Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 11868 (KAR)
DEVINDRA v. BHARATHRAO DIED PER HIS LRS DEFENDANTS NO. 1 DIED PER LRS (A). AMBUBAI AND ORS
WP/203326/2024 · 2025-01-13
R Nataraj
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 11868 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 11868 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "#"$
%&#!# '& (
! ! "
#$
%%
&#&''$
(
"
)! "
"
&#&!*
Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: High Court Of Karnataka
- 2 -
'
"
+ )$
!('$ (! &$$$('
"
&#
!'&!(
&
" + &)
!$
%
!(!$&
) +""
&'
%
&# + !'$$&
"
*
(
!'&'! #
"
+
'
- 3 -
" !'$$&
* +
! %%
&#&''$
!$
)'
&#&$! "
() $' ($(! !! "
)! &#&''$
!(
'$
&#&''$
!' +
&! %
!'&!(
- 4 -
! +
)
&#&''$
!&
'(
&#&''$
!)
')
&#&''$
! "
+
&
(!)( ,&#&$! !# "
+ " &#&!*
!*
"
(
" &#&!*
($ ++
+
- 5 -
(#
&#&!*
%
* !&($- !'$!($(&
! #!)
!*
"
"
%
(() (( %
%
" %
+ + !) ($!'
()$*($( . "
" '&%
%%
! %
%
%
" / %
+
%
+
%
% %
"
"
%
%
! & # %+
% 0/
"
1+
+
234567897::78 ;!) ($!'438<78=;8923:753;:923 >78?7465 387;> 7@75 +A<=3 68< + 7<6> 238?3:;>92
- 6 -
>3:3>>3<9;6B0923
>765;A>9/ 7BC3:;>3927B;A>9?265538=78= 923>3D3?97;8;:92364457?697;8;'& :753<CE27FA8<3> ><3> A53 ! ;: 923 ;<3 ;: 7@75 >;?3<A>3 !*$# :;> B2;>9 0/ 9; 6F38< 923 456789 68< 9; 78?;>4;>693 68 6<<797;8654>6E3>68<6<<797;8654536<78=B
( 2346>973BB2655238?3:;>92C3>3:3>>3<9;6B923E G3>36>>6E3<C3:;>3923
>765;A>9
23439797;83>23>378G6B 9234567897::G2753923>3B4;8<389B23>378G3>3923<3:38<689B C3:;>3923
>765;A>9
' 23 BA79 78 ;!) ($!' G6B :753< :;> 46>9797;8 68<B346>6934;BB3BB7;8;:9234567897::/B! &92B26>378923BA79 B?23<A53 4>;43>973B
23 4567897:: ?567F3< 9269 23 68< 923 <3:38<689B ?;8B979A93< 6 D;789 :6F75E 68< 9269 923 :6F75E 4;BB3BB3< BA79 B?23<A53 4>;43>973B G27?2 G3>3 235< D;7895E CE 923 4567897:: 68< 923 <3:38<689B
23 4567897:: ?567F3< 9269 27B >3HA3B9 :;> 46>9797;8 G6B 8;9 6??3493< CE 923 <3:38<689 ;! 68<23G6B923>3:;>36<@7B3<9;:7536BA79:;>46>9797;8
23BA79G6B?;893B93<CE923<3:38<689;B!9;& 68<#G2;?;8938<3<9269923>3G6B4>7;>46>9797;87893>FB ;: G27?2 ?3>9678 4>;43>973B G3>3 655;993< 9; 923 4567897:: 68<
- 7 -
B;F3 4>;43>973B G3>3 655;993< 9; 923 <3:38<689B
23E 65B; ?567F3<9269?3>96784>;43>973BG3>34A>?26B3<CE923F;A9;: 9237>36>878=B
& A>78=923?;A>B3;:?>;BB3I6F78697;8;:"!23 <7B?5;B3< 9269 923 <3:38<689 ;' 26< 96J38 923 <3:38<689 ;!'786<;497;8
234567897::923>3:;>37F4536<3<<3:38<689 ;!' 78 923 BA79
23 <3:38<689 ;!' :753< 27B G>79938 B9693F38992>;A=227B=A6><768?;8938<78=926923G6B96J38 786<;497;8CE923<3:38<689;'G27?2G6B3@7<38?3<CE923 <33< ;: 6<;497;8 <693< (*!!($!! 23 <3:38<689 ;!' 6<;493<923G>79938B9693F389:753<CE923<3:38<689;B!9; &68<#68<?;8938<3<9269239;;G6B3897953<9;683HA65 B26>3789234>;43>973B;:923<3?36B3<;>6J286923:38<689 ;( :753< 27B 6<<797;865 G>79938 B9693F389 9; 923 6F38<3< 456789 )
"238 923 BA79 G6B B39 <;G8 :;> 6>=AF389B 923 4567897:::753<6864457?697;8A8<3>><3>A53!;:9;
78?;>4;>693923:;55;G78=6946>6;!!6 78923456789
- 8 -
!
