Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 12087 (KAR)
BALAYYA AND ORS v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA AND ANR
CRL.P/201819/2023 · 2025-01-30
S Vishwajith Shetty
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 12087 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 12087 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "#
"
$%
#!!&! '# ! "
% ()(*+,(!!++ '
! "# $
%
% &
' (
! "# %
#$
Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
% %
%
& & % %
"
#(
(%
&& %
)#( (% ' &
%
%% &* & &
%
%
'
+(
#'(
" +(
#'($
,,-./0 1. 21 34/ 5/614/ 278. 1-42 -90/4 /,2819 16 4 :827 3 ;43</4 21 =-3.7 27/ /9284/ ;41,//089>.891 &;/9089>5/614/27/1-4216 489,8;3? 8@8? (-0>/ 390 (% 89>3.->-4 348.89> 1-2 16 48A/ 1 & & 4/>8.2/4/0 5< 89>3.->-4 1?8,/ 232819 38,7-4 614 27/ 166/9,/. ;-98.735?/ -90/4 /,2819. &* &390& 16
/340 ?/349/0 ,1-9./? 614 27/ ;/282819/4 390 ?/349/0 8>7 1-42 1@/49A/92 ?/30/4 614 4/.;190/92
- 3 -
1/.;190/921:718../4@/08927/A322/473. 4/A389/0-94/;4/./92/05/614/278.1-42
/349/0,1-9./?61427/;/282819/4..-5A82.2732 27/;/282819/4.:/4//A;?1<//.1627/,1A;39<B91:93. 9083 1A;39< 8A82/0 "614 .7142 C1A;39<)$ 390 27/<:/4/3;;1892/03.3>/92.1627/.380,1A;39<61427/ ;-4;1./ 16 ,1??/,289> </34?< .-5.,48;2819 3A1-92 21:340. 27/ .,7/A/ ;41;1./0 5< 27/ ,1A;39< 7/ ,1A;39< .-66/4/0 ?1.. 390 ?8=-8032819 ;41,/.. :3. 8982832/0 7/ 19)5?/ -;4/A/ 1-42 89 27/ .380 ;41,//089>. 730 084/,2/0 912 21 23B/ 39< 3,2819 3. 3>389.2 27/ ,1A;39< 7/ 8A;->9/0 ,48A893? ;41,//089>. 73. 5//9 8982832/0 :8271-234438>989>27/,1A;39<3.393,,-./07/4/614/ 27/8A;->9/0,48A893?;41,//089>.,399125/A3892389/0 ,,14089>?<7/;43<.213??1:27/;/282819
/4 ,19243 ?/349/0 8>7 1-42 1@/49A/92 ?/30/46144/.;190/92173.1;;1./027/;/282819/ .-5A82. 2732 89 27/ % 82 8. 3??/>/0 2732 27/ 3,,-./0 ;/4.19. 730 ,1??/,2/0 .-5.,48;2819 3A1-92 641A 27/ 684.2
- 4 -
89614A392390127/4./@/9362/427/,1A;39<:3.,?1./0 7/4/614/ 82 8. 614 27/ 3,,-./0 21 ;41@/ 5/614/ 27/ 483? 1-42 2732 27/< 73@/ 912 ,1??/,2/0 39< .-5.,48;2819 3A1-92641A27/684.289614A392390127/4.362/4,?1.-4/16 27/ ,1A;39< ,,14089>?< 7/ ;43<. 21 08.A8.. 27/ ;/282819
2 8. 912 89 08.;-2/ 2732 27/ ;/282819/4. 7/4/89 :/4/ 3;;1892/0 3. 3>/92. 16 27/ 3614/.380 ,1A;39< 9 27/ 684.2 89614A32819 032/0 & 82 8. 3??/>/0 2732 27/ ;/282819/4. 7/4/89 :71 730 ,1??/,2/0 </34?< .-5.,48;2819 3A1-92 641A 27/ 684.2 89614A392 390 127/4. :827393..-4/04/2-4927/4/362/4730638?/0214/;3<27/ 3A1-92,1??/,2/028..232/08927/%2732.-5./=-/92?< 27/ 684.2 89614A392 390 127/4. :/4/ 89614A/0 5< 27/ ;/282819/4. 2732 27/ ,1A;39< :3. ,?1./0 9 27/ 684.2 89614A32819 82 8. 3??/>/0 2732 /@/9 362/4 ,?1.-4/ 16 27/ ,1A;39< 27/ ;/282819/4. 73@/ ,1??/,2/0 ,/42389 .-5.,48;2819 3A1-92 641A 27/ 684.2 89614A392 390 127/4. 7/ ;1?8,/ 362/4 89@/.28>32819 73@/ 68?/0 ,734>/ .7//2 89
- 5 -
27/;4/./92,3./.;/427/,734>/.7//227/;/282819/4. :/4/ 3;;1892/0 3. 3>/92. 16 27/ 3614/.380 ,1A;39< 390 641A27/</34&&D&19:340.6143;/481016.8E</34. 27/< 730 ,1??/,2/0 </34?< .-5.,48;2819 3A1-92 641A *F ,-.21A/4.2127/2-9/16.&F 390362/4/E;84< 16 27/ ;/4810 16 .,7/A/ 27/< 730 638?/0 21 ;3< 27/ 3A1-92
* 7/ A32/483?
