- 1 - !"! #$ " % &" ! $ '(') *+,' ** & !" # $ % " & ' "(" & ) & "(" # $ & " % Digitally signed by SHILPA R TENIHALLI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - &)!* & $ % ) ! & "() & && !+$%$ %() &) & (" & & && & & & , - - $ , - -% " ../012 34 51.367 601 8(() 5142349 :1;8<1 =>1 .8/<= 8; 227 30=<3.= 642 1003840 -/291 326< 03==349 6= 606?6@67A64 6<30349 8/= 8; <3B1 8"() <1930=1<12 :A 64=>676 5873.1 0=6=384 326< ;8< 8;;14.10 5/430>6:71 /421< 1.=384 !+$%$4% ( 8; 6421.=3840)C8; .=("30:1;8<1=>30 8/<=/421<01.=384)!*8;<011@349<19/76<:637 16<2 =>1 716<412 .8/4017 ;8< =>1 51=3=3841< 642 716<412;8<<10584214=8" 10584214=8D>8 - 3 - 3001<?1234=>1B6==1<>60<1B63412/4<15<1014=12:1;8<1 =>308/<= ! & 34<3B18"()D60<1930=1<12:A64=>676 873.1 =6=384 326< 696340= =>1 51=3=3841< >1<134 343=3677A ;8<=>18;;14.105/430>6:71/421<1.=3840!+$!%()C (8;6421.=3840!)C$E%$%8; .=84 =>1 :6030 8; ;3<0= 34;8<B6=384 26=12 "!(() <1.13?12 ;<8B <10584214= 8 D>8 30 =>1 B8=>1< 8; =>1 ?3.=3B 69126:8/="+A16<0 ) /<349 =>1 .8/<01 8; 34?10=396=384 8; =>1 .601 51=3=3841< >1<134 D60 6<<10=12 84 ")(() 642 <1B64212 =8 E/23.367 ./0=82A >1 34?10=396=384 8; =>1 .60130.8B571=12642.>6<910>11=>60:114;3712696340= >3B;8<=>16;8<106328;;14.1063765573.6=384;3712:A=>1 51=3=3841< :1;8<1 =>1 =<367 .8/<= 34 <730.8"*+() D60 <1E1.=12 84(+"(() >1<1;8<1=>1 51=3=3841<30 :1;8<1=>308/<= - 4 - 16<412 .8/4017 ;8< =>1 51=3=3841< 0/:B3=0 =>6= =>1 ?3.=3B 93<7 >60 48= .8851<6=12 34 =>1 5<1014= .601 ;8< 01./<349=10=<158<=>151=3=3841<D>8>60488=>1< .<3B3467 64=1.1214= 30 34 ./0=82A ;8< B8<1 =>64 03F B84=>0 1< 84=<6716<412 >60 8558012 =>151=3=384 10/:B3=0=>6==>1?3.=3B93<7>60B621677196=384696340= =>151=3=3841<34>1<0=6=1B14=<1.8<212/421<1.=384") 8; < D>3.> D8/72 6==<6.= =>1 6771912 8;;14.10 ..8<23497A5<6A0=8230B300=>151=3=384 + &3<0= 34;8<B64= D>8 30 =>1 B8=>1< 8; =>1 ?3.=3B 93<7 >62655<86.>12=>15873.184"!(()6;=1<=>1?3.=3B 93<7 D>8 D60 B123.677A 1F6B3412 D60 ;8/42 =8 :1 5<19464= 4 =>1 ;3<0= 34;8<B6=384 3= 30 6771912 =>6= 84 14G/3<A =>1 ?3.=3B 93<7 >62 34;8<B12 =>1 ;3<0= 34;8<B64= =>6=51=3=3841<>6201F/6734=1<.8/<01D3=>>1<696340=>1< D30>10642>1>62=><16=1412>1<D3=>23<1.8401G/14.10 3;0>134;8<B0=>134.3214==864A:82A - 5 - /<349 =>1 .8/<01 8; 34?10=396=384 8; =>1 .601 =>1 51=3=3841< D60 6<<10=12 84 ")(() 4?10=396=384 30 .8B571=12 642 =>1 .