Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 12067 (KAR)
SHANKRAPPA v. STATE OF KARNATAKA
CRL.P/201587/2024 · 2025-02-01
C M Joshi
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 12067 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 12067 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! ! "#
$ #$
# %&'%()*&% )) +
! "# $ %
&$ '
%
%
! "&#'
LUCYGRACE Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Date: 2025.02.03 17:26:45 - 0800
- 2 -
# % ()
% " ' ( % "'
# ( ( %
%
%%
( ((*++ %%
$
&"&'&#%
# %
#
# ,
#&#&
" ,
#&#& '
-./0 12- 3-./4-0 -456/ 76849-3 /5 /84 2:.; <6/12-=-151564-/.4012-3-./4-05>268/16?-/4;-41 3-.0-/<6/12-/-9=640-41@1.1-
- 3 -
2- =-151564-/ 59 12- 963- .7789-0 54 /5;- 6 ( ( 6< 540.466/ =6357- 91.1564 /->591-/-0 <6/ 12- 6<<-47-9 =84592.A3- 840-/ -715649 ( ( (*+ .40+6<2-9.507/5;-B.9/->591-/-06412- A.9596<12-76;=3.541<53-0A:64--48C.;;.B2-/-5451 59 91.1-0 12.1 64 * ( .1 .A681 54 12- ;5045>21 12- .7789-0 7.;- 16 2-/ 2689- 840-/ 12- 5416D57.15646<12-35E86/.40.336<.9800-47.;-6?-/12- 76;=3.54.41 .40 7.89-0 .A/.95?- 54F8/5-9 64 2-/ 72--C 2-30 2-/ 4-7C .40 76;;511-0 /.=- 64 2-/ 1 B.9 91.1-0 12.1 9547- 51 B.9 12- 45>21 15;- -?-4 5< B2-4 92- 97/-.;-0 464- 6< 12- 4-5>2A6/9 7.;- 16 2-/ 2-3= 2-/-.<1-/ 12- .7789-0 .A89-0 2-/ 54 <5312: B6/09 .40 12/-.1-4-0 16 C533 2-/ 5< 92- 0597369-9 12- 54750-41 16 612-/9.402.091/-B412-2689-2630./1573-96412-<366/ 6<12-2689-.40/.4.B.:2-9.5054750-41B.954<6/;-0 16 12- 964543.B6< 12- 76;=3.54.41 .40 2- 7.;- 54 12- ;6/454>2-/-.<1-/B512259.99591.47-92-7.;-1612- =6357- 91.1564 .40 360>-0 12- 76;=3.541 16 12- =6357- B2572 B.9 /->591-/-0 54 12- .A6?- 7/5;- 48;A-/ .40 54?-915>.1564B.93.8472-0
- 4 -
( 8/54> 12- 54?-915>.1564 12- 54?-915>.154> 6<<57-/ 2.0 /-76/0-0 . <8/12-/ 91.1-;-41 6< 12- 76;=3.54.41B2-/-5492-91.1-012.112-.7789-02.03-<1 . 8/C-: 6B-3 A-364>54> 16 25; 54 2-/ 2689- .40 2.0 /.4.B.: 2- .396 0597369-0 54 12- <8/12-/ 91.1-;-41 0.1-0 ) (12.192-B.9.364-5412-2689-.4012- .7789-07.;-.1 5412-;5045>21.4076;;511-012- 6<<-47- 2- 76;=3.54.41 B.9 98AF-71-0 16 ;-057.3 -D.;54.156464 (.40.112-15;-6<12-;-057.3 -D.;54.1564 51 B.9 <6840 12.1 12-/- B-/- 46 -D1-/4.3 54F8/5-96412-A60:6<12-?5715;A8112-/-B.9.-/695?- .40 /-04-99 9--4 54 12- ?.>54.3 ./-. 6< 12- ?5715; 2-/-.<1-/64 (.<1-/12-.//-9112-=-151564-/ B.9 .396 98AF-71-0 16 ;-057.3 -D.;54.1564 .40 12- ;-057.3 /-=6/1 926B-0 12-/- B-/- 46 -D1-/4.3 54F8/5-9 <1-/ 76;=3-1564 6< 12- 54?-915>.1564 12- 54?-915>.154> 6<<57-/2.9<53-012-72./>-92--1.>.549112-.7789-0
- 5 -
2- 3-./4-0 76849-3 .==-./54><6/ 12- .7789-0 98A;519 12.1 12- .7789-0 2.0 <53-0 . =-151564 <6/ /->83./ A.53 54 /5;54.3 -151564 6 (+ .40 12- 9.;- B.9 B5120/.B4 64 ( B512 35A-/1: 16 <53- .
