- 1 - ! "# !$ %! #&&'()*+ % !"# $ % & ' ! & % !"(' # )& !"# $ % & * ! #&' * !%#' * %' !#!!#"# ! "" #"# ) * + * Digitally signed by SHILPA R TENIHALLI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - #+ #"# * & * * ) * ** ! ,%#' !,!%#'%+' !!%#' !",+#+!%#'!"+%!' !," * +%!'%-'%.'+%#'%/' * * )& 0)&) !# % 0)&) ' 112.34 5# 67 -683 5#+ #"# -396.:3-34 ;< 76/3-.6:< 5=613 :>:657 >=>;2->96 ?5- :@3 5??3713. A276.@>;=3 2743- 31:657. ! ,%#' !,!%#'%+' !!%#' !", +# +!%#' !"+%!' -3>4 B6:@ 31:657 !," 5? @>->:6<><><>>7@6:>#"#+%?5-.@5-:C#"#+D'>74 2743- 31:657. +%!'%-'%.' +%#'%/' 5? 1@342=34 >.:3. >741@342=34-6;3.%-3/37:6575?:-516:63.'1:!, , %?5- .@5-: C % ' 1:' 6. ;3?5-3 :@6. 52-: 67 :@6. >AA3>= ?6=34 2743- 31:657 !%#' 5? % ' 1: B6:@ > A-><3- :5 .3: >.643 :@3 5-43- 4>:34 !#!!#"# A>..34 67 -=6.15! "" #"# ;< :@3 52-: 5? - 3 - 446:657>= 6.:-61: >74 3..657. )2493 >=>;2->96 >74 37=>-93:@3>AA3==>7:57-392=>-;>6= # 3>-4 =3>-734 1527.3= ?5- :@3 >AA3==>7: >74 =3>-734 69@ 52-: 5/3-7837: =3>43- >AA3>-679 ?5- -3.A57437:5!3.A57437:5#B@56..3-/3467:@3 8>::3-@>.-38>673427-3A-3.37:34;3?5-3?5-:@6.52-: + * 67 -683 5#+ #"# B>. -396.:3-34 ;< 76/3-.6:< 5=613 :>:657 >=>;2->96 6:< 676:6>==< ?5- :@3 5??3713. A276.@>;=3 2743- 31:657. !", !!%#' ! ,%#' !," !,!%#' !,!%+' +!%#' >74 +# 5? #"#+ >74 2743-31:657+%!'%-'%.'5? % '1:57:@3;>.6. 5? :@3 ?6-.: 67?5-8>:657 4>:34 #"!"#"# -3136/34 ?-58 )>9>43/6 B@5 6. :@3 B6?3 5? 4313>.34 @>74->E>7: >9>67.: 5273.@ >74 ?52- 5:@3-. @3 >AA3==>7: @3-367 B@5 6. :@3 85:@3- 5? >112.34 5! B>. >--><34 >. >112.34 5# 67 :@3 * 2-679 :@3 152-.3 5? 67/3.:69>:657 5? :@3 1>.3 :@3 >AA3==>7: @3-367 B>. >--3.:34 57 #!!"#"# >74 .2;.3F237:=< -38>7434 :5 G24616>= 12.:54< 7/3.:69>:657 5? :@3 1>.3 6. 158A=3:34 - 4 - >741@>-93.@33:@>.;337?6=34>6=>AA=61>:657?6=34;< :@3 >AA3==>7: ;3?5-3 :@3 G2-6.461:657>= 3..657. 52-: 67 -=6.15! "" #"# B>. -3G31:34 57 :@3 !#!!#"# @3-3?5-3.@36.;3?5-3:@6.52-: 3>-7341527.3= ?5- :@3>AA3==>7: .2;86:.:@>: >AA3==>7: 6. > =>4< >934 >;52: <3>-. >74 57=< >==39>:657>9>67.:@3-6.:@>:.@3@>4>..>2=:344313>.34 B6:@ @3- @>74. 7/3.:69>:657 6. 158A=3:34 >74 >115-4679=<@3A-><.:5>==5B:@3>AA3>= 3- 157:-> =3>-734 69@ 52-: 5/3-7837: =3>43- @>. 5AA5.34 :@3 A-><3- 8>43 67 :@3 >AA3>= >74 A-><34:546.86..:@3>AA3>= 3-2.>= 5? :@3 8>:3-6>= 57 -315-4 B52=4 95 :5 .@5B :@>: :@3-3 B>. .583 46.A2:3 ;3:B337 :@3 A>-:63. B6:@ -39>-4 :5 13-:>67 =>74 >74 57 #"!"