Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 11959 (KAR)
GENERAL LIBRARY v. THE COMMISSIONER
WP/203031/2023 · 2025-01-23
R Nataraj
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 11959 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 11959 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"!#
$%" "
& '
! " #
$
! " #
$
%
& ' (" #"#
)
**
+(
$
,
Digitally signed by SACHIN Location: High Court Of Karnataka
- 2 -
-./.010123.4-567-588.39.:532017.166;.:<=0-. 4.6/23:.30 ;3:.4 .70123 (" #"># 2? 0-. *543505@5 ;3171/58101.670 +("-.37.?240-4.?.44.:0256A702? +(B# :.C53:139 544.546 2? /42/.40= 05D 58239 E10- 130.4.60?240-./.412:02F(
-. /.010123.4 7230.3:6 0-50 10 16 5 6271.0= 4.9160.4.:;3:.40-.*543505@5271.01.6.916045012370 +53:1613>28>.:13/-18530-42/175701>101.6<=4;33139 581<454=?240-.;6.2?0-.9.3.458/;<8175/540?42C20-.4 <;613.66-.4.6/23:.30166;.:532017.020-./.010123.4 ;3:.4 .70123 (" #"># 2? 0-. 70 2? +( :.C53:139 544.5462?/42/.40=05D?240-./.412:02F( 5C2;30139 02 5 6;C 2? 6 +% ' -. /.010123.4 7230.3:60-500-.4.6/23:.30-5:0-4.50.3.:02827@:2E3 0-. 81<454= 1? 10 :1: 320 /5= 0-. 05D :.C53:.: -. /.010123.4 16 0-.4.?24. <.?24. 0-16 2;40 7-588.39139 0-. 32017.166;.:<=0-.4.6/23:.30
- 3 -
F -.8.543.:72;36.8?240-./.010123.47230.3:6 0-50 532017. ;3:.4 .70123 (" #"># 2? 0-. 70 2? +( 753 <. 166;.: 238= 5?0.4 72C/81537. 2? 0-. /427.:;4. 7230.C/850.: ;3:.4 .70123 2? 0-. 70 2? +( . 7230.3:6 0-50 0-. 4.6/23:.30 E56 <2;3: 02 ?1460 166;. 5
32017. :.C53:139 05D 94530139 F :5=6 01C. 02 0-. /.010123.4 02 4.6/23: 53: 0-.4.5?0.4 72361:.4 0-. 2<G.701236 ?18.: <= 0-. /.010123.4 53: /566 5//42/4150. 24:.46E10-13:5=6-.4.6/23:.30E10-2;072C/8=139 0-.5?24.651:/427.:;4.-56604519-05E5=851:5:.C53:
?24 5 6;C 2? 6 +% ' E10-2;0 723:;70139 5 6/20 136/.70123 -. /.010123.4 16 0-.4.?24. <.?24. 0-16 2;40 7-588.391390-.651:32017. ( .4 723045 0-. 4.6/23:.30 -56 ?18.: 106 6050.C.302?2<G.7012367230.3:1390-500-./.010123.4-56 0-.4.C.:=2?535//.58;3:.4.70123 2?0-.702? +( 53: 0-.4.?24. 10 753320 5//4257- 0-16 2;40 0 16 5862 7230.3:.: 0-50 0-. /.010123.4 16 4;33139 72CC.47158 6-2/653:5/;<81781<454=53:0-.4.?24.0-.5701>10=2?0-. - 4 -
