-<:-7--7@->:-8:->-<:-7--7>$-:->3J- -:=,-8- :-58-@67>- ?=B45DB3 <85?57-B <-939 E68 <6??54457@ :3576=96EE37<39B5,3?=8>3834<;383D37>57@<6795>38-4567 <<=93> 6$-:->3J- -:=,-8- :-58-@67>- :-> <679D583> ;54: 64:38 -<<=93> D389679 57 85?3 6** 46 <6??54 4:3?=8>386E-E6839-5>:-8?-8-C:->-<:-7--7>:59.864:38 -7@->:-8 :->-<:-7- -7> 4:3 D3454567389 :38357 ;383 -B96 D-84A 46 4:3 9-5> <679D58-<A 7 E=84:38-7<3 6E 4:3 9-5> - 10 - <679D58-<A 67 * - E-,3 37<6=7438 ;-9 :3B> -7> 57 4:3 9-5> 57<5>374 -<<=93>6D-B -BB=8 :-> 9:64 >3-> :-8?-8-C :->-<:-7- -7> 4:383-E438 -4 4:3 5794-7<3 6E -<<=93>$-BB5,-8C=796>3674:3.-9596E4:3E589457E68?-4567 9=.?5443> .A + # ;-9 83@594383> 57 85?3 6** ;:38357 54 ;-9 94-43> 4:-4 :-8?-8-C :->-<:-7- ;-9 9:64 >3-> ;:37 :3 -443?D43> 46 -44-<, 6B5<3 EE5<389 ;:6 :-> @673 46 -88394 :5? 7 4:3 <:-8@3 9:334 54 59 ?3745673> 4:-4 -<<=93>$-BB5,-8C=7 96>3 4:83-4373> + 46 +* ;:6 ;383 D839374 -4 4:3 9D64 -7> -B96 :-> 4:383-E438 E5B3> E-B93 <85?57-B <-939 -@-5794 4:3? :3 5?D=@73> <85?57-B D86<33>57@9;-94:383E68383@594383>-@-5794+46+*57 85?3 6** .A 6D-B -BB=8 -4 4:3 5794-7<3 6E $-BB5,-8C=796>3674:3E-B93-BB3@-45676E<6??54457@>-<654A E438 374583 57J3945@-4567 57 85?3 6** ;-9 >673 54 ;-9E6=7>4:-4:-8?-8-C:->-<:-7-;-9?=8>383>57-E-,3 37<6=7438 .A 4:3 -<<=93>6D-B -BB=8 57 E=84:38-7<3 6E 4:3 <679D58-<A;54:4:364:38-<<=93> * 4 -DD3-89 4:-4 .-93> 67 4:3 3H48- C=>5<5-B <67E399567 ?->3 .A 673 6E 4:3 -<<=93> 7J3945@-457@ EE5<38 <-?3 46 - 11 - ,76;-.6=44:3?=8>386E-7@->:-8:->-<:-7-.864:386E -E6839-5>:-8?-8-C:->-<:-7-;:5<:;-9-B96<6??5443>67 * 5493BE 57 - >5EE38374 DB-<3 4 59 57 4:393 <58<=?94-7<39 # 57 85?3 6 ;-9 83@594383> -7> <:-8@3 9:334 E5B3> 57 4:3 9-5> <-93 ;6=B> @6 46 9:6; 4:-4 -7@->:-8:->-<:-7-;-99=??673>464:3DB-<3;:383:3 ;-9 ?=8>383> 94-457@ 4:-4 -E6839-5> $-BB5,-8C=7 96>3 :-> -9,3> :5? 46 <6?3 4:383 +:37 -7@->:-8 :->-<:-7- 83-<:3> 4:3 9-5> 9D64 -<<=93> 7-?3> 57 85?3 6 <6??5443>:59?=8>38-7><=4:59.6>A5746D53<39-7>4:83; 4:3 9-?3 5746 - <:-773B J37 57 4:3 <:-8@3 9:334 E5B3> 57 85?3 64:38359-93856=9-BB3@-4567-9-@-57944:3 D3454567389 :3 5?D=@73> <85?57-B D86<33>57@9 -85957@ 6=4 6E # 83@594383> 57 85?3 6** 85?3 6*'* -7> 85?3 6 * 83@594383> .A :->-<:-7 6B5<3 4-4567 5C-A-D=8- ;-9 83@594383> .A -<<=93>6D-B -BB=8 57 :59 <-D-<54A -9 6B5<3 =. 79D3<468 6E :->-<:-7 6B5<3 4-4567 -@-5794+46+*5785?3 6**:3-BB3@-456757 4:3 <:-8@3 9:334 E5B3> 57 85?3 6** 85?3 - 12 - 6*'* -7> 85?3 6 * 83@594383> .A :->-<:-76B5<3 4-4567-@-57944:3D3454567389:38357594:-4 E-B93 <-939 ;-9 57545-BBA 83@594383> -@-5794 + 46 +* 57 4:3 -E6839-5> 4:833 <85?57-B <-939 67 4:3 .-959 6E 4:3 E5894 57E68?