Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 12048 (KAR)

MANOJ KUMAR AND ANR v. THE GOVERNMENT OF KARNATAKA AND ORS

WP/203354/2024 · 2025-02-13

R Nataraj

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - !!" #$% % & ' ! " # $ % &! ''' &!(!' Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: High Court Of Karnataka - 2 - ) &!(!' ( &' ! &!(!' " # %)!* %$ % + % % % , & '') % % -. / 0121343456178971:1;57130485<73811=46>9?74346 301693<715;@96A9@<8A471B346>301718256A163535 B5684A17 30147 71271816393456 A931A '') 96A 35 - 3 - A1BC971 301 93?9A9 79@ 96B09D93 98 19A <973178 B5@27481A 5; 93?9A9 E4CC9>1 93?9A9 096A9 5669CC4 9C9892<796A9C9892<7096A9 01 21343456178 B56316A 3093 301 3931 5E176@163 46 1F17B481 5; 438 25?17 <6A17 734BC1 ) 96A)5;301568343<34565;6A4909A71BC9884;41A96A A1C4@431A 301 G<748A4B3456 5; 79@ 96B09D938 98 217 301 5E176@16357A17A931A'')'309AB568343<31A9 5@@43311 019A1A :D 74 96G<6A9DD969 9309 ;57 301 71B568343<345696A1839:C480@1635;61?>79@296B09D938 46 301 3931 01 5@@43311 B56A<B31A 9 8<7E1D 96A 71B5@@16A1A;5771B568343<345696A1839:C480@1635;61? >79@ 296B09D938 <78<963 3017135 301 718256A163 5) 488<1A A79;3 6534;4B93456 A931A H''! 30171:D 6534;D46>979><33498019AI<9731785;301>79@296B09D93 ;57301E4CC9>18979><334979@96B045669CC4293?9A9 93?9A9 096A9 96A 9C892<7 46 1F17B481 5; 438 25?17 <6A171B34565;301 976939=996B09D939GB3HH) 96A46E431A5:G1B34568;75@3012<:C4B0121343456178;4C1A - 4 - 5:G1B34568 B56316A46> 3093 93?9A9 E4CC9>1 098 :13317 ;9B4C43418 96A 48 @571 8<439:C1 ;57 :146> 6534;41A 98 9 019AI<973179843C9D93301B163715;301>79@296B09D93 9719 96A ?98 :13317 C5B931A 3096 979><334 01 21343456178 09A 197C417 8<:@4331A 712718163934568 46 301 D197 ''H 35 718256A163 5 96A 718256A163 5) 35 B5684A17 301 ;1984:4C43D 5; 3719346> 93?9A9 E4CC9>1 98 301 019AI<973178 98 979><334 ?98 ;97 9?9D ;75@ 301 53017 E4CC9>18 B5@2971A 35 93?9A9 01 712718163934568 ?171 2C9B1A:1;571301718256A16358)96A01718256A163 5)A471B31A301718256A163535B56A<B39616I<47D 96A8<:@439712573<78<9633017135301718256A1635 B56A<B31A 96 16I<47D 96A 8<:@4331A 9 712573 A931A !'''H 71B5@@16A46> 301 B096>1 5; 019AI<973178 ;75@979><3343593?9A901718256A16358163301 89@1 35 301 3931 5E176@163 ;57 5:394646> 217@488456 ;57 B096>1 5; 019AI<973178 01 21343456178 B56316A 3093 301719;31765 83128 ?171 39=16 :D301 3931 5E176@163 35 92275E1 301 712573 5; 718256A163 5) 01D 922759B01A 301 96G<6A9DD969 9309 5@@43311 :<3 - 5 - 653046> 0922161A 301719;317 01 21343456178 30171;571 B09CC16>1A 301 9J1331 6534;4B93456 A931A '''! A1BC9746>97><33498301019AI<973178:1;571718256A163 5 01 92219C ;4C1A :D 301 21343456178 ?98 71G1B31A ;5CC5?46> ?04B0 301D B09CC16>1A 43 :1;571 3048 5<73 46 5'! '! 