- 1 - ! !" #$$ % ! " # $ ! ! % %" " ! % "% !!!! %& %" " ' ! %& % Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - " $ ( ! )&&$$ & " " %( % " " ( ! *( ! )&&$$ # $ '+ &) " $ " , ! " ( ! - $ " ( , ( ! " " ( ! " % % ". ( (" $ %". ( (" $ "/012 3/014/2 56748/3 099/01:4; <61 =>/ 099/3304=)4871045/6?904@0423/014/256748/3099/01:4; <61=>/1/89642/4=8)530:?04=8 - 3 - >67;> =>/ ?0==/1 :8 830=/2 <61 02?:88:64 A:=> =>/ 5648/4= 6< B6=> =>/ 901=:/8 := :8 =0C/4 79 <61 <:403 2:896803 /:4; 0;;1:/D/2 B@ =>/ E72;?/4= 042 0A012 :4 6$20=/2-9088/2B@=>//4:61:D:3 (72;/ 042 6??:88:64/1 742/1 =>/ ?936@//8, 6?9/480=:64 5= (/A01;: <61 8>61= F=>/ 6??:88:64/1, =>/4871045/6?904@:8B/<61/=>:8671=:4099/03 ' >/ 87B8=04=:03 G7/8=:648 6< 30A =>0= 01:8/ <61 5648:2/10=:64:4=>:8099/0301/08B/36A% $ !>/=>/1=>/6??:88:64/1:8E78=:<:/2 :4 80223:4; =>/ /4=:1/ 3:0B:3:=@ 0;0:48= =>/ 4871045/ 6?904@ =>67;> =>/ 055:2/4= 655711/2 67=8:2/ =>/ 3650=:64 6<=>/1:8C56D/1/2742/1=>/963:5@H !>/=>/1=>/6??:88:64/1:8E78=:<:/2 :4 80223:4; =>/ 099/3304=)4871045/ 6?904@ =6 90@ =>/ :4=/1/8= 0= $I 9/1 0447? =>67;> =>/ :4=/1/8= 042 9/403=@ 50446= B/ 80223/2 7964 =>/ - 4 - 4871045/ 6?904@ 08 9/1 =>/ =/1?8 6<=>/963:5@H & >/<05=703?0=1:J6<=>/508/:8=>0==>/>78B042 6< 9/=:=:64/1 6$ K 0330990 A08 0 30B671/1 A61C:4; 08 0 0864 742/1 1/89642/4= 6$ 4 $' 08 9/1 =>/ :48=175=:648 6< 1/89642/4= 6$ >/A08 A61C:4;0=(/A01;: =02:7?:4=>/5648=175=:64A61C=0B67=&9?A>:3/ >/8=6624/01=>/42661=02:7?!03327/=68=164;A:428 0428=61?@A/0=>/1=>/A0330429:3301</3364=>/2/5/08/2 03309905078:4;>:82/0=>508/A081/;:8=/1/2B@63:5/ :4 1:?/ 6$ >/ 9/=:=:64/18 <:3/20 530:? 9/=:=:64 0;0:48= =>/ /?936@/1 042 =>/ :4871/1 564=/42:4; =>0= =>/ 2/5/08/2 A08 /014:4; A0;/8 6< 8$&) 9/1 ?64=> >/ A080;/20B67='@/018042=>/1/<61/=>/@01//4=:=3/2<61 =>/56?9/480=:64 L >/ 1/89642/4= 6$ K /?936@/1 02?:==/2 =>/ 1/30=:648>:9 6< /?936@// 042 /?936@/1 042 564=/42/2 =>0= 2/5/08/2 A08 2/936@/2 0= =>/ 5648=175=:64 6< =>/ :42661 8=02:7? 64 $' 042 27/ =6 8=61?@ - 5 - A:428 =>/ A033 </33 26A4 64 >:? 042 >/ 2:/2 = :8 564=/42/2 =>0= >/ A08 B/:4; 90:2 A0;/8 6< 8'&) 9/1 20@ 8$$')9/1?64=>"/03868=0=/2=>0=>/>02 6B=0:4/2 F ?936@//8 6?9/480=:64 :0B:3:=@ 63:5@, <16? 1/89642/4=6042=>/1/<61/1/89642/4=6:83:0B3/=6 90@=>/56?9/480=:64 >/1/89642/4=62/4:/2033=>/564=/4=:6486< =>/ 9/=:=:64/18 042 87B?:==/2 =>0= := >02 :887/2 =>/ 963:5@ 042 := A08 6B3:;0=61@ 64 =>/ 901= 6< 1/89642/4= 6$ =6 56?93@ 033 =>/ 5642:=:648 = 564=/42/2 =>0= =>/ 0A012 6< :4=/1/8=B/1/8=1:5=/2=6=>/5642:=:6486<=>/963:5@ >/ 6??:88:64/1 1/5612/2 =>/ /D:2/45/ 6< 9/=:=:64/16$08!$042 J8$=6A/1/?01C/2 >/ 6<<:5:03 6< 1/89642/4= 6 A08 /J0?:4/2 08 !$ 042 2657?