- 1 - ! - 1 - ! "# " $% # & '# " % ()(*+,!( ++ ' !" # " $ % & " ' """ & ( ' !" #"&% $ Digitally signed by SHILPA R TENIHALLI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - "&')&"#$ '&"(" " " *'* & & & * " & && " +#$#&$#$#$ *+ & " ' +&"*% " & ( , ( #", ( $ --./01 23 40-256 5/0 7*'* 4031238 90:7;0 <=0 7.;< 7: 112<27356 2/<;2-< 531 0//273/ .180215;/2<<2385<5/5>5?56@532/<;2-<215;5;2/238 7.<;2A07*;082/<0;019@.1924762-0/<5<273 215; :7; <=0 7::03-0/ 4.32/=5960 .310; 0-<273/ +#$#:$#2$#3$ 531 *+ 7: " 531 0-<273/ ' 531 + 7: ";7<0-<2737:=261;03:;7A0B.56::03-0/-<*%#:7; /=7;<C"-<D$2/90:7;0<=2/7.;<.310;0-<273') 7:;"'7:*/00?238;08.65;9526 - 3 - 05;1 605;301 -7.3/06 :7; <=0 40<2<2730; 531 605;301 28= 7.;< 7>0;3A03< "60510; :7; ;0/473103< 7%0/473103<7E=72//0;>0123<=0A5<<0;=5/ ;0A52301.3;04;0/03<0190:7;0<=2/7.;< & 23 ;2A0 7* E5/ ;082/<0;01 9@ .1924762-0/<5<273215;58523/<<=040<2<2730;=0;023:7; <=05:7;0/5217::03-0/73<=095/2/7:<=0:2;/<23:7;A5<273 15<01**;0-02>01:;7A;0/473103<7E=72/ <=0 A7<=0; 7: <=0 >2-<2A 82;6 5801 %+ @05;/ .;238 <=0 -7.;/0 7: 23>0/<285<273 7: <=0 -5/0 40<2<2730; =0;023 E5/ 5;;0/<0173**531;0A53101<7F.12-256-./<71@ 3>0/<285<273 7: <=0 -5/0 2/ -7A460<01 531 -=5;80 /=00< =5/ 9003 :2601 58523/< <=0 40<2<2730; :7; <=0 5:7;0/521 7::03-0/=0952654462-5<273:26019@<=040<2<2730;90:7;0 <=0 <;256 7.;< 23 ;62/-7 *' E5/ ;0F0-<01 73 %%%*'=0;0:7;040<2<2730;2/90:7;0<=2/7.;< ' 05;301-7.3/06:7;<=040<2<2730;/.9A2</<=5< 40<2<2730; 2/ 5 @7.38/<0; 5801 597.< @05;/ =5>238 37 -;2A2356 53<0-0103</ "0<2<2730; 531 >2-<2A 82;6 E0;0 23 - 4 - 67>0 E2<= 05-= 7<=0; "0<2<2730; 2/ 23 -./<71@ :7; <=0 65/< A7;0 <=53 %+ A73<=/ =0 ;256 23 <=0 -5/0 2/ @0< <7 -7AA03-0/23-040-256".962-";7/0-.<7;=5/37<9003 544723<01 23 <=2/ -5/0 <266 15<0 --7;12386@ =04;5@/ <7 5667E<=040<2<273 "0; -73<;5 605;301 28= 7.;< 7>0;3A03< "60510; 7447/0/ <=0 40<2<273 =0 /.9A2</ <=5< <=0 40<2<2730; 2/ <=0 9276782-56 :5<=0; 7: <=0 -73-04<273 7: 597;<./:7;E5;101:7;<0/<;047;<3<=00>03<2:<=0 40<2<2730; 2/ 0365;801 73 9526 =0 2/ 62?06@ <7 <5A40; E2<= <=0 4;7/0-.<273 E2<30//0/ --7;12386@ =0 4;5@/ <7 12/A2//<=040<2<273 + =0&23<=04;0/03<-5/0=5/9003;082/<0;01 58523/<<=040<2<2730;73<=095/2/7:<=0:2;/<23:7;A5<273 /.9A2<<019@<=0A7<=0;7:<=0>2-<2A82;65801%+@05;/ 3 <=0 :2;/< 23:7;A5<273 15<01 ** 2< 2/ 5>0;;01 <=5< /23-0 <=0 >2-<2A 82;6 E5/ -7A46523238 7: /<7A5-= 4523/=0E5/<5?03<7<=07/42<565315:<0;=0;A012-56 0B5A235<273 <=0 012-56 ::2-0; =51 23:7;A01 <=0 :2;/< - 5 - 23:7;A53< <=5< <=0 >2-<2A 82;6 E5/ 4;08353< 9@ <E7 A73<=/303G.2;@<=0>2-<2A82;656608016@23:7;A01<=0 :2;/< 23:7;A53< <=5< <=0 40<2<2730; E5/ <=0 -5./0 :7; =0; 4;08353-@531=0=51/0B.5623<0;-7.;/0E2<==0;58523/< =0;E2/=9@<=;05<03238=0;=040<2<2730;5801597.