Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 11981 (KAR)
TUKARAM REDDY v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
CRL.A/200316/2023 · 2025-01-27
Rajesh Rai K, S Sunil Dutt Yadav
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 11981 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 11981 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! " #
$! %
#
$!! $"" &'&(")*'&
) +
! " # $
%
& %
%
'
%%
&%
! " $
Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
% &
"($
& % & &
()()
%& &
#
% # &
* (( ( (( %
#
()()
& %
%&
%
&&% ( *"$ (
& + %
&%
()()
%
& & %% # ' %
%
, #
%
, ##%
!$
"%
, ##%$
-./ 00123 45 6-1 789:.761; 200133296277</1; 8 ./ ;.=1761; 2>2.9/6 6-1 ?<;>@196 8A 789:.76.89 29; 8=;1= 8A /1961971;261;* ((02//1;.9 8 ()()456-1 ;;3 ./6=.76 29; 1//.89/ #<;>1 .;2= .66.9> 26 2/2:2B23529"-1=1.92A61==1A1==1;682/6-1,312=91;1//.89/ #<;>1,$ C-1=145 6-1 312=91; 1//.89/ #<;>1 789:.761; 6-1 200133296277</1; 8 A8= 6-1 8AA1971/ 0<9./-2431 <9;1=
- 3 -
176.89/ ( *D 29; ( 8A 29; 27E<.661; 6-1 277</1;8/ (29;A8=6-1/2.;8AA1971/
( -124=.;>1;A276/8A6-172/12=12/A8338C/ -1 @2==.2>1 416C119 6-1 277</1; 8 29; 88?2 F 2=2/2@@2. 1 6-1;1712/1;.96-./72/1C2//831@9.G1;89 ) ) (266-1
AA.718A6-11>./6=2=2/2:2B23529
96-1 A8338C.9>;25277</1;8 D2=:26.>8602=235G1; C8@896-/ .968 6-1 @2==.2>1 6-1 200133296277</1; 8 =1387261; 68 <91"2-2=2/-6=2$89A.9;.9>2?8429;-18772/.892335:./.61;
-./-8@168C9 A61=A8<=@896-/8A@2==.2>18C.9>68277</1;
8 41.9> 02=235G1; 6-1 277</1; 8/ ( 68 D.9D32C/ 8A 6-1 ;1712/1; -2=2//1; -1= 486- 0-5/.72335 29; @1962335 /626.9> 6-26/-1C2/29.338@19686-1A2@.35 -=11@896-/0=.8=68 6-1 .97.;196 6-1 02=196/ 8A 6-1 ;1712/1; :./.61; -1= @26=.@89.23-8@1682;:./16-1277</1;8 29;-./02=196/ 68/-1;.33DC.332>2.9/66-1.=;2<>-61=29;6862B1>88;72=18A -1= >2.9/6 6-./ 427B;=80 89 ( * ( C-19 6-1 277</1;
8 :./.61; A=8@ <91 -1 -2; 2 =8C C.6- 6-1 ;1712/1; 29; =1.61=261;6-26/.971/-1C2/29.338@19686-1A2@.35/-1@</6 312:1 -1= @26=.@89.23 =1/.;1971 6-1 A8338C.9> @8=9.9> A2.3.9> C-.7- -1 6-=126191; -1= /-1 C8<3; 41 A8=71A<335 1:.761; -1
- 4 -
A8338C.9>;25. 1 89( * (6-1277</1;8 -2;2A=1/- =8C C.6- 6-1 ;1712/1; -1 :1=42335 24</1; 29; 0-5/.72335 2//2<361;-1=68A8=71A<335312:16-1@26=.@89.23-8@1 '-19 /-18008/1;68E<.6-1=@26=.@89.23-8@16-1277</1;4=<62335 2//2<361; -1= 8C.9> 68 C-.7- 6-1 ;1712/1; 08<=1; B1=8/191 89-1=/13AC.6-29.9619668/16-1=/13A2432G1-8C1:1=C-.31 /-1 /12=7-1; A8= 2 @267-48H 6-1 277</1; /16 -1= 2432G1 -1=12A61= -1 A31; 6-1 /086 6-1 91.>-48<=/ =1/7<1; 6-1 ;1712/1; 29; 2;@.661; -1= 68 2 8:1=9@196 %8/0.623 26 2/2:2B23529 @@1;.26135 <089 -1= 2;@.//.89 68 6-1 %8/0.62321;.78D1>232/1C2/=171.:1;45 ' ()D6-16-19 8A 6-1 =1/089;19683.71 29; -1 :./.61; 6-1 %8/0.623 =178=;1; 6-1 /6261@196 8A 6-1 .9?<=1; 2/ 01= H (( 29;
=1>./61=1; 2 72/1 2>2.9/6 6-1 277</1; A8= 6-1 8AA1971/ 0<9./-2431 <9;1= 176.89/ ( *D 29; =C 176.898A.9=.@18 ((;261;( * (2/ 01=H ( <4/1E<196356-12-/.3;2=D ' *23/8:./.61;6-1 %8/0.623 29; =178=;1; 6-1 ;5.9> ;1732=26.89 8A 6-1 .9?<=1; 2/ 01=H ) 261=/-1C2/=12;@.661;A8=-.>-1=6=126@19668 2324<=2>.
