Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 11834 (KAR)
NATHAPPA @ MALLINATH PUJARI AND ORS v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA AND ANR
CRL.A/200286/2024 · 2025-01-07
S Vishwajith Shetty
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 11834 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 11834 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "#
! $ %! #&&
'()*+*+, %
! ! "
#$" % !&!'
(
#
" $
Digitally signed by SHILPA R TENIHALLI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
)
%
*!&!'
! #$" % *!&!'
(
#" )
"$
) *#$ ) #$
'''
! ' # ) '# $'$
%
+ '# $ ' ) ) ) ))
,&!!'!' +) #$#-$#.$#/$) #$ +&+
- 3 -
)
"
0
"
!# # 0
"
$
112.345.674 85+97:3196;6.3# $ 5' :37497< =3>5-3 8?3 52-8 5> 44989576; 9.8-9186743..957.24<3674:3196;24<36;6=2-6<9 6-9.97< 528 5> -9@3 5 ' -3<9.83-34 =A 3;5<9 :5;913 .868957 6;6=2-6<9 >5- 8?3 5>>3713. :279.?6=;3 2743-318957.,&!!'!' -364/98?318957+5>318957#$#-$#$#.$674 #$#/$ 5> 1?342;34 6.83. 674 1?342;34 -9=3. #-3B378957 5> 8-519893.$ 18 +&+ #>5- .?5-8 C #$18C$6-3=3>5-38?9.52-8978?9.6::36;>9;342743- 318957*#$5>8?3 #$18
36-4 ;36-734 1527.3; >5- 8?3 6::3;;678. 674 ;36-734 9<? 52-8 5B3-7@378 ;3643- >5- -3.:574378
- 4 -
53.:5743785/?59..3-B34978?3@6883-?6. -3@6973427-3:-3.37834=3>5-38?9.52-8
36-7341527.3;>5-8?36::3;;678..2=@98.8?68 3B37 9> 8?3 6B3-@378. @643 97 8?3 ) 674 6;;3<68957. >5274978?31?6-<3.?3386-3:-9@6>6193:-3.2@3485=3 8-238?36;;3<345>>3713.:279.?6=;32743-8?3:-5B9.957. 5>8?3 #$18/9;;758<38688-6186.6<697.88?3 6::3;;678.?3-397 3.2=@98.8?688?36::3;;678.45758 ?6B367A1-9@976;6783134378.112.345.!674 ' 85 6. 6<697.8 /?5@ 6;;3<68957. 6-3 @643 6=528 6=2.97< 8?3 >9-.8 97>5-@678 674?9. >6@9;A @3@=3-.?6B3 =337<-67834-3<2;6-=69;=A8?3 -96;52-8 3.2=@98. 8?688?397B3.89<689575>8?316.39.6;-364A15@:;3834674 .9713 757 =69;6=;3 /6--678 ?6. =337 9..234 =A 8?3 -96; 52-88?36::3;;678.6::-3?3748?39-6--3.8978?3:-3.378 16.3 ?3-3>5-3?3:-6A.856;;5/8?36::36;
3- 1578-6 ;36-734 9<? 52-8 5B3-7@378 ;3643- ?6. 5::5.34 8?3 6::36; 3 .2=@98. 8?68 8?3
- 5 -
