- 1 - !"! # $" % &" ! $ '()'*+,-(' ++ ,& $ ( '()'+'*+,-('(+' ++ , & ! " # $% & ' ! ( Digitally signed by SHILPA R TENIHALLI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - # # $ ! $" & ' # #( # ")#'("# '*( * "" # ) " # !# " "+ ""'("# * ")# (, & ! , -"" !* ! , $"" & ' ( - 3 - # # ' $"%( ! , $"" & ' # ! #( # ") '( # '( "'( # '*( " " ! # , ! # * .! *! '.! *! ( /012 34252 367 823/3/705 9:/52 7;3 7< :/=2 7"" :2>/532:2? @A 2B9?;:>9 7C/12 393/70 - 4 - 9/14;: <7: 342 7<<20125 8;0/549@C2 ;0?2: 213/70 " "+ " " $ " :29? 6/34 213/70 ")7< 820?/0>@2<7:23427;:37<!#2B9?;:>9 9/14;:?/53:/13342A9:2429:?37>2342:90??/58752?7<< @A34/517==707:?2: 29:?C29:02?17;052C<7:34289:3/25 # /0 :/=2 7"" 695 :2>/532:2? @A 2B9?;:>9 7C/12 393/70 9/14;: <7: 342 9<7:259/? 7<<20125 9>9/053 ;149889 90? 2/>43 7342:5 70 342 @95/5 7< 342 </:53 /0<7:=93/70 ?932? :212/B2? <:7= ?9889 7/??9889;:/0>34217;:527</0B253/>93/70 7<34219529CC3420/02911;52?82:570564762:209=2? /0 342 # 62:2 9::2532? 42 /0B253/>93/70 7< 342 1952 69517=8C232?90?149:>254223495@220</C2?42@9/C 988C/193/70</C2?@A911;52?75 90?@2<7:2342 D;:/5?/13/709C 255/705 7;:3 /0 :C/517 " 695 :2D2132? 90? /3 695 9CC762? 95 9>9/053 7342: 911;52? 82:570542:2<7:2911;52?7590?9:2@2<7:2 34/5 7;:3 /0 :/=/09C 23/3/70 7+" " 64/C2 342 - 5 - ?2$<9137 17=8C9/0903 90? 7342: /0D;:2? 9:2 @2<7:2 34/5 7;:3 /0 :/=/09C 23/3/70 7"+ " 6/34 9 8:9A2: 3719012C342:2>;C9:@9/C>:9032?37911;52?7 " 29:02? 17;052C <7: 342 823/3/702:5 /0 :/=/09C 23/3/70 7+" " 5;@=/35 3493 823/3/702:5 ?7 073 49B290A1:/=/09C903212?203590?342A9:2/01;537?A<7: 342C953=7:23490702A29:25;@=/353493347;>41952 /517==/332?3:/9C/03421952/5A2337@217==2012?2 5;@=/35 3493 342:2 9:2 52:/7;5 1703:9?/13/705 /0 342 53932=203 7< 342 9CC2>2? 2A26/30255 90? C73 7< /=8:7B2=2035 62:2 =9?2 @A 342 </:53 /0<7:=903 /0 4/5 <;:342: 53932=203 >/B20 70 342 B2:A 59=2 ?932 2 5;@=/353493959>9/053911;52?7342:2/59@57C;32CA 07 9CC2>93/70 <7;0? /0 342 </:53 /0<7:=93/70 5;@=/332? @A 342/0D;:2?2A26/3025590?342:2<7:2342:/9C7;:3695 D;53/</2?/0>:903/0>@9/C374/=7/032:<2:2012/519CC2? <7:959>9/0533427:?2:7<@9/C>:9032?37911;52?7 2: 1703:9 C29:02? />4 7;:3 7B2:0=203 C29?2: 90? C29:02? 17;052C 98829:/0> <7: 342 ?2$<9137 - 6 - 17=8C9/0903 49B2 788752? 342 @9/C 988C/193/70 </C2? @A 911;52? 