< @05;/=5>238377<=0;-;2A235653<0-0103</2/5;;0/<0123 <=0 4;0/03< -5/0 73 ** =0 23>0/<285<273 2/ -7A460<01 531 -=5;80/=00< 2/ :2601 =0 7;10;/=00< 7: <=0 <;256 7.;< E7.61 ;0:60-< <=5< <=7.8= <=0 -=5;80 E5/ :;5A0123<=04;0/03<-5/073 **'2</06:<=0<;256 23<=0-5/02/37<-7AA03-0190-5./0<=040-256".962- ";7/0-.<7; =5/ 37< 9003 544723<01 &;7A **' 73E5;1/<=0A5<<0;=5/900351F7.;30173323015<0/:7; <=0 4.;47/0 7: :2B238 <=0 15<0 :7; <;256 531 -73<23.7./ ;0A2310;/5;0902382//.019@<=0<;2567.;<<7<=07A0 0-;0<5;@ 7: <=0 <5<0 7: 5;35<5?5 <7 544723< 5 40-256 ".962-";7/0-.<7;<7-731.-<<=0-5/0/:2601.310;" -< =0 73D960 .4;0A0 7.;< 23 <=0 -5/0 7: - 6 - ;047;<01 23 !"# E=0;023 5< 45;58;54=7% 2<2/79/0;>015/.310; =0 4;7/0-.<273 23 <=0 4;0/03< -5/0 =5/ -2<01 56<780<=0;-=5;80/=00<E2<30//0/=040<2<2730;E=7 =5/37-;2A235653<0-0103</2/23<=0-./<71@:7;65/<A7;0 <=53 %+ A73<=/ 531 <=0 <;256 23 <=0 -5/0 2/ 37< @0< -7AA03-01 :7; <=0 ;05/73 <=5< <=0 <5<0 =5/ :52601 <7 544723< 5 40-256 ".962- ";7/0-.<7; <7 -731.-< <=0 <;256 =0;0:7;0 <=0 -=53-0/7: <=0 <;256 90238 -73-6.10123 <=0 305;/773531<=0-5/09023812/47/017:73A0;2</2/>0;@ ;0A7<0 310;<=0/0-2;-.A/<53-0/5A7:<=07423273 <=5<<=040<2<2730;=5/A5107.<4;2A5:5-20-5/0:7;8;53< - 7 - 7: ;08.65; 9526 --7;12386@ 4;7-001 <7 45// <=0 :7667E2387;10; =040<2<2732/5667E01 =0 40<2<2730; 2/ 12;0-<01 <7 90 0365;801 73 9526 23 ;2A0 7* 7: .192 "762-0 <5<273 215; 12/<;2-< ;082/<0;01 :7; <=0 7::03-0/ 4.32/=5960 .310; 0-<273/ +#$#:$#2$#3$*+7:"5310-<273/'531+7:" -<*% 4031238 23 40-2565/07*'* 73<=0 :2607:<=0112<273562/<;2-<5310//273/ .1807.;< 215; /2<<238 5< 5/5>5?56@53 /.9F0-< <7 <=0 :7667E238 -7312<273/ 5$=040<2<2730;/=5660B0-.<040;/73569731:7;5 /.A 7: /%***** E2<= <E7 /.;0<20/ :7; <=0 62?0/.A <7 <=0 /5<2/:5-<273 7: <=0 F.;2/12-<27356 7.;<H 9$=0 40<2<2730; /=566 54405; ;08.65;6@ 73 566 <=0 15<0/7:=05;23890:7;0<=0;2567.;<.360//<=0 ;256 7.;< 0B0A4</ =2/ 54405;53-0 :7; >5621 ;05/73/H - 8 - -$ =0 40<2<2730; /=566 37< 12;0-<6@ 7; 2312;0-<6@ <=;05<03 7; <5A40; E2<= <=0 4;7/0-.<273 E2<30//0/H 1$=0 40<2<2730; /=566 37< 23>76>0 23 /2A265; 7::03-0/23:.<.;0H 0$=0 40<2<2730; /=566 37< 605>0 <=0 F.;2/12-<273 7: <=0 ;256 7.;< E2<=7.< 40;A2//273 7: <=0 /521 7.;< .3<26 <=0 -5/0 ;082/<0;01 58523/< =2A 2/ 12/47/017:: 2/<7%67 " -, ( & '# "+ #