19 4/,140 :1-?0 >1 21 .71: 2732 27/ 3614/.380 ,1A;39< 16 :78,7 27/ ;/282819/4. :/4/ 3>/92. 730 .-66/4/0 ?1.. 390 ?8=-8032819 ;41,//089>. :3. 8982832/0 3>389.2 27/ .380 ,1A;39< 390 89 27/ .380 ;41,//089>. 27/ 19)5?/ -;4/A/ 1-42 73. ;3../0 39 140/49122123B/39<3,28193.3>389.227/,1A;39<-90/4 ?8=-8032819 89 1D & / 2732 3. 82 A3< 27/ 3??/>328193>389.227/;/282819/4.8.273227/<730,1??/,2/0 A19/<195/73?61627/,1A;39<641A82.,-.21A/4.390 .-5./=-/92?<27/3A1-92,1??/,2/039027/3..-4/04/2-49 :3. 912 4/;380 21 27/ ,-.21A/4. 9 27/ ,734>/ .7//2 27/4/ 8. 91 3??/>32819 2732 27/ ;/282819/4. 730 912
- 6 -
0/;1.82/027/3A1-92,1??/,2/0641A27/,-.21A/4.2127/ ,1A;39< 914 27/4/ 8. 39< 3??/>32819 2732 27/< 730 ,1??/,2/0 A19/< 641A 27/ ,-.21A/4. 362/4 27/ ,1A;39< :3. ,?1./0 9 27/ 35./9,/ 16 .-,7 3??/>32819 89 27/ ,734>/ .7//2 82 73. 21 5/ ;4/.-A/0 2732 27/ ;/282819/4. 34/ 5/89> @8,3481-.?< 7/?0 ?835?/ 614 27/ 3,2 16 27/ ,1A;39<927/.380,84,-A.239,/.8927/35./9,/1627/ ,1A;39<
82. /A;?1</4. ,39912 5/ 890/;/90/92?< ;41./,-2/0
908.;-2/0?< 27/ ,1A;39< 8. 912 34438>9/0
3. 39 3,,-./0 89 27/ 8A;->9/0 ,48A893? ;41,//089>. 7/4/614/3A1627/1;89819273227/8A;->9/0,48A893? ;41,//089>. 3. 3>389.2 27/ ;/282819/4. 8. ?835?/ 21 5/ =-3.7/0,,14089>?<61??1:89>140/48.;3../0
7/,48A893?;/2828198.3??1:/0 7/ /9284/ ;41,//089>. 89 1 & ;/9089> 5/614/ 27/ 1-42 16 489,8;3? 8@8? (-0>/ 390 (% 89>3.->-4 348.89> 1-2 16 48A/ 1 & & 4/>8.2/4/0 5< 89>3.->-4 1?8,/ 232819 30>84 614 27/ 166/9,/. - 7 -
;-98.735?/ -90/4 /,2819. &* & 390 & 16 3. 3>389.2 27/ ;/282819/4. 3,,-./0
1. 21
.2390. =-3.7/0
!-,
(!&! '# ! "+ #
8.21?1