- 1 - ! " #!$ %! # &'(&)*+,'&** % !" # $% & ' % ' % %()* + ) !" # $% ' , & Digitally signed by SHILPA R TENIHALLI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ' !" '$ & ! '%$& % ! ) $ !*) & ' ' - - ' ' ' '' %!*.$&$&). ' . ' ) ' /%- - $ /%- - & 001234 56 730589 823 :!.) 736456; <3=:>3 ?@3 :1>? := 445?5:689 52?>50? 864 3225:62 -14;3 850@1> 25??56; 8? 564@861> 8>5256; :1? >5A3 :!*) >3;52?3>34<B1??57:95032?8?5:6 850@1>=:> ?@3:==3603271652@8<931643>30?5:62!*.$&$&864). := 86430?5:62 864.:=>:?30?5:6:=@594>36=>:A 3C189 ==36032 0? ) $=:> 2@:>? D 0?E& 52 <3=:>3 ?@52 :1>? 1643> 30?5:6 !" := > ! := % )!233F56;>3;198><859 - 3 - 38>4 938>634 0:16239 =:> ?@3 73?5?5:63> 864 938>634 5;@ :1>? :G3>6A36? 93843> =:> >327:6436? :327:6436?: H@:5223>G3456?@3A8??3> @82 >3A8563416>37>3236?34<3=:>3?@52:1>? ! ' 56 >5A3 :!*) H82 >3;52?3>34 <B 1??5 7:9503 2?8?5:6 850@1> 8;8562? ?@3 73?5?5:63> @3>356 =:> ?@3 8=:>32854 :==36032 :6 ?@3 <8252 := ?@3 =5>2? 56=:>A8?5:6 48?34 ).) >3035G34 =>:A G50?5A ;5>9 8;34 8<:1? . B38>2 H@: 52 ?@3 481;@?3> := >327:6436? : 1>56; ?@3 0:1>23 := 56G32?5;8?5:6 := ?@3 0823 73?5?5:63> @3>356 H82 8>>32?34 :6 .).) 864 >3A86434?:I1450589012?:4B 6G32?5;8?5:6:=?@3082352 0:A793?34 864 0@8>;3 2@33? @82 <336 =5934 8;8562? ?@3 73?5?5:63>=:>?@38=:>32854:==36032@3<8598779508?5:6 =5934 <B ?@3 73?5?5:63> <3=:>3 ?@3 ?>589 :1>? 56 >9520:! ) H82 >3I30?34 :6 ) @3>3=:>3 73?5?5:63>52<3=:>3?@52:1>? 38>6340:16239=:>?@373?5?5:63>21<A5?2?@8? A8?3>589 :6 >30:>4 H:194 ;: ?: 2@:H ?@8? 73?5?5:63> 864 - 4 - G50?5A ;5>9 8>3 56 9:G3 H5?@ 380@ :?@3> 3?5?5:63> 8;34 8<:1? B38>2 @8G56; 6: 0>5A5689 86?303436?2 52 56 012?:4B=:>?@3982?A:>3?@86.A:6?@2>58956?@30823 52 B3? ?: <3 0:AA36034 00:>456;9B @3 7>8B2 ?: 899:H ?@373?5?5:6 3> 0:6?>8 938>634 5;@ :1>? :G3>6A36? 93843> H@: :77:234 ?@3 <859 73?5?5:6 21<A5??34 ?@8? G50?5A ;5>9 @82 A843 8993;8?5:62 8;8562? ?@3 73?5?5:63> 56 @3> =5>2? 56=:>A8?5:6 864 892: 56 @3> 2?8?3A36? >30:>434 1643> 30?5:6 . := > H@50@ H:194 7>5A8 =8053 8??>80??@30@8>;32@33?34:==3603200:>456;9B@37>8B2 ?:452A522?@373?5?5:6 . 3>1289 := ?@3 =5>2? 56=:>A8?5:6 48?34 ).) 21<A5??34<B?@3G50?5A;5>9H:194>3G389?@8? 2@3 @84 2?14534 17?: )?@ 2?8648>4 864 25603 2@3 @84 =85934 56 )?@ 2?8648>4 3C8A568?5:6 2@3 H82 2?8B56; 8? @:A3 @3@82 2?8?34?@8? 