- 1 - !! "#$ % &$ ! # '(')*+(' ** & !" # $ % & ' (( ) "* Digitally signed by SHIVAKUMAR HIREMATH Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - " ( " $ % & ( +(& (' ( " ( %' "( '+(,- " .. ( (( #( ) ( ( / ((%0 ' 0( ' / ( ( ( ( 1 1 2 0 &0 %1 2 0 &0' 3345-6 75 87 ,9 :,;- 7" :-<,58-:-6 => ?6?: ?@?: 7A,3- 8?8,79 ?,3B4: C7: 8B- 7CC-93- D49,5B?=A- 496-: -38,795 # :-?6 E,8B -38,79 7C ?:- =-C7:- 8B,5 74:8 496-: - 3 - -38,79"7C : :-?6E,8B-38,79"7C B?:?8,>? ?<?:,F?4:?F5B??9B,8?E,8B?D:?>-:87G4?5B 8B- -98,:- D:73--6,9< ,9 8B- ?C7:-5?,6 3?5- ?5 ?<?,958 8B-; -?:68B-A-?:9-637495-AC7:8B-D?:8,-5 -?:9-6 37495-A C7: 8B- D-8,8,79-:5 54=;,85 8B?8 79A> ?5 ? 37498-: 87 8B- ( ,9 :,;- 7 :-<,58-:-6=>,5B? 4984:96:?D:?6-5B8?8-8B- ,;D4<9-6 3:,;,9?A D:73--6,9< B?5 =--9 ,9,8,?8-6 ?<?,958 8B- D-8,8,79-:5 - 54=;,85 8B?8 8B-:- ,5 ?9 ,97:6,9?8- 6-A?>7C;7:-8B?9C,H-;798B5,9?DD:7?3B,9<8B-D7A,3- EB,3B ,5 978 5?8,5C?387:,A> -IDA?,9-6 9A> 87 E:-3F H-9<-?93- 8B- ,;D4<9-6 3:,;,9?A D:73--6,9< B?5 =--9 ,9,8,?8-6 ?<?,958 8B- D-8,8,79-:5 337:6,9<A> B- D:?>5 87 ?AA7E8B-D-8,8,79 -: 3798:? A-?:9-6 ?96 8B- A-?:9-6 37495-A?DD-?:,9<C7:8B-:-5D796-98 7B?H-7DD75-6 8B-D-8,8,79B->54=;,88B?83795,6-:,9<8B-?AA-<?8,795 - 4 - C7496 ,9 8B- C,:58 ,9C7:;?8,79 ,9H-58,<?8,79 ,5 9-3-55?:> ?96 8B- 5?;- ,5 496-: D:7<:-55 B-:-C7:- 97 ,98-:C-:-93-,53?AA-6C7:,98B-D:-5-983?5-337:6,9<A> 8B->D:?>876,5;,558B-D-8,8,79 B-;?8-:,?A79:-37:6E74A6<7875B7E8B?8 8B-:-5D796-98 7,58B-B45=?967C8B-D-8,8,79-: 7 B-:-,9-8,8,79-: 7?96D-8,8,79-: 7?:-8B-=:78B-: ?96 ;78B-: 7C D-8,8,79-: 7 8 ?DD-?:5 8B?8 8B- :-A?8,795B,D=-8E--98B-D-8,8,79-: 7?96B-:B45=?96 37;DA?,9?98 ,9 8B- D:-5-98 3?5- ,5 978 37:6,?A ?96 79 8B- 37;DA?,98 54=;,88-6 => 8B- D-8,8,79-: 7 B-:-,9(,9 :,;- 7E?5:-<,58-:-6=>,5B? 4984: ?<?,958 :-5D796-98 7 ?96 B,5 C?;,A> ;-;=-:5C7:8B-7CC-93-D49,5B?=A-496-:-38,795"?96 * 7C ?96 -38,795 ?96 7C 8B- 7E:> :7B,=,8,79 38 B- 5?,6 ( E?5 :-<,58-:-6 79 " 9 8B- 37;DA?,98 EB,3B B?5 :-54A8-6 ,9 :-<,58-:,9< 8B- ( ,9 :,;- 7 8B- D-8,8,79-: 7B-:-,9B?5;-98,79-68B?85B-E?5,AA8:-?8-6,9B-: - 5 - ;?8:,;79,?A B745- => 8B- ?3345-6 D-:5795 ?96 8B-> B?6 8B:7E9B-:748C:7;8B-;?8:,;79,?AB745-?968B-:-?C8-: 5B-E?537958:?,9-6878?F-5B-A8-:,9B-:D?:-985B745- B-:-C7:- ,8 ,5 ?DD?:-98 8B?8 ?5 79 " 8B- D-8,8,79-: 7B?6A-C88B-37;D?9>7CB-:B45=?96?96 5B-B?6?A:-?6>8?F-95B-A8-:,9B-:D?:-985/B745- # B- C,:58 ,9C7:;?8,79 ,9 8B- D:-5-98 3?5- ,5 54=;,88-679..?AA-<,9<8B?879.?8 ?