8:1=9@196 %8/0.623 <=.9> 6-1 78<=/1 8A 6=126@19689( * (26248<62 @ /-1/<77<@41;
68 6-1 .9?<=.1/ &8338C.9> 6-1 ;1@./1 8A 6-1 .9?<=1; ' ()
- 5 -
/1962=1E<./.6.8941A8=16-1?<=./;.76.89232>./6=26168.9:8B1 176.89 ( 8A
9 8462.9.9> 01=@.//.89 A=8@ 6-1 2>./6=261 176.89 ( 8A C2/ .9:8B1; .9 =.@1 8 ((;261;( * (2>2.9/66-1277</1;
A61= 6-1 ;126- 8A ;1712/1; ' ( 789;<761;
A<=6-1= .9:1/6.>26.89 45 =178=;.9> 6-1 /6261@196 8A 233 6-1 C.691//1/ 29; 200=1-19;1; 6-1 277</1; -15 789;<761;
=178:1=5 @2-2G2=/ 29; 6-1=12A61= 89 8462.9.9> 9171//2=5 ;87<@196/A=8@6-178971=91;2<6-8=.6.1/-132.;6-17-2=>1 /-116 2>2.9/6 6-1 277</1; 8 29; 6C8 86-1=/ . 1 277</1;
8/ (29;A8=6-18AA1971/0<9./-2431<9;1=176.89/*D (29;(=C176.898A41A8=16-178@@.66238<=6
A61= 78@@.6623 8A 6-1 72/1 41A8=1 6-1 1//.89/ 8<=66-1312=91;1//.89/#<;>1A=2@1;6-17-2=>1/2>2.9/6 6-1277</1;A8=6-12A8=1@196.891;8AA1971/29;6-1/2@1C2/ =12;D8:1=:1=426.@686-1@ %8C1:1=6-1277</1;;19.1;6-1 7-2=>1/31:1331;2>2.9/66-1@29;732.@1;68416=.1;
9 8=;1= 68 0=8:1 6-1 7-2=>1/ 31:1331; 2>2.9/6 6-1 277</1; 6-1 0=8/17<6.89 .9 68623 1H2@.91; ( C.691//1/ 2/
- 6 -
' 68' (@2=B1;(*;87<@196/2/H 68H (*29;
.;196.A.1;@261=.2384?176/2/
68
) &8338C.9>6-12 @1968A8=2329;;87<@1962=5 1:.;1971 03271; 41A8=1 6-1 1//.89/ 8<=6 6-1 312=91;
1//.89/ #<;>1 27E<.661; 277</1; 8/ ( 29; 29; 789:.761;
6-1200133296277</1;8 A8=6-17-2=>1/31:1331;2>2.9/6-.@ 29; /1961971; -.@ 2/ /6261; /<0=2 -1 /2.; ?<;>@196 ./ 7-23319>1;.96-./200123
'1-2:1-12=;6-1312=91;78<9/13=. 29?2526.3 A8=6-120013329629;312=91;;;3 6261<43.7=8/17<68==. .;;23.9> 26.3 A8= 6-1 =1/089;196D6261 29; C1 -2:1 23/8 01=</1;6-1=178=;/@2;12:2.3243141A8=1</