2@3H82 80J1856?34 H5?@?@3 73?5?5:63>=:>?@3982? B38>2864?@3BH3>3569:G3H5?@ 380@ :?@3> 6 ?@3 =5>2? 56=:>A8?5:6 5? 52 2?8?34 ?@8? =:> - 5 - ?@373>5:4=>:A)!?599)) ) 73?5?5:63>@84 23C18956?3>0:1>23H5?@?@3G50?5A;5>98;8562?@3>H52@32 8221>56; ?: A8>>B @3> @3 @82 2?8?34 ?@8? 25603 ?@3 73?5?5:63> @84 0>5A56899B 56?5A548?34 @3> 2@3 @84 6:? 56=:>A34 8<:1? ?@3 2854 =80? ?: 86B<:4B 7>5:> ?: 877>:80@56;?@37:9503@3G50?5A;5>9@82>35?3>8?34?@3 8G3>A36?2A84356?@3=5>2?56=:>A8?5:656@3>2?8?3A36? >30:>4341643>30?5:6. :=><B?@3I1>52450?5:689 8;52?>8?3 * 3?5?5:63> H@: 52 8;34 8<:1? B38>2 @82 6: :?@3> 0>5A5689 86?303436?2 3 52 56012?:4B =:> ?@3 982? A:>3?@86.A:6?@2 ?526:?5645271?3?@8?73?5?5:63>52 82?1436?3?5?5:63>E20:6?5613443?36?5:65295F39B?:@8G3 884G3>235A780?:6@52=1?1>37>:2730?286408>33>@3 7>:2301?5:6 56 899 @82 05?34 0@8>;3 2@33? H5?632232 56 ?@37>3236?0823864?@30823<3=:>3?@3>859:1>?522?599 8? ?@3 2?8;3 := @38>56; <3=:>3 0@8>;3 @3>3=:>3 ?@3 0@86032 := ?@3 ?>589 <356; 0:A793?34 864 ?@3 0823 <356; 4527:234:=:6A3>5?256?@3638>=1?1>352G3>B>3A:?3 - 6 - 643> ?@3 05>01A2?86032 H5?@:1? 3C7>32256; 86B :7565:6 :6 A3>5?2 864 43A3>5?2 := ?@3 0823 73?5?5:63>E2 7>8B3> =:> ;>86? := >3;198> <859 52 >3J15>34 ?: <3862H3>348==5>A8?5G39B00:>456;9B 7>:0334?:7822 ?@3=:99:H56; @373?5?5:652 @3 73?5?5:63> 52 45>30?34 ?: <3 3698>;34 :6 <859 56 730589 823 :!.) 8>5256; :1? := >5A3 :!*) := 1??5 7:9503 2?8?5:6 850@1> =:> ?@3 :==3603271652@8<931643>30?5:62!*.$&$&864).:= 864 30?5:62 864 . := >:?30?5:6 := @594>36 =>:A 3C189 ==36032 0? ) $=:> 2@:>? D 0?E& 736456; :6 ?@3 =593 := 938>634 445?5:689 52?>50? 864 3225:62 -14;3 850@1> 25??56; 8? 564@861> 21<I30? ?: ?@3=:99:H56;0:645?5:62 8& 3?5?5:63>2@8993C301?373>2:689<:64=:>8 21A := 2 )) )))( H5?@ ?H: 21>3?532 =:> ?@3 95F321A ?: ?@3 28?52=80?5:6 := ?@3 I1>52450?5:689 :1>?, - 7 - <& 3?5?5:63> 2@899 87738> >3;198>9B :6 899 ?@3 48?32:=@38>56;<3=:>3?@3>589:1>?169322?@3 >589 :1>? 3C3A7?2 @52 87738>8603 =:> G8954 >382:62, 0& 3?5?5:63> 2@899 6:? 45>30?9B :> 5645>30?9B ?@>38?36 :> ?8A73> H5?@ ?@3 7>:2301?5:6 H5?632232, 4& 3?5?5:63> 2@899 6:? 56G:9G3 56 25A598> :==3603256=1?1>3, 3& 3?5?5:63>2@8996:?938G3?@3I1>52450?5:6:= ?@3 >589 :1>? H5?@:1? 73>A5225:6 := ?@3 2854 :1>? 16?59 ?@3 0823 >3;52?3>34 8;8562? @5A 52 4527:234:== -+ &$ %! * ! 52?:9:)