Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 11979 (KAR)
LALITA v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
CRL.RP/200130/2023 · 2025-01-28
S Vishwajith Shetty
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 11979 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 11979 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"
! #$
"% &" ! $
% '()'*+,- '++ &
! "
#$%&
&'( )% *&#%$# *%*&
"
! !! ( *%*
#* **( +
Digitally signed by SHILPA R TENIHALLI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
,! ! ,! ! -. /0012.3 4* 56 7.05/8 49917:546 /2. 4( *%* 7.6356; <.=49. :-. 419: 4= 956057/8 .225462 !13;. 7.05/8 !13;. 5>/?/719/ 52 <.=49. :-52 419: /22/5856; :-. 493.9 3/:.3 *&%$*%*& 7/22.3 <? :-. 2/53 419: 9.>.0:56; :-. /77850/:546 =58.3 <? :-. 7.:5:546.9 163.9 .0:546**(4=92..@56;-.93520-/9;. * ./93 :-. 8./96.3 04162.8 =49 :-. 7.:5:546.9 /63 :-. 8./96.3 04162.8 =49 :-. 9.27463.6: A-4 -/2 =58.3 -52 2:/:.B.6:4=4<>.0:5462
& -. 7.:5:546.9 -.9.56 52 0-/9;.#2-..:.3 =49 :-. 4==.60. 71652-/<8. 163.9 .0:546 (/ 4= :-. 9.C.6:546 4= 49917:546B.63B.6:0:*%$/632-.52<.56;:95.3=49 :-. 0-/9;.#2-..:.3 4==.60. 56 7.05/8 49917:546 0/2. 4( *%* <.=49. :-. 419: 4= 956057/8 .225462
- 3 -
!13;. 7.05/8 !13;. 5>/?/719/ 6 :-. 2/53 7940..356;2 :-. 7.:5:546.9 -/3=58.3 /6 /77850/:546 163.9.0:546 **( 4= 9 2..@56; 3520-/9;. -. 2/B. A/2 47742.3 <? :-. 9.27463.6:<?=5856;2:/:.B.6:4=4<>.0:546-.:95/8419:
C53.:-.5B71;6.3493.9-/29.>.0:.3:-./77850/:5464=:-. 7.:5:546.9 =58.3 163.9 .0:546 **( 4= 9 /63 <.56; /;;95.C.3<?:-.2/B.:-.7.:5:546.952<.=49.:-52419:
) ./96.3 04162.8 =49 :-. 7.:5:546.9 -/C56;
9.5:.9/:.3 :-. ;941632 19;.3 56 :-. 7.:5:546 21<B5:2 :-/:
:-.9. 52 /<2481:.8? 64 B/:.95/8 :4 2-4A :-/: :-. 7.:5:546.9 -/39.0.5C.3/21B4=2*%%% #56.D0.22=94B:-. 04B78/56/6: /2 /88.;.3 56 :-. =592: 56=49B/:546 6 :-. /<2.60.4=B/:.95/8:42-4A:-/::-.7.:5:546.9-/29.0.5C.3 :-.<95<./B416:/2046:.63.3<?:-.04B78/56/6: 2-. 0/664: <. 7942.01:.3 =49 :-. 0-/9;.#2-..:.3 4==.60. -. :95/8 419: -/2 =/58.3 :4 /779.05/:. :-52 /27.0: 4= :-. B/::.9/63-/2.99.3569.>.0:56;:-./77850/:546=58.3163.9 .0:546**(4=9
.9 046:9/ 8./96.3 04162.8 =49 :-. 9.27463.6:
-/2 47742.3 :-. 79/?.9 B/3. 56 :-. 7.:5:546
. 21<B5:2
- 4 -
:-/: :-. 046C.92/:546 4= :-. 04B78/56/6: A5:- :-. 7.:5:546.956-.94==50.46:-.3/?A-.62-.9.0.5C.3/21B 4= 2*%% # =94B -5B -/2 <..6 9.0493.3 56 :-. B4<58. 7-46.9./356;4=:9/620957:4=:-.2/53046C.92/:546A4183 08./98?;4:42-4A:-/:/3.B/63A/2B/3.=497/?B.6:4= 2*%% #<?:-.7.:5:546.9:4A/9329.6.A/8=..:-41;-:-. /0:1/8 9.6.A/8 =.. 52 468? 2%% # -. 7.:5:546.9 A/2 79.2.6: /846; A5:- :-. /0012.3 4 46 :-. 3/? A-.6 :-. /0012.34C525:.3:-..:94816@4=3.=/0:404B78/56/6: /63-/33.B/63.3/21B4=2%%%% #=499.6.A/84=:-. .2:/<852-B.6: 0.9:5=50/:. 4= :-. 7.:948 <16@ A-50- 2:443 56 :-. 6/B. 4= :-. B4:-.9 4= :-. 04B78/56/6: 0049356;8?-.79/?.3:4352B522:-.7.:5:546
E 6:-.=592:56=49B/:5463/:.3%*%*%:-. 04B78/56/6: 95 17.2- /2/6:/8/ -/-/ -/2 2:/:.3 :-/: -52 B4:-.9 -/3 / .:948 16@ 850.60. 5221.3 <? 22/9 4B7/6?/63-52=/:-.9A/2:/@56;0/9.4=:-..:94816@
60. 56 =5C. ?./92 :-. 9.;52:9/:546 0.9:5=50/:. 4= .2:/<852-B.6: 4= :-. .:948 16@ -/3 :4 <. 9.6.A.3 -. 2/530.9:5=50/:.A/28/2:9.6.A.356:-.?./9*%E/635:A/2
- 5 -
31. :4 <. 9.6.A.3 46 &**%*% 6 %(%*%*% :-. /0012.342/63*-/3C525:.3:-./6@/635627.0:.3:-. 2/B. -.9./=:.9 :-. /0012.3 4 /=:.9 0488.0:56; :-. B4<58.7-46.61B<.94=:-.04B78/56/6:274@.:4 -5B/633.B/63.3/21B4=2%%%% #=499.6.A/84=:-. 9.;52:9/:546 0.9:5=50/:. 4= .2:/<852-B.6: -.
