Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 11962 (KAR)
MANIKANTH v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
CRL.P/201398/2024 · 2025-01-27
S Vishwajith Shetty
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 11962 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 11962 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "#
"
$%
#!!&! '# ! "
% (()*+(!!** +' %,- (()*+(!!** % (()*+(!!**
+
'
! " # $
%
Digitally signed by SHIVAKUMAR HIREMATH Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
" #
$
&#$
#
'$
(
)* #
&+ $ ,
, & ) & ! #$ * '!&) +
,-+
'
+ #
$
, ! " # ,$
( '
! +
"
#
$
&#$
#
'$
'
(
)* &
, ,
- 3 -
&+
& )& ! #$ '!&) + ,
' -
+
'
! (
' ., '
(
./
&
) ! '
& . )
0**& ! *!!&
" # ,$
- 4 -
( '
! +
" #
$
&#$
#
'$
' (
)* & ,
,
&+
& ) & ! #$ ' !&)
+
,
'
-
'
1, ',
- 5 -
#
1, ', $
! 223456
74) 87 !& 9:5 ;5<7:5 8=>4 73:8 >? 8=545 @58>8>7?4<>A563?65: 528>7?&7<:B>8=9@:9C5:87 D394= 8=5 5?8>:5 @:72556>?E4 94 9E9>?48 8=5F >? 7 )* @5?6>?E;5<7:58=573:87<>G>A,36E5 9?6 , =9=9@3: 96E>: 6>48:>28 9:>4>?E 738 7<:>F5 7&+ :5E>485:56;C =9=@3:7A>25 898>7?96E>:
<7: 7<<5?254 @3?>4=9;A5 3?65: 528>7? & ) & ! #$ * :
B !&) 7< 9?6 528>7?4 H + 7< 445?8>9A 7FF76>8>5428!)
59:68=5A59:?56273?45A<7:8=5@9:8>54
>?:>F5
7&+ B94:5E>485:56;C =9=@3:
7A>25 898>7?96E>:>?>8>9AAC<7:8=57<<5?254@3?>4=9;A5 3?65: 528>7?4& )& ! #$ *: B!&)7<9?6 528>7?4 H + 7< 445?8>9A 7FF76>8>54 28 !) #<7:
4=7:8 I28-$ 7? 8=5 ;94>4 7< <>:48 >?<7:F98>7? 69856 !! :525>G56<:7F7?5=55F9:9C9B=7>48=5
- 6 -
44>489?8>:5287:7<7769?6>G>A 3@@A>545@9:8F5?8 96E>:949E9>?487?5 =>G9@@9 79AA9@@99?678=5:4 & =5@7A>259<85:>?G548>E98>7?=9G5<>A562=9:E54=558 9E9>?48 !+ 9223456 @5:47?4 <7: 8=5 9<7:549>6 7<<5?254 =5<>:48>?<7:F9?8=55F9:9C9>49::9C56949223456 7!&>?8=52=9:E54=558223456
7487!9AA5E56AC =96 @3:2=9456 8=5 :>25 F59?8 <7: 3;A>2 >48:>;38>7? C485F<:7F9223456
7487*9?6=96487:568=549F5 >?8=5B9:5=7345;5A7?E>?E878=5F=5@7A>2563:>?E8=5 273:457<>?G548>E98>7?=9645>J568=549>6:>259AA5E56AC @3:2=9456 ;C 9223456
74 87 ! 9?6 487:56 >? 8=5>: B9:5=73459?68=5:59<85:=9G5<>A5692=9:E54=558<7:8=5 9<7:549>6 7<<5?254 9E9>?48 !+ 9223456 @5:47?4 5>?E 9EE:>5G56 ;C 8=5 49F5 9223456
74 87 ! 9:5 ;5<7:5 8=>473:8>?8=545@58>8>7?4
59:?56 273?45A <7: 9223456
7!& 43;F>84 8=98 9223456
7!& >4 8=5 @5:47? B=7=96 @:5@9:56 9 :5@7:8 9?643;F>88568=5<>:48>?<7:F98>7?;94567?B=>2=>4 :5E>485:56 >? :>F5
7&+ ? 8=5 @:545?8 2945
- 7 -
63:>?E8=5>?4@528>7?9223456
7!&=96<73?68=988=5:5 B9494=7:89E57<* ++&+D3>?89A47<:>25F59?8<7:
B=>2= B94 487:56 >? 8=5 B9:5=7345 7< 7< B=>2= 9223456
74!HB5:58=5234876>9?4543;F>848=98 5G5?>?8=527?<544>7?48985F5?87<9223456
74!H?7 9AA5E98>7? >4 F965 9E9>?48 8=5 @58>8>7?5:4 B=>2= B73A6 988:9288=52=9:E54=558567<<5?254 * 59:?56273?45A<7:9223456
7487!43;F>848=98 >8 >4 ?78 7?AC ;9456 7? 8=5 27?<544>7? 48985F5?8 7< 279223456 8=5C =9G5 ;55? 9::9C56 94 9223456 >?