/.010123.4 16 320 ?;88= /-18530-42/17 0 :.31.: 0-50 0-. 815<1810= 02 /5= 05D E56 :.0.4C13.: E10-2;0 723:;70139 5 6/20 136/.70123 0 7851C.:0-50 5?0.4 0-.:.C53:32017. E56166;.:?;882//240;310=E56/42>1:.:02/5=0-.05D 07851C.:0-500-./.010123.4-56/51:/5402?0-.5C2;30 :.C53:.: 53: 0-.4.?24. 753320 32E 7-588.39. 0-. :.C53:
-. 8.543.: 72;36.8 ?24 0-. 4.6/23:.30 4.10.450.:0-.5<2>.7230.301236
-5>.72361:.4.:0-.6;<C1661236C5:.<=0-. 8.543.:72;36.8?240-./.010123.453:0-.8.543.:72;36.8 ?240-.4.6/23:.30
% /.4;658 2? .70123 (" #"># 2? 0-. 70 2? +( 6-2E6 0-50 0-. 4.6/23:.30 16 .30108.: 02 C5@. 5 :.C53:2?0-./42/.40=05D58239E10-130.4.602E.>.4 0-./427.:;4.2?:.0.4C131390-./42/.40= 05D /5=5<8.16 7230513.:13.70123 2?0-.702? +(53:?244.5:= 4.?.4.37.0-.65C.16.D04570.:<.82E
- 5 -
! "
! "
"
# $
"
% &
'
())
- 6 -
* )
! "
"
+)
,
,
%
"
! "
"
'
,
"
"
- 7 -
- . /'
*
+"
! "
"
"
0
'
'
' /
'
! 12
"
3
! "
"
- 8 -
*
+ 42
! "
"
3
'
'
"
' 3
5 2
"
/'
'
6 )
'
'
'
'
7
3>1.E2?.70123 2?702?
+(E-.4.>.4 05D16320/51:24E42398=/51:0-.4.6/23:.3016<2;3:02
- 9 -
?1460 136/.70 0-. /42/.40= 53: C5@. 53 566.66C.30 53:
?24E54: 10 02 0-. 2E3.4 02 C5@. 0-. /5=C.30 3 2//240;310= 6-2;8: <. 94530.: 02 0-. 2E3.4 02 ?18. -16 2<G.701236 53: 5?0.4 72361:.4139 0-. 2<G.701236 53 24:.4 72;8: <. /566.: :.0.4C13139 0-. /42/.40= 05D /5=5<8. 58239E10-130.4.601?53=-.1C/;93.:32017.:2.6320 6-2E0-500-./427.:;4.7230.C/850.:;3:.4.70123 2?0-.702? +(E56?2882E.:-.4.?24.0-.1C/;93.: 32017.753320<.6;60513.:5610163201357724:537.E10- 0-./42>1612367230513.:13.70123 2?0-.702? +( 30-50>1.E2?0-.C500.40-16E410/.010123:.6.4>.602<. 5882E.: 13 /540 53: 0-. 1C/;93.: 32017. 166;.: <= 0-. 4.6/23:.3016815<8.02<.H;56-.:
+ .37.0-.?2882E139
"1# -.E410/.01012316
"11# -. 1C/;93.:
32017. 166;.: <= 0-. 4.6/23:.305033.D;4.I16H;56-.:
"111# 2E.>.4 81<.40= 16 4.6.4>.: 02 0-. 4.6/23:.30 02 05@. 2;0 /427..:1396 13
- 10 -
57724:537. E10- .70123
2? 0-. *543505@5 ;3171/58101.6 70 +( E10-13 0-4.. C230-6 ?42C 0-. :50. 2? 4.7.1/0 2? 5 7.401?1.:72/=2?0-164:.4
"1># -. 4.81.? 62;9-0 ?24 <= 0-. /.010123.4 02 .D.C/0 10 ?42C /5=C.30 2? 05D ;3:.4 0-. *543505@5 ;3171/58101.6 70 +( 16 @./0 2/.3 02 <. 72361:.4.: 13 53 5//42/4150. /427..:139
"># 3= 5C2;30 /51: <= 0-. /.010123.4 6-588 <. 5//42/4150.: <=0-.4.6/23:.30 02E54:6 0-. /42/.40=05D/5=5<8.<=0-./.010123.4
3 >1.E 2? :16/2658 2? 0-. /.010123 /.3:139 61?53=:23206;4>1>.?2472361:.45012353:0-.65C. 6053::16/26.:2?? ()
&"'
"
1602 82