2/53 046C.92/:546 A/2 9.0493.3 56 :-. B4<58. -.9./=:.9 5: 52 /88.;.3:-/:/21B4=2%%% #A/27/53:4/0012.34 6 *%*%*% :-. 3. =/0:4 04B78/56/6: -/3 C525:.3 :-. 4==50. 4= /0012.3 4* 7.:5:546.9 /63 -/3 21<B5::.3 / 9.6.A/8 /77850/:546 /846; A5:- :-. 483 0.9:5=50/:. /63 4:-.9 9.F1525:. 3401B.6:2 /63 /0012.3 4* /88.;.38? 3.B/63.3 9.6.A/8=..4=2*%% #=94B-5B/63-.-/37/53:-.2/53 /B416:560/2-:4-.9/63/8249.0493.3:-.59046C.92/:546 56-52B4<58.7-46. .-/22:/:.3:-/::-./0:1/8/B416: =499.6.A/8=..A/2468?2%% #/63:-./0012.34*-/3 3.B/63.3.D0.22/B416:/639.0.5C.3/21B4=2*%%% # 56.D0.22=94B-5B560.-52B4:-.9A/264:A58856;:47/? :-.<95<./B416:/23.B/63.3<?:-./0012.34-.-/3 /7794/0-.3 :-. 74850. 21<2.F1.6:8? 46 %*%*% /63
- 6 -
21<B5::.3:-.=592:56=49B/:546</2.346A-50-5695B. 4) *%*%A/29.;52:.9.3/;/562:/0012.342/63*-. B/:.95/8469.0493A4183;4:42-4A:-/:/0012.34A-4 A/2 / 52:950: /<419 ==50.9 A/2 0/1;-: 9.3#-/63.3 56 / :9/7 :-/: A/2 8/53 46 %*%*% /=:.9 9.;52:9/:546 4= -. 9.27463.6:#74850. /=:.9 :-. 56C.2:5;/:546 -/C. =58.3 :-. 0-/9;.#2-..: /;/562: :-. /0012.3 42 /63 * =49 :-. /=49.2/534==.60.2
( 7.912/8 4= :-. :9/620957: 4= 046C.92/:546 <.:A..6 :-. 04B78/56/6: /63 :-. /0012.3 4* A-50- 52 7/9: 4= :-. 0-/9;.#2-..: A4183 ;4 :4 2-4A :-/: A-.6:-.04B78/56/6:-/3/7794/0-.3/0012.34* 56-.94==50.46*%*%*%:-./0012.34*-/33.B/63.3 /21B4=2*%% #=94B-5B:4A/9329.6.A/8=../632-. /824-/3/2219.3:-/:A5:-56%:4*3/?2-52A49@A588<. 346.6:-.2/53046C.92/:5465:52/824=4163:-/:2-.-/2 2:/:.3 :-/: 2-. /846; A5:- /0012.3 4 -/3 C525:.3 :-. .:948 16@ 4= :-. 04B78/56/6:"2 B4:-.9 ./985.9 -.9.=49. 5: 0/664: <. 2/53 :-/: :-.9. 52 /<2481:.8? 64
- 7 -
B/:.95/8/2/;/562::-.7.:5:546.9=497942.01:56;-.9=49:-. 0-/9;.#2-..:.34==.60. $ 6 :-. 0/2. 4=
:-. 46"<8. 179.B.419: /: 7/9/;9/7-4% -/2 4<2.9C.3 /2=4884A2
! " # $ %&'("
) ) ) " ) ") ) )
) ! 1 2023 SCC OnLine SC 379
- 8 -
# $ %&' ( )
" )
" *
' 63.9 :-. 05901B2:/60.2 /B 4= :-. 4756546 :-/: :-. :95/8 419: A/2 =188? >12:5=5.3 56 9.>.0:56; :-. /77850/:546 =58.3 <? :-. 7.:5:546.9 163.9 .0:546 **( 4= 9 2..@56; -.9 3520-/9;. 34 64: =563 /6? ;443 ;94163:4.6:.9:/56:-527.:5:5460049356;8?:-.=4884A56; 493.9
-.95B56/8.C525467.:5:54652
.,
'% &" !+
"
52:484)%