8=5 >F@3E?56 2:>F>?9A @:72556>?E4 8=5 @7A>25 =9G5 ?78 27AA52856 9?C 27::7;7:98>G5 F985:>9A 94 9E9>?48 9223456 7487!63:>?E8=5273:457<>?G548>E98>7?9?6>?8=5 9;45?257<432=F985:>9A7?AC7?8=5;94>47<27?<544>7? 48985F5?87<2792234568=5@58>8>7?5:4 9223456
7487 !273A6?78=9G5;55?9::9C56949223456>?8=5@:545?8 2945543;F>848=988=5:5>4?7F985:>9A27AA52856;C8=5 @:745238>7?874=7B8=988=5:>25:527G5:56>?8=5@:545?8 2945 B94 F59?8 <7: 9?6 >? 8=5 9;45?25 7< 432=
- 8 -
F985:>9A@58>8>7?5:429??78;5@:74523856<7:8=59AA5E56 7<<5?254 + 5:27?8:9A59:?5666>8>7?9A 89853;A>2:7452387:
=947@@74568=5@58>8>7?543;F>848=989223456
7!& B94 =9?6 >? EA7G5 B>8= 78=5: 9223456 @5:47?4 >? 27FF>88>?E 8=5 9AA5E56 7<<5?254 9?6 7?AC 7? >?48:328>7?4 <:7F =>E=5: <<>25: =5 =96 27?632856 >?4@528>7? 7< 8=5 B9:5=7345 7? !! 9?6 43;F>8856 9 :5@7:8 ;9456 7? B=>2= >? :>F5
7&+ B94 :5E>485:56 3:>?E8=5273:457<>?G548>E98>7?9223456
74!H=9G5 27?<54456 9;738 8=5 F9??5: >? B=>2= 8=5 2:>F5 B94 27FF>8856=5459223456=9G54898569;7388=549A57< :>25 <:7F 8=5 B9:5=7345 87 9223456
74 87 * 9?6 9A47 9;738 8=5 @9CF5?8 F965 87 9223456
74!& 87 !+ B=7 9:5 8=5 7<<>2>9A4 7< 8=5 65@9:8F5?8 5 43;F>84 8=98 25:89>? @9CF5?84 9:5 5G5? F965 8=:73E= 9?K 8:9?4928>7?4 =7?5@5 582 9?6 ?525449:C F985:>9A4 9:5 27AA5285663:>?E8=5273:457<>?G548>E98>7?7:9@5:>76 7<F7:58=9?7?59?6=9A<C59:4@:>7:87:5E>48:98>7?7<8=5
- 9 -
8=5 :>25 F59?8 <7: B94 ;5>?E 2A9?6548>?5AC47A6 ;C 9223456
74! H 87 9223456
74 87 *<:7FB=7F 9223456
7487!=96@3:2=94568=5:>259?6487:56>? 8=5B9:5=73457<9223456
79?69223456
74!&87!+ B=7 9:5 7G5:?F5?8 45:G9?84 B5:5 @9>6 63:>?E 8=5 49A5 8:9?4928>7?4
5 43;F>84 8=98 >? 8=5 27?<544>7? 48985F5?8 7< 9223456
74+ H 8=5 :7A5 7< 9223456
74 87 ! =94 ;55?2A59:ACF5?8>7?569?68=5:>25B=>2=B94@3:2=9456 ;C 9223456
74 87 ! ;5A7?E>?E 87 B94 :527G5:56 <:7F8=5B9:5=73457<9223456
75<3:8=5:43;F>84 8=98 94 9E9>?48 9223456
7) 8=5:5 9:5 ) 29454 :5E>485:563?65:8=5@:7G>4>7?47<8=5289?69223456 74! 87!9:59AA=>4<9F>ACF5F;5:49?68=5C9AA=9G5 @A9C56 9? 928>G5 :7A5 >? 27FF>88>?E 8=5 2:>F5 9?6 8=5:5<7:5 8=5:5 >4 43<<>2>5?8 F985:>9A 87 @:7452385 9AA 8=5 9223456 <7: 8=5 2=9:E5 4=55856 7<<5?254 =5 :>25 B=>2= B94 F59?8 <7: B94 ;5>?E 2A9?6548>?5AC 8:9?4@7:856 <:7F 8=5 B9:5=7345 7< 8=5 776 9?6 >G>A 3@@A>54
- 10 -
5@9:8F5?8 9?6 47A6 87 @:>G985 @9:8>54 9?6 8=5:5;C 9223456@5:47?4B5:5F9K>?E3?A9B<3AE9>?=5:>25B94 ?7892839AAC:592=>?E87:59A;5?5<>2>9:>547<8=5 2=5F5 >?25 8=5 @7A>25 =9G5 27AA52856 43<<>2>5?8 F985:>9A 63:>?E 8=5 273:45 7< >?G548>E98>7? 87 @:7452385 8=5 9223456 @5:47?4 <7: 8=5 9AA5E56 7<<5?254 >8 >4 ?78 9 <>8 2945 87 >?85:<5:5227:6>?EAC=5@:9C4876>4F>448=5@58>8>7? ) =5F985:>9AF9659G9>A9;A5878=573:8B73A6E787 4=7B 8=98 9223456
7!& =96 89K5?