</-92 A.53=-151564.<1-/12-76;;-47-;-416<12-1/5.34612-/ /5;54.3 -151564 6 + B.9 B5120/.B4 64 * 6B 12- 3-./4-0 76849-3 .==-./54> <6/ 12- =-151564-/ 98A;519 12.1-?-4 .<1-/ 3.=9- 6< 64- :-.//5.3 68/1 59 84.A3- 16 2-./12-05972./>- .==357.1564 <53-0 A: 12-=-151564-/9987212-1/5.32.9461:-176;;-47-0 -98A;51912.112-=-151564-/593.4>859254>5412-F.53<6/ ;6/-12.4.:-./159.33->-012.112-=/69-78156459461 9-/568954764087154>12-1/5.32-/-76/09/-?-.312.112- =8A357 =/69-7816/ 59 9--C54> 15;- 16 ./>8- 12- ;.11-/ .1 12- 91.>- 6< 2-./54> A-<6/- 72./>- 519-3< %8/12-/ 51 59 98A;511-0 12.1 51 59 . <.39- 7.9- B2572 2.9 A--4 <53-0 .>.5491 12- =-151564-/ 08- 16 12- =635157.3 /5?.3/: 2-/-<6/-12-=-151564-/A-54>/-.0:.40B53354>16.A50- A:.4:764051564912.1;.:A-5;=69-0A:125968/1;.: A->/.41-0A.5315998A;511-012.1.4:<8/12-/0-1-41564 6< 12- =-151564-/ B6830 461254> A81 =/-1/5.3 =84592;-41 2-/-<6/-12-=-151564A-.336B-0
- 6 -
-/ 7641/. /5 &.;.0./ 2.2.A80054 12- 3-./4-0 5>2 68/1 6?-/4;-41 3-.0-/ 98A;519 12.1 12- ;-057.3/-76/06<12-?5715; 73-./3:54057.1-9.=6995A5351:
6< 9-D8.3 541-/768/9- .40 B2-4 12- ?5715; 2.9 <53-0 12- 76;=3.541 .40 3.1-/ 2.9 /-51-/.1-0 12- 54750-41 54 2-/ 91.1-;-41840-/-71564+6</12-/-5998<<575-41 ;.1-/5.316926B12.1.7789-02.076;;511-012-6<<-47- -98A;51912.112-=/69-78156459/-.0:16766=-/.1-<6/ 12- 1/5.3 .40 12- 7641-415649 6< 12- =-151564-/ ./- 461 9891.54.A3-543.B-98A;51912.112-/-./-;.4:612-/ 7.9-9B257212-/5.368/1591.C54>8=12-/-<6/-12-/- 590-3.:5476;=3-154>12-91.>-6<2-./54>A-<6/-72./>- - 98A;519 12.1 .4: >/.41 6< A.53 B6830 /-9831 54 . =6995A5351: 12.1 12- =-151564-/ ;.: 54<38-47- .40 2- ;.: 1.;=-/12-=/69-781564B514-99-9B26./-?834-/.A3- + 4 7./-<83 =-/89.3 6< 12- 72./>-92--1 =.=-/9 .40 12- /-76/09 51 59 -?50-41 12.1 64 12- 3.91 1B6 677.95649B2-412-A.53=-1515649B-/-B5120/.B4A:12- =-151564-/ 12- 6A9-/?.15649 B-/- 12.1 12- 1/5.3 59 461 :-1 76;;-47-0 12-/- A-54> 64- ;.1-/5.3 .40 91./ B514-99 12- A.53 =-151564 B6830 A- 764950-/-0 643: .<1-/ 9872 ?834-/.A3-B514-9959-D.;54-0
- 7 -
* 159=-/154-4116461-12.16412-=/-?56890.1- 6< 2-./54>1259 68/146157-0 </6; 12- 76=: 6<12-6/0-/ 92--1 6< 12- /5.3 68/1 12.1 -?-4 1268>2 12- 76849-3 .==-./54><6/12-=-151564-/2.0./>8-012-;.11-/A-<6/- 12-/5.368/1<6/05972./>-12-3-./4-08A357/69-7816/ 2.0 968>21 15;- 64 ;6/- 12.4 ( 677.95649 2-9- 75/78;91.47-9.396926B12.1<6/?./5689/-.964912-1/5.3 76830 461 A- 76;;-47-0 269- /-.9649 ./- 461 <6/1276;54></6;12-/5.368/1/-76/09
2- 72./>-92--1 =.=-/9 0597369- 12.1 12- ?5715; 59 .>-0 :-./9 .40 92- B.9 35?54> .364- 4 2-/ 76;=3.541 12-/- 59 .A96381-3: 46 ;-41564 12.1 8/C-: 6B-32.0A--43-<1A-2540A:12-.7789-042-/<8/12-/ 91.1-;-41 92- 91.1-9 12.1 12- .7789-02.0 3-<1A-2540 . 8/C-: 6B-3 54 2-/ 2689- .<1-/ 76;;599564 6< 12- 6<<-47- A?56893:12-%
/-=6/106-9461/-<3-7112.112- 9.50 8/C-: 6B-3 B.9 98AF-71-0 16 .