-1 0=.@2=5 7896196.89 8A 6-1 312=91; 78<9/13 A8= 6-1 200133296 ./ 6-26 6-1 312=91; 1//.89/ #<;>1 1==1; C-.31 789:.76.9>6-1200133296277</1;8 A8=6-17-2=>1/31:1331;
2>2.9/6 -.@ C.6-8<6 200=17.26.9> 6-1 1:.;1971 .9 =.>-6 01=/0176.:1 %1 A<=6-1= 789619;1; 6-26 6-1 312=91; 1//.89/ #<;>1 789:.761; 6-1 277</1; /83135 42/1; 89 H (( . 1 6-1 0<=08=61;/6261@1968A6-1;1712/1;41A8=1 ' ()D.96-1 -8/0.623 29; H )D2331>1; ;5.9> ;1732=26.89 =178=;1; 45
- 7 -
' *D6-12-/.3;2= 778=;.9>686-1312=91;78<9/13 ' () 29; ' * =178=;1; 6-1 /6261@196 8A 6-1 .9?<=1; C.6-8<6 8462.9.9> 295 A.691// 71=6.A.7261 45 6-1 ;<65 8768= 68 /<4/6296.261 6-26 6-1 .9?<=1; C2/ .9 2 3<7.; /6261 8A @.9; 68 >.:1/<7-/6261@196 %1A<=6-1=789619;1;6-266-191.>-48<=/ C-82=16-12331>1;151C.691//1/686-1.97.;196. 1 '/ 29; ) -2:1 7833176.:135 6<=91; -8/6.31 68 6-1 0=8/17<6.89 72/1 -8<>-6-1A2@.35@1@41=/8A6-1;1712/1;. 1 '/ ) 29;41A8=1C-8@6-1.9?<=1;@2;1-1=/6261@196.9 6-1%8/0.623.9.6.2335/<008=61;6-10=8/17<6.8972/1-8C1:1= 6-1=1 91.6-1= 2=1 1:.;1971/ 98= ;87<@196/ A8=6-78@.9> 6-26 1/6243./- 6-1 .9?<=1; C2/ A.6 68 ;108/1 41A8=1 6-1@ .9 6-1 %8/0.623 %1 23/8 789619;1; 6-26 6-1 78D277</1; 8/ ( 29;
2=1 6-1 02=196/ 8A 6-1 277</1; C-8 -2:1 23=12;5 4119 27E<.661; 45 6-1 312=91; 1//.89/ #<;>1 45 =135.9> 89 6-1 1:.;19718A '/ )29; 9/<7-7.=7<@/62971/6-1=1 ./ 98 /<7- 2;;.6.8923 1:.;1971 03271; 45 6-1 0=8/17<6.89 2>2.9/6 6-1/1 277</1; %1971 6-1 789:.76.89 29; /1961971 .@08/1;456-1312=91;1//.89/#<;>1./3.24316841/16D2/.;1 '.6-6-1/1/<4@.//.89/-10=25/682338C6-1200123
- 8 -
* 1A<6.9> 6-1 248:1 /<4@.//.89 312=91; ;;3 =.