2=9:E5 94 5@38C >:5287: 7< 776 9?6 >G>A 3@@A>54 9?6 7?43F5: <<9>:4 5@9:8F5?89896E>:7?! 89@@59:48=987?AC 7?8=5>?48:328>7?4<:7F8=5=>E=5:7<<>25:49223456
7!& =96 >?4@52856 8=5 B9:5=7345 7< =9=@3: 7? !! 9?6 43;F>8856 9 :5@7:8 4 @5: 8=5 49>6 :5@7:8 8=5:5 B94 9 4=7:89E5 7< * ++&+ D3>?89A4 7< :>25 B=>2= B94 F59?8 <7: @3;A>2 6>48:>;38>7? 4C485F =5 F985:>9A 7? :527:6 B73A6 E7 87 4=7B 8=98 9223456
74! 9?6=9643;F>8856:5@7:8459:A>5:94><8=5:5B944872K7< :>25878=59<7:549>65L85?8;38>?8=5>?4@528>7?8=98B94
- 11 -
=5A67?!! ;C9223456
7!&8=54=7:89E57<:>25 878=55L85?87<* ++&+D3>?89A4B94?78569?6;94567? 432= :5@7:8 >? :>F5
7&+ B94 >?>8>9AAC :5E>485:56 9E9>?48 9223456
74! 9?6 9?6 78=5:4 3:>?E 8=5 273:45 7< >?G548>E98>7? 9223456
74! 9?6 =9G5 27?<54456 87 8=5 2:>F5 9?6 8=5C =9G5 489856 8=98 8=5C =96 47A6 8=5 9;7G5 49>6 5L85?8 7< :>25 87 9223456 74 87 * 9<85: :525>G>?E F7?5C <:7F 8=5F 223456 7=949A474898568=988=5F7?5C:525>G56;C=>FB94 @9>6 87 78=5: 7<<>2>9A4 7< 8=5 65@9:8F5?8 B=7 9:5 ?7B 9::9C56 94 9223456
74!& 87 !+ >? 8=5 2=9:E5 4=558 223456
74! 9?6 =9G5 489856 8=98 =3E5 9F73?8 B94 @9>6 878=5 9<7:549>6 9223456 7? 6><<5:5?8 69854 9?6 49>6 @9CF5?84 B5:5 9A47 F965 8=:73E= 9?K 8:9?4928>7? =7?5@5582 9?68=545@9CF5?84 9:5@:>F9<92>5 @:7G56 B>8=6723F5?84;C8=5@:745238>7? ! =5 F985:>9A 7? :527:6 B73A6 E7 87 4=7B 8=98 9223456
7) =96 @3:2=9456 8=5 9<7:549>6 :>25 <:7F 9223456
7* 8 9@@59:4 8=98 8=5 :>25 B=>2= B94
- 12 -
@3:2=9456;C9223456
7)9?6=>478=5:<9F>ACF5F;5:4 B=79:59::9C56949223456
74! 87!B5:59AA4872K56 >? 8=5 B9:5=7345 ;5A7?E>?E 87 9223456
7 B=7 >49A47 9?78=5::5A98>G57<9223456
7)8>4?78>?6>4@3858=98 8=5 @:745238>7? 63:>?E 8=5 273:45 7< >?G548>E98>7? =94 45>J56 8=5 :>25 F59?8 <7: @3;A>2 6>48:>;38>7? 4C485F 9AA5E56AC47A6;C9223456
74!9?6<:7F8=5B9:5=7345 7<9223456
7223456
7+% =9:9?3. =9:9?9@@9 B=7>48=55F@A7C55B7:K>?EB>8=9223456
7487!=94 489856 >? =>4 27?<544>7? 48985F5?8 9;738 8=5 :7A5 7< 9223456
74 87 ! >? 8=5 9AA5E56 2:>F5 5 =94 9A47 489856 8=98 98 8=5 >?48:328>7?4 7< 8=5 9<7:549>6 9223456 B=7 9:5 =>4 5F@A7C5:4 8=5 :>25 B94 8:9?4@7:856 9?6 4=><856878=5B9:5=73457<9223456