>6<910>11= >60 :114 ;3712 =6=1B14= 8; =>1 ?3.=3B 93<7 6912 "+ A16<0 D60 <1.8<212 :A =>1 E/<3023.=38467 B6930=<6=1 /421< 01.=384 ") 8; < 84 "(() 1</067 8; =>1 06B1 D8/72 98 =8 0>8D =>6= =>1 51=3=3841< 642 =>1 ?3.=3B 93<7 D1<1 6.G/634=12 =8 16.> 8=>1< >8/9> =>1 ?3.=3B 93<7 >60 0=6=12 =>6= 51=3=3841< >62 5>A03.67 <176=3840>35 D3=> >1< 0>1 >60 48= B621 64A 677196=384 =>6= =>1 51=3=3841< >62 01F/67 34=1<.8/<01 D3=> >1< 696340= >1< D30>10 >1 >60 6708 48= 0=6=12 34 >1< 01.=384")< 0=6=1B14==>6= 51=3=3841<D60=>1.6/01;8<>1<5<19464.A 1.8<20B621 6?6376:71 :A =>1 716<412 D8/72 98 =8 0>8D =>6= 51=3=3841< >62 .8851<6=12 ;8< =>1 5/<5801 8; =10= <158<= 642 >1 6708 >62 93?14 >30 :7882 06B5710 ;8< =>30 =10= 8D1?1< =>1 ?3.=3B 93<7 642 >1< B8=>1< >6?1 8558012=893?1:788206B5710;8<=>15/<58018;=10= <158<= - 6 - * 1=3=3841<D>8>60488=>1<.<3B346764=1.1214=3034 ./0=82A 4?10=396=384 8; =>1 .601 30 .8B571=12 642 =>1 .>6<910>11= >60 :114 ;3712 <801./=384 >60 .3=12 !) .>6<910>11=D3=410010345<1014=.601642=>1=<36734=>1 .60130A1==8.8BB14.1 "( 421<=>101.3<./B0=64.106B8;=>18534384=>6= D3=>8/=1F5<10034964A853438484=>1B1<3=064221B1<3=0 8;=>1.601=>151=3=3841<H05<6A1<;8<9<64=8;<19/76<:637 41120 =8:19<64=12 ..8<23497A 5<8.112=8 5600 =>1 ;8778D3498<21< >151=3=384306778D12 >1 51=3=3841< 30 23<1.=12 =8 :1 1476<912 84 :637 34 <3B1 8"() <1930=1<12 :A 64=>676 5873.1 0=6=384 326< ;8< 8;;14.10 5/430>6:71 /421< 1.=384 !+$%$4% ( 8; 642 1.=3840 ) C 8; .= (" 5142349 34 51.367 601 8(() 84 =>1 ;371 8; 716<41222730=<3.=6421003840-/291326<03==349 6=606?6@67A640/:E1.==8=>1;8778D349.8423=3840 - 7 - 6%>151=3=3841<0>6771F1./=151<08467:842;8<6 0/B 8; 0"((((( D3=> =D8 0/<1=310 ;8< =>1 73@10/B =8 =>1 06=30;6.=384 8; =>1 E/<3023.=38467 8/<=I :%>1 51=3=3841< 0>677 65516< <19/76<7A 84 677 =>1 26=108;>16<349:1;8<1=>1<3678/<=/47100=>1 <367 8/<= 1F1B5=0 >30 65516<64.1 ;8< ?6732 <160840I .% >1 51=3=3841< 0>677 48= 23<1.=7A 8< 3423<1.=7A =><16=14 8< =6B51< D3=> =>1 5<801./=384 D3=410010I 2%>1 51=3=3841< 0>677 48= 34?87?1 34 03B376< 8;;14.1034;/=/<1I 1%>1 51=3=3841< 0>677 48= 716?1 =>1 E/<3023.=384 8; =>1 <367 8/<= D3=>8/= 51<B300384 8; =>1 0632 8/<= /4=37 =>1 .601 <1930=1<12 696340= >3B 30 230580128;; -+ ' % &" !* " 30=8"78"*