/4=8 0= J8 $ 042 A/1/ ?01C/2 <=/1 >/01:4; B6=> =>/ 8:2/8 =>/ 6??:88:64/1 >/32 =>/ A0;/8 6< 2/5/08/20= 8$$')0420993@:4;0<05=616<$'08 9/1=>/5>/273/=6=>/ 5=080993:50B3/<61=>/0;/6< '@/0180A012/256?9/480=:646< 8$&):45378:D/ - 6 - 6< <74/103 /J9/48/8 = 80223/2 =>/ /4=:1/ 56?9/480=:64 0?674= =6 B/ 90:2 B@ 1/89642/4= 6$ K 4871045/ 6?904@ - 9/17803 6< J =>/ 963:5@ :887/2 B@ 1/89642/4=6A67328>6A=>0==>/3650=:646<=>/1:8C:8 ?/4=:64/2 08 "73371 "678/ :2@0 0;01 (/A01;: 042 =>/ 963:5@ 56D/18 =/4 748C:33/2 30B671/18 A:=> 2/5301/2 =6=03 ?64=>3@A0;/80= 8$&)=:89/1=:4/4==646=/=>0= =>/ 90;/ 6& 6< =>/ 963:5@ 8>6A8 =>0= =>/ /J5378:648 01/ 89/5:<:5033@?/4=:64/23078/B6<=>/ J5378:6481/02808 B/36A% ! - 7 - " $ >:8 53078/ :4 =>/ 963:5@ A6732 53/013@ :42:50=/ =>0= =>/ 963:5@ 56D/18 =>/ 9305/8 A>/1/ =>/ /?936@// :8 2/936@/2 B@ =>/ /?936@/1 <61 =>/ 971968/ 6< >:8 B78:4/88 >/1/<61/ =>/ 564=/4=:64 6< =>/ 3/014/2 56748/3 <61 =>/ 099/3304=)4871045/ 6?904@ =>0= =>/ 2/5/08/2 A08 2/936@/20=42661=02:7?(/A01;:042=>/1/<61/=>/963:5@ 26/8 46= 56D/1 =>/ 055:2/4= :8B/1/<= 6< 04@ ?/1:= "/45/ =>/80?/>08=6B/1/E/5=/2 $$ >/ 8/5642 089/5= :8 A>0= A6732 B/ 3:0B:3:=@ 6< =>/099/3304=K4871045/6?904@=:89/1=:4/4==646=/ =>0==>/2/5301/2?64=>3@A0;/8<61=/4/?936@//8A6732B/ 8$&) >/1/<61/ 9/1 /?936@// =>/ A0;/8 A6732 B/ 8$&) 9/1 ?64=> !>/4 1/89642/4= 6$ K /?936@/1>0802?:==/2=>/A0;/86< 8$$')9/1?64=> =>/ B03045/ 0?674= >08 =6 B/ 90:2 B@ =>/ /?936@/1 4 6=>/1A6128=>/099/3304=K4871045/6?904@:83:0B3/=6 - 8 - 90@ =>/ 56?9/480=:64 6< 8$&) J $' J &I M 8$$'L-L) $ >/ B03045/ 0?674= 8-) J $' J &IM 8-$)042=>/<74/103/J9/48/86< 8&) 01/=6B/90:2B@=>//?936@/1 $ 6?:4; =6 =>/ 3:0B:3:=@ =6 90@ =>/ :4=/1/8= := :8 A61=> =6 46=/ =>0= =>/ E72;?/4= 6< =>/ 9/J 671= :4 =>/ 508/ 6< ! " "" # " #"$% A>:5> A08 5301:<:/2 30=/1 :4 =>/ 508/ 6< &# " ! ! ' >6328 =>0= =>/ 4871045/ 6?904@ :4 =>/ 0B8/45/ 6< 04@ 8=0=7=61@ ?0420=/ =6 90@ =>/ :4=/1/8= 042 9/403=@ 042 =>/ 963:5@ 46= ?/4=:64:4; 04@=>:4;0B67==>/3:0B:3:=@=690@=>/:4=/1/8=0429/403=@:8 46= 3:0B3/ =6 90@ =>/ 80?/ >/1/<61/ =>/ :4=/1/8= 64 =>/ /4=:1/56?9/480=:640==>/10=/6<$I9/10447?<16?=>/ 20=/6</J9:1@6<20@8<16?=>/20=/6<=>/055:2/4=:8=6 B/80223/27964=>//?936@/1 1 L&$- 2 -$' - 9 - $' >78 =>/ 87B8=04=:03 G7/8=:648 6< 30A >0D:4; B//4 048A/1/2 055612:4;3@ =>/ 099/03 8755//28 :4 901= "/45/=>/<6336A:4;% : >/099/03:80336A/2:4901= :: >/:?97;4/2E72;?/4=0420A0129088/2 B@=>/6??:88:64/1:8>/1/B@?62:<:/2 ::: >/099/3304=K4871045/6?904@:83:0B3/ =6 90@ =>/ 87? 6< 8$$'L-L) =6 =>/ 530:?04=8 :D >/ /?936@/1 1/89642/4= 6& >/1/:4 :83:0B3/=690@=>/87?6< 8$$)=6 =>/530:?04=8 D >/ /?936@/1 1/89642/4= 6& :8 0386 3:0B3/ =6 90@ =>/ :4=/1/8= 0= $I 9/1 0447?<16?=>/20=/6</J9:1@6<20@8 6<=>/055:2/4==:33=>/20=/6<2/968:=B/<61/ =>/ 6??:88:64/1 64 =>/ /4=:1/ 87? 6< 8$&) - 10 - D: >/ /J5/88 0?674= 2/968:=/2 B@ =>/ 099/3304=)4871045/ 6?904@ B/<61/ =>/ 6??:88:64/1B/1/<742/2=6:= 2) &$ ' $ :8=6%$36%L %