7<:7FB=5:58=5 @:745238>7? =96 45>J56 8=5 :>25 63:>?E 8=5 273:45 7< >?G548>E98>7? 223456
7* >? =>4 27?<544>7? 48985F5?8 69856 !!! =94 489856 8=98 8=5 :>25 B=>2= B94 @3:2=9456;C=>F>AA5E9AAC<:7F9223456
74!9?6B94 ;5>?E47A6;C=>F879223456
7B=7>48=57B?5:7<8=5 B9:5=7345<:7FB=5:58=5@7A>25=9G545>J568=5:>255
- 13 -
=94498568=988=5:>25B94;5>?E@3:2=9456;C=>F<:7F 9223456
74! 9?6 98 9 A7B5: @:>25 9?68=5:59<85:47A6 ;C=>F879223456
7989=>E=5:@:>259?68=5:5;C=5 =96F9653?A9B<3AE9>?7<A9K=4:3@554 !! =5@7A>2563:>?E8=5273:457<>?G548>E98>7?=9G5?78 7?AC45>J568=5:>25<:7F8=5B9:5=73457<9223456
7 B=>2= B94 @3:2=9456 ;C 9223456
74 87 * 9?6 8=5:59<85: 47A6 87 9223456
74 87 ! ;38 9A47 =9G5 45>J56 8=5 49A5 @:725564 <:7F 8=5 9<7:549>6 9223456 B=>2=:3?487A9K=47<:3@554=5:>25B=>2=B94F59?8 87 8=5 @77: 9?6 ?556C @57@A5 8=:73E= @3;A>2 6>48:>;38>7? 4C485F =94 ;55?
47A6 ;C >84 234876>9?4 87 3?42:3@3A734 5A5F5?84A>K59223456
7487!9?6<7:8=549>6>AA5E9A 928>G>8>54 9223456
74!& 87 !+ B=7 9:5 7G5:?F5?8 45:G9?84 =9G5 =5A@56 8=5F 9?6 =9G5 :525>G56 =3E5 9F73?8 94 E:98><>298>7? 9?6 25:89>? @9CF5?84 87B9:64 E:98><>298>7? 87 8=545 9223456 B94 F965 8=:73E= 9?K 8:9?4928>7?4 =7?5@5 582 8 >4 3?65: 8=545 2>:23F489?254 8=5 7<<5?25 @3?>4=9;A5 3?65: 528>7? & )
- 14 -
7<=94;55?>?G7K56>?8=52=9:E54=5589?68=549>6 7<<5?25 >4 @3?>4=9;A5 B>8= A><5 >F@:>47?F5?8 59:?56 =94 ;:73E=8 87 8=5 ?78>25 7< 8=>4 73:8 8=98 94 9E9>?489223456
7)8=5:59:5)4>F>A9:29454B=>2=9:5 @5?6>?E 27?4>65:98>7? 9?6 9223456
7 9?6 9223456 74! 87!9:58=52A745:5A98>G547<9223456
7)B=7 =9G5 9A47 >?G7AG56 8=5F45AG54 >? 27FF>88>?E 8=5 2:>F5 =5 F985:>9A 7? :527:6 F9K54 738 9 2945 9E9>?489AA8=59223456@5:47?49?68=5:5<7:58=5:5>4?7 427@5<7:8=>473:887>?85:<5:5B>8=8=549F59?6D394= 8=5>F@3E?562:>F>?9A@:72556>?E494@:9C56<7:>?8=545 @58>8>7?4
! 59:?56 273?45A <7: 8=5 @58>8>7?5:4 =9G5 9A47 43;F>8856 8=98 3?A544 8=5 @:745238>7? @:7G>654 F985:>9A 9A7?E B>8= 2=9:E5 4=558 8=98 8=5 :>25 B=>2= B94 >AA5E9AAC 47A6 8:9?4@7:856 9?6 487:56 >? 8=5 @:>G985 B9:5=7345 B=>2= B94 43;45D35?8AC 45>J56 ;C 8=5@7A>25 B94 F59?8 <7: 8=5 @3:@745 7< @3;A>2 6>48:>;38>7? 4C485F 9?6 >? 8=5 9;45?25 7< 9?C 25:8><>2985 87 8=5 49>6 5<<528 <:7F 8=5
