Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 11944 (KAR)
SIKANDAR PATEL v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA AND ORS
WP/203502/2023 · 2025-01-28
R Nataraj
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 11944 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 11944 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "#"$
%&# #
' ( )
!"###
$
!"%"$#$
&
!"%"$#$
'
&
!"%"$#$
( &)
'
Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: High Court Of Karnataka
- 2 -
$$ $$*
+
$$#,$#$&
$
,
$#$!$$ -! $%#$#$$ & ./ -! 01
2(
(
34 546.6.7/48 39: ;39<<4/=4> 9/ 78>48 59::4> ?@ 84:57/>4/6 7& ./ 9 587;44>./= ?498./= 7
>964> $%#$#$$ A.<4> B/>48 4;6.7/&$7A63498/969C99/>4D4/B4;6,' A78 :3786 1634 ;6 7A ,'1 9/> 634 78>48 59::4> ?@ 84:57/>4/6 7$ ?498./= 7 ,
$#$!$$ >964> $$#,$#$& ./ 9 84D.:.7/ 546.6.7/ A.<4> B/>48 4;6.7/ &&7A634;67A,' $ . 34 546.6.7/48 .: 634 59648/9< B/;<4 7A 84:57/>4/6 7' 34 546.6.7/48 ;<9.E: 6396 63484 F9: 9
- 3 -
5986.6.7/ ?46F44/ 3.: A96348 9/> 3.: A.D4 ?876348: 7/ &#,,% ./ 648E: 7A F3.;3 634 <9/> ?498./= @7#
E49:B8./= 9;84 & =B/69: F9: 9<<7664> 67 634 :3984 7A 634 546.6.7/481: A96348 34 A96348 7A 634 546.6.7/48677C57::4::.7/7A634:9.>9;84&=B/69:9/> ./.6.964>587;44>./=:A78EB696./=3.:/9E4./63484D4/B4 84;78>:?9:4>7/6345986.6.7/ 34EB696.7/587;44>./=:
F484 ./.6.964> 9/> 634 /76.;4 7A 634 EB696.7/ F9:
5B?<.:34> 9/> 9: /7!7?G4;6.7/ F9: 84;4.D4> ?@ 634 84D4/B4 ./:54;678 634 EB696.7/ F9: 9;;4564> 9/> 634 /9E4 7A 634 A96348 7A 634 546.6.7/48 F9: 4/6484> ./ 634 84D4/B484;78>:./634@498,%,.:/9E4F9:4/6484> ./ 634 84D4/B4 84;78>: A87E 634/ 7/ 4 <9648 >.4> 7/ $%#"$##$9/>634/9E47A634546.6.7/48F9:4/6484>./ 634 84D4/B4 84;78>: 7/ $#%$##$ 9/> 634 84D4/B4 84;78>:F484689/:A4884>67634/9E47A634546.6.7/48 ..
