Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 12086 (KAR)

NEELAWWA v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA AND ORS

WP/203390/2024 · 2025-01-23

R Nataraj

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - !"!# $%" " & ' !" " #$ % &'( $ ) # &'( $ !! &'( $ ' *+ Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: High Court Of Karnataka - 2 - *( + *') ( , * - ! *' $ *)( " *)+ % *% ) *)) *) ' - 3 - *') ! * * #'( $ " " ! ). !. " !' ' ! %% %%+ ! ! ! ! - ! " " ,# ! ' %$% ) ,# ! ! )$ %%$%' ! * * / 01 2134345617 81469 301 271:4;163 5< 7=> =6?0=@=3 188=A4;=9B6;4=ABC4D=@=2B7=4:374?30=:<4A1;304:E743 21343456?0=AA1694693016534?1;=31; ' %$%4::B1;8@301 71:256;163 5) ?56F16469 = >113469 5< 301 >1>817: 5< 301 - 4 - =6?0=@=3 56 $% %%$% 35 ?56:4;17 = >53456 5< 65 ?56<4;16?1 % 012134345617E=:1A1?31;=:30171:4;1635<7=> =6?0=@=3 188=A 56 $%$(%$%) <57 301 71>=46;17 317> 5< )$ >5630: 01 =6?0=@=3 ?5>274:1; 5< ) >1>817: 5B3 5< E05> >1>817: 1G271::1; A=?C 5< ?56<4;16?1 46 301 2134345617 =6; :B8>4331; = 71271:163=3456 46 !57> 5 56 $' %$%71HB1:346971:256;1635)35?56F161=>113469 35 ?56:4;17 = >53456 5< 65 ?56<4;16?1 !5AA5E469 304: 301 71:256;163 5) 4::B1; = 6534?1 56 ' %$% 27525:469 35 ?56F161=>11346956$% %%$%0121343456174:30171<571 81<571304:5B73?0=AA169469301:=4;6534?1 ) 1=761;?5B6:1A<573012134345617?56316;:30=356?1 =61A1?34563530125:35<71:4;1634:;1?A=71;<57=21745;5< <4F1 @1=7: 301 :B8:1HB163 =>16;>163 35 1?3456 - 01 "=76=3=C==6?0=@=3=D ?3 --)017146=<31771<1771;35=: 301 I ?3 --)J ?=6653 =<<1?3 305:1 E05 =71 =A71=;@ 1A1?31; 5E1F1701A=317:B8>4331;30=301E5BA;653271::304:25463 1=A:5?56316;1;30=3=:2171?3456-%5<301 ?3 --) 6571271:163=3456?=681>5F1;1G271::469A=?C5<?56<4;16?1 - 5 - 46 301 71:4;163 B6A1:: :21?4<4? =AA19=3456: =71 >=;1 46 301 71271:163=3456 1=761;?5B6:1A<57274F=3171:256;163:5630153017 0=6; ?56316;1; 30=3 301 71271:163=3456 <4A1; 8@ 301 274F=31 71:256;163:46!57># E=:46=??57;=6?1E4301?3456- 5< 301 ?3 --) =6; 30171<571 30171 E=: 65 611; 35 >=C1 =6@ =AA19=3456=9=46:330121343456171:B8>43:30=3301275?1;B71 <5AA5E1; <57 >5F469 = 65 ?56<4;16?1 >53456 =9=46:3 301 21343456174:46=??57;=6?1E430301275?1;B71271:?7481;B6;17 1?3456 - 5< 301 ?3 --) =6; 301 BA1: -- 1 =A:5 ?56316;:30=33012134345617E=:1A1?31;=:30171:4;163=3301 1A1?3456: 30=3 E=: 01A; 56 $%$(%$%) =6; 30171<571 301 274F=31 71:256;163: E171 16343A1; 35 >5F1 = 65 ?56<4;16?1 >53456=9=46:3301213434561756 ' %$% ' 0=F1 ?56:4;171; 301 :B8>4::456: <57 301 A1=761; ?5B6:1A <57 301 2134345617 =6; 301 A1=761; ?5B6:1A <57 274F=31 71:256;163: 05B90A1=761;?5B6:1A<5730121343456170=:7=4:1; =975B6;30=3301=>16;>163351?3456-5<301 ?3 --)4: 275:21?34F1 46 6=3B71 =6; :0=AA 653 =<<1?3 301 1A1?3456: 01A; - 6 - 274573543:=>16;>16371A=346935301>464>B>317>E43046 E04?0=65?56<4;16?1>53456?5BA;81>5F1;:46?1A1=761; ?5B6:1A <57 301 2134345617 :B8>4331; 30=3 01 E5BA; 653 271:: 30=325463304:5B730=:653?56:4;171;43 + 5E1F1746:5<=7=:301?56316345630=3!57>5 :B8>4331; 8@ 301 274F=31 71:256;163: :05BA; ?563=46 :5>1 =AA19=3456:434:71A1F=6335653130=3301>1>817:=7116343A1; 35>5F1=71271:163=34561G271::469A=?C5<?56<4;16?1E4305B3 >163456469 =6@ =AA19=3456 B6;17 1?3456 - 5< 301 ?3 --) 0171<571 46 301 46:3=63 ?=:1 301 274F=31 71:256;163: 0=F1 >5F1; :B?0 = 71:5AB3456 =6; 301 71:256;163 5) 0=: 3=C16 <B73017 :312: 35 ?56F161 = >113469 5< 301 >1>817: 35 ?56:4;1730165?56<4;16?1>534560171<571301714:6517757 46 301 275?1;B71 =;5231; 8@ 301 71:256;163 5) E=77=63469 46317<1716?146304:25:43456 ( 56:1HB163A@ E743 21343456 4: =6; ?56:1HB163A@ 301 57;17 5< :3=@ 97=631; 8@ 304: 5B73 56 %- %$%4:F=?=31; :301>113469;=31;$% %%$%?5BA; 6538101A;46F41E5<301463174>57;1797=631;8@304:5B73 301 71:256;163 5) :0=AA ?56F161 = <71:0 >113469 56 301 - 7 - :=>171271:163=3456E43046=21745;5<)$;=@:<75>301;=31 5<71?14235<=?1734<41;?52@5<304:57;17 () &"' " 4:35* A5* ) *