#"# B@37 >112.34 5.! # >74 :@3 G2/376=3 >112.34 B@5 6. :@3 4>29@:3- 5? :@3 >AA3==>7: @3-367 B3-3 B5-E679 67 :@3 46.A2:34 =>74 4313>.34 @>74->E>7: 1>83 :@3-3 >74 - 5 - F23.:65734:@3>112.34A3-.57.:6.>==3934:@>:>112.34 5.! # >74 :@3 G2/376=3 >112.34 @>4 >;2.34 @>74->E>7:>74>=.5@>4>..>2=:34@68B6:@:@36-@>74. ::@3.>64:683 !">74!67:3-?3-34>74 @>74->E>7: @>4 -3:2-734 :5 @6. @52.3 >74 67?5-834 >;52: :@3 6716437: :5 @6. B6?3 ! B@5 6. :@3 ?6-.: 67?5-8>7: 67 :@3 A-3.37: 1>.3 @3-3>?:3- @>74->E>7: @>/679 ?5274 :@>: @6. 85;6=3 A@573 @>4 ?>==37 73>- :@3 =>746746.A2:3@3>74@6.B6?3 !@>4957373>-:@3 =>74 67 46.A2:3 ?5- :@3 A2-A5.3 5? .3>-1@679 :@3 85;6=3 A@573112.345!B@5B>.A-3.37:73>-:@3=>7467 46.A2:3 .33679 :@3 4313>.34 >74 @6. B6?3 5713 >9>67 15867973>-:@3A-5A3-:<6746.A2:3A61E342A>B55437 1=2;>74@>4>..>2=:34@>74->E>7:B6:@:@3.>8357@6. @3>4 . > -3.2=: 5? :@3 .>64 >..>2=: @>74->E>7: @>4 15==>A.34 :5 :@3 9-5274 >74 :@529@ @3 B>. 688346>:3=< .@6?:34:5>@5.A6:>=@3@>4.21128;34:5:@367G2-63.67 :@3 @5.A6:>= >74 B>. 431=>-34 >. 43>4 : 6. 67 :@6. ;>1E9-5274*B>.-396.:3-34>9>67.:5273.@>74?52- 5:@3-.7/3.:69>:6575?:@31>.36.158A=3:34>741@>-93 - 6 - .@33: @>. ;337 ?6=34 746.A2:34=< >==39>:657 5? >..>2=:679 4313>.34B6:@:@3 B55437 1=2;57 @6. @3>46. 57=<>.>9>67.:>112.345!>74>::@3.>64A567:5?:683 >AA3==>7: >112.345#B>.75:3/37A-3.37:>::@3.A5: @3 >AA3==>7: 6. > =>4< >934 >;52: <3>-. @>/679 75 1-6867>=>7:313437:. ( 743- :@3 16-128.:>713. >8 5? 5A67657 :@>: :@3A-><3-8>43;<:@3>AA3==>7:?5-9->7:5?-392=>-;>6= 7334.:5;3>7.B3-34>??6-8>:6/3=<115-4679=<?5==5B679 5-43-6.A>..34 @3>AA3>=6.>==5B34 @3 68A29734 5-43- A>..34 ;< :@3 52-: 5? 446:657>= 6.:-61: >74 3..657. )2493 >=>;2->96 67 -=6.15! "" #"#4>:34!#!!#"#6..3:>.643 @3 >AA3==>7: 6. 46-31:34 :5 ;3 37=>-934 57 ;>6= 67 -6835#+ #"#5?76/3-.6:<5=613:>:657>=>;2->96 6:<-396.:3-34?5-:@35??3713.A276.@>;=32743-31:657. - 7 - ! ,%#'!,!%#'%+'!!%#'!",+#+!%#'!"+%!'-3>4 B6:@ 31:657 !," 5? #"#+ >74 2743- 31:657. +%!'%-'%.'+%#'%/'5? % '1:A374679;3?5-3:@3 52-: 5? 446:657>= 6.:-61: >74 3..657. )2493 >=>;2->96.2;G31::5:@3?5==5B67915746:657. >'AA3==>7:.@>==3H312:3A3-.57>=;574?5->.28 5? .!""""" B6:@ :B5 .2-3:63. ?5- :@3 =6E3.28 :5 :@3 .>:6.?>1:657 5? :@3 G2-6.461:657>= 52-: ;'AA3==>7:.@>==>AA3>--392=>-=<57>==:@34>:3. 5?@3>-679;3?5-3:@3-6>=52-:27=3..:@3-6>= 52-:3H38A:.@3->AA3>->713?5-/>=64-3>.57. 1' AA3==>7:.@>==75:46-31:=<5-6746-31:=<:@-3>:37 5-:>8A3-B6:@:@3A-5.312:657B6:73..3. 4'AA3==>7: .@>== 75: 67/5=/3 67.686=>- 5??3713.67 ?2:2-3 ,( )$ %! * ! 6.:5!=5!(