75 90? 42A 5;@=/3 3493 /0 342 5;@52E;203 53932=203 7< 342 /0D;:2? 2A26/30255 42 495 =9?29CC2>93/7059>9/0539CC34252911;52?90?342:2<7:2 342 :/9C 7;:3 695 D;53/</2? /0 :2D213/0> 342/: @9/C 988C/193/70 % 42 C29:02? 17;052C <7: 342 ?2$<9137 17=8C9/0903 5;@=/35 3493 342:2 /5 9CC2>93/70 95 9>9/053 911;52?79@7;3429559;C3/0>342?212952?704/5<912 6/34 90 9F2 90? ?2934 7< 342 ?212952? /5 95 9 :25;C3 7< /0D;:A5;<<2:2?704/5429?42:2<7:2342:/9C7;:3695 073D;53/</2?/0>:903/0>@9/C37911;52?7117:?/0>CA 42 8:9A5 37 19012C 342 7:?2: 7< @9/C >:9032? /0 <9B7;: 7< 911;52?7 + 42 =932:/9C 70 :217:? 67;C? >7 37 5476 3493 34289:3/2549?9/CC$6/CC9>9/05329147342:6/34:2>9:?37 12:39/01/B/C?/58;32590?342A9C5749?987C/3/19C:/B9C:A 0 342 9CC2>2? ?932 7< /01/?203 6420 ?212952? 695 3:9B2CC/0> 9C70> 6/34 </:53 /0<7:=903 '*( /0 4/5 - 7 - =737:@/G2 342 911;52? 82:5705 647 19=2 /0 9 3:9137: 64/14695?:/B20@A911;52?7?9542?34259/?3:9137: 959>9/053342=737:@/G290?6420342?212952?90?342 </:53 /0<7:=903 <2CC ?760 342 911;52? 82:5705 647 >73 ?760 <:7= 342 3:9137: 9CC2>2?CA 9@;52? 90? 9559;C32? 342= 0 342 59/? /01/?203 ?212952? 9:G90?9AA9 647 49?5;<<2:2?>:/2B7;5/0D;:/2549??/2?9334258737<342 /01/?20342:29<32:93A82?17=8C9/036955;@=/332?@A 342 /0D;:2? 2A26/30255 @952? 70 64/14 # /0 :/=2 7"" 695:2>/532:2?@A2B9?;:>97C/12 393/70 9/14;: 0 342 3A82? </:53 /0<7:=93/70 9CC2>93/70 7< 9559;C3/0> ?212952? 9:G90?9AA9 6/34 9F2 /5 =9?2 95 9>9/053 911;52? 75 90? B20 /0 342 <;:342: 53932=2037<342/0D;:2?2A26/302553493695:217:?2?70 342:2 /5 9CC2>93/70 95 9>9/053 911;52? 75 90?9@7;3342A9559;C3/0>342?212952?6/34909F2 7 <9: 95 911;52? 7 /5 17012:02? 347;>4 /3 /5 9CC2>2? /0 342</:53/0<7:=93/7034934249?9559;C32??212952?6/34 342 9F2 70 4/5 C2<3 C2> /0 342 <;:342: 53932=203 7< 342 /0D;:2?4249553932?3493911;52?749?9559;C32?342 - 8 - ?212952?6/34342490?C27<3429F259>9/053911;52? 7 /0 342 </:53 /0<7:=93/70 /3 695 9CC2>2? 3493 42 49? 539@@2?342?212952?6/349G0/<2704/514253@;3/0342 <;:342: 53932=203 /3 /5 9CC2>2? 3493 42 49? 9559;C32? ?212952?9:G90?9AA96/34909F2704/5C2>42:2<7:2 /3 /52B/?20334939CC2>93/705=9?29>9/053911;52?75 90?/0342</:53/0<7:=93/7090?/0342<;:342:53932=203 7< 342 </:53 /0<7:=903 9:2 073 1705/53203 90? 342:2 9:2 1703:9?