6::3;;678. ?6B3 758 155:3-6834 /98? 8?3 :5;913 >5- 8?3 :2-:5.3 5> 97B3.89<68957 674 8?3-3>5-3 8?3A ?6B3 =337 8-368346.6=.157497<6112.34 3.2=@98.8?6897B93/5> =6-2743-318957&5>8?3 #$18678919:685-A =69;167758=3<-67834858?36::3;;678. ! )?6.=337-3<9.83-34978?3:-3.37816.3=A 3;5<95;9138689576;6=2-6<9>5-8?36>5-3.6945>>3713. 57 8?3 =6.9. 5> 8?3 >9-.8 97>5-@68957 46834 +'' -3139B34 >-5@ -3.:574378 5 ?3-397 3-2.6; 5> 8?3 8A:34 15:A 5> 8?3 >9-.8 97>5-@68957 46834 +'' /52;4 <5 85 .?5/ 8?68 6;;3<68957. 5> 6=2.97< 8?3 >9-.8 97>5-@678674?9.>6@9;A@3@=3-./98?-3>3-3713858?39- 16.839.@6436<697.86112.345.!674'85 112.345.!674'85/?5/?3-36--3.83497 8?3 :-3.378 16.3 ?6B3 =337 <-67834 -3<2;6- =69; =A 8?3 -96; 52-8 ?3 6::3;;678. ?3-397 6-3 6112.34 5. 674 85 + 674 8?3-3 9. 75 6;;3<68957 6. 6<697.8 8?3@ 97 8?3>9-.897>5-@689576=5288?3A6=2.97<8?3>9-.897>5-@678 5-?9.>6@9;A@3@=3-./98?-3>3-3713858?39-16.83/?91? - 6 -
/52;4 :-9@6 >6193 688-618 8?3 :-5B9.957. 5> 8?3 #$ 18 ?3 57;A 6;;3<68957 6<697.8 8?3 6::3;;678. ?3-3979.8?686;57</98?58?3-6112.34:3-.57.8?3A?64 6..62;8348?3>9-.897>5-@678674>52-58?3-.89.75897 49.:283 8?68 6. 6 -3.2;8 5> 6..62;8 @643 =A 6112.34 :3-.57. 8?3 97D2-34 ?6B3 .2.869734 57;A .9@:;3 97D2-93. 89.6;.57589749.:2838?688?36::3;;678.?3-397494758 ?6B3 67A 1-9@976;
6783134378. 674 8?3A 6-3 6;; 6<-912;82-9.8.=A6B5168957
743- 8?3 19-12@.86713. 6@ 5> 8?3 5:97957 8?68-9<5-2743-318957&5>8?3 #$18167758 =3 @643 6::;916=;3 85 8?3 6::3;;678. 674 8?3-3>5-3 8?3 :-6A3-@643=A8?3@>5-<-6785>678919:685-A=69;7334. 85=367./3-346>>9-@689B3;A115-497<;A>5;;5/97<5-43- 9.:6..34
?3 1-9@976; 6::36; 9.
6;;5/34 ?3 5-43- 46834 ''' :6..34 =A 8?352-85> 44989576; 9.8-918
- 7 -
6743..957.24<36;6=2-6<997-;
9.15! ' 9..38*6.943
?3 -3.:574378 * 5;913 5- 67A 58?3- :5;913 97 8?3 86835>6-7686E66-349-3183485-3;36.38?36::3;;678. 97 8?3 3B378 5> 8?39- 6--3.8 97 -9@3 5 ' -3<9.83-34 =A 3;5<9 5;913 868957 6;6=2-6<9 >5- 8?3 5>>3713. :279.?6=;3 2743- 318957. , & ! !' !' -364 /98? 318957 + 5> 674 318957.#$#-$#$#.$674#$#/$5>8?3 #$ 18 :37497< 57 8?3 >9;3 5> 44989576; 9.8-918 674 3..957. 24<3 6;6=2-6<9 97 :3196; 6.3 # $ 5'.2=D318858?3>5;;5/97<157498957. ::3;;678. .?6;; 6::36- =3>5-3 8?3 7B3.89<6897< >>913- /98?97 ! 46A. >-5@ 8?3 46835>-3139:85>13-89>93415:A5>8?9.5-43-674 .?6;; 3F31283 6 :3-.576; =574 >5- 6 .2@ 5> .!''''* 361? /98? 8/5 .2-3893. >5- 8?3 ;9E3.2@ 85 8?3 .689.>618957 5> 8?3 97B3.89<6897< 5>>913-
- 8 -
::3;;678..?6;;-3<2;6-;A6::36-=3>5-38?3 -96; 52-8 /98?528 >69; 27;3.. 3F3@:834 =A 8?3 -96;52-8>5-B6;94-36.57. ::3;;678. .?6;; 758 86@:3- /98? 8?3 :-5.3128957 /9873..3. 6748?3A .?6;; 15*5:3-683 /98? 8?3 :5;913 >5- 97B3.89<68957 674 6::36- =3>5-38?3@/?373B3-16;;342:57
::3;;678. .?6;; 758 97B5;B3 97 .9@9;6- 5>>3713.97>282-3
-(
*
$ %! + ! 9.85;5