Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 12063 (KAR)
SAGAR DUBEY AND ANR v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA AND ANR
CRL.P/201545/2024 · 2025-01-10
S Vishwajith Shetty
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 12063 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 12063 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"! #$" % &" ! $ '(')*+(' ** &
! "#$#%
&
%
! #$#%
'
(
)
* &
*
#$#%
Digitally signed by SHILPA R TENIHALLI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
&
! #$#%
'
( *
& *)
*
+$* () #$* (&) ,
* %%+ %$
%+ * %+ & *** +%#%+ #%- * * * *
* &
. &
( . &) //0123 41 563 572 829472 :;<1 407: 06327 2/:<46+$497 =<:;:;2>75?27:4@051;:;226:<72 >74/223<6A1<6 4%$
%+>263<6A829472:;2407: 4933<:<465B<C<B03A2563*5B5807A<563*<6 7<D2 4
%+ 72A<1:2723 8? ;4=E 4B</2 :5:<46
- 3 -
5B58075A<<:?947:;249926/21>06<1;58B2063272/:<461 +%#%+563#%-49
2573:;2B257623/40612B947:;2>57:<21
;2721>46326:4;272<6;519<B235>7<C5:2 /4D>B5<6: 829472 :;2 07<13</:<465B 5A<1:75:2 <6 4%$
%+=;</;=51729277238?:;207<13</:<465B 5A<1:75:2 :4 :;2 >4B</2 947 <6C21:<A5:<46 06327 2/:<46 #-() 49 7 563 <6 :076 :;2 ;4=E 4B</2 :5:<46 5B58075A< ;5C2 72A<1:2723 * <6 7<D2 4
%+ 5A5<61: >2:<:<4627 ;272<6 563 564:;27 947 :;2 49926/21 >06<1;58B2063272/:<461+%#%+563#%-49 +
2<6A 5AA7<2C23 8? :;2 15D2 :;2 >2:<:<46271 ;272<6=;45725775?23515//012341563<67<D2 4
%+ 572 829472 :;<1 407: 06327 2/:<46 +$ 49 7 # 257623 /40612B 947 :;2 >2:<:<46271 ;5C<6A 72<:275:23 :;2 A740631 07A23 <6 :;2 >2:<:<46 108D<:1 :;5: 5//01234;51<6<:<5:23$>74/223<6A1515A5<61::;2
- 4 -
;01856349:;2721>46326:;272<6563515/406:27:4:;2 15D2 :;2 >72126: /4D>B5<6: ;51 8226 9<B23 2 108D<:1 :;5: :;272 <1 56 <6473<65:2 32B5? <6 9<B<6A :;2 >7<C5:2 /4D>B5<6: 563 64 72>B? =51A<C26:4 :;2 1:5:0:47?64:</2 <110234682;5B9495//01234<6:;2>74/223<6A106327 2/:<46$492A4:<58B261:70D26:/:6B?:4;57511 :;2>2:<:<46271595B12/7<D<65B/512;51822672A<1:2723 - 27 /46:75 B257623 <A; 407: 4C276D26:
B25327 563 B257623 /40612B 947 721>46326: 4 ;5C2 4>>4123 >2:<:<46 21>46326: 4 108D<:1 :;5: 46 :;2 >72:2F: 49 5C5<B<6A B456 974D 5 >7<C5:2 9<656/2 /4D>56? 5//0123 >271461 ;5C2 :5E26 :;2 8B56E 1<A623/;2@02149 721>46326: 4 563 46 :;2 851<1 49 :;2 15<3 8B56E /;2@021 5//0123 41 563 ;5C2 5B7253? <6<:<5:23 >74/223<6A1 947 49926/2 >06<1;58B2 06327 2/:<46 $ 49 :;22A4:<58B261:70D26:1/:6:;22C26::;2/7<D<65B >74/223<6A1 572 @051;23 :;2 32926/2 49 :;2 721>46326:
4 <6 :;2 >74/223<6A1 06327 2/:<46 $ 49 2A4:<58B2 61:70D26:1 /: <1 B<E2B? :4 82 >72G03</23 4B</2 ;5C2
- 5 -
72A<1:2723 56 * 5A5<61: 5//0123 >271461 563 <9 :;2 <6C21:<A5:<46 <1 <6:27/2>:23 :;2 15D2 <1 B<E2B? :4 /5012 127<401<6G01:</2:4721>46326:4//473<6AB?>75?:4 3<1D<11:;2>2:<:<46
27015B 49 :;2 >7<C5:2 /4D>B5<6: 9<B23 8? :;2 721>46326: 4 =40B3 72C25B :;5: <: <1 ;27 1>2/<9</ /512 :;5: 5//0123 41 :4 =;4 ;53 /4BB2/:23 :;722 1<A623 /;2@021 974D ;27 563 ;27 ;018563 46 :;2 >72:2F: 49 5C5<B<6A9<656/<5B95/<B<:?974D 5G5G *<656/25B857A<;53 64:>74C<32356?9<656/<5B95/<B<:?:4:;2D56346:;24:;27 ;563 :;2 :;722 /;2@021 =;</; =272 :5E26 8? :;2D =51 D<10123 563 :;2?