.;;23.9> 26.3A8=6-1=1/089;196D6261/<4@.661;6-26 6-1?<;>@196;81/986/<AA1=A=8@01=:1=/.658=.331>23.652/6-1 312=91; 1//.89/ #<;>1 -2/ 789:.761; 6-1 277</1; 89 @16.7<38</35 1H2@.9.9> 6-1 1:.;1971 2:2.32431 89 =178=; .9 2 C133D=12/891; ?<;>@196 %1 789619;1; 6-26 6-1 02=196/ 29;
86-1==1326.:1/8A6-1;1712/1;. 1 '/ )29;-2:1 7261>8=.72335 ;108/1; .9 1:.;1971 6-26 8C.9> 68 277</1; 8 41.9>02=235/1;6-1277</1;200133296.33D6=1261;6-1;1712/1;
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
- 9 -
%2:.9>-12=;6-1312=91;78<9/13A8=6-1=1/0176.:1 02=6.1/29;<08901=</.9>6-1196.=11:.;197129;;87<@196/ 03271; 41A8=1 </ 6-1 08.96/ 6-26 2=./1 A8= 8<= 789/.;1=26.89 2=1
! "#"$ %&'$ '()*+
"&#
,-./
9 8=;1= 68 0=8:1 6-1 -8@.7.;23 ;126- 8A 6-1 ;1712/1;6-10=8/17<6.890=1;8@.929635=13.1;896-11:.;1971 8A ' (29; ' ((6-1 8768=/C-8789;<761;6-12<680/5 896-178=0/18A6-1;1712/1;
972=1A<301=</238A6-108/6D @8=61@ =108=6DH 6-1 8768= -2/ 80.91; 6-1 72</1 8A ;126-2/I6-1;126-./;<168J-508:831@.7/-87B;<168K 4<=9/L &<=6-1= 6-1 0=8/17<6.89 23/8 =13.1; 89 6-1 .9E<1/6 0297-292@2 789;<761; 89 6-1 78=0/1 8A 6-1 ;1712/1;2/ 01= H 29;6-10297-C.691//1/. 1 ' 29; ' (;108/1;
6-26 6-15 .;196.A.1; 6-1 4<=9 .9?<=.1/ 89 6-1 ;12; 48;5 8=18:1=6-10=8/17<6.8923/8=13.1;89H D(6-172/1/-116 8A6-18:1=9@196%8/0.6232/2:2B23529C-.7-=1:1231;6-26 896-1;2618A.97.;196. 1 89( * (26248<6) 0 @
- 10 -
6-1.9?<=1;88?2C2/2;@.661;686-1-8/0.623A8=6-14<=9//-1 /</62.91; 9/<7-7.=7<@/62971/C12=18A6-1:.1C6-266-1 0=8/17<6.89 -2/ 0=8:1; 6-1 ;126- 8A 6-1 ;1712/1; 2/ 4<=9 .9?<=.1/29;6-26-1=;126-C2/<9926<=23
( 878991766-1277</1;C.6-6-1<9926<=23;126-8A 6-1;1712/1;D88?26-10=8/17<6.89/.>9.A.729635=13.1;896-1 1:.;19718A '/ )29;C-82=16-102=196/29;86-1= =1326.:1/ 8A 6-1 ;1712/1;
9 72=1A<3 1H2@.926.89 8A 6-1 1:.;19718A6-1/1C.691//1/6-15-2:17261>8=.72335/6261;6-26 2A61= 6-1 .97.;196 89 ( * ( 6-15 C1=1 .96.@261; 45 6-1 91.>-48<=/ 8A 6-1 ;1712/1; 41.9> /</62.91; 4<=9 .9?<=.1/ 29; 6-26 /-1 C2/ 2;@.661; 26 6-1 8:1=9@196 %8/0.623 2/2:2B23529 -1=12A61= /-1 C2/ =12;@.661; 68 2324<=2>. 8:1=9@196 %8/0.623 A8= -.>-1= 6=126@196 <4/1E<19635 233 6-1/1C.691//1/:./.61;6-1%8/0.623262324<=2>.3261269.>-6 =8<>-35248<62 @ 29;<0896-1.=2==.:236-1;1712/1; ;.:<3>1;686-1@248<66-1.97.;196C-1=16-1277</1;-2;2 =8C C.6- -1= A8338C.9> C-.7- /-1 08<=1; B1=8/191 89-1=/13A 29;6-266-1277</1;/16-1=2432G1 -1/1C.691//1/-2:123/8 ;108/1; 6-1 /2@1 .9 6-1.= ) /6261@196 6-26 6-1 ;1712/1;
72331; 6-1@ 6-=8<>- @84.31 0-891 29; .9A8=@1; 248<6 6-1
- 11 -
-2=2//@196 @161; 8<6 45 6-1 277</1; 45 ;1@29;.9> 2@8<96 29; A8=7.9> -1= 68 312:1 6-1 @26=.@89.23 -8@1 %8C1:1= 41A8=161/6.9>6-1:1=27.658A6-11:.;19718A6-1/1C.691//1/ .6./9171//2=5681H2@.91C-16-1=6-1;1712/1;C2/0-5/.72335 A.629;@19623353<7.;68@2B1/<7-8=23/6261@196/686-1@
/.672941>26-1=1;A=8@6-1=178=;/2778=;.9>68 6-1 0=8/17<6.89 .@@1;.26135 2A61= 6-1 .97.;196 42/1; 89 6-1
' ()D :./.61; 6-1 8:1=9@196 %8/0.623 26 2/2:2B2352929;=178=;1;6-1/6261@1968A6-1.9?<=1;2/01= H (( 9 6-1 /2.; /6261@196 6-1 ;1712/1; /6261; 6-26 1:1= /.971 -1= @2==.2>1 -1= .9D32C/ .