- 15 -
27F@585?8 938=7:>8C ?7 @:745238>7? <7: 8=5 7<<5?254 @3?>4=9;A5 3?65: 528>7?4 9?6+7< 8=5 28 29? ;5 >?>8>9856 9E9>?48 8=5 9223456 @5:47?4 =73E= 432= 9 43;F>44>7?>4F965;CA59:?56273?45A<7:8=5@58>8>7?5:4 8=5C=9G5<9>A5687@A9259?C?525449:CF985:>9A>?43@@7:8 7< 8=>4 27?85?8>7? 3:E56 ;C 8=5F =5 :5A5G9?8 4898385 6754 ?78 @:7G>65 <7: 9?C 432= :5D3>:5F5?8 9?6 >? 8=5 9;45?257< 8=5 49F5 49>6 27?85?8>7? :9>456 7? ;5=9A<7< 8=5 @58>8>7?5:4 29??78 ;5 9@@:52>9856 8 >4 ?556A544 87 48985 8=98 >8 >4 <7: 8=5 @:745238>7? 87 @:7G5 >84 2=9:E54 9E9>?488=59223456@5:47?463:>?E8=5273:457<8:>9A9?6 988=>4489E58=5@:745238>7?29??78;594K5687@:76325 9AA432=F985:>9A87@:7G5>842=9:E549E9>?488=59223456 <7: 8=5 2=9:E5 4=55856 7<<5?254 =>4 273:8 >4 ?78 5L@5285687=7A69F>?>8:>9A988=>4489E5<8=52=9:E5 4=558F985:>9AF9K547389@:>F9<92>529459E9>?489AA8=5 9223456@5:47?487;58:>56<7:8=59AA5E567<<5?2548=>4 73:8 29??78 5L5:2>45 >84 @7B5:4 3?65: 528>7? & 7< :
- 16 -
! =5 7?-;5A 3@:5F5 3:8 >? 8=5 2945 7<
!"#!=947;45:G568=98>8>4 8:>85 A9B 8=98 8=5 >E= 73:8 29??78 5F;9:K 3@7? 8=5 9@@:52>98>7?7<5G>65?25B=>A527?4>65:>?E8=5@58>8>7?<>A56 3?65: 528>7? & 7< : <7: D394=>?E 8=5 2:>F>?9A @:72556>?E4 8 >4 2A59: <:7F 8=5 A9B A9>6 67B?
;C 8=>4 73:88=98><9@:>F9<92>52945>4F9657386>42A74>?E8=5 >?E:56>5?847<8=57<<5?259AA5E569E9>?488=592234568=5 73:829??78D394=92:>F>?9A@:72556>?E4 !& ?8=529457<#"$# %#"&"
'()& !"#8=57?-;A5 3@:5F53:898 @9:9E:9@=
7! =947;45:G5694<7AA7B4
! 1 (2020) 3 SCC 317 2 2023 SCC OnLine SC 379
- 17 -
" # $ %&'
(
"
) )
) " )
" ) ) )
) ! # $ %&'
(
)
"
)
" * ! >?25 8=5 @:745238>7? =94 A9>6 2=9:E5 4=558 9E9>?48 8=59223456>?8=5@:545?829459<85:27AA528>?E?525449:C F985:>9AB=>2=27::7;7:9854B>8=8=527?<544>7?48985F5?8
- 18 -
7<8=52792234569F7<8=57@>?>7?8=988=5:5>49@:>F9 <92>5 2945 9E9>?48 8=5 9223456 @5:47?4 <7: 8=5 2=9:E5 4=55856 7<<5?254 9?6 8=5:5<7:5 >8 >4 ?78 9 <>8 2945 <7:
5L5:2>4>?E 8=5 >?=5:5?8 @7B5:4 3?65: 528>7? & 7< :227:6>?EAC<7AA7B>?E7:65:>4@94456
:>F>?9A@58>8>7?49:56>4F>4456
!.+
(!&! '# ! "* #
>48
7! A
7*