Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 12076 (KAR)
VINODKUMAR RATNAKAR v. THE JOINT DIRECTOR AND ORS
WP/203504/2024 · 2025-01-13
R Nataraj
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 12076 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 12076 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "
#$!! % &$'
! "
#
$%
" &
"
'
''
% (!!)"
"
%
( ! "
*"
''
' '
%
( !"
"
Digitally signed by SACHIN Location: High Court Of Karnataka
- 2 -
+
,
%
( +"
#
$%
"
'
-
%
'
-
'
&
, '
'
'
& ,
'
" *
'
% ' %
'
' % '
' % , ' '
'' %'
, ' % ,
% . ,
"
'
,
/%
"
"
$ /%
"
" &
01213434561708995:;03<578=74346301683:715< >86?8>:9 ?471@346; 719256?163 59" 86? * 653 35 163173846 301 65>4683456 4< 86A <4B1? CA 301 719256?163
- 3 -
5" 46 301 1B1@3456 35 301 %587? 5< 471@3579 5< 719256?1635"46D41=5<049?49E:8B4<4@83456"
" 012134345617@56316?930830186?719256?163 5" 871 301 >1>C179 5< 719256?163 5"" 19256?163 5" 2752591? 35 05B? 301 1B1@3456 35 301 %587? 5< 471@3579 5< 719256?163 5" 86? 82254631? 719256?163 5"*89301 13:7646;<<4@17352712871D53179B49386?35 @56?:@3 301 1B1@3456 89 217 @8B16?87 5< 1D1639" 01 2134345617 @56316?9 3083 719256?163 5" =89 917D46; 89 86 9949386318@01786?=898B957:6646;8B53317A46301 68>1 5< 049 =4<1 86? @01831? >86A 318@0179" ?49@42B4687A16E:47A=89@56?:@31?8;8469304>=017101 =89 01B? ;:4B3A 5< 8BB 301 @087;19" 1 @56316?9 3083 719256?163 5" @08BB16;1? 301 57?17 5< ?49@42B4687A 8:305743A C1<571 876838F8
3831 ?>464937834D1 74C:68B 46 822B4@83456 59"! 86? !! 86? 301 984? 822B4@834569 =171 8BB5=1? 46 2873 86? 301 2:6490>163 4>2591?CA301?49@42B4687A8:305743A=89>5?4<41?86?8 B199172:6490>163=894>2591?"34930171<571@56316?1? - 4 -
3083 89217301 CA1B8=95< 719256?163 5" 719256?163 5" 089 46@:771? ?49E:8B4<4@83456 86? 30171<571 @86653 @56346:1898>1>C175<719256?1635""1@56316?1? 3083 719256?163 5" 49 30171<571 653 16343B1? 35 @563193 301 1B1@3456 35 301 %587? 5< 471@3579" 561301B199 719256?163 5" 08? 9:C>4331? 049 65>4683456 86? 719256?163 5"* =89 46 301 275@199 5< 8@@12346; 43" 0171<571213434561749C1<57130495:73911F46;<578=743 46301683:715<>86?8>:9 35?471@3719256?1635"*653 3516317384630165>46834565<719256?1635""
*" 18761? @5:691B <57 301 2134345617 9:C>4331? 3083 301 CA1B8=9 5< 719256?163 5" 275D4?1 3083 8 >1>C17 =5:B? C1 ?49E:8B4<41? 4< 01 49 @56D4@31? 5< 86A 5<<16@1 46D5BD46; >578B 3:7243:?1" 1 9:C>439 3083 301 57?175<?49@42B4687A8:305743A=04@0=89B8317>5?4<41?CA 301 =898F46358@56D4@34565<719256?1635"86? 30171<571 719256?163 5" 9:<<171? ?49E:8B4<4@83456" 0171<571 01 9:C>439 3083 719256?163 5" @86653 C1 217>4331?35<4B104965>4683456"
- 5 -
" 18761?@5:691B<572134345617469:225735<049 @5631634562B8@1?71B486@156301G:?;>1635<4;05:73 5< BB808C8?46301@8915<
86?@56316?1?3083301=57?H>578B3:7243:?1I49653 ?1<461?86A=0171C:343>186986A3046;?561@563787A35 G:934@1 056193A >5?193A 57 ;55? >578B9" 0171<571 01 9:C>4393083719256?1635"08D46;9:<<171?8657?175< ?49@42B4687A 8:305743A <57 @56?:@346; 8 B53317A ?192431 C146; 8 1>2B5A11 5< 301
3831 5D176>163 089 35 C1 @56937:1? 89 08D46; C116 @56D4@31? <57 86 5<<16@1 46D5BD46;>578B3:7243:?1"
" 17@56378B18761?@5:691B<57719256?1635" 9:C>439 3083 3049 =74321343456089C1@5>1 46<7:@3:5:9 89 65>46834565<719256?1635"498B718?A8@@1231?86?301 719:B3 5< 301 1B1@34569 35 301 %587?