=748 ?; EB-9 8B- C,:58 ,9C7:;?98 ?96 B,5 E,C- EB7 ,5 8B- D-8,8,79-: 7 B-:-,9 E-:- ,9 8B- B745- ?3345-6 75?96EB73?;-8B-:-?AA-<-6A>?=45-6B,; ?968B-:-?C8-:?55?4A8-6B,;B-98B-;?,6,98B-B745- 8:,-687,98-:C-:-8B-D-8,8,79-: 7?AA-<-6A>?=45-6B-: 45,9< C,A8B> A?9<4?<- ?96 D4AA-6 B-: 5?:-- ?96 748:?<-6 B-: ;76-58> B-9 8B- >749<-: =:78B-: 7C 8B- C,:58 ,9C7:;?98 8:,-6 87 ,98-:C-:- -H-9 B- E?5 ?=45-6 ?96 ?55?4A8-6 ?96 8B-:-?C8-: 8B- ?3345-6 D-:5795 B?6 3:,;,9?AA> ,98,;,6?8-6 8B-; ?96 A-C8 8B- DA?3- B- C,:58 ,9C7:;?8,79 ,9 :-5D-38 7C 8B- ?AA-<-6 ,93,6-98 8B?8 B?6 - 6 - 8?F-9DA?3-79.,5A76<-679..EB,3B ,5 ?C8-: ? D-:,76 7C ;7:- 8B?9 C,H- ;798B5 B- 5?;- ,5 A76<-6?C8-:8B-D-8,8,79-: 7B?6?DD:7?3B-68B-D7A,3- ?8 4984: ?96 54=;,88-6 ? 37;DA?,98 ?<?,958 :-5D796-98 7 B-:-,9 ?96 B,5 :-A?8,H-5 EB,3B B?6 :-54A8-6 ,9 :-<,58-:-6(,9 :,;- 7?<?,9588B-;C7:8B- 7CC-93-5 D49,5B?=A- 496-: -38,795 " ?96 * 7C ?96 -38,795 ?96 7C 7E:> :7B,=,8,79 38 B-:-C7:- 8B- 37::-389-55 7C 8B- ?AA-<?8,79 C7496 ,9 8B- D:-5-98 3?5- ?5 ?<?,958 8B- D-8,8,79-:5 ?A57 =-37;-5 674=8C4A9?66,8,79878B-5?;-8B-,97:6,9?8-6-A?>7C ;7:- 8B?9 C,H- ;798B5 ,9 ?DD:7?3B,9< 8B- D7A,3- ,5 ?A57 978D:7D-:A>-IDA?,9-6B-79/=A-4D:-;- 74:8,98B- 3?5-7C 1?8D?:?<:?DB 7B?57=5-:H-6?5C7AA7E51 %"' " - 7 - ! " # # # $ * 795,6-:,9<8B-,97:6,9?8-6-A?>,9?DD:7?3B,9< 8B-D7A,3-?96?A578B-8,;,9<7C8B-37;DA,?9854=;,88-6 =>8B-:-5D796-98 7,8?DD-?:58B?879A>?5?37498-: 878B-3:,;,9?A3?5-:-<,58-:-6,9 :,;- 78B- ,;D4<9-6 3:,;,9?A D:73--6,9< B?5 =--9 ,9,8,?8-6 96-: 8B-3,:34;58?93-5?;7C8B-7D,9,798B?83798,94?8,79 7C 8B- ,;D4<9-6 3:,;,9?A D:73--6,9<5 E74A6 ?;7498 87 ?=45- 7C D:73-55 7C A?E ?96 8B-:-C7:- ,8 ,5 9-3-55?:> 87 G4?5B8B-5?;-337:6,9<A>8B-C7AA7E,9<7:6-:1 %,' B-3:,;,9?AD-8,8,79,5?AA7E-6J - 8 - %,,' B- -98,:- D:73--6,9<5 ,9 :,;- 7" 6?8-6 .. :-<,58-:-6 => ?6?: ?@?: 7A,3- 8?8,79 ?,3B4: C7: 8B- 7CC-93-5 D49,5B?=A- 496-: -38,795 #:-?6E,8B-38,797C D-96,9<=-C7:-8B- 74:87C ,H,A046<-%0:9' ?96 0( ?,3B4: ,5 G4?5B-6 ?5 ?<?,958 8B- D-8,8,79-:5B-:-,9 ,+ ' % &$ !* $ & ,58 71A 71" 1