/137:AB2:5/705 0?2: 342 1/:1;=5390125 9= 7< 342 78/0/70 3493 342 8:9A2: =9?2 @A 823/3/702: 75 90? " 911;52? 75 90? <7: >:903 7< :2>;C9: @9/C 022?5 37 @2 2032:39/02?64/C23428:9A2:=9?2@A823/3/702:7590? 911;52? 75 90? <7: >:903 7< :2>;C9: @9/C 022?5 37 @2:2D2132? ) 057<9: 95 911;52? 7 /5 17012:02? 342:2 /5 079CC2>93/70959>9/0534/=/0342</:53/0<7:=93/709@7;3 429559;C3/0>342?212952?7:342/0D;:2?11;52?7 /559/?37@23425707<911;52?790?/59>2?9@7;3 - 9 - A29:5 0 342 <;:342: 53932=203 7< 342 </:53 /0<7:=903 9CC2>93/70695=9?23493911;52?79C5749?9559;C32? ?212952? 6/34 90 9F2 70 4/5 <912 762B2: 342 :/9C 7;:339G/0>/0371705/?2:93/703493075;149CC2>93/70695 <7;0?/0342</:53/0<7:=93/70959>9/053911;52?7495 >:9032? :2>;C9: @9/C 37 4/= 0?2: 342 1/:1;=5390125 9=7<34278/0/70349307>:7;0?/5=9?27;3@A342?2$ <9137 17=8C9/0903 37 19012C 342 7:?2: 7< :2>;C9: @9/C >:9032? 37 911;52? 7 @A 342 D;:/5?/13/709C 255/705 7;:3117:?/0>CA342<7CC76/0>7:?2:/589552? 42 :/=/09C 23/3/70 7+" " /5 89:3CA 9CC762?23/3/702:7590?" 911;52?7590?9:2 ?/:2132? 37 @2 20C9:>2? 70 @9/C /0 :/=2 7"" :2>/532:2? @A 2B9?;:>9 7C/12 393/70 9/14;: <7: 342 7<<20125 8;0/549@C2 ;0?2: 213/70 " "+ " " $ " :29? 6/34 213/70 ") 7< 820?/0> /0 7) " @2<7:2 342 7;:3 7< !# - 10 - 2B9?;:>9 9/14;: ?/53:/13 5;@D213 37 342 <7CC76/0> 170?/3/705 9( 23/3/702:7590?" 911;52?7590? 549CC 2F21;32 82:5709C @70? <7: 9 5;= 7< 5 $ 2914 6/34 367 5;:23/25 <7: 342 C/G25;= 37 342 593/5<913/70 7< 342 D;:/5?/13/709C 7;:3H @( 23/3/702:7590?" 911;52?7590? 549CC98829::2>;C9:CA709CC342?93257<429:/0> @2<7:2 342 :/9C 7;:3 ;0C255 342 :/9C 7;:3 2F2=835342/:98829:9012<7:B9C/?:295705H 1( 23/3/702:7590?" 911;52?7590? 549CC073?/:213CA7:/0?/:213CA34:293207:39=82: 6/343428:7521;3/706/3025525H ?( 23/3/702:7590?" 911;52?7590? 549CC073/0B7CB2/05/=/C9:7<<20125/0<;3;:2H 2( 23/3/702:7590?" 911;52?7590? 549CC073C29B2342D;:/5?/13/707<342:/9C7;:3 6/347;3 82:=/55/70 7< 342 59/? 7;:3 ;03/C 342 1952:2>/532:2?9>9/053342=/5?/58752?7<< 42 :/=/09C 23/3/70 7+" " /5 ?/5=/552? 95 9>9/053 823/3/702: 75 90? 911;52? 75 90? - 11 - 6/34C/@2:3A37</C29<:254@9/C823/3/709<32:2F9=/093/707< 342 /0D;:2? 6/30255 '*( /5 17=8C232? @2<7:2 342 :/9C 7;:3 42 :/=/09C 23/3/70 7"+ " </C2? @A 342 ?2$<913717=8C9/090390?342B/13/=5390?5?/5=/552? ., ' % &" !+ " /537 C7)