%
-D.;54.1564 2-/-59.A96381-3:46/-.964.916B2:12-8/C-:6B-3
- 8 -
B.9 461 98AF-71-0 16 %
-D.;54.1564 2- /-=6/1 6< 12- %
B6830926B12.1464-6<12-73612-96<12-?5715;2.0 .4: 9-;54.3 91/.549 .40 464- 6< 12- 73612-9 6< 12- =-151564-/ .7789-0 B-/- 2.?54> .4: 54057.1564 6< 12- -=512-35.3 7-339 6< 12- ?5715; 2-/-<6/- 12- ;-057.3 -D.;54.1564 .9 A6/4- 681 </6; 12- /-76/0 59 461 76//6A6/.154>12-?-/95646<12-=/69-7815646B-?-/12- 6/.3 1-915;645-9 6< 12- ?5715; .40 612-/ B514-99-9 .9 /-76/0-0A:12-4?-915>.154> <<57-/840-/-71564+6< /./-5498==6/16<12-=/69-781564?-/9564
) 40-/12-9-75/78;91.47-912-1/5.359>654>16 A-=/6364><8/12-/.40125968/1594619.159<5-0B51212- ;.44-/54B257212-=/69-7815642.07640871-012-7.9- A-<6/- 12- /5.3 68/1 40-/ 12-9- 75/78;91.47-9 12- <8/12-/0-1-415646<12-.7789-0B6830A-461254>A81=/- 1/5.3 =84592;-41 .40 .396 C--=54> 54 ?5-B 12.1 12- =-151564-/5954F80575.3789160:<6/;6/-12.4.:-./12- =-1515640-9-/?-916A-.336B-0776/054>3:12-<6336B54>G
- 9 -
2-/5;54.3-15156459.336B-0
2- =-151564-/ 59 6/0-/-0 16 A- /-3-.9-0 64 A.53 54 /5;- 6 ( ( 6< 540466/ 6357- 1.1564 <6/ 12- 6<<-47-9 =84592.A3- 840-/ -715649 ( ( (*+.40+6<=-4054>6412-<53-6<12- 0051564.3591/571.40-99564968/1.1.5728/ 951154>.1540466/546 98AF-7116 12-<6336B54>7640515649
.' -151564-/ 92.33 <8/4592 . =-/964.3 A640 <6/ . 98; 6< 9 B512 64- 98/-1: <6/ 12- 35C-98; 16 12- 9.159<.71564 6< 12- 3-./4-0 6;;511.368/1 /5.368/1
A' 2- =-151564-/ 92.33 .==-./ A-<6/- 12- /5.3 68/1 64 .33 2-./54> 0.1-9 98AF-71 16 F891 -D7-=15649 12.1 ;.: A- =-/;511-0 A: 12- /5.3 68/1
- 10 -
7' 2-=-151564-/92.334612.?-.4:96/16<7641.71 B512 12- ?5715; 6/ .4: 6< 12- =/69-781564 B514-99-9 -512-/ 05/-713: 6/ 5405/-713: .40 54<38-47-12-;54B2.196-?-/;.44-/8415312- 1/5.3596?-/
0 %#$ ) $
&& 591636)