-4567@5J37.AD389679;:6;383934=D.A4:3D3454567389 :38357E684:36EE37<3D=759:-.B3=7>38 3<45676E -7> 3<45679 -7> * 6E 4:3 <4 :3 -BB3@-4567 57 4:3 # ;-9 4:-4 >3<3-93> :-8?-8-C :->-<:-7-7> :59 -<<6?DB5<39 :-> .-8@3>57464:3:6=936EE589457E68?-74574:3-E6839-5>4:833 <-939 -7> :-> E68<5.BA 4-,37 4:3 E583-8?9 ;:5<: ;383 4:3 9=.C3<4 ?-4438 6E 4:393 4:833 <85?39 :3 9-5> E583-8?9 ;383 9=.93I=374BA DB-743> -4 4:3 9D64 6E <85?3 57 85?3 6** .A 6D-B -BB=8 -7> -7 -443?D4 ;-9 ?->3 46 <83-43 E-B93 3J5>37<3 -@-5794 >3<3-93> :-8?-8-C :->-<:-7 -7> -B96 46 E-B93BA 5?DB5<-43 :59 -<<6?DB5<39 57 4:3 -E6839-5> 4:833 <-939 7-?3BA 85?3 6** 85?3 6*'* -7>85?3 6* 45967BA-E4384:386B3DB-A3>.A4:3 D3454567389 57 4:3 ?=8>38 6E :-8?-8-C :->-<:-7- -7> :59 .864:38-7@->:-8:->-<:-7-;-983J3-B3>>=857@4:3<6=893 6E57J3945@-45675785?3 6**-7>85?3 6 54 -DD3-89 4:-4 4:358 86B3 57 83@5943857@ E-B93 <85?57-B <-939 57 - 13 - 85?3 6** 85?3 6*'* -7> 85?3 6 * -B96 @64 83J3-B3> 4 59 =7>38 4:393 <58<=?94-7<39 4:3A :-J3.337 <:-8@3 9:3343> 57 85?3 6** 85?3 6*'*-7>85?3 6* :6=@: 54 59 <67437>3> 67 .3:-BE 6E 4:3 D3454567389 4:-4 4:36EE37<3D=759:-.B3=7>38 3<45676E @349-448-<43> 574:393<-939-7>7644:36EE37<39D=759:-.B3=7>38 3<45679 ))-7>)*6E <6795>3857@4:37-4=836E-BB3@-45679E6=7> -9 -@-5794 4:3 D3454567389 57 4:3 <:-8@3 9:334 -? 6E 4:3 6D57567 4:-4 4:3 6EE37<3 D=759:-.B3 =7>38 3<4567 6E >639 764 @34 -448-<43> -@-5794 4:3? -7> 67BA 6EE37<39 D=759:-.B3 =7>38 3<45679 )) -7> )* 6E @349 -448-<43> -@-57944:3? 3<45676E 83->9-9=7>380 K)./012345.623726823613669.:01 ;:</29014=.366:01820/.7:/;714668123>:4? .36814 ;1403 +:63J38 @5J39 46 -7A D=.B5< 938J-74-7A57E68?-4567 ;:5<::3 ,76;968.3B53J39 46 .3E-B9357437>57@4:383.A46<-=9368,76;57@5446.3 B5,3BA4:-4:3;5BB4:383.A<-=939=<:D=.B5<938J-74 !-" 46 >6 68 6?54 -7A4:57@ ;:5<: 9=<: D=.B5< 938J-746=@:476446>6686?545E4:348=3 - 14 - 94-43 6E E-<49 839D3<457@ ;:5<: 9=<: 57E68?-456759@5J37;383,76;7.A:5?68 !." 46 =93 4:3 B-;E=B D6;38 6E 9=<: D=.B5< 938J-74 46 4:3 57C=8A 68 -776A-7<3 6E -7A D38967 9:-BB .3 D=759:3> ;54: 5?D85967?374 6E 354:38 >39<85D4567E68-438?;:5<:?-A3H437>4695H?674:9 68;54:E573;:5<:?-A3H437>466734:6=9-7>8=D339 68;54:.64:L #68 4:3 D=8D693 6E -448-<457@ 4:3 6EE37<3 D=759:-.B3 =7>38 3<4567 .-93>6757E68?-4567@5J3746-D=.B5< 938J-74 ;:5<: 4:3 57E68?-74 ,76;9 68 .3B53J39 46 .3 E-B93 <-=9399=<:D=.B5<938J-74>69=<:-<49-994-43>57<B-=93!-" M !." 6E 3<4567 59 B5-.B3 46 .3 D=759:3> :383E683 4:3 -BB3@-45679 E6=7> -9 -@-5794 4:3 D3454567389 57 4:3 <:-8@3 9:334 >6 764D85?- E-<53 -448-<4 4:3 6EE37<3 D=759:-.B3 =7>38 3<4567 :3-BB3@-4567-@-57944:3D3454567389:38357594:-46D-B -BB=8 ;:6 ;-9 ;68,57@ -9 - 6B5<3 =. 