;5C2 7290123 :4 72:076 :;2 /;2@021 <6 1><:24932D563D5328?:;2D6:;2>7<C5:2/4D>B5<6: <: <1 1:5:23 :;5: 721>46326: 4 ;53 5>>745/;23 :;2 >4B</2 563 62/21157? 2634712D26: :4 :;2 15<3 3292/: <1 5B14 >7430/23 829472 :;2 07<13</:<465B 5A<1:75:2 5B46A =<:;:;2>7<C5:24D>B5<6::/5664:8215<3:;5::;272<1 5814B0:2B? 64 D27<: <6 :;2 5BB2A5:<461 94063 <6 :;2 9<71:
<6947D5:<46 563 721>46326: 4 ;51 /4D>B<23 :;2
- 6 -
72@0<72D26:49B5=>7<47 :4 1;2 9<B<6A 5 >7<C5:2 /4D>B5<6:
829472 :;2 07<13</:<465B 5A<1:75:2 ;2729472 <: /5664:
82 15<3 :;5: :;2 07<13</:<465B 5A<1:75:2 ;51 27723 <6 729277<6A :;2>7<C5:2/4D>B5<6::4:;207<13</:<465B>4B</2 06327 2/:<46 #-() 49 7 947 :;2 >07>412 49 <6C21:<A5:<46272B?947:;2725146:;5:721>46326:4 ;5364:72>B<23:4:;21:5:0:47?64:</2<11023:4;2706327 2/:<46$49:;22A4:<5:<4661:70D26:1/::;215D2 /5664: 82 5 A74063 :4 @051; :;2 <D>0A623 /7<D<65B >74/223<6A15::;<11:5A2=;26:;2D5::27<11:<BB06327:;2 <6C21:<A5:<468?:;2>4B</2 $ ;2 46H8B2 0>72D2 407: <6 :;2 /512 49
72>47:23 <6 563 <6 :;2 /512 49
72>47:23 <6 !"#!$ % ;51 48127C23 :;5: :;2 >4=271 06327 2/:<46+$497 1;40B364:82647D5BB?2F27/<123:4
- 7 -
1/0::B2:;2<6C21:<A5:<468?:;2>4B</2563:;2<A;407:
1;40B3 82 1B4= =;<B2 2F27/<1<6A :;2<7 <6;2726: >4=271 063272/:<46+$497 =;272<65>75?27<1D532:4 <6:279272=<:;:;2<6C21:<A5:<468?:;2>4B</2
6327 :;2 /<7/0D1:56/21 5D 49 :;2 4><6<46 :;5: 5: :;<1 1:5A2 :;2 >75?27 D532 8? :;2 >2:<:<46271 /5664:82A756:23 % //473<6AB?:;294BB4=<6A
;2/7<D<65B>2:<:<46<1&#'#$&
,+
' % &" !*
"
AMM List No.: 1 Sl No.: 37