1 6-1 277</1; 8/ ( 68 .971//29635 -2=2//1; -1= 23/8 C-191:1= 6-1 277</1; :./.61;
-8@1A=8@<91-1-2=2//1;-1=0-5/.7233529;@1962335
9 6-1 1:19.9> 8A ( * ( 6-1 277</1; -2; 2 =8C C.6- 6-1 ;1712/1; 29; 2//2<361; -1= /<4/1E<19635 89 ( * ( A8338C.9>2986-1==8C/-108<=1;B1=8/19189-1=/13A29;6-1 277</1; /16 -1= 2432G1 -./ /6261@196 8A 6-1 ;1712/1; C2/ =178=;1;45 ' ()89( * (26248<6 68 0 @ 778=;.9> 68 ' () 2A61= =178=;.9> H (( -1 >2:1 2 =1E<./.6.89 68 6-1 2-/.3;2= ' * 68 =178=; 6-1 ;5.9> ;1732=26.898A6-1;1712/1; 778=;.9>356-12-/.3;2= ' *
- 12 -
:./.61; 6-1 %8/0.623 26 248<6 0 @ 29; =178=;1; H ) %8C1:1= 26 6-1 6.@1 8A =178=;.9> 486- 6-1/1 /6261@196/ 91.6-1= ' ()29; ' *8462.91;A.691//71=6.A.7261A=8@6-1 8768=98=C2/295 8768=0=1/196266-16.@18A=178=;.9>6-1 /2@1 6.//16631;0=.97.0318A32C6-266-1=12=198/<7--2=; 29;A2/6=<316-266-1;5.9>;1732=26.89@</641=178=;1;.96-1 0=1/1971 8A 2 8768= 29; 6-1=1 /-233 41 2 A.691// 71=6.A.7261 A=8@6-1 8768=686-261AA176 -189352/01766-26-2/6841 789/.;1=1;./C-16-1=6-1;1712/1;C2/789/7.8</68>.:1/<7- /6261@19629;C-16-1=6-1=1C1=108//.4.3.6.1/8A6<68=.9>-1= 452958918A6-1A2@.35@1@41=/
9 72=1A<3 1H2@.9.9> 8A 6-1 1:.;1971 29; =178=;/ 03271;456-10=8/17<6.89H (. 1 6-172/1/-1160=8;<71;
45 6-1 0=8/17<6.89 ;10.76/ 6-26 6-1 ;1712/1; 88?2 C2/ 2;@.661; 68 2/2:2B232529 8:1=9@196 %8/0.623 89 ( * ( 26 248<6 ) 0 @ C.6- 6-1 -./68=5 8A 277.;19623 4<=9/ &<=6-1= .6 ./ 23/8 /6261; 6-26 /-1 -2; /</62.91; *K 4<=9/ 89 6-1 48;5 -1 -./68=5 8A 0=1/196 .3391// -2/ 4119 19<@1=261;.9H (2/I2331>1;-./68=58A277.;196234<=9/89 ( * ( 26 248<6 0 @M -1 0-5/.723 /.>9/ 29; 789;.6.89/8A6-1.9?<=1;=1:123/6-26/-1C2/;=8C/5-1=
- 13 -
29; 0<3/1 C1=1 986 =12;2431 H ( A<=6-1= ;10.76/ 6-26 26 248<6 0 @ 6-1 .9?<=1; C2/ =12;@.661; 68 8:1=9@196 %8/0.6232324<=2>.A8=-.>-1=6=126@196
9 78==848=26.9> 6-1 7896196/ 8A H ( C.6- 6-1 1:.;19718A ' ()29; ' *29;C.6-6-17896196/8AH (( 29;H ) ' ()-2//6261;6-26-1:./.61;6-1-8/0.623. 1 8:1=9@196 %8/0.623 2/2:2B23529 26 248<6 0 @ 29;
=178=;1; 6-1 /6261@196 8A 6-1 .9?<=1; 26 68 0 @ &<=6-1= 6-1 2-/.3;2= ' * 23/8 /6261; 6-26 -1 :./.61; 6-1 /2@1%8/0.62326248<6 0 @ 29;=178=;1;H ) /01= H (266-1/6.0<3261;6.@16-1026.196-2;6841=12;@.661; 686-18:1=9@196%8/0.623262324<=2>. 3/8.6./.@01=26.:1 6898616-26/-1-2;/</62.91;*K4<=9.9?<=.1/29;C2/.92 ;=8C/5 789;.6.89 29; <92431 68 >.:1 /6261@196 %1971 6-1 1:.;19718A ' () ' *6-1:1=27.658AH ((29;H ) /61@ ;8<46/ .9 6-1 @.9; 8A 6-./ 8<=6 A8= 6-1 =12/89 6-26 H ( ./ 6-1 ;87<@196 C-.7- C2/ =178=;1; 45 6-1 19.8= 1;.723