79D3<468 -4 :->-<:-76B5<3 4-4567-44:35794-7<36E$-BB5,-8C=796>3 ;:6 ;-9 ;68,57@ -9 58<B3 79D3<468 6E :->-<:-7 6B5<3 4-4567 5C-A-D=8 :-> 83@594383> 4:393 4:833 E-B93 <-939 57 - 15 - 85?3 6** 85?3 6*'* -7> 85?3 6 *-9-@-5794+46+*;:6;383D839374-44:3 9D646E<85?3;:37:-8?-8-C:->-<:-7;-9?=8>383>57- E-,337<6=7438.A6D-B-BB=8:383E6834:357@83>53749E68 4:36EE37<3D=759:-.B3=7>38 3<45676E 59764E6=7>57 4:3 -BB3@-45679 ?->3 -@-5794 4:3 D3454567389 :38357 57 4:3 <:-8@39:334;:383-9-BB3@-45679-9-@-57944:3?;6=B>67BA -448-<44:36EE37<39D=759:-.B3=7>38 3<45679))-7>)*6E :383E6834:3C=>@?3746E4:367G.B3 =D83?36=8457 4:3<-936E <-7764.3?->3-DDB5<-.B346 4:3E-<496E4:3D839374<-939 :3-<4<6??5443>.A4:3D3454567389574:3D839374<-93 <-7764 .3 9-5> 46 :-J3 .337 <6??5443> >=857@ 4:3 <6=893 6E >59<:-8@3 6E 4:358 6EE5<5-B >=4539 3454567389 ;:6 -83 E-<57@ <:-8@39 E68 <6??54457@ 4:3 ?=8>38 6E :-8?-8-C :->-<:-7- -7> -7@->:-8 :->-<:-7- 57 85?3 6** -7> :-J3 ?-7-@3> 46 83@59438 E-B93 <85?57-B <-939 -9 -@-57944:3;54739939574:693<-939;:6;383D839374-44:3 9D64 6E <85?3 57 85?3 6** ;:37 6D-B -BB=8 <6??5443> 4:3 ?=8>38 6E :-8?-8-C :->-<:-7 57 4:358 - 16 - D83937<3 :3 -BB3@-4567 -@-5794 $-BB5,-8C=7 96>3 57 85?3 6** 59 4:-4 :3 ;-9 - D-84A 46 4:3 <679D58-<A 46 <6??544:3?=8>38-7>:->4:83-4373>+46+*6EE5B57@ E-B93<85?57-B<-939-@-57944:3?574:33J3744:3A83J3-B3>4:3 E-<4 6E E-,3 37<6=7438 -7> 54 -DD3-89 4:-4 57 E=84:38-7<3 6E 9=<: 4:83-4 4:3 -E6839-5> 4:833 <85?57-B <-939 ;383 @64 83@594383> .A :5? 4:86=@: :59 /=7568 EE5<38 6D-B -BB=8 57<3 4:3 -<49 <6??5443> .A D3454567389 59 764 <6??5443> >=857@ 4:3 <6=893 6E >59<:-8@3 6E 4:358 >=4A 9-7<4567 =7>38 3<4567*6E85976473<399-8A46D8693<=434:3? :367G.B3 =D83?36=84574:3<-936E %& & &!! ,-!*:-96.938J3> 4:-4545948543B-;4:-44:35@:6=84<-77643?.-8,=D674:3 -DD83<5-4567 6E 3J5>37<3 ;:5B3 <6795>3857@ 4:3 D3454567 E5B3> =7>38 3<4567 ' 6E 8 E68 I=-9:57@ 4:3 <85?57-B D86<33>57@9 E- <-9359?->36=4>59<B6957@4:3 57@83>53749 6E 4:3 6EE37<3 -BB3@3> -@-5794 4:3 -<<=93> 4:3 6=84<-7764I=-9:-<85?57-BD86<33>57@9 - 17 - ' 74:3<-936E &!&! " ! ! ! ! * 4:3 67G.B3 =D83?3 6=84 -4 D-8-@8-D: 6 :-9 6.938J3> -9 E6BB6;90 ! "# " $ ## " $ % " $ ! &" ' $# % # $ ( $ ) *+,"-"# " & " . . & $ % . ! % . & . . ! % . ! & # " ! . # ' %$ ( $ ) *+, "-"# " . ! $ ! . - 18 - $ / 3454567389 ;:6 -83 839D6795.B3 6B5<3 EE5<389 :-J3 764 67BA57>=B@3>57<6??54457@:3576=96EE37<36E?=8>385785?3 6**-7>85?3 6.=4:-J3-B9657>=B@3>57 <6??54457@ 4:3 -BB3@3> 6EE37<39 57 4:3 5?D=@73> <85?57-B D86<33>57@9 -7> 4:383E683 >6 764 E57> -7A @66> @86=7> 46 374384-574:393D34545679<<68>57@BAD34545679-83>59?5993> !@( ,!&! '% ! "- %