5< 471@3579 =89 ?1@B871? 56 !"! "! 86? 3083 01 49 1B1@31? 89 301 471@357"':73017019:C>4393083301719256?1635"49
1 +* BB808C8?)
- 6 -
653@56D4@31?5<86A5<<16@146D5BD46;>578B3:7243:?186? 30171<571 719256?163 5" 089 653 9:<<171? 86A ?49E:8B4<4@83456:6?17301CA1B8=9"
"
19256?1635"?519653?492:31301<8@33083 8 ?49@42B4687A 16E:47A =89 46434831? 8;84693 04> 56 301 @087;1308301=89@56?:@346;B53317A4630168>15<049 =4<1 86? 3083 01 08? @01831? >86A 318@0179" 01 ?49@42B4687A8:305743A4>2591?2:6490>1635<71?:@34565< 46@71>1639=430@:>:B834D11<<1@386?08?8B95?1@B871? 8275>5345605B4?8A<57<5:7A1879"34965346?492:313083 3049 57?17 =89 @08BB16;1? C1<571 301 876838F8 ?>464937834D1 74C:68B 46 822B4@83456 59"! 35 ! ! " 01 74C:68B 46 317>9 5< 301 57?17 ?831? *"!"!* >5?4<41? 3012:6490>163 4>2591? CA913346; 894?1 301 2:6490>163 5< 259325646; 301 275>53456 <57 8 21745?5<A1879"
)" 01 @563163456 5< B18761? @5:691B <57 301 2134345617 3083 3049 8>5:631? 35 @56D4@3456 <57 5<<16@1
- 7 -
46D5BD46; >578B 3:7243:?1 @86653 C1 8@@1231? <57 301 94>2B1 718956 3083 719256?163 5" =89 8@@:91? 5< >49@56?:@3 <57 08D46; @56?:@31? 8 C:946199 1D16 =04B1 C146; 1>2B5A1? :6?17 301
3831 5D176>163" 01 8BB1;834568;8469304>=895615<301>49@56?:@386?34BB ?831 30171 089 C116 65 5<<16@1 71;493171? 8;84693 04> 86? 01 49 653 @56D4@31? 5< 86A 5<<16@1 46D5BD46; >578B 3:7243:?1"0171<571301@5631634565<B18761?@5:691B<57 301 2134345617 @86653 C1 8@@1231?" D16 53017=491 946@1 719256?1635"4965=1B1@31?89301?471@3575<%587?5< 471@3579 301 82275274831 71>1?A 8D84B8CB1 <57 301 2134345617 49 35 @08BB16;1 049 1B1@3456 46 8@@57?86@1 =430 B8=C1<571301822752748315:73"
" 63083D41=5<301>833172134345649?49>4991?" 5=1D17B4C173A89>1634561?8C5D14971917D1?" (&
%!' ! 4935"
B5" +