- 1 - ! "#" $ %# & '# " % ()*+,-* ,. ' ! " # $ % $ & %' & ( ! "%% $ # Digitally signed by SHILPA R TENIHALLI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - $) $ " # ) $ ' $ &*& " $ % % &# $ $ + , $ $$ *"#"%# ) "# ) ")# $ &) ' * $ $ $ % - $$ ' )" #"'# )"#"# )"#"# $ " $ # % $ '% % .%, ', " .%, ',# //0123 45 62/478 712 9&*& 625345: ;2<9=2 >?2 90=> 9< 334>49578 41>=4/> 753 2114951 ,03:2 437= 14>>45: 7> 717@7A78B75 7=4145: 90> =4C2 9 & =2:41>2=23 ;B %7557 A?2884 6984/2 1>7>495 437=<9=>?29<<25/2160541?7;820532=2/>4951*"#"C# ) "# ) ")# 9< ?7=7>4B7 B7B7 75?4>7 &) "<9= 1?9=>D+#2/>4951*7539< =9>2/>4959< ?483=25 <=9C 2E078 <<25/21 /> & "<9= 1?9=> D />+# 753 2/>4951 )" #"F# )"#"@# 753 )"#"@7# 9< /?230823 - 3 - 71>21 753 /?230823 =4;21 " =2@25>495 9< >=9/4>421# C253C25>488& 41;2<9=2>?41 90=>0532=2/>495 )9<?7=7>4B77:7=4A0=7A1?775?4>2&)122A45: =2:087=;748 27=3 827=523 /905128 <9= >?2 62>4>4952= 753 827=523 4:? 90=> 9@2=5C25> 82732= <9= =21695325> 9 21695325>9F?94112=@2345>?2C7>>2=?71 =2C7452305=26=2125>23;2<9=2>?41 90=> ) $ 45 =4C2 9 & F71 =2:41>2=23 ;B %7557 A?2884 6984/2 1>7>495 437= 7:7451> >?2 62>4>4952= ?2=245 <9=>?27<9=217439<<25/21 95 >?2 ;7141 9< >?2 <4=1> 45<9=C7>495 37>23 &&& =2/24@23 <=9C =21695325> 9F?9 41 >?2C9>?2=9<>?2 @4/>4C :4=8 7882:238B7:23 7;90> G B27=1 C95>?1 0=45: >?2 /90=12 9< 45@21>4:7>4959<>?2/71262>4>4952=?2=245F717==21>2395 &&& 5@21>4:7>495 9< >?2 /712 41 /9C682>23 753 /?7=:21?22>?71;225<48237:7451>>?262>4>4952=<9=>?2 7<9=21743 9<<25/21 ?2 ;748 76684/7>495 <4823 ;B >?2 62>4>4952= ;2<9=2 >?2 H0=4134/>49578 2114951 90=> 45 - 4 - 62/478 712 9&*& F71 =2H2/>23 95 && ?2=2<9=262>4>4952=41;2<9=2>?41 90=> 27=523 /905128 <9= >?2 62>4>4952= ?7@45: =24>2=7>23>?2:=905310=:2345>?262>4>49510;C4>>23>?7> >?2 @4/>4C :4=8 ?71 59> C732 75B 7882:7>4951 7:7451> >?2 62>4>4952=45?2=1>7>2C25>=2/9=3230532=2/>495 *9< = 210;C4>1>?7>7895:F4>?/?7=:21?22>C234/78 2E7C457>495=269=>9<>?2@4/>4C:4=841781959>6=930/23 25/2?26=7B1>97889F>?262>4>495 2= /95>=7 827=523 4:? 