AA.71= 8A 2/2:2B232529 8:1=9@196 %8/0.623 26 6-1 12=3.1/6 -1 7896196/ 8A H ( 7312=35 ;.AA1=/ A=8@ 6-1 7896196/ 8A H ) 29; H (( 29; 23/8 C.6- 6-1 1:.;1971 8A ' ()29; ' *
- 14 -
) >2.9/6 6-./ 427B;=80 89 29 1:23<26.89 8A 6-1 1:.;1971 8A 6-1 A2@.35 @1@41=/ .
1 '/ ) 29; .6 8971 2>2.9 7=1261 ;8<46/ =1>2=;.9> 6-1 61/6.@895 8A 6-1/1 C.691//1/ 6-26 6-1 ;1712/1; >2:1 /6261@196 41A8=1 6-1@ 26 248<6 2 @ .9 6-1 %8/0.623 2/ 6-1 .9?<=1; /<77<@41; 68 6-1 4<=9 .9?<=.1/ .@@1;.26135 6-1=12A61= 26 248<6 2 @ 3/8 /-1 C2/ .9 2 ;=8C/5 /6261 26 6-1 6.@1 8A =138726.9> -1= A=8@ 2/2:2B23529 =.@2=5 %1236- 196=1 68 8:1=9@196 %8/0.623 2324<=2>. 9/<7-7.=7<@/62971/@<7-1:.;196.2=5 :23<17299864126627-1;686-11:.;19718A '/ )29;
&<=6-1=6-191.>-48<=/D6-12331>1;151C.691//1/68 6-1 .97.;196 C-8 2;@.661; 6-1 .9?<=1; 68 6-1 %8/0.623 . 1 '/ )29;(-2:17833176.:1356<=91;-8/6.31686-1 0=8/17<6.89 72/1 9 /<7- 7.=7<@/62971/ 6-1=1 ./ 98 @261=.23 1:.;1971 2:2.32431 89 =178=; 68 7899176 6-1 277</1; A8= 6-1 <9926<=23;126-8A6-1;1712/1; 6./200=80=.26168@196.89 6-26H (7312=35;10.76/6-266-1.9?<=1;/</62.91;277.;19623 4<=9.9?<=.1/ H ((23/8=1:123/6-26/-108<=1;B1=8/19189 -1=/13A 29; 6-1=12A61= 277</1; /16 -1= 2432G1 9 /<7- 7.=7<@/62971/ 6-1 2331>1; ;5.9> ;1732=26.89 @2;1 45 6-1
- 15 -
;1712/1; 2/ 01= H ) 29; (( 729986 41 /83135 =13.1; 89 C.6-8<629578==848=26.:11:.;1971 -1%89L43101H8<=6.9 6-1 72/1 8A .9 ! ! C-.31/<@@2=.G.9>6-132C.9=1/01768A6-1;5.9>;1732=26.89 -13;2602=2>=20-8 )(2/<9;1=
0
1
! 2
. 3
! . !1
! $ 1 $
1
1
!4 *
5
1
6
1
7
8 9 /
! ! 1
1
$
1
$
! $
! - 16 -
$
:
1
5
6 $
1
6 ,
$ 1 $
1
6 $
$
1
! ! 5
/
&<=6-1= 6-1 %89L431 01H 8<=6 .9 6-1 72/1 8A
" #$ % &' =108=61; .9 ( ! )* 23/8 /<@@2=.G1; 6-1 32C =1326.9>68@<36.031;5.9>;1732=26.89/ -1%89L43101H8<=6 .902=2>=20-8 *68* -13;2/<9;1=
+
;
. $
1
$
. 1
1
4
+* 0
3
! ! ! + +
! ,
1
$
!1
! < :
! ! 52
+! !1
$
! ! ! - 17 -
+, 0
! + =
! >
1
0 . 6
1
! +
$
! ! ? 5
! $ ! ! 3
! +) ,
$
5
$
$
1
! ! $ /
* &<=6-1= 6-1 %89L431 01H 8<=6 .9 6-1 72/1 8A -
.