"
#
$
% & &
!'()*)+++)%+)%+% , %-..%+
#
/
; 6F38< 46>6 ;!( ;: 923 456789 6:93> 5783 ;!)68<6<<923:;55;G78=
0+++.)
0 %1.)
%*234 #5
"
6 7-18
- 9 -
;6F38<9234>6E3>?;5AF8;:92345678969: 6B:;55;GB
2$3 #
!'()*)+++)%+)%,%-..%+
"
0 ! #
27B 64457?697;8 G6B ;44;B3< CE 923 <3:38<689 ;B(9;&68<#G2;?;8938<3<9269923B6F3?688;9C3 3893>96783< 69 923 :6= 38< ;: 923 4>;?33<78=B
23E 65B; ?;8938<3<92699234567897::<7<8;9<3F;8B9>6936B9;2;G923 4>;4;B3<6F38<F389G6B83?3BB6>E:;>9236<DA<7?697;8;:923 BA79
# 23
>765 ;A>9 78 93>FB ;: 923 7F4A=83< ;><3> >3D3?93< 923 64457?697;8 ;'& ;8 923 =>;A8< 9269 923 4567897::<7<8;9<7B?5;B36B9;G23823?6F39;J8;G6C;A9923 3I3?A97;8;:9236<;497;8<33<9235<9269G2389234567897:: <7<8;9<7B?5;B3923B67<>353@689:6?923?688;9C343>F7993< 9;:7536864457?697;8:;>6F38<F389;:923456789696C35693<
- 10 -
B96=3 ;: 923 BA79 ;8B3HA3895E 79 >3D3?93< 923 64457?697;8 78 93>FB;:9237F4A=83<;><3> * 378= 6==>73@3< CE 923 B67< ;><3> 923 4567897:: 7B C3:;>3927B;A>9
!$ 36>83<?;A8B35:;>9234567897:: 439797;83>?;8938<B 9269 923 <3:38<689 ;!' ?567F3< 9; C3 923 6<;493< B;8 ;:
<3?36B3< <3:38<689 ;' 68< 9269 923 4>;43>973B 9269 26< :65538 9; 923 B26>3 ;: 923 <3:38<689 ;' G3>3 9>68B:3>>3< 9;
923 <3:38<689 ;!' A8<3> 923 B67< 6<;497;8 <33< 3 923>3:;>3?;8938<B92697:9234567897::7B6C539;3B96C57B29269 923B67<6<;497;8<33<G6B8;F78655E3I3?A93<;>9269797B8;9 53=65;>38:;>?36C53;>8;96?93<A4;892389234567897::9;;7B 3897953< :;> 6 B26>3 923>378
2AB 23 ?;8938<B 9269 923 6F38<F389B;A=29:;>CE9234567897::G6B83?3BB6>E68<923 >765;A>9?;FF7993<683>>;>78>3D3?978=92364457?697;8 ;'&
!! 3> ?;89>6 923 536>83< ?;A8B35 :;> 923 ?;893B978= >3B4;8<389B ?;8938<B 9269 923
>765 ;A>9 26< :>6F3< 68 6<<797;8657BBA36B9;G23923>923<3:38<689;!'4>;@3B9269 23 G6B 6<;493< CE 923 <3:38<689 ;' 6B 43> 6<;497;8 <33<
- 11 -
<693<(*!!($!!3923>3:;>3?;8938<B9269923CA><38;:
4>;@78= 923 B67< 7BBA3 7B A4;8 923 <3:38<689 ;!' 68< 923>3:;>3923>37B8;833<:;>9234567897::9;6F38<923BA799;
B33J:;>6<3?56>697;892699236<;497;8<33<<693<(*!!($!! 7B8;9C78<78=A4;827F3BACF79B92699234567897::26B8;