34 546.6.7/48 ;7/64/>: 6396 84:57/>4/6 7' ;39<<4/=4>634EB696.7/587;44>./=:./.6.964>./634/9E4 7A 3.: A96348 ?@ A.<./= 9/ 95549< B/>48 4;6.7/ &$ 7A
- 4 -
634;67A,'./634@498$#$4:57/>4/67&59::4> 9/ 78>48 7/ $%#$#$$ 37<>./= 6396 634 /9E4 7A 634 A963487A634546.6.7/48F9:4/6484>./63484D4/B484;78>: ?9:4>7/9/B/84=.:6484>5986.6.7/9/>63484A784:469:.>4 634EB696.7/9:F4<<9:63484D4/B44/68.4:./634/9E47A 634 A96348 7A 634 546.6.7/48 3.: F9: ;39<<4/=4> ?@ 634 546.6.7/48./984D.:.7/546.6.7/B/>484;6.7/&&7A634 ;67A,'F3.;3677F9:>.:E.::4>7/634:9E4=87B/> 4./=9==8.4D4>?@634:9.>78>48634546.6.7/48.:?4A784 63.:7B86 &
34<498/4>;7B/:4<A78634546.6.7/48;7/64/>: 6396634A963487A84:57/>4/67'F37F9:58.D@67634 5986.6.7/ >.> /76 ;39<<4/=4 634 84D4/B4 84;78>: 9/> 634 EB696.7/A87E634@498,%%!%,6.<<634@498$###!$4 63484A784 ;7/64/>: 6396 84:57/>4/6 7' >74: /76 39D4 9/@8.=3667/7F;7/64/>63966345986.6.7/>44>F9:/76 84=.:6484> 9/> 63484A784 634 84D4/B4 4/68.4: ?9:4> 7/ :B;3B/84=.:6484>5986.6.7/39>67?484D48:4>4AB86348 ;7/64/>: 6396 84:57/>4/6 7' >.> /76 4D4/ A.<4 9/
- 5 -
955<.;96.7/ A78 ;7/>7/96.7/ 7A >4<9@ ./ A.<./= 634 95549< 9/>/7849:7/:F484E4/6.7/4>9:67F3@634>4<9@39> 67?4;7/>7/4>4:B?E.6:639684:57/>4/67&F.637B6 4D4/;7/>7/./=634>4<9@39>4/64869./4>63495549<9/> :469:.>46344/68.4:6396F484?87B=369?7B6./634@498 ,%%!%, 4 ;7/64/>: 6396 .A 84:57/>4/6 7' F9:
./6484:64> 67 84D48:4 634 84D4/B4 4/68.4: 7/ 634 =87B/> 63966345986.6.7/F9:/7684=.:6484>34F9:?7B/>67=7 67 634 .D.< 7B86 9/> 7?69./ 9 >4;<9896.7/ 6396 34 F9: ./6484:64> ./ 634 5875486@ 4 ;7/64/>: 6396 84:57/>4/6 7:$9/>&;7EE.664>9/48878./>.84;6./=634546.6.7/48 67955879;3634.D.<7B86 ' <498/4>;7B/:4<A7884:57/>4/67' :B?E.6:6396634/9E47A634A963487A634546.6.7/48F9: 4/6484>./63484D4/B484;78>:?9:4>7/9/B/84=.:6484> 5986.6.7/4;7/64/>:639684:57/>4/67&F9:GB:6.A.4> ./37<>./=6396/7:B;34/68.4:;9/?4E9>4?9:4>7/:B;3 B/84=.:6484>>7;BE4/6:/:B557867A63.:;7/64/6.7/34 84<.4> B57/ 634 GB>=E4/6 7A 9 7!78>./964 4/;3 7A 63.:
- 6 -
7B86 ./ 634 ;9:4 7A
3B: 34 ;7/64/>: 6396 634 .E5B=/4> 78>48 59::4> ?@ 84:57/>4/67&9/>;7/A.8E4>?@84:57/>4/67$.:GB:6 9/> 587548 4 9<:7 ;7/64/>: 6396 634 <9/> ./ HB4:6.7/ :677>./634/9E47AA963487A84:57/>4/67'?4A784634 EB696.7/587;44>./=:9/>63484A784./6349?:4/;47A9/@ >7;BE4/6:67:37F6396634A963487A84:57/>4/67'39> ;7/D4@4> .6 67 634 A96348 7A 634 546.6.7/48 634 84D4/B4 84;78>:;7B<>/7639D4?44/?87B=369?7B6
" 498/4> >>.6.7/9< 7D48/E4/6 >D7;964 9<:7 :B557864> 634 ;7/64/6.7/: 7A <498/4> ;7B/:4< A78 84:57/>4/67'
39D4;7/:.>484>634:B?E.::.7/:E9>4?@634 <498/4>;7B/:4<A78634546.6.7/489/>634<498/4>;7B/:4< A78 84:57/>4/6 7' 9/> <498/4> >>.6.7/9< 7D48/E4/6 >D7;964955498./=A7884:57/>4/67:67&
!