/0 =108=61; .9 # !' * -2/ -13; 6-26 2-12; 8A 42/.9> 789:.76.89/ /83135 89 ;5.9>;1732=26.896-18<=6@</678@168278973</.896-266-1 ;5.9>;1732=26.89./6=</6C8=6-5=13.243129;891C-.7-.9/6.3/ 789A.;1971
( 0035.9> 6-1 A.9;.9>/ 8A 6-1 %89L431 01H 8<=6 .9 6-1 248:1 ?<;>@196/ 68 6-1 A276/ 29; 7.=7<@/62971/ 8A 6-./ 72/12/;./7<//1; 8972=1A<301=</238A6-17896196/8A H/ ) 29; (( 78<031; C.6- H ( C1 2=1 8A 6-1 789/.;1=1; :.1C 6-26 6-1/1 6C8 ;5.9> ;1732=26.89/ 729986 41
- 18 -
=13.1; 89 C.6-8<6 295 /<7- 78==848=26.:1 1:.;1971 &<=6-1= 6-8<>-6-10=8/17<6.8903271;6-11:.;19718A '/ )29; 6-1.=1:.;1971./23/8<96=</6C8=6-5A8=6-1=12/896-266-1 .9?<=1; C2/ 986 .9 2 08/.6.89 68 @2B1 295 ;1732=26.89/6261@19641A8=16-1@2/732.@1;456-1@ 9/<7- 7.=7<@/62971/6-10=8/17<6.89-2/A2.31;6803271@261=.2329;
78>196 1:.;1971 68 0=8:1 6-1 ><.36 8A 6-1 277</1; 41589; 233 =12/892431;8<46/ 778=;.9>35C12=18A6-1789/.;1=1;:.1C 6-266-11//.89/8<=61==1;C-.31789:.76.9>6-1277</1;A8= 6-1 7-2=>1/ 31:1331; 2>2.9/6 -.@ 778=;.9>35 .961=A1=1971 ./ =1E<.=1; .9 6-1 .@0<>91; ?<;>@196 02//1; 45 6-1 1//.89/ 8<=6 96-26:.1C8A6-1@2661=C129/C1=08.968 ".$.96-1 2AA.=@26.:1 29; 08.96 8 "..$ .9 6-1 91>26.:1 29; 0=8711; 68 02//6-1A8338C.9>
".$ -1 =.@.923 00123 A.31; 6-1 200133296 277</1;8 ./1
"..$ -1 ?<;>@196 8A 789:.76.89 29; 8=;1= 8A /1961971 ;261; * (( 02//1; .9 8 ()() 45 6-1 ;;.6.8923 ./6=.76 29; 1//.89/ #<;>1 .;2= /.66.9> 26 2/2:2B23529 ./ -1=145 /16 2/.;1 .9/8A2= 2/ 789:.76.9> 6-1 200133296277</1; 8 29; 6-1
- 19 -
200133296277</1; 8 ./ 27E<.661; 8A 6-1 8AA1971/ 0<9./-2431 <9;1= 176.89/ ( *29;(8A
"...$ -1 78971=91; #2.3 <6-8=.6.1/ 2=1 ;.=1761; 68 =1312/16-1200133296277</1;8 .A-1./986 =1E<.=1;.929586-1=72/1
1>./6=5./;.=1761;6878@@<9.72616-1801=26.:108=6.89 8A6-1?<;>@196686-178971=91;#2.3<6-8=.6.1/
,*
& %) ! ,*
&! ) ! %' ./68 38 D