90=> 9@2=5C25> 82732= F?9 9669123 >?2 ;748 62>4>495 3921 59> 34160>2 >?210;C411495C732;B827=523/905128<9=>?262>4>4952= ?2 10;C4>1 >?7> >?2 39/>9= 45 ?41 751F2= >9 >?2 I021>495574=2 ?71 1>7>23 >?7> ?BC25 9< >?2 @4/>4C :4=8 41 59>45>7/>//9=345:8B1?26=7B1>9341C411>?262>4>495 * %7>2=478 95 =2/9=3 F9083 :9 >9 1?9F >?7> $ ?71;225=2:41>2=237:7451>>?262>4>4952=95>?2;71419< >?2 <4=1> 45<9=C7>495 =2/24@23 <=9C >?2 C9>?2= 9< >?2 - 5 - @4/>4C :4=8 0=45: >?2 /90=12 9< 45@21>4:7>495 62>4>4952= F717==21>2395&&&5@21>4:7>4959<>?2/71241 /9C682>23753/?7=:21?22>?71;225<4823>7>2C25>9< >?2@4/>4C:4=80532=2/>495 *9< = F71=2/9=323 ;B>?2H0=4134/>49578%7:41>=7>295&*&&?2@4/>4C :4=8 ?71 59> C732 75B 7882:7>4951 7:7451> >?2 62>4>4952= F?4/? F9083 6=4C7 <7/42 7>>=7/> >?2 7882:23 9<<25/21 7:7451>>?262>4>4952=?2C234/782E7C457>495=269=>9< >?2@4/>4C:4=84159>67=>9<>?2/?7=:21?22><482345>?2 6=2125> /712 534160>238B 62>4>4952= ?71 59 9>?2= /=4C4578 75>2/2325>1 5@21>4:7>495 9< >?2 /712 41 /9C682>23753/?7=:21?22>?71;225<4823 G 532= >?2 /4=/0C1>75/21 F4>?90> 2E6=21145: 75B 9645495 95 >?2 C2=4>1 753 32C2=4>1 9< >?2 /712 62>4>4952=+1 6=7B2= <9= :=75> 9< =2:087= ;748 41 =2I04=23 >9 ;2751F2=237<<4=C7>4@28B//9=345:8B6=9/223>96711 >?2<9889F45: ?262>4>495417889F23 - 6 - ?2 62>4>4952= 41 34=2/>23 >9 ;2 2587=:23 95 ;748 45 62/478 712 9&*& 7=4145: 90> 9< =4C2 9 & 9< %7557 A?2884 984/2 >7>495 437= =2:41>2=23 <9= >?2 9<<25/21 60541?7;82 0532= 2/>4951 *"#"C#) "#) ")#9<&)2/>4951*753 9< /> 753 2/>4951 )" #"F# )"#"@# 753 )"#"@7# 9< /?230823 71>21 753 /?230823 =4;21 " =2@25>495 9< >=9/4>421# C253C25> 488 & 625345: 95 >?2 <482 9< 827=523 334>49578 41>=4/> 753 2114951 ,03:2437=10;H2/>>9>?2<9889F45:/9534>4951 7# 2>4>4952=1?7882E2/0>262=19578;953<9=7 10C 9< 1 &&&&&( F4>? >F9 10=2>421 <9= >?2 84A210C >9 >?2 17>41<7/>495 9< >?2 H0=4134/>49578 90=>J ;# 2>4>4952= 1?788 76627= =2:087=8B 95 788 >?2 37>219<?27=45:;2<9=2>?2=478 90=>058211>?2 =478 90=> 2E2C6>1 ?41 76627=75/2 <9= @7843 =271951J /# 2>4>4952= 1?788 59> 34=2/>8B 9= 4534=2/>8B >?=27>25 9= >7C62= F4>? >?2 6=912/0>495 F4>521121J - 7 - 3# 2>4>4952= 1?788 59> 45@98@2 45 14C487= 9<<25/2145<0>0=2J 2# 2>4>4952=1?78859>827@2>?2H0=4134/>4959< >?2 =478 90=> F4>?90> 62=C411495 9< >?2 1743 90=> 05>48 >?2 /712 =2:41>2=23 7:7451> ?4C 41 341691239<< /- * & '# ", # 41>9 89