- 7 -
*
34587;44>./=:F484./.6.964>?@634A963487A 634546.6.7/48674/6483.:/9E4./84:54;67A<9/>?498./= @7#
9 E49:B8./= # 9;84 #& =B/69: 34 6769< 4I64/6 7A <9/> ./ @7#
9 F9: #$ 9;84 #* =B/69:
34 A96348 7A 634 546.6.7/48 ;<9.E4> 6396 63.: # 9;84 #& =B/69:7A<9/>A4<<673.::39849695986.6.7/?46F44/3.E 9/> 3.: ?876348:
34 /76.;4 7A 634 EB696.7/ F9: 5B?<.:34> 34A963487A84:57/>4/67'>.>/767?G4;667 634689/:A487A634C9639?9:4>7/6345986.6.7/ 34A96348 7A84:57/>4/67'9<:7>.>/7689.:49/@HB4:6.7/9/>>.> /76;39<<4/=4634EB696.7/587;44>./=:6396F9:./.6.964> 67 4/648 634 /9E4 7A 634 A96348 7A 634 546.6.7/48 ./ 634 84D4/B4 84;78>: A87E &$,%% 6.<< 634 @498 $#$ 34 A96348 7A 84:57/>4/6 7' .: :6964> 67 39D4 4I5.84> 7/ &#"$##$ 3484A784 634 84:57/>4/6 7' ;7B<> /76 39D4;39<<4/=4>63484D4/B44/68.4:7/6349::486.7/6396 63484 F9: /7 5986.6.7/ >44> ?46F44/ 3.: A96348 9/> 3.: ?876348:A63484:57/>4/67'F9:./6484:64>6758764;6 3.: 6.6<4 ./ 634 5875486@ 634 9558758.964 84E4>@ F9: 67 955879;3 634 .D.< 7B86 9/> 9::486 3.: ;<9.E 7D48 634
- 8 -
5875486@ 3484:57/>4/67&;7B<>/7639D44/64869./4> 9/95549<6396677F3.;3F9:?4<964>9/>6396677F.637B6 9/ 955<.;96.7/ A78 ;7/>7/96.7/ 7A >4<9@ 9/> 34 ;7B<> /76 39D4 9//B<<4> 634 EB696.7/ 587;44>./=: 6396 :677> 634 64:6 7A 6.E4 3484A784 634 .E5B=/4> 78>48 59::4> ?@ 84:57/>4/67&9/>63478>4859::4>?@84:57/>4/67$ >4:48D4: 67 ?4 :46!9:.>4 84:48D./= <.?486@ 67 634 84:57/>4/67'67955879;3634.D.<7B869/>4:69?<.:3 3.:6.6<47D486345875486@ % 6.:/44><4::67E4/6.7/6396./6344D4/6634 84:57/>4/6 7' A.<4: 9/@ :B.6 634 84D4/B4 84;78>: :69/>./=./634/9E47A546.6.7/48:39<<9<F9@:?4:B?G4;6 676347B6;7E47A6396:B.64/;4634A7<<7F./=
. 34F8.6546.6.7/.:9<<7F4> .. 34 .E5B=/4> 78>48 59::4> ?@ 84:57/>4/6 7& >964> $%#$#$$ ?498./= 7
.: :46!9:.>4 7/:4HB4/6<@63478>48>964>$$#,$#$&
- 9 -
?498./= 7 59::4> ?@ 84:57/>4/67$.:9<:7:46!9:.>4 ... 34 84:57/>4/6 7& .: >.84;64> 67 A7863F.63 84:6784 634 /9E4 7A 634 546.6.7/48 ./ 634 84D4/B4 84;78>: 9: 548 634./348.69/;4>964>$#%$##$./3969 7&$%F.63./9548.7>7A63844E7/63:
*(
'#) #
989!67 989!*676.<<6344/> .:67<7"'