048 5<73 71@4331A 301 B981 35 718256A163 5 ;57 9 B5684A1793456 9;7180 01 718256A16359>94629881A9657A17A931A'')'! B56;47@46> 301 6534;4B93456 A931A '''! 048 ?98 9>946 B09CC16>1A :1;571 3048 5<73 46 5'!' ( 'H0485<739CC5?1A301?74321343456 96A I<9801A 301 57A17 29881A :D 301 718256A163 5 A931A '+''( 96A A471B31A 301 718256A163 5 35 B5684A17 301 71B5@@16A93456 @9A1 :D 718256A163 5) 96A29889227527493157A1780121343456178B56316A3093 301D 922759B01A301718256A1638 96A 71I<1831A 301@ 35 B5@2CD 301 57A17 29881A 46 5'!' ( 'H 5?1E1730189@1?98653B5684A171A96A30171;571301 21343456178?1719AE481A35;4C19B5631@232134345646 5'' ' 01D B56316A 3093 301 746B429C - 6 - 1B71397D 5; 301 12973@163 5; <79C 1E1C52@163 96A 96B09D93 9G ;4C1A 96 9;;4A9E43 839346> 3093 301 2752589C ;57B096>15;019AI<973178?98;57?97A1A35301%4696B1 12973@163 ;57 B56B<7716B1 96A 3093 301 %4696B1 12973@163 09A A1BC461A 35 92275E1 301 :4;<7B93456 A<1 35 ;4696B49C 1F4>16B418 96A 9C85 846B1 301 168<8 471B35793109AB5@@16B1A301B168<8?57=;57301' B168<8 048 5<73 BC581A 301 B5631@23 21343456 :<3 217@4331A 301 21343456178 35 8<:@43 561 @571 71271816393456 9;317 B5@2C13456 5; 301 B168<8 ?57= 01 213434561783016@9A197127181639345635718256A1635 56 '') 01 718256A1638 ?4305<3 B5684A1746> 301 71271816393456 09E1 488<1A 96 1C1B3456 6534;4B93456 A931A H' ;57 301 1C1B34568 35 301 >79@ 296B09D93 5; 979><334 0121343456178971 30171;571:1;5713048 5<73 811=46> ;57 9 A471B3456 35 718256A163 58 96A 35 B5684A1730171271816393456 ) 19761A AA434569C 5E176@163 AE5B931 8<:@4331A 3093 301 1C1B3456 35 979><334 296B09D93 48 - 7 - 9C719AD 01CA 96A 301 296B09D93 48 9C719AD B568343<31A 561301C188 01 8<:@438 3093 301 71271816393456 5; 301 21343456178 809CC :1 B5684A171A 46 301 C4>03 5; 301 712573 8<:@4331A :D 718256A163 5) 96A 92275274931 57A178 ?5<CA :1 29881A 1 8<:@4331A 3093 ;57 301 2<72581 5; B5684A1746>30171271816393456301B168<829734B<C9789C85 ?5<CA:1E174;41A96A8<439:C157A178?5<CA:129881A 6 E41? 5; 301 9;571894A 8<:@488456 @9A1 :D 301 C19761A AA434569C 5E176@163 AE5B931 3048 ?743 21343456 A1817E18 35 :1 A482581A 5;; 56 301 ;5CC5?46> 317@8 4$ 012134345648 44$ 01718256A163596A)971A471B31A35 B5684A17 301 71271816393456 ;4C1A :D 301 21343456178 56 '') 96A 2988 9227527493157A178469BB57A96B1?430C9? 444$ 3 48 611AC188 35 @163456 3093 718256A163 5 ?04C1 B5684A1746> 301 71271816393456 5; 301 21343456178 809CC 39=1 4635 B5684A1793456 301 712573 8<:@4331A :D 04@ - 8 - 35 718256A163 5) 96A 2988 92275274931 57A178 4E$ 048809CC:1A561?43046921745A5;30711 @56308 ;75@ 301 A931 5; 71B1423 5; 9 B52D 5;304857A17 () &%' % 4835C5+