9; ?265538=3 923 6<;497;8 6B 923 6<;497;8 7B C39G338<3:38<689;!'68<923<3:38<689;'
!( 26@3 ?;8B7<3>3< 923 BACF7BB7;8B ;: 923 536>83< ?;A8B35 :;> 923 439797;83> 68< 923 536>83< ?;A8B35 :;> 923 ?;893B978=>3B4;8<389B !' 8923 BA79 :;> 46>9797;8 G2753 923 4567897:: ?567F3< 9269 923 BA79 4>;43>973B G3>3 235< D;7895E 923 <3:38<689B ?;8938<3<9;923?;89>6>E68<?567F3<9269923>3G6B64>7;> 46>9797;868<9269B;F3;:9234>;43>973BG3>34A>?26B3<;A9;:
9237> B35:36>878=B
23>3:;>3 79 7B A4;8 923 4567897:: 9; 3B96C57B2923:6?992699234>;43>973BG3>3235<D;7895E6B;8923 <693;:923BA7968<9269923>3G6B8;46>9797;8
23<3:38<689B 6>3C;A8< 9; 4>;@3 923 4>7;>46>9797;8 68< 923 ;8AB A4;8 923 <3:38<689B 7B F;>3 9268 923 4567897:: 6B 923 <3:38<689B 26< ?567F3<9269923>3G6B64>7;>46>9797;8923>3CE6<F79978=9269
- 12 -
923 BA79 4>;43>973B C35;8=3< 9; 923 :6F75E 8 B; :6> 6B 923 <3:38<689 ;!' 7B ?;8?3>83< F3>3 3I3?A97;8 ;: 6 <33< ;:
6<;497;8 G;A5< 8;9 <7B438B3 79B 4>;;: 68< 79B @657<79E
23 <3:38<689 ;!' 7B C;A8< 9; 3B96C57B2 9269 923>3 G6B 6 @657< 6<;497;8
23>3:;>3923
>765;A>926B>7=295E:>6F3<687BBA3 6B9;G23923><3:38<689;!'4>;@3B926923G6B6<;493<CE <3:38<689 ;' 78 93>FB ;: 923 <33< ;: 6<;497;8 <693< (*!!($!!
8 923 3@389 <3:38<689 ;!' 7B 8;9 6C53 9;
3B96C57B2 9269 23 G6B 6<;493< CE <3:38<689 ;' 68< 7: 923 ;923><3:38<689B6>38;96C539;3B96C57B264>7;>46>9797;89238 79=;3BG792;A9B6E78=92699234567897::G;A5<C33897953<9;6 B26>3786559234>;43>973B78?5A<78=9234>;43>973B92696>3923 BACD3?9F6993>;:9236<;497;8<33<<693<(*!!($!! ! 2;A=2923>36B;878=;:923
>765;A>978>3D3?978= 92364457?697;8?688;9C36??3493<CA9E3992364457?697;8G6B >7=295E>3D3?93<6B9236F38<F389B;A=29:;>CE9234567897:: G6B8;9>3655E83?3BB6>E:;>923?;8B7<3>697;8;:923BA79 !& 8 9269 @73G ;: 923 F6993> 68< BACD3?9 9; 923 ;CB3>@697;8B F6<3 6C;@3 927B G>79 439797;8 B968<B
- 13 -
7C3>9E 7B >3B3>@3< 9; 923 439797;83> 9; >67B3 927B 6B 6 =>;A8<78686443659269F6EC3:753<CE923439797;83>6=678B9 923DA<=F3899269F6EC346BB3<78923BA79
!)*
'#( #
46>6;B!9;!( 46>6;!'975592338< 7B9;! 5;) /